Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Tim Tebow must play

By CosmicConservative
Of all the bone-headed, ignorant, foolish, unaware, un-coachly things that the Broncos did yesterday, the most bone-headed, ignorant, foolish, unaware and un-coachly thing of all was not putting Tim Tebow in when Kyle Orton took a rib injury. Putting Orton back in when the game was lost, lost, lost, and Orton had already thrown three interceptions and been the cause of at least one fumble... Well, it tells me that these coaches are either just plain stupid, or else they have something against Tebow. I know there are a lot of people who are knee-jerk anti-Tebow people because Tebow has had the gall to speak out against abortion. I have no doubt that some of those people are NFL coaches. I'd put the odds at about 50/50 that Tebow's current coaches are among those NFL coaches. But regardless, Tebow must play. I can't think of any team in the past fifty years who would not have put a first round draft pick in under those circumstances. Kyle Orton is a known commodity. I like Kyle Orton. But it is quite literally true that there will never be a better time to put Tebow in a game than when the Broncos were down 3+ touchdowns in the 4th quarter and their starting QB after throwing three interceptions and fumbling the ball had received a rib injury. I mean it simply doesn't get any more "no-brainer" than that. This does not bode well for the Broncos current coaching competence.

Comments (21)

pace
Could it just be that they don't want to demoralize the guy by giving him field time surrounded by such a dismal team? No o-line and no running game to speak of doesn't provide the kind of environment to nurture your rookie QB. Count me as rather skeptical of the idea that he's on the bench because of his views on abortion.
CosmicConservative
Pace, I've read and heard a lot of NFL commentary where the undercurrent of his anti-abortion views comes through loud and clear to me. You can pretty much bet that anyone who criticizes Tebow and can't stop themselves from making some snark on his religion is fundamentally against Tebow because of that. Since the commentary and comments I've seen from fans on Tebow has been split pretty evenly between those who support him and those who call him "Jesus Freak" or who make some snide comment like the one I saw today ("If Yahweh wants him to play, he'll play"), I'm pretty confident that NFL coaches, players and front office have a similar split on him, and will until that becomes moot either due to his skills or lack of skills at the NFL level. And, oh yes, I absolutely believe NFL coaches could keep someone down because of their ideology. Absolutely I do.
CosmicConservative
Actually I didn't even answer that part of pace's question so thanks for providing that link Tom. pace, there is plenty of evidence to show that rookie QBs who get "thrown into it" tend to become better long-term QBs than rookies who are "protected" for long periods at the start of their careers. I don't know which examples I used with Tom but I'll throw out these names here: Terry Bradshaw, Troy Aikman, Brett Favre (heh, well, he's got the skills, it's his mental game I fault), Ben Roethlesberger, John Elway, Dan Marino, etc. Yes there are some great QBs who were gradually introduced into the role, most notably probably Steve Young. You could make a case that Roger Staubach, who shared the starting role for several games, was protected as well. So it's not a binary situation. But I believe the evidence favors getting them into the game early and often, regardless of the circumstances. Heck Troy Aikman didn't even win a single game his rookie season, the one game the Cowboys won in 1989 was won by backup Steve Walsh. By the way, Steve Walsh would qualify as one brought into the game slowly, and his career never took off even though he and Troy Aikman were considered near equals when both were drafted by the Cowboys in 1988.
Andy
These are different times for sure in the NFL. Even though I don't watch it much now, I catch a piddling bit of what is going on. I remember the '89 season with Troy. And, I remember the early days with Bradshaw (where he sustained damage to his...well...I'll just leave it at "sustained damage"). Elway was another. Timbow's place with Denver is puzzling to me. Heck, you don't pay a guy that many coins, and not at least use him to keep your ace from permanent frustration, or injury. Ya' gotta know that he's chomping at the bit, and even willing to get his own brains bashed in to build his own cred with his teammates. It's puzzling. But, it is Denver...and the corching ain't been worf a crap since my Daddy's second cousin was there. So... Man, that was a LONG comment that added nothing. I'm good at that. :)
CosmicConservative
Andy, Troy did take a beating, but the bulk of concussions he suffered which truly endangered his career and mental faculties occurred at the end of his career. In fact he suffered several in the year before he retired. He himself identifies the concussion he suffered in the 1995 NFC Championship game as the one that really made a difference. He claims not to remember anything about his second Super Bowl appearance, which occurred two weeks after that concussion.
