Unconstitutional?
By CosmicConservativeThe righty blogosphere is exulting over a Virginia judge ruling Obamacare unconstitutional. Now, to be sure, I think he ruled correctly. I think that if the SCOTUS eventually rules that the federal government has the power to force people NOT to NOT BUY a product, then you can pretty much kiss any concept of limitation to federal power goodbye.
BUT, the reality is that this is the first judge who has ruled this way, when two other landmark cases have already been decided the OTHER way, and dozens more cases challenging the constitutionality of Obamacare have been summarily dismissed as without merit.
So don't count me among those all excited about this ruling. From the first day this passed I have been consistently saying this will be decided by the Supreme Court of the United States. Nothing about this ruling changes that, and the judge deliberately refused to suspend enforcement of the law because he knows it too.
UPDATE, in case my "NOT to NOT BUY" locution is too hard to read... what is at stake here is that this law is not only asserting that the federal government has the right to regulate the health care market (a stretch in itself) but in this case, for the first time in our history, it is saying that no citizen has the RIGHT to NOT participate in a particular market. In other words this law takes the word "regulate" to mean not only that the government can control those who CHOOSE to participate in a market, but that it can FORCE citizens to participate in a market AGAINST THEIR WILL.
This is a critical thing to understand. It is why, for example, the ruling (I'm not a lawyer so I forget the name of the case) that farmers cannot grow wheat to feed it to their own cows to avoid wheat price and distribution regulations does not apply (as Obama/Pelosi/Reid have used this as the key precedent to support their assertion of the Constitutionality of Obamacare). At least then farmers can choose NOT to grow wheat. So this is a huge new power that the federal government is seeking, and if it is allowed here, it can be forced anywhere. If the government decides hybrid cars are essential then they can FORCE you to buy one.
That's what's at stake here.
UPDATE 2: Oh, and to be clear, I find the ruling about farmers growing wheat and feeding it to their livestock to be one of the most egregious rulings in the history of the SCOTUS. The whole purpose of that ruling was to justify yet another federal power grab for the purpose of setting up a government bureaucracy to regulate the production of wheat and other crops. It is hard to call this an actual "free country" and realize that a rancher cannot set aside 40 acres of their own land to grow wheat which they then haul over their own land to feed their own cows on another pasture they own. But that's the law of the land in the USA.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.