Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Some tax day musings

By CosmicConservative
I've been engaged in some discussions about the nature of government, the obligations of citizens and the future of this country, and some of those thoughts might bear repeating here so that others can contemplate and comment on them. What obligations does a citizen have towards the welfare of other citizens? Is the concept of "do no harm" enough, or are human beings obligated to sacrifice their own wealth so that others can live better lives? This really boils down to a discussion of the value of "altruism" and as such it's hard to contemplate without at least recognizing the philosophy of "Objectivism" which denounces any such obligation as a form of mutual enslavement. It enslaves the beggar to the availability of handouts from others, and enslaves the giver to the needs of the beggar. On the other end of the scale is the concept of collective ownership where nobody really owns anything individually, and all wealth is shared equally by society as a whole. Of course I come down somewhere in between, but much closer to the Objectivist side than to the Collectivist side. But I am still open to the idea that human beings do have some obligation to provide some sort of safety net to keep other decent people from falling into despair. But how far should that go? What amount of my personal wealth should I be obligated to make available for the welfare of others? 5%? 10%? 30%? 50%? Does it matter how much wealth I have? Does the mere possession of more wealth necessarily place a higher burden on me? This is the concept behind a "progressive" tax code, where the more money you make, the higher percentage you pay in taxes. This is where Obama wants to make his most drastic changes in our country, his goal is to drastically increase taxes on higher income earners based on his view that those who have more, should give more. But even if I accept the notion that all citizens have some obligation to help others in need, AND if I also accept the notion that wealthier citizens should shoulder a larger share of that burden, is there any connection between how much I am obligated to give, and how that wealth should be disposed of? What if I don't approve of the method of distribution? Am I obligated to give "my share" anyway, even when my personal ethical code is violated by those who do the distribution? Does the government itself have any moral obligation to ensure that my own ethical code is not violated by what they do with my money? Of course these are considered subjective questions because different people would answer these questions differently. But it seems to me that as we see much of the Western world falling into unsustainable debt while trying to fulfill their adopted "moral imperatives" of providing costly services to everyone regardless of the cost, while simultaneously raising the tax ceilings as high as possible. At some point there has to be some recognition that the path we are headed on is not going to lead to the promised land. I had more to say, but my time is running out....

Comments (8)

Andy
Hey Cosmic...a good read. When you have more time, I'd be interested in Chapter II.
Dadman
I have some stong feelings about this particular topic. In short, I believe it is our moral obligation to give and serve our fellow human beings according to the dictates of our conscience. Charity should be a manifestation of free agency. However, when the government presumes to mandate and force individuals to conform to their notion of charity - a clearly counterfiet charity - it is nothing short of evil...
esox67
To compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves and abhors, is sinful and tyrannical. Thomas Jefferson
Debt | Debt Negotiation
[...] » Some tax day musings CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains [...]
Andy
Dadman kinda hit my wheelhouse. And esox, also. Forced charity is nothing more than forced labor..."slavery." I think I'm a reasonable fellow, and truly do have compassion for people that just can't quite make it on their own due to circumstances BEYOND THEIR CONTROL. Dadman notes well that the dictates of our conscience should drive our giving. This very truth (that all truly loving people know in their hearts) is what has become a callous. Millions of generous, loving, forward-thinking folks have been so "burdened" by government that they have come to the "the hell with it!" attitude. Politicians, lawmakers, judges (and too many other leeches to name) owe our nation an apology. They have made slaves of freemen...and have made certain that the enslaved will never become free. I thank God always that THIS IS NOT "ALL THERE IS." Better world a'comin'...
CosmicConservative
Andy, are you channeling Ayn Rand?
Old Goat
The issue about supporting and aiding those who are less fortunate is really a separate one from the government using tax dollars to do so. When the government does this I have no say where the money goes, what programs are supported or not supported. Far too much of the government run charities, err, assistance, comes with far too much spent on administrative costs compared to what help is given. What if the aid being given supports and increases abortion benefits when I oppose abortion? What about how they run drug programs? Or housing? Having some bureaucrat deciding where the aid is to go is just giving more power to the government and creating a beholden group of people who become enslaved by the very system that is "morally" helping them. My brother had a lot of mental issues. My parents practically threw money at him to give him the help and support he needed to live. He really was incapable of continually holding a job. The more they gave, the more guilty he felt and yet conversely the more he expected. I also believe that the government itself is morally corrupt, and therefore cannot give any "charity" without it having a form of payback for them. Its not about giving aid as much as retaining power. Being poor isn't supposed to be fun or easy. Welfare doesn't help people, it enslaves them and gives disincentives to make the changes for themselves.