So, I had reviewed the first book here, then gone to see the movie while still reading the second book, ("Catching Fire") and then yesterday I finished the final book of the trilogy ("Mockingjay").
In the past few days I've had a number of conversations about the books, plus I've read a bunch of reviews. After discussing this with the Cosmic Daughter this morning on the way to work, she suggested that I post my thoughts about the book, since apparently my thoughts are somewhat unusual compared to what I am seeing on the web and she has seen in discussions with her friends.
Here's the deal. I think these books are incredibly well written and have a much deeper political purpose than most people seem to be getting. I see a lot of discussion, for example, about how the book is a fairly typical "teenage love triangle" between Katniss, Gale and Peeta, much like Twilight is a love story between whoever the three main characters of that book are. In fact I see a lot of fan discussion about how Katniss should choose Gale, or should choose Peeta, or neither, or whatever.
These sorts of things seem, to me, to be badly missing the point of the book. And here's why. This book appears to me to be deliberately constructed as allegory, with the characters each symbolizing an aspect of human culture or ideology. And how they interact is a metaphor for how cultures act, react and evolve. And it's all pretty brilliantly done.
Here are my interpretations of the symbology involved in the book:
Katniss - represents human society as a whole. This, to me, is so blindingly obvious and so deliberately presented, that I find it almost incomprehensible that people don't immediately get it. Viewing Katniss as an individual is completely missing the point. Katniss represents all of us.
Peeta - represents morality, altruism, loyalty and everything that is good and noble about humans. He is Sam to Katniss's Frodo. He is the conscience of the story. He provides Katniss with her moral compass and her aspirations to be good, aspirations she frequently falls short of.
Gale - represents rebellion against authority. Gale is Thomas Paine and Che Guevera rolled into one person. His entire purpose revolves around fighting against what he sees as oppression, and he has no visible limits to the lengths he will go to oppose his enemies.
Prim - represents hope. Not much more to say here, Prim is the center of Katniss's life, and the entire story revolves around Katniss's desire to keep Prim (hope) alive. That is, I believe, very deliberate.
President Snow - represents absolute authority. But NOT, as some have supposed, absolute evil. Snow is not Sauron, nor is he the Sith emperor. This book is far more subtle and complex than that. Snow is brutal, remorseless, inexorable and violent. But Snow is not the source of the evil in the book, he is merely its face. The evil is buried deeper in the soul of society, and is revealed through Katniss's own actions.
President Coin - well... I can't reveal what Coin represents in case some of my readers have not yet finished all the books. What Coin represents is almost the core of the final true climax of the book. So to reveal that would be to essentially spoil the books.
Haymitch - perhaps the most enigmatic figure in the book. I believe Haymitch represents the author's proxy, much as Farimir represents Tokien's proxy in Lord of the Rings. Haymitch is the one who pulls the strings from behind the scenes. He is Katniss's soulmate, but he is badly damaged. He provides a way for the author to telegraph her intentions to the reader.
Even many of the "bit part" characters are clearly archetypes as well. Madge, Johanna, Finnik, even Katniss's mother have specific roles they play to weave the cultural actions, reactions and evolution outlined in the books.
When Katniss is kissing Gale, that is an allegory for cultures flirting with rebellion. That, I believe, is entirely deliberate.
The fact that the story works as a character study is simply a demonstration of the author's skill in wrapping the layers of the story in a vehicle that allows it to be delivered to readers in an entertaining, gripping manner. But it's done so well that I believe the deeper purpose may well escape some readers.
This has definitely gotten onto my list of best stories ever. I believe this story will grow in reputation over the years, as more and more people realize what Collins actually accomplished here.
I am totally humbled by this book. This is a tour de force of writing. A masterpiece. It is so brilliantly done that it may well be too brilliantly done. I hope not. The message in this book is a powerful indictment of authoritarian central government and a full-throated scream for the freedom and empowerment of individuals.
I love Katniss. I love these books.
Heh.. this has to be some sort of record between reviewing a book and then reviewing the movie made from the book.
So, we saw the movie Saturday. Like fools we went to the IMax viewing, figuring that the movie would be real crowded but the IMax early afternoon viewing would be the least crowded. We ended up sitting in the next to last row in the theater. But that's the beauty of IMax I guess, we ended up with a view comparable to sitting in our normal spot in a non-IMax theater.... it just cost us four dollars more per ticket.