Drax
Hmmm... Two thoughts in this. First that Teebow should play and, second, that throwing rookie QB's in the mix has a record of producing better QB's than ones brought along more slowly. I agree Teebow should be playing. I thought he should have been playing before now. I believe that he could, in a year or so, make this his team, with his winning personality. But, there's evidence to show that throwing rookie QBs into the game produces better QBs? How about Ryan Leaf? Alex Smith? Jamarcus Russell, Leinart? Vince Young? Jason Campbell? Etc. Etc. Some who are "thrown into the mix" ultimately turn out to be starting NFL QB's of whatever quality. Some are wash outs to one degree or another. Some who are brought along slowly ultimately turn out to be starting NFL QB's of whatever quality while others usually turn out to be back-ups -- with few of them flaming out like Russell or Leaf. I'm not sure there's "evidence" one way or another about (choose random 1st round draft pick QB on random NFL team) "throwing that QB into the mix" being a positive or negative thing as to that QB. What I do see is that some QB's (Matt Ryan - Matthew Stafford, for example) who can take a crappy team and make it better so that, over time, he becomes a star NFL QB and his team becomes a winning team. What I do see is that some rookie QB's who are put on good teams seem to fare fairly well (Big Ben, Eli Manning, Peyton Manning) whether they start immediately or later. What I do see is that some QB's don't seem to get it no matter when they begin playing full time or how quality of a team they begin playing with. What I don't see is a pattern.
CosmicConservative
Drax, there's a lot of ways to look for patterns in data. Part of the process is in determining how to isolate the data you are trying to evaluate. So, if the question is "does starting early improve the odds that a QB will become an 'elite' QB" then the best way to look at that is to look at "elite QBs" and then check to see if there is any pattern of how they started. If you try to take a random sampling of "rookie QBs" then you run into "noise in the system" issues with the data. So, If we take the top 10 QBs as rated by some Sports authority, and we see that a majority of them started early, then we'd be able to say that the data suggests some bias in favor of starting early. If we look at all rookie QBs and try to project forward, the problem is that there are so few "elites" that any tendencies that would produce "elites" can easily get washed out in the overall data variance. Here's the list: Dan Marino Fran Tarkenton John Elway Steve Young (not sure I agree...) Brett Favre (less sure than Steve Young...) Johnny Unitas Peyton Manning Roger Staubach Tom Brady Joe Montana It's not my list. My list would not include Brett Favre and would probably have someone like Bart Starr or even Terry Bradshaw on the list instead, but let's work with this one. How many of these QBs started in their rookie year? Dan Marino (selected to pro bowl even) Fran Tarkenton (4 TD in first game) John Elway (lined up under guard in first game) Johnny Unitas (set a rookie completion record) Peyton Manning (set several rookie QB records) So five out of the ten became the starter in their rookie season. I would add Brett Favre to this list since he was drafted by Atlanta but Jerry Glanville openly ridiculed him and refused to play him. He was traded to Green Bay and became the starter on, I think, his second game in Green Bay. Two others, Roger Staubach and Joe Montana, played extensively in their first year (Joe played at least a series in every game) and both became the starter at the beginning of their sophomore season. Tom Brady famously started his rookie season as the Patriots #4 QB, but by the end of the season was #2 and effectively became the starter in game 2 of his sophomore season when Drew Bledsoe went down with an injury. So basically of the top 10 QBs of all time, six were thrown into the fire their rookie season, with five of them playing the majority of the season in that role. Three of the remaining 4 became the starter by the second game of their sophomore season after seeing significant game play in their rookie season. Of the top 10 ONLY Steve Young can be said to have been "protected" and "groomed" as an NFL QB. I think that's pretty interesting and pretty indicative that, if nothing else, playing a rookie QB certainly doesn't HURT their chances of becoming elite. Interestingly, my list would probably replace Brett Favre with Bart Starr and replace Steve Young with, say, Dan Fouts, but that wouldn't change the results since Starr did not start until his third season (similar to Young) and Fouts started his rookie season (similar to Favre). If I wanted to "game" the data, I'd put Terry Bradshaw (started his rookie season) in place of Bart Starr and end up with 7 out of 10 starting as rookies instead of 6. So start Tebow.
