Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Trilogy Review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
So, I had reviewed the first book here, then gone to see the movie while still reading the second book, ("Catching Fire") and then yesterday I finished the final book of the trilogy ("Mockingjay"). In the past few days I've had a number of conversations about the books, plus I've read a bunch of reviews. After discussing this with the Cosmic Daughter this morning on the way to work, she suggested that I post my thoughts about the book, since apparently my thoughts are somewhat unusual compared to what I am seeing on the web and she has seen in discussions with her friends. Here's the deal. I think these books are incredibly well written and have a much deeper political purpose than most people seem to be getting. I see a lot of discussion, for example, about how the book is a fairly typical "teenage love triangle" between Katniss, Gale and Peeta, much like Twilight is a love story between whoever the three main characters of that book are. In fact I see a lot of fan discussion about how Katniss should choose Gale, or should choose Peeta, or neither, or whatever. These sorts of things seem, to me, to be badly missing the point of the book. And here's why. This book appears to me to be deliberately constructed as allegory, with the characters each symbolizing an aspect of human culture or ideology. And how they interact is a metaphor for how cultures act, react and evolve. And it's all pretty brilliantly done. Here are my interpretations of the symbology involved in the book: Katniss - represents human society as a whole. This, to me, is so blindingly obvious and so deliberately presented, that I find it almost incomprehensible that people don't immediately get it. Viewing Katniss as an individual is completely missing the point. Katniss represents all of us. Peeta - represents morality, altruism, loyalty and everything that is good and noble about humans. He is Sam to Katniss's Frodo. He is the conscience of the story. He provides Katniss with her moral compass and her aspirations to be good, aspirations she frequently falls short of. Gale - represents rebellion against authority. Gale is Thomas Paine and Che Guevera rolled into one person. His entire purpose revolves around fighting against what he sees as oppression, and he has no visible limits to the lengths he will go to oppose his enemies. Prim - represents hope. Not much more to say here, Prim is the center of Katniss's life, and the entire story revolves around Katniss's desire to keep Prim (hope) alive. That is, I believe, very deliberate. President Snow - represents absolute authority. But NOT, as some have supposed, absolute evil. Snow is not Sauron, nor is he the Sith emperor. This book is far more subtle and complex than that. Snow is brutal, remorseless, inexorable and violent. But Snow is not the source of the evil in the book, he is merely its face. The evil is buried deeper in the soul of society, and is revealed through Katniss's own actions. President Coin - well... I can't reveal what Coin represents in case some of my readers have not yet finished all the books. What Coin represents is almost the core of the final true climax of the book. So to reveal that would be to essentially spoil the books. Haymitch - perhaps the most enigmatic figure in the book. I believe Haymitch represents the author's proxy, much as Farimir represents Tokien's proxy in Lord of the Rings. Haymitch is the one who pulls the strings from behind the scenes. He is Katniss's soulmate, but he is badly damaged. He provides a way for the author to telegraph her intentions to the reader. Even many of the "bit part" characters are clearly archetypes as well. Madge, Johanna, Finnik, even Katniss's mother have specific roles they play to weave the cultural actions, reactions and evolution outlined in the books. When Katniss is kissing Gale, that is an allegory for cultures flirting with rebellion. That, I believe, is entirely deliberate. The fact that the story works as a character study is simply a demonstration of the author's skill in wrapping the layers of the story in a vehicle that allows it to be delivered to readers in an entertaining, gripping manner. But it's done so well that I believe the deeper purpose may well escape some readers. This has definitely gotten onto my list of best stories ever. I believe this story will grow in reputation over the years, as more and more people realize what Collins actually accomplished here. I am totally humbled by this book. This is a tour de force of writing. A masterpiece. It is so brilliantly done that it may well be too brilliantly done. I hope not. The message in this book is a powerful indictment of authoritarian central government and a full-throated scream for the freedom and empowerment of individuals. I love Katniss. I love these books.