I have to add my raves for the performance of Jennifer Lawrence. I also thought the other cast members were excellent.
If I were a fan of the books on the level that I am a fan of the LOTR books, there is plenty I could pick apart. Haymitch being a casual drunk vs the book version of Haymitch being a falling-down vomit-stained drunk for example. But they did stick with the story much better than most movies do. Probably because Suzanne Collins was a co-writer of the movie script.
The one thing that I have to point out for those who have seen the movie but not read the book is that the violence in the movie is downright tame compared to the book. Too tame, really. The movie just doesn't give the same emotional impact as the book from a pure graphic violence perspective. I suppose that was necessary to maintain a PG-13 rating, and I don't know how much it really matters except that gut-wrenching response was one of the main strengths of the book. None of the injuries sustained by Katniss or Peeta seemed remotely as serious or life-threatening as they did in the book.
The notes in the parachuted items was probably a necessary movie device which avoided some of the problems Dune had with the internal dialog issues. In the book Katniss had to figure out Haymitch's strategies by inferring them from the timing and content of his sponsor deliveries. In the movie there's an actual note included. It diminishes Katniss's cunning and resourcefulness. But frankly don't know how else to have done it, so that's probably the best compromise.
Not enough time setting up the Gale or Prim relationship. Too much reliance on a few longing glances or brooding stares. But again, the movie was long enough already, so it's hard to be too critical.
In the end I think they did about as well as they could have with a book that had to be a real challenge to turn into a movie. For the most part I think they did an excellent job.
Just wrapped up this book on my break. Yeah, I took it to work to read on my breaks.
That's actually a first for a work of fiction. I mean I've brought lots of technical books, and even "Why We Get Fat" to work, but not to read, just to have handy if I had a question or wanted to look something up. This time I actually took a book to work so I could read it on a break.
So... this is a book that in my opinion gets every big thing right about story telling. I do think it's got some issues with some of the small things, but I've rarely read a book that hits so many right notes on the most basic, and usually missed, things about story telling.
Unbelievably great characters. Riveting action. Multiple layers of complex and sometimes shifting conflict. There were moments in this book that I teared up, and I don't tear up easily.
Katniss, the protagonist, is one of the more compelling fictional characters I've encountered in a long, long time. Her life story is heartbreaking even before she gets thrown into a murderous last-child-standing-wins arena.
The book reminds me of many other books for different reasons. Many people are comparing it to "Harry Potter" but I don't see any resemblance whatsoever to that bloated mass of incomprehensible magic and incompetent battle tactics. (Full disclosure, I liked Harry Potter, but the story in those encyclopedic tomes could have been told better and been more compelling at less than half the number of words).
No, what Hunger Games reminds me of are the following works:
"The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson
"Anthem" by Ayn Rand
"Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card
"The Giver" by Lois Lowry
You might notice that all of those books are acknowledged to be deeply and deliberately political satires or exposes. Which is how I would characterize "Hunger Games."
I hope that most readers understand that Katniss's story is not about Katniss. Katniss is used as a window into the dark nature of human political and social dysfunction. Katniss and Peeta provide a way to explore that dark dysfunction in a raw and visceral way. The clash of cultures between the Capital and the districts is a deliberate and merciless expose of the capability of human indifference to suffering, acceptance of defeat and imposition of power.
I suppose some will consider it to be heavy-handed, but I found it to be very deftly done. This is a book that will get a whole lot of people thinking about the danger inherent in allowing overwhelming power to exist in the hands of a privileged few.
Which is where this country is headed right now. I hope it helps to wake some people up.
Haven't done a movie review in a while. Haven't really been watching many movies lately, it's gotten too expensive even for my profligate spending habits.
But, we had been planning to see JC of Mars when the first previews came out so we finally managed to see it (two weeks after it premiered, I think).
It was OK. The graphics were awesome of course, but it's getting to the point that stunning 3D computer graphics are only worth mentioning when they suck. It's become a commodity almost. And it's likely to just get easier and cheaper to do it in the future.
