Online gaming, Player vs. Player ruminations...
By CosmicConservativeIn my last post Drax and I got into a bit of back-and-forth over Player vs. Player (PvP) styles. He used to be a major player in Ultima Online (UO) and I've done a fair bit of PvP (in the past, not lately) on World of Warcraft (WoW).
PvP play is considered by some to be the only real challenging and rewarding online play. As Drax put it in the other post, "everything else is just farming." ("Farming" is the process in a MMORPG of gaining items that can be used to make things or to sell for gold.)
I disagree with that because I think defeating the game's bosses is plenty challenging and rewarding and requires significant amounts of coordination and cooperation with other players, which is pretty good practice for real life getting along with people. If you are a jerk in a raid, you frequently won't be invited back. The skills required for succeeding in raiding are not limited to the mastery of your character's abilities, you have to master real life skills in negotiation, socialization, communication, cooperation and fair play. A good raid team is very much like a team in any sport, people know their roles, they know the rules of engagement and they have practiced and studied their role extensively so that they perform at their best. For the most part all of these are valuable real life skills and I believe raiding promotes socialization and cooperation, skills a lot of people lack in the modern world.
The fundamental concept of PvP is that one or more human players are pitted against one or more other human players in competition. That's why it's called "PvP." ("PvE" by the way, means "Player versus Environment" and indicates a situation where the player is competing against the game itself.)
Now the first thing I want to make clear is that I greatly prefer human vs. human competition to human vs. machine competition, so my initial and preferred bias in playing games is to do PvP. So far my favorite PvP situation I've ever played was in "Janes WWII Fighters" a combat WWII fighter simulation where players could dogfight other players over the internet. The graphics were incredible and the experience of dogfighting was so realistic that the Air Force uses these sorts of simulations in their training today.
Whether this is a character flaw or not, I have to admit that defeating another human being has an entirely different visceral feel to it than simply defeating the computer. Early on, even before playing Jane's WWII fighters, I used to fly on a local network using the Macintosh flight simulator "Falcon" against one of my co-workers, named Jeff. Jeff had completely mastered the game and had all the awards and medals possible, so he clearly knew how to fly his virtual falcon and according to the computer itself, he was a master ace. I never came close to mastering the game to that level and had only a handful of medals and awards. But whenever we flew against each other, I won more than I lost in one-on-one combat against Jeff.
There are two reasons for that. The first is that I simply get more energized and excited about human vs. human competition, so I raise my game. The second is that human beings can only know what they process and can only process what they see and hear in the context of what they are expecting. The computer knows everything about the game all the time, because it IS the game. That means that I was able to do things that I knew would mess Jeff up, but which the computer would simply process and file away. For example, in one of our big head-to-head battles with several co-workers observing (this was when I worked for a software development company, so this qualified as "research" ;) ) I added a couple of air to ground missiles to my Falcon along with my six air to air missiles. Usually you don't carry air to ground missiles if you are going to dogfight because they don't do any good in a fight and they marginally decrease your Falcon's performance. So no virtual "top gun" wannabe would carry air to ground weapons because they don't add anything to your offensive capabilities and they detract from your airplane's aerodynamic performance.
But what I knew from playing the game is that launching an air to ground missile looks and sounds to another player almost exactly the same as an air to air missile launch. So by carrying two air to ground missiles, I had two decoys that I could use to fool Jeff into thinking I was out of missiles when I wasn't. The idea was that I could sucker him in close where I could lock missiles on him after he thought I was out of missiles.
And it worked perfectly. During the fight I fired off four sidewinders, which he managed to evade, while I also evaded several of his missiles. But during the fight I had launched two maverick missiles (air to ground) and after I fired my fourth sidewinder, Jeff relaxed, thinking I only had guns left, and got sloppy. So I was able to get a lock on him fairly easily and blew him out of the sky. That would never have worked against the computer because the computer "knows" the difference between a sidewinder and a maverick launch, while a human would have to be paying very close attention to have any hope of identifying the difference in the middle of dogfighting.
I love that sort of thing. I loved the look of incredulity on his face when I launched that fatal missile. "What? How? .. Where?...." He was convinced I had hacked the game to allow me to carry more sidewinders.
That's what I love about PvP, the ability to match wits and skills against an opponent.
In MMORPGs though, PvP is something entirely different. In those games you don't log in just to do combat and then log off, a MMORPG is defined by the persistence of an individual character as that character advances from level to level and acquires goods, skills and abilities.
So even the discussion of what "PvP" is or should be is eventually a philosophical discussion.
As was clear in the previous post, UO and WoW have implemented PvP almost entirely at the separate ends of the MMORPG PvP spectrum. UO has an almost anything goes approach while WoW has a far more restrictive and arbitrary approach.
