So, for what it is worth, here is my take on the Duck Dynasty founder's "homosexuality is illogical" kerfuffle:
Fundamentally this is an issue not so much of "freedom of speech" but this is simply the latest front opened up in the ongoing culture wars between the hard core left and the religious right.
The comments made by Phil Robertson are essentially a mild restatement of the biblical New Testament statements about homosexuality and sin, peppered with a bit of Phil's trademark colorful backwoods coarseness.
The reason Phil has landed in the crosshairs of the left's personal destruction machine is because he has committed the most hated of all behaviors to the hardcore left. He has expressed Christian values on morality and sin, and has stated that people will ultimately be judged for their behavior. This is like waving red meat in front of a starving tiger.
I have to believe that Phil is smart enough to have realized the consequences of his statement. He has to know that the Left is, and has been for years, engaged in open and all-out war against Christianity. He has to have known that making a public statement about Christian views on homosexuality would light the fuse of outrage and retribution that has fallen on him now.
So I have to believe that this is deliberate, and that Phil wanted to directly confront the left on this issue.
If so I understand the desire to do so. However, I think that our society has long ago passed the tipping point on this issue and there is no way that Phil and the religious right can win this thing. In the end it will almost certainly result in the cancelation of "Duck Dynasty" and the permanent destruction of Phil and the rest of the Duck Dynasty family in the realm of public opinion. The stakes are simply too high for the left. Phil has committed the ultimate sin against the left, and he must be made an example of.
So, my previous post on the "Super" and "Micro" moons were a rather tame example of my problem with mainstream media "reporting" about "science". Here is a much more common sort of example, with a reporter from "The Atlantic" hyperventilating about "warp drives" and travel to Alpha Centauri in two weeks. (Note to those who might have some understanding of relativity. She's not talking about two relative weeks which would be over four years in earth-time. She means four weeks in earth time AND ship time.)
So, one-tenth the speed of light and we could be there in 40 years. That's not half bad. As Seager notes, many people would be willing to give up Earth and make that assuredly miserable journey for the privilege of being the first humans to explore another solar system. But still: 40 years, it's no cakewalk.
That's why a new number, care of NASA physicist Harold White, is so stunning: Two weeks. Two weeks to Alpha Centauri, he told io9, if only we can travel by warping space-time.
How is such a thing even theoretically possible?
Well, the concept is based around a highly controversial paper published years ago which has generated wild speculation among the pseudo-scientific about zipping through the universe like the starship Enterprise. Here's how it "works".
Heh, notice the Federation starship image there? I wonder if the Atlantic got permission to use that image in their article.
Anyway, I'm not going to pretend to understand all the math involved in this, it's highly speculative interpretation of general relativity equations generated essentially by assuming a mathematical symmetry between positive and negative energy. The rationale behind the "theory" (and I put "theory" in quotes because this sort of proposed starship drive is not only not theoretical, it's based on such a highly controversial interpretation of general relativity equations that "wild guess" is a better word than "theory" to describe it) was first inspired by the sudden "realization" that the universe is mostly comprised not of normal "matter" (the stuff that makes up you, me, the earth, the stars, galaxies, and everything else we can see), not even of exotic "dark matter" (the stuff that gravitational mechanics analysis of the universe seems to imply has to exist in huge amounts and makes up the vast majority of the universe's mass, even though we can't see it and have no idea what it is), but that the vast majority of the universe is actually made up of "dark energy" which not only dwarfs normal matter, but dwarfs "dark matter" and is the driving force behind the expansion of the universe which will eventually rip apart the very protons and electrons themselves.
"Dark energy" is theorized to be constantly flooding the universe and appears to come from nowhere, as far as our normal physical laws of the universe are concerned.
