Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Book review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
Just wrapped up this book on my break. Yeah, I took it to work to read on my breaks. That's actually a first for a work of fiction. I mean I've brought lots of technical books, and even "Why We Get Fat" to work, but not to read, just to have handy if I had a question or wanted to look something up. This time I actually took a book to work so I could read it on a break. So... this is a book that in my opinion gets every big thing right about story telling. I do think it's got some issues with some of the small things, but I've rarely read a book that hits so many right notes on the most basic, and usually missed, things about story telling. Unbelievably great characters. Riveting action. Multiple layers of complex and sometimes shifting conflict. There were moments in this book that I teared up, and I don't tear up easily. Katniss, the protagonist, is one of the more compelling fictional characters I've encountered in a long, long time. Her life story is heartbreaking even before she gets thrown into a murderous last-child-standing-wins arena. The book reminds me of many other books for different reasons. Many people are comparing it to "Harry Potter" but I don't see any resemblance whatsoever to that bloated mass of incomprehensible magic and incompetent battle tactics. (Full disclosure, I liked Harry Potter, but the story in those encyclopedic tomes could have been told better and been more compelling at less than half the number of words). No, what Hunger Games reminds me of are the following works: "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson "Anthem" by Ayn Rand "Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card "The Giver" by Lois Lowry You might notice that all of those books are acknowledged to be deeply and deliberately political satires or exposes. Which is how I would characterize "Hunger Games." I hope that most readers understand that Katniss's story is not about Katniss. Katniss is used as a window into the dark nature of human political and social dysfunction. Katniss and Peeta provide a way to explore that dark dysfunction in a raw and visceral way. The clash of cultures between the Capital and the districts is a deliberate and merciless expose of the capability of human indifference to suffering, acceptance of defeat and imposition of power. I suppose some will consider it to be heavy-handed, but I found it to be very deftly done. This is a book that will get a whole lot of people thinking about the danger inherent in allowing overwhelming power to exist in the hands of a privileged few. Which is where this country is headed right now. I hope it helps to wake some people up.

Comments (14)

Dadman
I completely concur. I really enjoyed this story and look forward to reading the rest of the trilogy...just as soon as my son is done with Catching Fire. I'm glad you liked it...
CosmicConservative
Discussing this with the Cosmic Daughter this morning as we both drove to work (at 5:00 in the morning...) she asked what I thought might have inspired the story. My response was that I thought it could have been inspired by reading "The Lottery" while watching "Survivor." Today I read an excerpt of an interview where Suzanne Collins said she had the inspiration while channel surfing between "a reality show" and coverage of the Iraq War. Close enough I suppose... In reading some reviews of the upcoming movie I saw references to a Japanese book/manga called "Battle Royale" which has a similar high school children in a fight to the death theme. Having looked at some synopses of "Battle Royale" I don't think the accusation is fair, although there are some striking similarities. The movie reviews are remarkably positive, particularly about the performance of Jennifer Lawrence in the role of Katniss. The one thing that concerns me is the number of references to the "shaky camera" technique first popularized in "The Blair Witch Project" and horribly overrused ever since. Why directors are in love with the "immediacy" of a camera technique that has been demonstrated to give some watchers a motion sickness response is a mystery to me. I've never liked that technique and I don't get motion sickness. I'm hoping it's not actually too distracting. I'll probably see the movie this weekend. I'm looking forward to it.
jussayin'
Just finished the first book and into the second book. It struck me that this is a totalitarian regime. A few things stood out, no weapons allowed in any of the districts, socialized communities made to survive as best they can when the main provider dies. Oppression and acceptance because of failed prior fights. I think there is a hint of Sofie's Choice type of philosophy as well. Katniss is a great character, and while I understand she is young, sometimes making her immature, I find some aspects of her annoying, even though understandable. I've read a number of these type of books, where it is about the children providing the leadership against the oppression, in the aftermath of a major war/ global disaster that wipes out. The thing I keep thinking is that, wow, the current Democrats were the ones who survived. Not really, but it is like their projected view of how government should be able to control things. Sadly, too many Republicans seem to think the same thing. I agree about the Harry Potter books going on too long. I read the Sword of Truth novels, they have the same tendency to go on and on too much. Sometimes the simple story telling, keeping it less wordy and repetitive, makes the biggest impact. Too many authors tend to go overboard when they get a big novel out, and think they have to double their words in the second and so on, of a series. It is one of the problems I see with the Song of Fire and Ice series. (Which I've read all published books, and find enjoyable, or compelling.) My wife and kids have read the books, the movie coming out is what made me think I should read it. I will probably go see the movie as well.