CosmicConservative
We could also look at this another way. Let's look at what the top head coaches do with their top QB draft picks. Here's my list of the top five coaches in NFL history: Chuck Noll Tom Landry Don Shula Vince Lombardi Bill Walsh Noll and Shula started true rookies and let them play virtually the entire season. Tom Landry and Bill Walsh gave their top draft pick QBs extensive play in their rookie season and started them by game 2 of their sophomore season. Vince Lombardi groomed Bart Starr for two seasons. So four of five pushed their young QBs into starting roles, and two started their draft picks almost as soon as they got their locker assigned. If we add Bill Belicheck to the list, then he also started his future "elite" by game 2 of his sophomore season... I think the evidence is strong that a true potential elite QB should be put in the game as early as possible. ESPECIALLY if the season is otherwise over. In the case of Tebow and the Broncos last weekend, with the game out of control and the starting QB injured, it is inconceivable to me that Tebow did not play the last quarter. Inconceivable.
Drax
You can't compare yesteryear QB's with today's. It was commonplace for rookie QB's to start yesteryear. Throw them in the mix. You're going to stick with them for a few years and bring them along. You have them under contact. No union. It was a totally different time. (Not to mention that head coaches weren't fired after one bad season -- i.e., there wasn't the impetus to "win now" that there is today -- nor is there such a huge monetary investment in a single position such as there is today for 1st round picks.) It simply was different then. And, it simply stands to reason that some of the "best of all time" were QB's that started their rookie season since every QB had to start SOMETIME. And, the list of "elite" QB's almost entirely consists of 1st round picks. The ones (like Aikman, Manning, Favre, and others) who had crappy first/second seasons were stuck with by their coaches -- built around -- and they became elite QB's. Others (currently Big Ben, Vince Young, Drew Breese, Matt Schaub, Matt Ryan, etc (all first rounders who didn't have spectacular rookie seasons) were stuck with (or were traded to a team who stuck with him) and became "elite" over the years. The point is that, for every quarterback who started his rookie season and became "elite" over time, I can name you at least two from the same draft (on average) who did likewise and either flamed out, became a back-up, or journeyman. The "pattern," if any, is that throwing them into the mix (in these days and times) is the opposite of your assertion. But, I don't give any credence to EITHER proposition. It is entirely dependent on so many factors which are entirely out of the control of the quarterback. If he has a bad first season (say on a last place team) does the coach stick with him? If the coach sticks with him, does the GM draft or build the team so that the QB actually have a chance to win? (Stafford, Beck, Sanchez, Brees, Rivers, Campbell compared to Big Ben, Matty Ice, Peyton Manning) There has to be such a combination of individual qualities (compare Ryan Leaf to Peyton Manning) with qualities completely outside the control of the QB to create an "elite" QB that starting them in their first season or later really doesn't matter when it comes to creating such an "elite" QB.
CosmicConservative
No doubt there are lots of variables Drax. It's funny you should challenge my analysis because a few (two?) of the QBs in the list were not "modern age" QBs. I first considered using the top 10 of the last 20 years or so, but that would only have replaced Fran Tarkenton with, say, Ben Roethlesberger and Johnny Unitas with, say, Troy Aikman. The statistical results would have been identical (or perhaps even stronger) since both of those QBs started their first rookie game. In fact a quick glance at the ranking of QBs shows me that it has actually been MORE common for rookie QBs to start and become "elite" in the modern game than it was in the early NFL. If anything Bart Starr was the model for most NFL teams well into the 80s, not Johnny Unitas. I personally believe a part of that is due to the high cost of modern #1 draft pick contracts and the desire of NFL owners to quickly recoup some of that expense by giving the fans what they want. At least there is a lot of circumstantial evidence of owners pressuring coaches to play their high-priced draft picks. I still maintain that actual statistical analysis suggests that IF you are lucky enough to get a QB who has the potential to become "elite" the sooner you get them into the starting role, the better they perform in their careers, and the longer they give their teams (and owners) the benefits of their eliteness. And since most teams tend to be in the same spot as the Broncos when they get their hands on a potential elite QB (well below mediocre with their existing QB), it is uncommon for a situation to exist where the current starting QB is obviously a better bet for the organization. Which I would argue is true even for the Broncos now, as much as I like Kyle Orton. The Broncos are going nowhere now. Putting Tim Tebow in as QB for a team that has lost 16 of their last 21 games could not possibly "hurt" the franchise, even if Tebow proves to be a total bust. In