In some ways I liked the "prologue" of the movie better than the Mars scenes. The movie starts with John Carter in the Arizona territory where he's been summoned by a local military leader to try to get him to sign up and help fight the Apache. He refuses. Several times. It's a pretty funny sequence and does a good job of setting the character of John Carter for the movie.
Once he gets to Mars though, things get a little.... strange. Which is to be expected I suppose. The martian landscapes alternate between stunningly artistic vistas pulled from NASA's orbiters to obvious shots of Lake Powell or the Arizona desert. The dichotomy is startling for those of us who have spent any time in Arizona. And I haven't spent that much time there.
The Tharks are presented almost as a schizophrenic race. My memories from the book of the Tharks is that they were brutally savage, but respectful of strength and courage. Sort of like four-armed Apaches in fact...
It was sort of strange how Carter was super strong enough to leap about like 1940s Superman, but was overmatched in hand to hand wrestling with both Tharks and martian humans. I suppose it was that way in the book too, although I don't really remember it well enough to be sure.
The story was entertaining enough, both the love story and the save the world story. I liked Dejah Thoris, although she came off as a little too buff in some scenes. She was much softer in the original story. But these days female leads in action/adventure movies have to be badass swordfighters or it's sexist. OK, I get that.
We all enjoyed it. The fight scenes were well choreographed if a little over the top. The flying ships were really cool, and came across as downright steampunkish.
All in all it was probably worth the destruction of a cool C-Note to see the movie, get some snacks and eat out for the evening. But it wouldn't be terrible to wait for the DVD either.
So... what have we got?
QB - A first ballot hall of famer at the end of his career after losing an entire season to four neck surgeries.
RB - A retread who was ineffectual until paired with Tim TEbow in the backfield
WR - A sophomore with promise (DT) and a journeyman who made a brief splash three seasons ago but has underperformed since
TE - ? Denver has tight ends? Who knew?
O-line - One of the worst offensive lines in the game. Much like Willis McGahee benefited from Tebow's running and escapability, so did the offensive line that allowed among the most sacks in the league while trying to protect much less mobile Kyle Orton. Think Peyton Manning is going to be as mobile as Kyle Orton? uh uh.
CB - Another first ballot hall of famer at the end of his career, badly exposed in several games last year as no longer being an elite cover CB. He does tackle though. On the other side of the field.... pppfffffttttt!
S - This is like the tight end on the other side of the ball.
LB - Losing their best tight end of the last decade, and their much-hyped rookie never played up to his previous level after breaking a thumb. Who knows?
D-Line - Unable to rush the QB, unable to stop the run, and losing their "core" lineman to free agency. This is expected to be the FIRST place Denver will try to fix with the draft. Which means they won't be drafting a wide receiver, running back or offensive line to help Peyton.
How does this shape up to be a "top contender for the Super Bowl" again?
I try to be a careful and safe driver. As part of that I do my best to keep my eyes open for people who drive inappropriately. I hate being surprised by dangerous drivers.
This morning, on my way to work on Highway 285 east bound between Santa Fe and Broadway, I noticed a brown Honda SUV weaving in and out of traffic behind me. I watched as the SUV cut off several drivers and could see that it would soon be coming up behind me. As I expected, the driver cut off the car behind me and entered my lane dangerously close to my rear bumper. I noticed that it was a young woman driving the car.
As we went under the Broadway bridge, she remained hard on my bumper, and I could see her looking for an opportunity to cut into another lane to get around me. No such opportunity afforded itself. As we reached the red light past Broadway, I merged into the right hand lane. As I did so, she moved quickly into the lane where I had been, but was unable to pass me due to traffic in that lane. So as I moved forward, she cut in again behind me, right on my tail.
As it happened, just as she was doing that, the light ahead turned orange, at just that wrong time where you have to stop fast, or run the red light. As I hit the brakes to stop, I also looked in my rear view mirror to see if she was paying attention so that if it looked like she would hit me, I could continue forward. She did notice I was stopping, but she became enraged that I did so. Apparently she had assumed that I would push on through the red light, and her intention was clearly to follow as closely as she could.
