Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
Heh.. this has to be some sort of record between reviewing a book and then reviewing the movie made from the book. So, we saw the movie Saturday. Like fools we went to the IMax viewing, figuring that the movie would be real crowded but the IMax early afternoon viewing would be the least crowded. We ended up sitting in the next to last row in the theater. But that's the beauty of IMax I guess, we ended up with a view comparable to sitting in our normal spot in a non-IMax theater.... it just cost us four dollars more per ticket. I have to add my raves for the performance of Jennifer Lawrence. I also thought the other cast members were excellent. If I were a fan of the books on the level that I am a fan of the LOTR books, there is plenty I could pick apart. Haymitch being a casual drunk vs the book version of Haymitch being a falling-down vomit-stained drunk for example. But they did stick with the story much better than most movies do. Probably because Suzanne Collins was a co-writer of the movie script. The one thing that I have to point out for those who have seen the movie but not read the book is that the violence in the movie is downright tame compared to the book. Too tame, really. The movie just doesn't give the same emotional impact as the book from a pure graphic violence perspective. I suppose that was necessary to maintain a PG-13 rating, and I don't know how much it really matters except that gut-wrenching response was one of the main strengths of the book. None of the injuries sustained by Katniss or Peeta seemed remotely as serious or life-threatening as they did in the book. The notes in the parachuted items was probably a necessary movie device which avoided some of the problems Dune had with the internal dialog issues. In the book Katniss had to figure out Haymitch's strategies by inferring them from the timing and content of his sponsor deliveries. In the movie there's an actual note included. It diminishes Katniss's cunning and resourcefulness. But frankly don't know how else to have done it, so that's probably the best compromise. Not enough time setting up the Gale or Prim relationship. Too much reliance on a few longing glances or brooding stares. But again, the movie was long enough already, so it's hard to be too critical. In the end I think they did about as well as they could have with a book that had to be a real challenge to turn into a movie. For the most part I think they did an excellent job.

Comments (1)

CosmicDaughter
I agree with your review. Miriam and I talked about this today after work. It's probably the rating that Suzanne Collins focused on when she wrote the script. The movie had to be the same rating as the book, for teens.