Well, this guy, Miguel Alcubierre, took that idea and made the assumption that "dark energy" is essentially what you get if you flip the mathematical sign on Einstein's general relativity equations. Which is fine, in a way, that's not terribly controversial. Other physicists have speculated that dark energy could arise in that fashion and the result would be a set of symmetrical field equations, which is always highly desirable by physicists. Physicists love symmetry. Symmetry is the fundamental concept that drove Einstein's general relativity theory, and was a driving concept behind Newton's theories as well.
But there is not only no experimental evidence to support this idea, there is no plausible means of devising an experimental test. It's closer to metaphysics than it is to real-world physics. It's fun to contemplate, but it's really pure speculation at this time. But even that speculation is generally done in cosmological scales with no real exploration of where all the energy comes from to do this stuff. (One of the truly amazing things to me about modern cosmological high-energy physics is that the entire concept of "Dark Energy" totally violates everything physicists have ever believed about the "Law" of conservation of matter and energy. It totally violates that "Law" and nobody seems to care. But I digress, this sort of thing will eventually lead me to discuss why I can't believe that black holes are what they are supposed to be...).
Anyway, what Miguel Alcubierre did that was so breathtakingly revolutionary is that he assumed that the dark energy theories can be applied on a local scale. Since the whole new cosmological model is all about how the space-time continuum is as malleable as cookie dough, he just asked the question "can you warp space and time locally? And if so, can you use that as a means to travel through space?"
Then he just started applying the equations to see what it would take to warp space to the degree that a ship could travel "faster than light".
That last part is in quotes because even these equations assume that in local frames of reference you can't travel faster than light. Instead you have to stretch or compress space-time outside of the ship, while maintaining a "bubble" of "normal" space-time for the ship to survive the process.
That led to the concept of warping space-time in front of the ship (compressing it) and in back of the ship (expanding it). The combination of the two results in the ship "moving" from one location to another, while remaining dead stationary in its local frame of reference. Meaning the ship itself would feel no acceleration from the process.
The problem is that the equations suggest that while this might be possible, it requires energy input that is truly astronomical. The first proposed technique would have required the total conversion of Jupiter's mass into pure energy in order to move a ship from our solar system to Alpha Centauri.
Which seems a bit excessive since even if it would work, there aren't enough Jupiter-sized masses laying around to convert into energy, so this would be a one-time effort. Not to mention that the total destruction of Jupiter might offend some environmentalists' sensibilities and they might register a lawsuit to stop the endeavor.
But since that early paper enthusiasts have refined the process and come up with tricks that reduce the amount of energy required to manageable levels of matter-energy conversion.
This is fun to speculate, not just because of the potential for writing stories with some supposed link to theoretical physics, but also because of the remarkable ramifications of such a "warp drive".
Basically this sort of drive would potentially operate in a very, very similar manner to the "warp drive" as conceived by Gene Roddenberry in the iconic "Star Trek" TV series and movies. One of the things that always used to amuse me is how the ship would accelerate to faster than light travel on a dime without crushing the ship from the acceleration effects. The drive as proposed would keep the ship in a stationary local frame of reference, so you could, hypothetically, drink your coffee comfortably as your ship zipped along its jaunt through the galaxy.
In fact, if plausible, this sort of drive would not only make travel within the galaxy feasible, but would also make travel BETWEEN galaxies possible. That is beyond amazing.
Of course all of it is currently nothing more than a crazy idea that exploits several completely untestable hypotheses, including the need for us to finally completely understand dark energy and how it can be manipulated, but at one point that's what all new theories are. Einstein's relativity theories were no less mind-bending when they were first proposed, and yet we now accept them as basic universal laws.
Unfortunately there is a major, major problem with this theory. That problem is that if this sort of drive is technically possible, then even if intelligent life is rare, by now some race of space-faring aliens should have created fleets of galaxy-spanning ships zipping around like buzzing bees.
Which takes us back to the famous question first proposed by Enrico Fermi: "Where are they?"
I haven't posted anything about my ongoing effort to complete my first novel in a while. Things have been moving forward, in large part due to the weekly novel writing workshops I've been taking. I've truly learned a lot about writing novels in those workshops. Turns out that there really is a "craft" aspect of writing novels, and I have always been pretty good at the "craft" side of most endeavors...