Comments (10)

CosmicConservative
One of the most frequent complaints about the story is how Katniss is changed in "Mockingjay" compared to how she acts in "Hunger Games" and "Catching Fire." **** WARNING SPOILERS WARNING WARNING **** I can't help but shake my head. I see comments like "Katniss wouldn't hide in a closet!" or "What happened to our fearless warrior girl?" I personally find the physical and emotional breakdown Katniss experiences in the book as heartbreakingly realistic. She goes through literal and figurative hell. It is too much for any human to endure. For her to have suffered what she suffered and not have reacted the way she did would have been far too unbelievable. Hiding in closets rolled up in fetal position desperately hoping not to be found.... That's exactly what human beings who have been broken do. In fact, it is through this breakdown that Katniss's true strength and resilience is actually revealed. She is broken, but not destroyed. Damaged, but not defeated. But she's not appealing. And if there is one thread that I see repeated in the negative reviews of Mockingjay, it can usually be broken down into "I didn't like seeing Katniss being so unattractive." Again, I can't help but feel that people are missing the point entirely. The fact that some people see Katniss as "weak" in Mockingjay, tells me that most people don't actually understand what strength really is. It worries me how superficially people view this transformation. It's like they want a comic book heroine, not a human being. But Katniss has to be a human being since she represents humanity itself. For her to not break under the pressure would have turned this story into an unbelievable mess. She had to break. And she did. It was how she broke, and how she rebuilt herself that matters. Another common comment is that Prim's death was anticlimactic, and that such a thing should have been the central aspect of the book's climax. Again, I feel that this misses the point. Prim had to die. Katniss had to lose her, because of what both represented. Katniss had to go on after all hope was lost, broken, confused, lost... that's what society has to do after war. They have to rebuild hope somehow. The book would simply not have been complete without Katniss breaking, Prim dying and Peeta planting the primroses around Katniss's house as part of the rebuilding of hope in the world. It isn't pleasant, but that's the whole point.
CosmicConservative
Heh, we'll see. I think my track record with identifying great works of fiction is pretty solid.
Dadman
Oh, I don't disgree with your assessment of the trilogy. I mean you're totally in love with Katniss. Nyuk! Can't say I blame you though; she's an awesome character... ;)
Dadman
Darn, my attempt to initiate some light-hearted banter fails again. Sigh...
CosmicConservative
Heh... I am pretty busy today, actually. I had a short response prepared but got called into a crisis meeting before I could finish it, and eventually just deleted it...
CosmicDaughter
Since we did talk about this, I still feel like I need to read the books again, but everything you said makes complete sense. The Hunger Games trilogy is probably the most symbolic story I've read in teen literature besides Ender's Game and Harry Potter. Again, I'm glad you liked these books, and I'm glad they inspired you to write again ^_^
Dadman
I just finished the trilogy and absolutely loved it. 'Mockingjay' may be my favorite of the three books. I agree with your assessment of 'Mockingjay' above (I had not read it until now). These books are brilliant literature and I look forward to seeing how well they are translated to film...
CosmicConservative
"Catching Fire" will be easy enough to adapt to film. It will be very similar to "Hunger Games" both in tone and in execution. I expect that to be as good as the first movie. "Mockingjay" is going to be tough. Probably tougher than the producer and director realize yet. Because Mockingjay is so drastically different in tone and scope, it will seriously challenge the filmmakers to transition from a small story of a few dozen people in small rooms and a controlled arena into a violent continent-wide war with cities burning, mountains collapsing, fleets of hovercraft bombing... Done right "Mockingjay" should have a bit of "Saving Private Ryan" feel to it. Or maybe "Band of Brothers." Casual filmgoers who expect another film in the same vein as the first two are likely to be seriously surprised.
Dadman
I think the most formidable challenge of translating 'Mockingjay' to film is making it accessible to its largest fanbase - which is teens and pre-teens - while preserving the gut-wrenching drama, psychological themes, and overall serious tone of the book. I agree with you that the combat scenes in 'Mockingjay' should have a similar style and impact as SPR. That should be the goal, but SPR is a a fairly hard 'R' and I think the BoBs series was rated TV-MA. Anyway, I hope they don't water it down too much, but unfortunately I think they probably will given all the commercial implications. 'Ender's Game' is supposed to be released next year. As you well know its themes are very similar to 'Mockingjay's'. I'm concerned they may not take EG seriously either. But of course EG is considered by most as more of an adult SciFi novel so maybe there's hope. These books are powerful allegories and I really hope the producers of the remaining two Hunger Games films (and Ender's Game too) make an effort to go beyond the superficialities and tell the deeper tale...