Because I stopped, she had to stop, and she began gesticulating wildly and yelling at me. After a few seconds of watching her antics, I raised my right hand in a gesture of “what can I do? The light turned red.” This enraged her further and she took out her phone and took a photo of my car. Then she called someone, I presume she decided to pay me back for making her stop by reporting me as an aggressive driver.
So... if this happened to you, what would you do?
So, last year when I began my attempt to reverse a potential descent into type 2 diebetes, several people recommended that I read a book called "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes.
Having long considered dietary literature to be essentially as credible and scientific as paranormal literature, I politely declined offers to loan the book to me and responded with variations of "dieting is simple. You eat less and exercise more. Thermodynamics takes care of the rest." And I went on my way, dropped to a 1,200 calorie per day diet, made sure to exercise at least 45 minutes per day and sure enough, the pounds melted away.
But having now been exposed to the book, and a previous book by the same author, "Good Calories, Bad Calories", I started seeing recommendations for the book everywhere, including on some sites (such as "Instapundit" which relentlessly promotes the books) that I hold in high regard.
So, although I have not regressed badly in my dietary habits and have managed to keep off the weight I lost last year, when my weight started creeping back up and I decided to reinstate my "draconian dietary restrictions", on a whim, I purchased the books off of Amazon.com. And I promptly put them in a pile of "books to read" that I have not gotten to (that pile includes "The Hunger Games" by the way).
Well, this weekend I decided to pick up "Why We Get Fat" and began reading it.
My initial reaction was "huh, so 'calories in, calories out' doesn't work eh? What about me? It worked fine for me."
But I found the book to be very interesting as it was a pretty decent high-level introduction to the biological basis for gaining weight. So I kept reading.
And it was making sense. And the more I read, the more I realized that the book wasn't about "getting fat" it was about "Why we develop type 2 diabetes, heart disease and a host of other western diseases'." "Getting fat" was really more of a symptom of a deeper hormonal imbalance that was tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning.
Not to go into any great detail but the fundamental concept presented in the book is that the modern carbohydrate based diet pushed by doctors, the government and even nutritionists for the past fifty years is basically a blueprint to wrecking your insulin balance, which leads directly to type 2 diabetes and all the health problems related to that.
The more I read, the more I realized that my own dietary history was directly implicated. In fact I could have been the model for the book. The high-carbohydrate diet leading to insulin resistance causing pancreatic insulin over-production ending up with type 2 diabetes could have been taken directly from my medical charts. The litany of health problems associated with insulin imbalance included kidney problems, liver problems, gall bladder problems, gout, kidney stones.... GEEZ LOUISE!!! This was reading like a biography of ME.
And the message of the book was clear, even if Taubes didn't put it into these words.
The modern western diet is tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning.
This isn't even about losing weight! Gaining weight might be the LEAST concerning health consequence of a high-carbohydrate diet.
So I'm thinking hard now about my diet not from a "losing weight" perspective, but more from a "reversal of sugar poisoning" perspective. Blood sugar is downright toxic. Chronic blood sugar elevation is toxic to almost all of the cells in the body. It is particularly hard on internal organs such as the heart, liver and kidneys.
The book did not really provide a road map for "eating right" because that book had already been written ("Good Calories, Bad Calories"). So now I'm starting to read that book.
But the fundamental concept is clear. Sugar is not merely fattening. Sugar is addictive and is toxic. Carbohydrates from common sources like breads, potatoes, rice, pasta and desserts are converted to sugar almost instantly in the blood, so are not much different than sucking down spoonfuls of sugar. Fructose is, if anything, WORSE than table sugar.
I am now embarking on a war against sugar. I'll let you know how it goes.
It's close. Very close. Still missing a few things, but is it close enough for me to take the plunge?
Not sure. Maybe. Remember this post about third generation tablets?
Here's the story:
It's easy to see why the new iPad will be a big hit. It has four times the resolution of its predecessor, four times the graphics power and 4G LTE. (For those scoring at home, that's a lot of fours.) But there's another four that should scare Apple's competition even more: $400.
Read more:
$400? That's an attractive price point. Four times the resolution of existing iPads? Getting pretty dang nice. 4G network speeds? Also very nice...
If this thing can handle word processing with a bluetooth keyboard, and print to a wireless printer, I may just retire all my existing computer hardware...