So here's where I am. I am on my third rewrite of the first draft. I'm on chapter 12 out of some 36 chapters, so about 1/3 of the way through what I hope will be my final rewrite effort. However, as with all previous rewrites, I have added some significant new plot points and that has meant throwing out whole chapters and adding whole new chapters, so there will probably be a fourth rewrite if only to polish up the newly added content. Sigh...
In the original draft I had the protagonist's mother being killed along with 90% of the village by the invading army. In this rewrite I have added a major plot thread involving Lirak's mother being captured due to a twist in her own past that she had never revealed to her children. This twist also ties directly into the main plot point of Lirak figuring out his dreams and mastering his own abilities.
In the FIRST draft the main conflict of the book was supposedly Lirak and his army vs the invading army. But I never felt comfortable with that conflict since the invading army was not only hundreds of times as large as any force Lirak could put together, but also had vastly superior technology (iron age vs. stone age basically). So after struggling with why the conflict felt so flat time after time, in spite of some (I think) gripping battle scenes where Lirak's brilliant tactical mind and super-human abilities allowed them to defeat small units from the invading army, I finally realized that the real challenge for Lirak which he must figure out and overcome was not the invading army (which he has no chance of defeating) but was his ability to interpret the meaning of his dreams and figure out what his abilities and powers are and how to unlock them.
That has meant some SERIOUS rewriting of almost every scene in the book. But I think the end result is a far more interesting story, where Lirak ends up at the end of the first book with a hugely important victory which unlocks his true potential, instead of ending up in an ignominious defeat as he is driven from the forest by the invading army.
So still some serious work to do, but the overall story is feeling like a truly interesting story now, and the conflict is feeling much more compelling and vibrant. Plus this gives me a chance to do a lot more exploration of the world's magic system and how it is used by both the good and the bad guys. Plus it gives me the opportunity to create more of a personal level of conflict between Lirak and the leader of the invading army's chief wizard since with the capture of Lirak's mother, there is now a way to overcome the previously plot-hampering difference in languages and culture between the two.
Anyway, I'm really liking the new approach, and it drives much more cleanly and directly towards the true plot of the overall story, gives the reader some good feeling as the book ends and (hopefully) whets the reader's appetite to see what Lirak can do now that he's unlocked his own powers to some extent.
Tonight I get direct feedback from the workshop attendees on the first three chapters.... I'm crossing my fingers...
When my father-in-law passed away one item from his garage collection of life's detritus fell into my hands. It was an old bamboo fly rod. Since I am the only fly fisherman in the immediate family, it was naturally assumed that the fly rod would find a home in my fishing collection. Of course I was happy to have it both as a potential additional fishing implement, and, more importantly, as a memento of the life of a hard-working, decent, caring and intelligent man.
Alas, after taking it to a local fly rod shop which specializes in restoring old bamboo fly rods, the rod is essentially unusable due to years where it appears to have soaked up so much water that it has de-laminated to the point of structural failure. Still it remains valuable in non-fishing ways.
But the whole episode exposes the atavistic side of my own personality, a side which is surprisingly strong for a person who is totally into technology in virtually all of its forms.
I don't own a functioning bamboo fly rod. It turns out that you can buy one for about $100, which is quite comparable to modern graphite fly rods, of which I own several. So there is no reason, other than financial limitations, for my next fly rod purchase not to be a bamboo rod. Of course if you buy a bamboo rod, you really need to buy silk fly line to go with it if you truly want to complete the "traditional" picture of the compleat angler. And I admit, I have a strong desire to do exactly that.
There is something very appealing to me in the idea of using a traditional bamboo fly rod along with flies I have tied myself using traditional patterns, materials and techniques. Doing so provides a sort of link back to generations of anglers and to a simpler, slower world that we've all but left behind, and which will likely disappear entirely within this century. To catch a fish, especially a spunky sixteen inch trout, with such gear would be a proud moment.