fact at that level you could argue that losing more games can only HELP the team by improving their draft position. Where the Broncos are now, either winning more OR losing more provides benefits. Yes it's sad that a QB like Kyle Orton is hurt by the process, but that's how the game is played. If I were the coach I'd be looking for every reason I could to play Tebow. There is no down side and there is plenty of upside. Even if the upside is that Tebow does not demonstrate the ability to play at this level, at least then you would KNOW and the squabbles from fans and critics to FIND OUT would stop. There really is no FOOTBALL reason imaginable not to be playing Tebow for significant periods of time. That's why I suspect the reasons he is not playing are more likely to be personnel or ideological. I have ZERO DOUBT that any NFL team of the past century, when faced with the situation the Broncos had Sunday, with Orton obviously ineffective and hurt, would have played their rookie first round draft pick under those circumstances. It is my position that NOT playing Tebow in those circumstances is gross incompetence. It is a decision that I will not likely overlook in evaluating the new interim head coach's ability to coach at this level. Right now I'd say my impression of Coach Eric Studesville is a very poor one. Not just due to this decision, but due to the obvious lack of effort from the Broncos and the play calling in the game as well. But nothing is as glaring as having such a golden opportunity to evaluate the supposed future franchise QB of the team and choosing to put an ineffective and injured QB back into the game. That was just mind-blowingly inept. By the way, since my tendency to get into people's heads and dissect their internal motivations based on their external actions is well known, I'll do that for Coach Studesville. Here's the most likely reason why he did not put Tim Tebow in the game: He thinks that if he can somehow miraculously win these final four (now three) games, he might be the Broncos next head coach. And so his decision making has become irrational and he made the decision because he so desperately believed that a miracle might happen with Orton and the Broncos might have been able to pull off a historic comeback. That's why I think he made the decision. And I think that decision indicates that he does not have the right temperament to coach at this level. If I'm right he is letting his own personal ambition overrule reason, logic and common sense, not to mention what is best for his team. Plus I think his hope to become the next head coach is a fool's dream anyway. Bowlen is almost certainly going to hire a proven commodity this time. He went with the long odds bet with McDaniels, and I don't think you'll see him offer the job again to anyone who doesn't have a track record of winning in the NFL. Just my opinion.
CosmicConservative
By the way, looking at "The Bleachers Report" for the current supposed top 10 NFL QBs, all but three of them either started as a rookie, or played significant time as a rookie and started in the first four games of their sophomore season. The exceptions are: Phillip Rivers, who WOULD have started except for the resurgence of Drew Brees. Aaron Rodgers, who had to wait for Brett Favre to "retire". Tony Romo, who was not considered as a potential "elite" QB contender at all until he finally got the starting job by default when the Cowboys finally gave up on Drew Bledsoe. This list includes Joe Flacco, another rookie who started all 16 games for his team (and went on to win a playoff game as well). So that's 7 out of the current top 10 who either became starters their rookie season, or who had major play time and became starter early in their sophomore year. What is very interesting about this list is that two of the three current best QBs who did not get pushed into service as starters early in their career were held back by two other QBs on this list who did! (Brett Favre and Drew Brees) So you could argue the sole QB in the current NFL top ten who did not get to start as rookies or early in their sophomore year that wasn't held back by an elite QB who DID was Tony Romo. It stands to reason that if Aaron Rodgers or Philip Rivers had been on teams that didn't already HAVE an elite QB, they'd likely have started too. I think my point is made, hammered, cast in stainless steel and can be considered proven.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I also just have to point out that if you want to put Jay Cutler on this list (which I would not) he also became starter in his rookie season... As did Eli Manning... And Michael Vick, and David Garrard (albeit due to injury to the starter). In fact the only QB in the current top 10 QB rating list for 2010 that we haven't mentioned is Matt Cassel, another QB who was unfortunate to be on a team with an existing elite QB but who became a starter immediately upon being traded. The more I look at this the more clear it is that the NORM in the NFL is to get potential elite QBs into a starting role as soon as possible. In general the ONLY thing stopping a team from putting a top draft pick in as starter is that they already have a QB which they already had done just that. The SOLE exception to that seems to be the Tony Romo situation. And Tony was not a high draft pick so that makes sense.
