So, let's talk about AI. As with just about everything in modern culture, people are drawing lines and picking sides. And as with just about everything in modern culture, those lines are being drawn according to tribal rituals and ideological biases. There is a growing sense that mobs of torch and pitchfork wielding villagers are going to start roaming the streets looking for anything AI related they can descend upon with hate in their hearts and rage in their eyes. The opposing camp is eagerly using AI for everything from writing emails to managing their finances.
And, as usual, I'm sort of in the middle trying to figure out what the true moral and ethical boundaries are in using AI, because AI is not going away. And there are legitimate reasons for using AI, many of which can provide a competitive advantage in everything from writing emails to job performance.
I've been using AI pretty substantially in multiple areas of my life, not just writing or research. In fact I am currently setting up an AI "Chief of Staff" to help me manage my many competing life priorities and keep track of things that I've tended to allow to slide, sometimes with negative effects. I'm using ChatGPT for that mostly, but I also use Claude.
For full disclosure I use AI in my writing. I have used ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Grok. I have paid accounts for ChatGPT and Claude. I've only used the free versions of Gemini and Grok.
So, other than the Chief of Staff thing I'm experimenting with right now, what have I used AI for? Well, here's a bulleted list:
- Proofreading. particularly focusing on spelling, grammar, and puncutation.
- Scene reviews. when I finish writing a scene, I bounce it off of AI and get AI's thoughts and recommendations. Most of those tend to be spelling, grammar, and punctuation issues, which is sort of disheartening sometimes, but oh well, it is what it is. But occasionally the AI will question the scene on more substantive grounds. It might suggest that I've used the same sort of terminology or wording multiple times in quick succession. Things like "He smiled" or "She nodded." It's very good at picking up stuff like that. It will occasionally suggest rewording a sentence, but I almost never like the reworded attempt. AI is reasonably good at READING scenes, so far at least I have found even the most advanced AI models to be very poor at WRITING scenes.
- Continuity reviews. When I finish a chapter I will submit that chapter to AI and ask for any continuity problems. Do my timelines check out mathematically? Do I say Friday is two days from Monday? Things like that. Again, AI is very good at that sort of thing.
- Brainstorming. Sometimes I'll reach a point in writing a scene where I'm not entirely sure what direction to take. In those cases I use AI like a sounding board, I might give it four options and ask which it likes best and why. Occasionally it makes a good point. Usually not so much.
- Comparisons to market comps. When I finish an entire novel I will allow AI to read it and I usually ask it to rate the story on the following axes:
- Literary merit
- Prose effectiveness
- Genre reader appreciation
Again, occasionally it provides some meaningful feedback. Usually it will flag any significant sections of the book that focus on world building or character development as "slow" because AI tends to focus its evaluation on plot movement. That's because plot points can be mathematically tracked and analyzed. I occasionally will reread sections to see if I agree that a chapter or scene truly does "drag." Occasionally I grudgingly admit the AI has a point, and in those cases I'll try to rework the scene to be more attentive to plot elements. I admit I have a tendency to fall in love with my world building, or get caught up in character relationships and dialog.
What I do NOT do with AI is ask AI to write anything for me. In fact I have a strict prompt guideline that tells AI that I DON'T WANT the AI to rewrite or reword my prose. It's OK to point out what AI considers to be a problem, I'll look at it myself and decide if I agree. But as I said above, AIs tend to write truly terrible prose. It amazes me when I see "authors" bragging about using AI to write a book in a week and sell thousands of copies of the drivel. But they do. I won't. I find that to be unethical, misleading, and deeply dishonest. But what are you going to do.
I'm very interested in seeing where this "Chief of Staff" experiment takes me. I'll let you all know.