Again, back to that quiet, contemplative, atavistic side of my personality, at such moments I can understand how some people view modern technology as dehumanizing and spiritually destructive. This is the side of me that makes me pick up a flint rock and try to make a functioning knife, arrowhead or spearhead. Or the side that wants to one day build a canoe out of traditional pre-technological materials and go fishing in it.
Isaac Asimov once wrote a short story about human civilization which had forgotten simple arithmetic because technology had developed to the point that it was self-sustaining and humans no longer participated even in the production of technological devices, they simply used them. With ubiquitous calculators available from cradle to grave, humans had forgotten how to add, subtract, multiply and divide. In this world one man eventually became curious about how calculators worked, and essentially reverse-engineered simple mathematical rules. He attempted to educate others about his discovery but the common reaction was a deep aversion to his "parlor tricks". Calculators were, after all, free and made no errors.
Sometimes I contemplate the far future and see a time when human civilization (perhaps with or without actual "humans" involved) has colonized a large portion of our galaxy. I wonder if there will remain even the tiniest fraction of historical knowledge about humanity's past and the long, arduous struggle from the muck and mud of pre-historical hunter-gatherer societies. At some point whatever beings have replaced the humans we know today may try to determine the point of human civilization that provided the most rewarding lifestyle which balanced the human's connection with nature against their utilization of technology.
And I think the bamboo fly rod and hand-tied flies just might epitomize that perfect blend of the two sides of human nature.
It seems to do it for me anyway. Yeah, I'll be getting a bamboo fly rod, and I'll be using it with silk line and hand-tied flies, and I will quietly revel in the contemplation of the simple fusion of nature and human ingenuity as I reel in a spunky cutthroat trout.
I've been in lots of disputes and debates over the years about Islam, Islamism, Islamophobia and Islamic jihadism.
In every case I will be lectured by well-meaning libertarians and leftists who say that the world is simply bubbling over with calm, moderate Muslims who are lumped into the jihadist set by ignorant Islamophobes who believe only in a caricature of Islam.
So here is my challenge.
Let's define "Moderate Muslim" in the same way that we would define "Moderate Christain." In pure black and white terms let's define a "Moderate" as one who does not demand that government itself should be a theocracy.
That's more or less the definition of "secularism" and "secularism" has been the hallmark of "moderate" religionists for going on five hundred years. Secularism is the very foundation of the US concept of freedom of religion meaning that you are free to practice your religion, but you are not free to use the legal mechanisms of the state to enforce a state religion. At a more fundamental and important level, it means that government can be "of the people, by the people and for the people" with laws and customs being defined through democratic means.
When you look into the statements of "moderate" Muslims, however, you find no such acceptance of secularism. In fact you find it repudiated directly in favor of Sharia law, the theocratic rule of Muslim religious authorities operating under the iron heel of Koranic mandate.
So the next time I am in a debate on the subject, I am going to take the position that unless a Muslim "authority" on the subject is willing to accept secular rule coexistant with religious practice (which is the fundamental concept of "freedom" in the West), then the word "moderate" does not remotely mean what "moderate" means when applied to any other "authority" from any other religion. In that sense "moderate" when applied to a Muslim "authority" means "only slightly less extremist and theocratic than the average Muslim".
So I had a dream.
In real life the Cosmic Daughter is about to graduate college, and the Cosmic Son is about to graduate from high school. And I haven't been in college at all since about 1986.
In the dream I was taking college classes, and the Cosmic Daughter was too, but the Cosmic Son was still in grade school.
Somehow I had to pick up the Cosmic Son from a school event between my classes, but the school event was at my daughter's college, so I had driven from work (yes I was working and taking college classes at the same time... go figure...) to the college to pick up the Cosmic Son, but he was not where he was supposed to be. So I called the Cosmic Daughter (since the grade school version of the Cosmic Son did not have a cell phone, I suppose) and we were frantically scouring the college looking for him.