Drax
Again. They have to start sometime. Other QB's who were taken in the first round and starting in their rookie season who are NOT "elite" quarterbacks VASTLY outnumber those who are. When you think about it, the VAST VAST majority of quarterbacks who are currently starting who are "elite" are 1st round picks. Let's take a look: Baltimore Ravens: Joe Flacco. Starting Rookie. 1st Round pick. Elite? Maybe. Cincinnati Bengals. Carson Palmer. Started Second year. 1st Round pick. Elite? Depends on the year you're talking about. 2005-7 probably. Never been the same since the injury. Cleveland Browns. Colt McCoy. Started first year due to injury to Jake Delhomme, the original starter. 3rd round pick (although was projected to be 1st round by most experts. Elite? Too soon to tell. Pittsburgh Steelers. Big Ben Roethlisberger. Started 1st year. 1st Round pick. Elite? Not hardly. Chicago Bears. Jay Cutler. 1st round pick. Started 1st year. Elite? Not hardly. Detroit Lions. Matthew Stafford. 1st round pick. Started first year. Elite? Too early to tell, but certainly not yet. Green Bay Packers. Aaron Rodgers. 1st Round pick. Rode the bench for years. Elite? According to most analysts. Minnesotta Vikings. Brett Favre. 2nd round pick. Rode bench first year. Elite? Yeah. OF ALL TIME. Houston Texans. Matt Schaub. 3rd round pick. Rode bench for years. Elite? By most accounts. Indianapolis Colts. Peyton Manning. 1st Round pick. Started 1st year. Elite? OF ALL TIME. Jacksonville Jaguars. David Garrard. 4th round pick. Rode bench for years. Elite? Not hardly. Tennessee Titans. Vince Young. 1st round pick. Started 1st year. Flamed out. Tried again. Flamed out again. Now, Kerry Collins, another 1st round pick. He started 1st year. Elite? Not hardly. Atlanta Falcons. Matt Ryan. 1st Round pick. Started 1st year. Elite? Questionable, but some think so. Carolina Panthers. Jimmy Clausen. 2nd Round Pick. Started 1st year. Elite? Too early to tell. New Orleans Saints. Drew Brees. 2nd round pick. Sat first year. Elite? Surely. Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Josh Freeman. 1st Round pick. Started first year. Elite? Sincerely doubt it, but its early yet. Buffalo Bills. Ryan Fitzpatrick. 7th Round. Rode the bench for years. Elite? Not hardly. Miami Dolphins. Chad Henne. 2nd round. Rode bench 1st season. Elite? Nope. New England Patriots. Tom Brady. 6th Round. Rode the bench first year. Elite? OF ALL TIME. New York Jets. Mark Sanchez. 1st Round. Started rookie year. Elite? Not hardly. Dallas Cowboys. Tony Romo. Undrafted. Rode bench for years. Elite? Depends on who you talk to. Philadelphia Eagles. Mike Vick. 1st Round. Played a little first year, but mostly rode the bench. Elite? Maybe today...hard to tell. Certainly had one of the best all time QB games I've every seen or heard about. Washington Redskins. Donovan McNabb. 1st Round pick. Started end of 1st year, but rode the bench 2/3rds of season. Elite? Not hardly. Denver Broncos. Kyle Orton. 4th Round pick. Played first season. Elite? Not hardly. Kansas City Chiefs. Matt Cassel. Undrafted. Rode bench early years. Elite? Not on a bet. Oakland Raiders. Jason Campbell. 1st round pick. Rode bench for years. Elite? Not hardly. (Can't forget Jamarcus Russell, can we? Maybe the biggest 1st round QB bust in the history of football -- maybe tied with Ryan Leaf - both of whom started their first years...) San Diego Chargers. Phillip Rivers. 1st round pick. Sat for 2 years. Elite? By most accounts. Arizona Cardinals. Derek Anderson. 6th round. Rode bench for years. Elite? Not even in an alternate universe. (Can't forget Matt Lienart, can we?) San Francisco 49'ers. Alex Smith. 1st Round. Played significantly 1st year. Elite? He's back-up to Anderson. Seattle Seahawks. Matt Hasselbeck. 6th round. Rode bench for years. Elite? Not likely. (Had good run 2003-2005). St. Louis Rams. Sam Bradford. 1st Round. Started first year. Elite? Not yet, for sure. So...what does this tell us? 1st. I'm amazed at what percentage of the current starting QB's started their first year (roughly 1/2). 2nd. The sheer number of 1st round picks who are starting QB's (and how many of them are bad, or have taken the job of another 1st round pick who was a bust..) 3rd. Of the "elite" (Rodgers, Favre, Manning, Ryan, Brees, Brady, Rivers) 4 of 6 rode the bench for 1 or more years. (You can put Big Ben in the mix if you want to, but on pure QB numbers, he doesn't belong in the mix.) But, at best, it's about 1/2 and 1/2. I'm sorry...I just don't see the pattern. Got 1st round picks sitting/starting - being "elite" and flaming out. Got undrafted/low drafted starting (mostly after sitting) and being "elite." Maybe you see something I don't.
