Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL Week who cares report

By CosmicConservative
Blah blah, Football sucks. Miserable season in virtually every imaginable way... Denver looked like they couldn't beat Colorado State University. Dallas made it interesting, but that's all. I guess I should focus on the positives... Tom Brady is having another career year, in fact one of the most impressive years yet considering the receiver talent drain on the Patriots. Yet Brady continues to be one of the most precise and effective passers in league history. Should be an MVP candidate, imho. Not a lot of people this year saying Brady is a poor cousin to Peyton Manning.... (Plus I did take some schaudenfrade in Jay Cutler reverting to form against a defense that knows how to confuse him.) New Orleans is still not quite back on track, but they are at least winning again. They should be a force in the playoffs, and if they continue to improve, could go deep into the playoffs again. Mike Shanahan is doing almost exactly what I predicted he would do so far. He continues to have personnel problems and his teams continue to make mental mistakes which cost them games. This is what he did here in Denver. Most people who considered him some sort of super genius when he won two Super Bowls in Denver forget that the majority if the team he won two Super Bowls with was inherited from (cough, cough) Wade Phillips. Wade sucked as a head coach, but he's always been a pretty good judge of talent... Especially defensive talent. If you want to know when the Denver Broncos went south, it was when Wade's defensive scheme was finally completely removed in Denver and Shanahan began going through an amazing run of new defensive coordinators every year. That, coupled with Shanahan's inability to settle on a QB, as well as massively poor draft and free agent acquisitions is what started the Denver decline. Of course that accelerated with Josh McDaniels and now Denver looks like a joke. (Oh, this is supposed to be the positive view... oops.) Anyway, very little to look forward to in the NFL. Probably the suckiest season in a long, long time. Probably since the mid-80s when I was a Dallas and New Orleans fan and both were mired in mediocrity... Now I'm mostly a Dallas and Denver fan, and both are mired in, well, let's just say that mediocrity would be a major improvement for both...

Comments (9)

Yup
and earlier you thought Brady getting a nice fat extension would continue his decline. ;) I hated seeing Rodgers get another concussion; love seeing where the Chiefs are at. Shaking my head at the typically pathetic Favre; and laughting at the Jets. Loving this season - loving it.
CosmicConservative
I did say that Brady would continue his decline didnt I? Well, I'm glad that prediction didn't come to pass. In fact, in retrospect, that was really unfair to Brady anyway, his "decline" of last year is completely understandable in light of the injury he suffered the year before. It takes a while to recover from something like that, most QBs take a year to return to form. I apologize to Tom, I should have had more faith.
CosmicConservative
I hate to say it, but the enter Denver Broncos coaching staff looked totally and completely lost and overwhelmed on the sidelines yesterday. I mean totally. They looked totally shell-shocked for most of the game. And it ain't like Arizona is an elite NFL team. Geebuz, what if they had run into the Patriots?
Yup
been a lot of mid-season changes this year. Had McDaniels had a stronger GM above him it probably would have turned out a lot different. Gonna take rebuilding time now.
CosmicConservative
Yup, I concur. I think the biggest mistake the Broncos made wasn't hiring Josh McDaniels, it was not hiring a stronger GM and allowing such an untested person to assume too much responsibility too quickly. They should have given him a contract with the head coaching responsibilities and transitioning to personnel control over a couple of years, and than put a strong football-minded GM in place. I think if they had done that, McDaniels would still be here, there would have been no London video-gate and Cutler, at least, would still be in Denver. Maybe not Marshall, and probably not Payton Hillis, but we'd still have Cutler. Not that I think that would be a good thing...
Drax
Mike Shanahan was a "good" coach when he had a great quarterback. He became a "great" coach when Denver added a great running back. He has been neither since he has had neither. Who woulda thunk...
CosmicConservative
Drax, yes and no. In terms of pure head coaching ability, I would agree with you. But I have other issues with Mike Shanahan, and always have. Mike Shanahan is a dirty coach and a miserable leader. He repeatedly coached his linemen to do chop blocks even after the NFL outlawed them. Those are perhaps the most vicious, career-ending blocks in the game, and instead of building a line that could play fair, he, for YEARS, continued to coach the technique after it had been proven to be seriously injurious to people's livelihoods. Then there's the whole issue of how he manages his other coaches and his players. The guy went through five defensive coordinators in six years (or something like that). That is a stunning revelation of administrative incompetence. It is also a revelation of serious ego problems. Then there's the whole situation with his skill position players. Shanahan could not settle on a QB, running back or wide receiver once Elway, Davis and Rod Smith retired or became ineffective. He was never satisfied, and would rotate players in such a way that no player, not even his "franchise" players ever felt that Shanahan was committed to them. This continued all the way into the Jay Cutler era. The names of players who went through Shanahan's revolving door of penthouse to doghouse and back again is huge, including, but not remotely limited to, Javon Walker, Bubby Brister, Jake Plummer, Brian Griese, Gus Frerotte, Ashley Lelie, Reuben Droenes (sp?), Mike Bell, Clinton Portis, Mike Anderson... I mean the list goes on and on and on... How the heck can any team thrive when virtually every major skill player on the team is rotating from the bench to starter or getting traded from week to week? I mean I know that the NFL is an unstable work environment, but geez, under Shanahan it was clear that he used his roster as a way to communicate his displeasure to his players. The message was clear, get in Mike's doghouse, and you sit on the bench and are trade bait until you get out of the doghouse IF you aren't traded first. I really did not like him. I'm glad to see him doing the same things in Washington. Washington needs to be driven into the dirt like a whipped bull in a rodeo, and nobody could be better for that job than Mike. I just hope he uses a hefty dose of spurs...
Tom DeGisi
I've heard that Shanahan was only sucessful with players inherited from Wade Phillips. If true (and I am truly not remotely close to knowledgeable enough to say) Jerry Jones could compound your misery by hiring Shanahan to coach the Cowboys.... Yours, Tom