Then I needed to wake up. But in the dream I didn't want to wake up because I hadn't found my son. So I fought to stay asleep.
But I woke up anyway, and spent about a minute in a fuzzy state of near-panic that I had abandoned a critical search for the Cosmic Son and would now never know what happened to him.
Weird.... No doubt it is full of deeper meaning...
Everyone knows that I am a firmly committed agnostic when it comes to theology, but on occasion I entertain the arguments for and against the existence of a supreme deity that created the universe and all that is in it.
Today, as I was preparing and eating my breakfast I think I hit upon the strongest argument yet for the existence of God.
Fresh-picked, fist-sized strawberries.
I assume all of my readers are familiar with the story of Prometheus. In Greek mythology Prometheus was a Titan, one of the race which preceded the Gods of Olympus, but who survived the battle between Zeus and Cronos when Zeus and his siblings overthrew the Titans (as the Titans had overthrown Uranus before them).
In Greek mythology Prometheus is the divine being who was variously credited with teaching humans to use fire, to slaughter animals and keep the good meat (as opposed to sacrificing it to Zeus) and in some cases, teaching humans the very foundations of civilization.
In reward for his efforts, Zeus chained Prometheus to a rock and had an eagle eat his liver every day, while it grew back overnight. That Zeus, what a kidder.
The allegorical message behind the Prometheus myth was that humans received the blessings of civilization as a divine gift, and you can trace that concept all the way through to the Declaration of Independence if you really want to. Prometheus means something like "forethought" and as a concept the name probably most closely means "reasoned thought" or something like that. That's not coincidental. Prometheus essentially is credited in Greek mythology as the being who taught humans how to be human.
Now, I am probably not the first to point out the striking similarities between Prometheus and Satan (Lucifer). Both were supremely powerful divine beings, Prometheus a Titan and Lucifer the most powerful arch-angel. "Lucifer" means "light-bearer" or "light-bringer" and the name has elements of fire associated with it.
Both Lucifer and Prometheus defied the supreme God of their respective mythologies to give humans their first taste of "knowledge." Both first taught humans how to (or how to try to) deceive that supreme God. Both were punished for eternity for their sins.
It has always been interesting to me that eating from the "tree of knowledge" was the "original sin" of Christian myth. In Greek myth that same event, delivered by Prometheus instead of Lucifer, was not considered to be a human sin, far from it, it was considered a key event in the growth and development of humankind.
Why do I bring all this up?
Well, lots of events of the past year or so have been used by Leftist moonbats to argue that the earth has grown tired of human arrogance and is out to teach us a lesson. Millions of words of drivel have been published by our major media outlets and spewed out on radio and television about how "mother earth" is striking back at us "arrogant" humans for our sins of burning carbon.
In it's most pure and essential form, the belief of these anti-human moonbats that "carbon" is an evil source of power is an absolute and direct repudiation of the use of fire itself. burning gas in your car engine is no different chemically and environmentally from burning a log in your fireplace, or in your cave to keep warm and to keep the beasts of night at bay. When people decry the use of carbon fuels, they are effectively calling human civilization itself a "sin." That's because there would be no human civilization without fire. Fire, in its various forms, is the unique and critical source of civilization.
When modern pseudo-intellectual moonbats talk about how earth is "fighting back" at humans for their arrogance, they are quite literally no different in any significant regard than the villagers who see a volcano and assume that the gods are displeased with the village. There is no substantive difference between Daniel Glover calling the Haiti earthquake a payback from mother earth for global warming and the seashell and feather decorated village shaman telling the village chief that the earthquake was caused by inadequate sacrifice from the village foodstores.
But there is a more fundamental and disheartening aspect of this anti-civilization perspective. Because at root, that's what it is. These people are striking a blow against the very foundation of civilization itself. They are quite literally saying that human beings would be better off without fire, so that our use of fire did not anger the spirits of the earth who are displeased when human beings display such arrogance.