CosmicConservative
See, you and I are looking at this from opposite directions. I've tried to point out that the approach you are taking does not allow for prediction because there's too much noise in the system. You simply can't take all draft picks, or even all high draft picks and follow them and say if they start or don't start they will or won't be "elite." There are too many other variables that skew the results. My approach is to say "start with the elites and see how they got there." That way our data set is entirely made up of elite QBs. I already pointed this out. It's like analyzing who could become President. You can't look at every citizen, there's simply too much noise. BUT you can look at all elected Presidents and analyze them and discover, for example, that Presidents TEND TO BE taller than average citizens. This is an important thing to recognize, but you could NEVER start with all average citizens and analyze all their attributes and conclude that if they are taller, they might be more likely to become President. Also, you aren't sticking to the parameters I set. I haven't said that the elite candidate has to "start in their first year". I said they have to get significant playing time, and that in general the elites became starters EITHER in their first year or in the early part of their second year. But the important thing is that they GET PLAYING TIME! Just a few examples from your list where you and I see the QB entirely differently. Matt Schaub. You say he "rode the bench for years" I say he started the final game of his rookie year and started multiple games his second year. Also Drew Brees did not START his rookie season, but he played significant time starting in November of his rookie year and was named starter his first game of his sophomore year. Again Brees is an example of MY argument. You seem to have a different interpretation of "significant playing time" than I do. You list a lot of QBs as "rode the bench" which I consider to have gotten "significant playing time." I never said they had to be the STARTER their rookie year. But they have to get playing time. And virtually ALL of the current crop of "elite" QBs DID get "significant playing time" their rookie year. Carson Palmer is an interesting case. He got zero play time his rookie year, but he still started the first game of his second year. I would say that qualifies him according to my standard of starting "early in his second season" although I lose some of the argument about Tim Tebow here since Palmer didn't play at all his rookie year. I stand by my analysis here. Elite QBs of all eras, and more so today, tend to be the high-drafted QBs who get put into real NFL games early and often, and because of that tend to become starters either in their rookie year or early in their second year. Other than Tony Romo that describes every "elite" QB of the past 20 years EXCEPT those QBs who were unfortunate enough to be drafted on teams who ALREADY HAD an elite QB who had played early and become starter in their first, or early in their second year. I think the data is unassailable.
CosmicConservative
So, there are certainly a number of JaMarcus Russel examples of QBs who fit the guidelines but did not become elite. I don't deny that. I'm not suggesting that being a high draft pick, getting significant playing time, and becoming a starter either in the first year or early in the second year GUARANTEES the QB will be elite. I'm saying that the evidence shows me that if you want to have an elite QB, you better start them early, often and promote them to starter as early as possible if you want to HAVE THE BEST CHANCE to have an elite QB. That's what I'm saying. And that's precisely what the Broncos are not doing with Tim Tebow.