And I don't like either of them. In fact I have never payed a MMORPG where I thought the PvP was done properly. Games which take the UO approach inevitably become dominated by hardcore players who exploit the weaknesses of casual gamers. This tends to drive casual gamers away and greatly reduces the ability of the game system to grow and expand. That's because nobody appreciates working their virtual butts off for a powerful scroll or item, only to have another player steal it or kill them and loot it. This violates many people's sense of fairness, plus it seriously angers people.
Games which take the WoW approach go to such great lengths to protect their casual players from predation by hard-core gamers that they end up feeling restrictive and arbitrary. You can fight another player but only in very ritualistic ways. And nobody can steal your stuff out of your backpack, nor can they loot your body when you die. Casual gamers love this because it means they can move more or less freely through the world without fear of roving bands of rapacious players opportunistically looking to cash in on the casual gamer's hard work.
I would prefer a third paradigm for PvP, one that is neither arbitrarily constrained, nor one which promotes anti-social greedy behavior which drives paying customers to other game systems.
Let's just look at a very simple example of player vs player interaction. Can I pickpocket that other player? If so, what are the consequences of doing so?
One of the things I really don't like about WoW is that your PvP interaction is entirely dependent on your location. What you can do just fine in one place is completely impossible to attempt somewhere else. What can be done against one player can not be done against another. Etc...
If we want to introduce the abiltiy to pickpocket, then there should be no limitations to when or where the player should be allowed to attempt it. If my character has the skill, he should be able to use that skill against friend and foe alike. But if we allow that, we have to deal with the consequences of getting caught. This is where things get sticky. If I'm caught stealing from someone from an opposing faction, that's no big deal, it probably just becomes a PvP fight. But if I'm caught stealing from a party member or a guild member, that has some interesting ramifications. What if I steal from a friendly NPC? Do I immediately become an enemy of that NPC's faction? What impact would pickpocketing have on my character's reputation? What if some of my abilties, skills or items are dependent upon reputation do I lose those abilities, skills or items immediately? What if I try to pickpocket something that is too high a level for me to use? What if I get away with it entirely? Is that a good thing (demonstration of a critical skill or ability) or a bad thing (stealing from allies isn't usually seen as a positive trait.) In the world of "soulbound" items, which are items a character cannot sell or give to another player, are soulbound items off limits? Or can I pickpocket them but not be able to use them? If so, what's the point of pickpocketing then?
Should pickpocketing have level limitations? For example should a level 10 character find it more difficult to pickpocket a level 80 character than a level 5 character? If so then that implies that a level 80 pickpocket could pretty much pickpocket low level players with impunity. And if that's possible, some will do so simply because they can, even if the result of the pickpocketing rarely provides anything of value to the level 80 character. Many players would simply revel in the realization that they've made life harder for some low level player even if they couldn't do anything with what they pickpocketed themselves. That's just how people are.
In the real world all of this is tied to our criminal system. Punishment is meted out by the state, generally, and according to specific laws. Society is patrolled and overseen by government agencies ranging from the Special Services to the local Police. Crimes are reported, warrants are obtained, searches are performed and trials are held. I don't think the vast majority of players want IronForge and StormWind (cities in WoW) to become havens for lawyers. So it is unlikely that we could deal with such infractions on fair play in game through any sort of civil procedure.
So what do we do with our pickpocket who has been caught picking the pocket of a party member or a guild officer? Let's say we are in a raid and a phat lewt dagger drops, which is won by the hunter, but which the rogue beleives should have been awarded to him. So the rogue pickpockets the item at the first opportunity, and is caught red-handed by the hunter. What happens next? And how does the hunter prove that the rogue attempted to pick-pocket him in the first place? Does this open the door to people abusing the system by accusing others of things they didn't do?
So even something as simple as pickpocket seems to have an unending tangled web of consequences that lead to all sorts of ways to abuse the system. Fighting, killing and looting a victim would be at least ten times worse than pick pocketing. Or a hundred times worse. what do you do when a player starts killing and looting all the citizens in a city, or every random player he encounters?
I'm sure the WoW game desingers have wrestled for years with exactly these questions. And it needs to be stated that these games are not real life, there is no way we could model real life to the point that allowing pickpocketing and killing of random players to have appropriate real world consequences. And that means it would be abused by those who want to pursue only their selfish ends.
I would like to see PvP introduced in such a way that players can interact more naturally and with fewer arbitrary and silly limitations. But unless you have enforcers of some sort constantly roaming the cities and the rest of the world, it's going to be impossible to handle without serious abuse occurring.
Comments (2)