In fact, these people aren't much different in principle than the hard-core fundamentalists of any religious stripe who argue that humans are too arrogant and need to be taken down a peg by their favorite sky-father.
In the end what this means is that for these people, Prometheus literally IS Satan. The "gift" of fire given to humans, as well as the gift of "forethought" or reason itself, is the most deadly of all sins because it has allowed humans to become too powerful and too populous for the good of the planet.
It's amazing to me that people can express these sorts of views without realizing just how atavistic and anti-rational they are.
I can accept the argument from some people that we need to carefully examine our use of energy and the growth of our species. I can accept that human civilization has had a demonstrable impact on the earth, and that from a purely naturalistic perspective, that impact has been detrimental to the "natural world" as we know it. However, I don't take a purely naturalistic perspective. Unlike most Lefty moonbats, I don't accept the notion that the earth was a pure and pristine magical wonderland before human beings arrived on the scene. I don't accept the notion that every single species on the earth is a special and unique specimen that must be preserved at all costs.
I take a different perspective. And that perspective is that human beings are the literal best hope for earth to have a chance to spread it's gift of life throughout the universe. No matter what human beings do on this planet, eventually the earth will be a lifeless ball of molten rock, spiraling down into the broiling surface of a red giant star. And that's if an asteroid, or a nearby supernova or any of a dozen other natural events don't wipe us out first. Super volcanoes, Pole shifts, orbital anomolies, comets, gamma ray bursts.... whatever your particular brand of poison, eventually something is going to destroy this earth. And if Al Gore and his ilk have their way, when that happens, all of earth's past, present and future will die and be forgotten. At this point in time only mankind has the potential to spread earthly life beyond this planet, and produce a civilization that can survive a solar flare, or a random passing black hole.
Al Gore and his ilk believe they are protecting the earth, instead what they are doing is making earth a cage instead of a cradle.
Prometheus gave humans the key to leave the cradle.
And I'm dead sick of those brain-dead Leftist moonbats who are hell-bent on taking that key and throwing it away in a misguided attempt to placate some sort of supernatural force which only they can see.
Carbon is that key. Prometheus was right.
So I've been thinking about life in general lately. I'm about to go on vacation and the first thing we will do when we land in Kentucky is head to a funeral. Those things always tend to focus your mind on your own life, for at least a few minutes. Also I had the experience of learning a valuable life lesson from my own daughter, which is nice to see that she's grown up level-headed enough to give me a wake-up call even. Yesterday the Cosmic Wife, Cosmic son and I drove to a large mountain reservoir that I've been wanting to investigate for a while, and it was an absolutely idyllic mountain lake, with very little conjestion. Although the lake has a very large and accomodating boat ramp, there were only two motor boats that I saw on the lake the whole time we were there. There were maybe half a dozen canoes and kayaks, but for the most part the lake was pristine and the water was clear and blue. The lake was dominated by the towering image of Pikes Peak just to the south. It made me once again decide that I just had to buy a boat. It's been too long since I've been out on the middle of a reservoir with a fishing rod, some soft drinks and some good old 70s rock and roll to listen to.
The whole "moving to Atlanta" thing has cooled down, my boss hasn't mentioned it in weeks. So it looks for now like we won't be moving for at least a year, and when we do, it will probably be just to move down into the city. I do love Colorado and would hate to have to leave it.
I've been trying to observe national and international events with a more detached and objective eye lately. I tend to get too obsessed in such things when I pay too close attention to them. I'm pretty much convinced that most of my caterwauling about this or that minor political upheaval is all just playiing harmonica on the Titanic anyway. This world is going to change drastically in the next few decades, and much of what I fret about will become more or less pointless if things go the way I think they will.
I was talking with the Cosmic Son about some of this on the drive to the lake. He was asking what the world would be like when people didn't have or need jobs anymore. He couldn't wrap his mind around an economy where people didn't spend the majority of their lives working. If technology continues to move in the direction it is moving, at the pace it is moving, I think it is likely that he will see a world where the majority of people in "developed" countries don't have "real" jobs. What jobs will people do when construction is done virtually entirely by machine? When trucks drive themselves? When the production of most necessary goods and services are automated and are done more efficiently and safely by machine than humans ever did? What will the humans do?