When I was a kid the skates they sold at toy stores or bicycle shops all had steel wheels. They were dangerous since if you hit even the tiniest pebble, the wheel would stop dead and immediately throw you hind-end-over-teakettle across the pavement or asphalt. There is no telling how much skin I lost over the years to those steel wheels.
Especially since we used to take our skates and remove the wheels to make home-made skateboards. Skateboards that could rocket down hills at speeds approaching thirty miles per hour. Until they hit a pebble....
Having learned to skate at a young age, and frankly enjoying the activity, it was somewhat of a surprise when I learned that our new stepbrothers and sister also enjoyed skating. So along with a group of neighborhood kids, we would hike down the street a mile or so to the local "Hot Wheels Skating Palace" almost every Friday night.
I wonder if kids still do that. Skate night was a big deal back then. The skating rink had pool tables and an arcade area, so it was both a skating rink and a local hangout. It's sorta fun to play pinball with skates on.
Back then a typical skate night started around 6:00 pm on a Friday and you'd pay your $2 to get in the door for a full night of skating fun. Since we had our own skates we didn't have to rent any, but we'd typically have to rent a locker to keep our stuff in so the local hoodlums wouldn't steal them. Then you had to buy some snacks, probably a slice of pizza and some "cokes" (back then we called all soft drinks "cokes.") A night of skating might wreck a five dollar bill, but that was usually good enough for the evening.
For the first hour or so the skating "rink" was just open for skating. The crowd of skaters would circle the pylons set to define the "legal" area for skating. The crowd would include everything from little babies just being dragged along by mothers and fathers to teenage speed-demons who darted in, around and through the crowd like little Dale Earnhardts, frequently causing commotions by colliding with, or frightening other, less adventurous, skaters.
It was good clean fun, coupled with the ability to check out a bunch of hot chicks in tight skating pants circling around again and again and again...
Every ten minutes or so the rink would go all disco. Sometimes they'd even light up a literal "disco ball" and turn out the lights so that you were skating in near darkness with brilliant shards of multi-colored light accompanied by the dulcet tunes of Ted Nugent's "Wango Dango!' During these periods the casual skaters would usually take a break.
Once every half hour or so they'd put on a "slow dance" song and lower the lights for some romantic skating. Young (and old) skating partners would take to the floor and dance-skate to Carole King or James Taylor.
At the top of every hour they'd clear out the rink and set up the races. I always hated that because I wanted to skate, and I didn't really like getting embarrassed by little kids who could skate twice as fast as I could in spite of being half my age. But I'd go ahead and compete sometimes.
See, the thing is, I was poor. The skates I used then no longer had the steel wheels. They weren't "in-line" skates either, they had four wheels on each skate situated like the wheels on a car. The toe also had a big round rubber "brake" that you used to stop yourself, and to run on to build up speed. They had hard rubber wheels that were slightly less inclined to throw you end-over-end but still could not handle any floor debris larger than a grain of rice. Actually they couldn't even handle a grain of rice. Plus they were HARD rubber, and as such did not have much traction with the floor, so when you tried to accelerate most of your "push" was wasted as the wheels slid against the floor.
A few years earlier a new sort of wheel had appeared on the skates of skating rinks. These were the fabled "urethane wheels" that were a much softer material that not only could skate cleanly across a grain of rice without skidding, but also allowed huge acceleration due to their ability to grab the floor, wasting none of your energy.
Oh man I wanted some urethane wheels... But, as I recall, they cost a fortune. And you needed EIGHT of them. But for a short period of my early high school career, there was nothing I wanted more than a set of urethane wheels for my skates.
So I saved my money. For months. And finally, FINALLY, I was able to purchase a set of urethane wheels.
Oh man they were sweet. My skating went from mediocre to amazing overnight. Suddenly I was competitive in the rink races. I was able to skate forward or backward, and could go from full speed to full stop in just a few feet. My acceleration was smooth and powerful. My turns were tight and clean.
For a few months I was a skating god.
Then I got my first motorcycle and somehow the skating rink vanished into my past like a mirage on the desert sands...
In my entire life there have probably only been a handful of times that I wanted something so badly as I wanted those urethane wheels. And now I don't even know what happened to those skates. Life is funny.