CosmicConservative
There was a story on Fox News home page warning parents that the PG-13 rating for this movie may not be appropriate and that they may not want their kids watching a movie showing kids killing other kids. The book is quite graphic in describing the kid-on-kid violence. From the reviews I've seen the violence is not terribly graphic in the movie, but it's still kids killing kids. I wonder if those sorts of warnings will have any impact on the ticket sales.
Dadman
It's disconcerting that some of the pundits and talking heads out there can't seem to wrap their puny brains around the deeper level satire of this story. But to be fair, many of the fans of this book, and those who will flock to the film, are pre-teens so some concern might be warranted. I have to admit, though, to being annoyed by those who get their undies in a bundle so easily and seem hell-bent on shielding younger people from this story thus missing a very teachable moment. If I had younger kids (9-12 age range) I would ask them what they thought about kid-on-kid violence in a game format. I'd teach them what satire is. And I'd ask them if they see any similarities between Hunger Games and the present modern-day TV line-up. I think it would be a very interesting conversation. My son went to the midnight showing last night, btw, but I haven't had time to talk to him about it yet. He just said, cryptically, that it was good and stuck closely to the book. My wife and I are going to see it tomorrow. Can't wait. Katniss is my hero... ;)
CosmicConservative
A couple thoughts, because it's Friday afternoon and I'm sorta bored... I think we protect kids too much from what we consider "unpleasant" themes. I can't help but think of these sorts of things from a long-term perspective, instead of just the last fify years of cultural imperatives. For the vast bulk of human history (and I mean 99.9% of human history, in the hundreds of thousands of years of our existence) children were routine witnesses to what today we would find to be horrific visions of life and death. Not to mention casual observance of sexual activity occurring in their immediate vicinity on a regular basis. Children used to be welcome attendees at public hangings, floggings and other punishment of criminals. That occurred well into the 20th century. I can't help but think that our society's modern squeamishness about what our kids are allowed to see has a large part in why our kids are taking so much longer to mature than they did even a few generations ago. Life has been nasty, brutish and short for most of our existence, and the sooner we learn and process that, probably, the better. Because I can't help but think that for our own descendents lives are going to be nastier, more brutish and shorter than our own, mostly because we've stolen from them to fund our own indulgences. I know this will probably sound odd, silly or self-indulgent, but no matter. When reading "The Hunger Games" my primary reaction to Katniss is how much she reminded me of my own female druid character, Yleris, in my Pathfinder role playing games. In terms of life history, skills, personality and outlook, they are remarkably similar. While reading I frequently found myself thinking, "huh, that's just about what Yleris would do." It's going to be interesting tonight when I play Yleris in a game for the first time since reading the book how much of Katniss bleeds into my role playing, whether I want it to or not.
Dadman
Um...so I guess you would agree with me...that there is too much authority/parent hand-wringing when it comes to things like Hunger Games. Sure, it's a serious, brutal tale, but like I said, it's also a very teachable moment...
CosmicConservative
Well, sure, I think I agree with you on this specific case, but I think my take on what we should or shouldn't allow kids to see just might go beyond what you would consider appropriate. i suppose that's the TL:DR version of my comment. We are planning on seeing the movie tomorrow.
Dadman
The wimpification of men and children in Western Civilization is nearly complete. We may be more aligned than you realize. May the odds be ever in you favor...
jussayin'
I agree about the shielding of the children these days. I think about how kids playing sports are in leagues where you aren't even allowed to keep score (even though everyone does) or records of wins/losses, some games banned for being "dangerous", even school grades being played with so it makes the kid who knows they are sucking feel they are doing well. Kids are not being prepared for real life. The Hunger Games is a brutal series when you think about what is involved, and you can see totalitarian principles throughout it. It shows how individualism is viewed as dangerous, needs to be killed off. It also shows how any unrest is met with brutal force, even though that pushes the people further toward the "I canst takes no more" phase. My daughters went to the movie last night. They loved it. I'm nearly through book 2. Very enjoyable series so far, even though it shows the darkest side of government control, it shows very touching moments brought by those who would be free. I am looking forward to seeing the movie, but will wait a bit so I can finish the books and so I don't have to deal with over crowded theaters.
hungergamesfreak018
I'm glad someone is finally seeing it as more than just an entertaining book about children killing other children. Most people just can't seem to understand that there is an underlying message to our world--If we don't wake up, this is potentially our future. I agree that Katniss is a complex, wonderful character and I absolutely love Collins' portrayal of her. Obviously, it will never be a literary masterpiece, but I think that it does its job of entertaining and proselyting very well.
Calcman
I haven't seen or read it.....yet, not sure if I will, as the proof is that everything recent, in the last 30 years of so is propaganda crap. Isn't there enough classical literature to let your kids read, or are we so keeping up with the Joneses and PC shit that we have to be enlightened by our 12 year olds and their friends? Nowadays, kids rule and parents wear pink bicycle helmuts.