I told him that some people thought humans would turn into lazy, shiftless lumps who do nothing but interact virtually and lose interest in the rest of the universe. And I told him that some people viewed such a world as the final freeing of humans from enslavement to mind-numbing labor so that each and every human can pursue their natural interests unfettered by worry about material things.
Of course I think the real answer is a little of both. In some cases people will tune out and lose contact with reality, but others would pursue their interests with vigor and continue to expand the sum of human knowledge and experience. There will likely be social upheaval as the economic model of human-based labor finally crumbles, but a new economic model based on human intellectual and artistic pursuits would likely rise from the ashes.
Whatever the result, one thing I know with certainty is that most of the political and cultural conflicts of today will seem downright quaint.
Will it be a better world? A worse world? I don't know. A little of both, I suspect.
But I do know that I probably wouldn't want to live in it. We all tend to be products of our times, and I sort of like the world as it is today, with all its warts and problems. I like being able to jump in my car and drive 40 miles to an idyllic mountain lake where I can sit in the sun and watch the kayaks go by and feel the wind blowing in what's left of my hair. I like the challenges that my career has afforded me, and the fact that by and large I have been successful in meeting those challenges. I like that I had to make my own way in the world and did not rely on the charity of strangers to survive.
I can't help but think that we are witnessing the approach of a transformative cultural shift that will be comparable to the taming of fire, or the invention of the wheel, or the domestication of horses... I wonder just how much of that I will be fortunate enough to actually see.
Mortality is still with us. But for how much longer?
I've been engaged in some discussions about the nature of government, the obligations of citizens and the future of this country, and some of those thoughts might bear repeating here so that others can contemplate and comment on them.
What obligations does a citizen have towards the welfare of other citizens? Is the concept of "do no harm" enough, or are human beings obligated to sacrifice their own wealth so that others can live better lives? This really boils down to a discussion of the value of "altruism" and as such it's hard to contemplate without at least recognizing the philosophy of "Objectivism" which denounces any such obligation as a form of mutual enslavement. It enslaves the beggar to the availability of handouts from others, and enslaves the giver to the needs of the beggar. On the other end of the scale is the concept of collective ownership where nobody really owns anything individually, and all wealth is shared equally by society as a whole.
Of course I come down somewhere in between, but much closer to the Objectivist side than to the Collectivist side. But I am still open to the idea that human beings do have some obligation to provide some sort of safety net to keep other decent people from falling into despair.
But how far should that go? What amount of my personal wealth should I be obligated to make available for the welfare of others? 5%? 10%? 30%? 50%? Does it matter how much wealth I have? Does the mere possession of more wealth necessarily place a higher burden on me? This is the concept behind a "progressive" tax code, where the more money you make, the higher percentage you pay in taxes. This is where Obama wants to make his most drastic changes in our country, his goal is to drastically increase taxes on higher income earners based on his view that those who have more, should give more.
But even if I accept the notion that all citizens have some obligation to help others in need, AND if I also accept the notion that wealthier citizens should shoulder a larger share of that burden, is there any connection between how much I am obligated to give, and how that wealth should be disposed of? What if I don't approve of the method of distribution? Am I obligated to give "my share" anyway, even when my personal ethical code is violated by those who do the distribution? Does the government itself have any moral obligation to ensure that my own ethical code is not violated by what they do with my money?
Of course these are considered subjective questions because different people would answer these questions differently. But it seems to me that as we see much of the Western world falling into unsustainable debt while trying to fulfill their adopted "moral imperatives" of providing costly services to everyone regardless of the cost, while simultaneously raising the tax ceilings as high as possible. At some point there has to be some recognition that the path we are headed on is not going to lead to the promised land.
I had more to say, but my time is running out....