Tom DeGisi
There are lots of reasons a coach might not play Tebow. Perhaps he hasn't learned the offense. Perhaps the coach is too dedicated to the game plan and it was written around Orton. Perhaps Tebow hasn't "clicked" with the receivers in practice. Perhaps Tebow can't work with the line and keeps getting 'hit' in practice. Etc. As regards the various contentions about playing a QB early: Neither of you have actually done the math. You are arguing anecdotally without true analysis. That's OK, but my point is this: Without real statistical analysis I doubt either of you will change anybodies mind, except maybe mine. :) Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, I've carefully chosen an argument where the statistical analysis is simple. The question is "What percentage of elite quarterbacks were given significant play opportunities when they were rookies and were promoted to starter either in their rookie year or very early in their sophomore year?" Then I used the following data sets: The top ten all-time QBs according to a respected sports commentary website. The top ten currently playing QBs according to that same sports commentary website. The top ten QB ratings as of this week in the ESPN statistics tracking web page. That gives a total population of about 20 quarterbacks because of the significant overlap of the data sets. Of those QBs 90% were given significant play opportunities in their rookie year and were promoted to starter either in their rookie year or early in their sophomore year. The two who did not meet this standard were Phillip Rivers and Tony Romo. Every other QB on the list meets this standard. And I would argue that Phillip Rivers does too since he may not have played at all his rookie season (due to a philosophical decision by his coach) but was prmoted to starter for game 1 of his sophomore season. Now there were a couple of QBs on this list that were promoted and demoted and promoted again (Matt Schaub was one). But that does not change the fact that they are elite now and were played significantly as rookies and were promoted to starter either in their rookie season or early in their sophomore season. Using this data and this analysis I submit that it is potentially damaging not only the Denver Broncos as an organization to not play Tim Tebow now, but also potentially damaging Tim Tebow himself. As to why he may not be playing... Well let's look at your options. If he "hasn't learned the offense" by now, he should be traded and demoted to complete bench warmer. However, every inside indication I have seen is that Tebow is doing fine with the offense in practice and his play at college would argue against this option. If the coach is too dedicated to a game plan that has led to 16 losses in 25 games, the coach is beyond incompetent. Which is my basic argument anyway, and this just supports it. As far as "clicking" with the receivers, unless the Broncos have a completely unique means of running practice, Tim Tebow will have had virtually no chance of practicing with the #1 receivers. It is rare for the #2 QB to get reps with the #1 receivers. That's what the #1 QB is doing in practice. So that means that most rookie QBs making their first start have not developed any "clicking" with the starting receivers. That's why you have to play him. As far as not working the line and getting hit, The main use that the Broncos have made of Tebow has been in short yardage heavy melee running plays where working the line and getting hit are the main things Tebow has done. That's the one time they have actually played him. So I don't buy any of the reasons you list. I stand by my own explanation which is a combination of the current coaches not being sold on Tebow due to ideological issues, and the coaches having delusions about being able to win long-term jobs by winning the remaining games in the season with Orton.
Drax
Your method, starting at the end with the elites and figuring out where they came from, is nonsensical. First, we have to have some better definition of "throwing them into the mix in their rookie season" than some sort of "he got some playing time his rookie season" or "he didn't play at all his first year but he started his second year, so he was thrown into the mix his rookie season" or whatever it is that you're attempting to sell here. I'm talking about STARTING THE SEASON AS STARTING QUARTERBACK YOUR ROOKIE SEASON. Playing a few snaps here and there, going in when the STARTER is hurt, or becoming the "starter" at the end of the season when your team is eliminated from the playoffs AIN'T being "thrown into the mix your rookie season" by my reckoning. It's being "brought along slowly" - perhaps not so slowly as Hasselbeck or Rodgers sitting behind Favre, but it ain't being thrown into the mix either. So, as I showed, the current crop of QB's HAD AN EQUAL CHANCE OF BEING "ELITE" if they started their rookie season or if they rode the bench which is the same approximate percentage of ALL quarterbacks, i.e., about 1/2 start their rookie season. So, it is INEVITABLE that about 1/2 of the ELITES started their rookie season since 1/2 of ALL quarterbacks started their rookie season. I thought this was blindingly obvious.
Tom DeGisi
I understand your method. It sounds like a good way to make the argument easy to follow, rather than a good way to make a sound argument. One of the biggest problems is that you make no effort at all to remove confounding variables, like the fact that teams have to pay salaries. The second is that you have such a limited data set over the history of the game. Twenty or thirty quarterbacks over several decades? Sure, your method will remove noise, but it also removes large amounts of information. It's hard to do science right: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/11/lies-damned-lies-and-medical-science/8269/ > the coaches having delusions about being able to win long-term jobs by winning the remaining games in the season with Orton. This one is a lot more plausible. Yours, Tom