Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More on raiding in MMORPGs

By CosmicConservative
I know that a few of my regular commenters here have played Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPGs), but most have not. There are probably others who have played WoW or games like WoW, but never raided themselves and may not really understand the whole raiding dynamic. In fact I am a big fan of "The Guild" a web video series that parodies the antics of members of a raiding guild in a generic MMORPG, but "The Guild" gets far more wrong than they get right, making me wonder if Felicia Day has ever really been seriously involved in raiding before or during the creative process of making "The Guild." It's possible she has but she feels that it is easier to parody the average person's assumptions about raiding to mine the humor there than to accurately parody an actual raiding guild. If so, she's probably right. Much of the stuff that happens in a raiding environment wouldn't make sense to a non-raider and as such wouldn't have much comedy potential. Years ago, when I set up my first account on EverQuest, I didn't know anything about raiding. I was looking for an online version of Dungeons and Dragons, not some totally new gaming experience. In fact, for a long time I was frustrated with EverQuest because I kept trying to make it into an online version of D&D, when really a MMORPG in combat is more like a networked first-person shooter than any table-top role playing game. But over time I became accustomed to that reality and committed myself to the level grind in EverQuest. I had a couple of friends I played with frequently and we would group to do instances, which is sort of a baby version of raiding that at least introduces the concepts of role-based combat. But it wasn't until my EQ wizard reached level 60 or so that I discovered raiding and realized that raiding was, in fact, the justification for the existence of the genre. Everything else about MMORPGs is basically some sort of grind, or some sort of training for raiding. Raiding is what it's all about. And why is that? Well, I suppose different people have different motivations for raiding, and there are no doubt lots of MMORPGamers who enjoy the game just fine without raiding. But the ultimate goal of the game itself, as created by the game designers, is to defeat the game's top bosses. And the top bosses are all in the raids. OK, OK, I can see an argument for PvP being just as fulfilling and just as much fun, and I've done lots of PvP myself in WoW, but PvP is, by its nature, a series of short, limited engagements with strategy and tactics that are defined and executed in fractions of a second. Raiding is much more strategic. It requires real planning and study to do successfully. Besides mastering your character's game abilities, you have to know when and why to use them over battles that frequently last ten minutes or more, in sessions that can last for two hours or more (most start-to-finish raids in IceCrown Citadel are set for three hour runs, and as often as not the raiders have to come back later in the week to complete the final bosses that they didn't get to in the three hours set aside). Raiding in a MMORPG is about as pure a meritocracy as I've ever encountered. It's a brutal example of survival of the fittest where your performance is quite literally rated on charts for the whole world to see, and if you don't reach certain thresholds, you simply aren't allowed to do certain things. That's because one under-equipped, under-skilled, or just plain ignorant player can wreck the plans of 24 other people simply by not having prepared properly for the raid. Raid leaders, in particular, scrutinize the equipment and performance of raiders. It is not uncommon at all for a raid leader to, without a word, kick someone who is not performing adequately out of the raid. Every serious raider has a series of meters and charts that they use to measure their performance. For Rhlyssa that is primarily how much damage she is doing. I use a damage meter that resets for every fight we get into. To save screen space I have it sized to ony show the top five damage producers in the raid. If Rhlyssa's name is not in that top five, I get nervous. Typically I want to be in the top three, and frankly I feel my proper place is at #1. Healers monitor their healing effectiveness both by how much healing they've done and by how few raid members are dying. Tanks monitor their ability to control the boss so that the boss focuses its attack on the tank. Everything is public to raiders who have the proper tools. When someone is doing an unacceptable amount of damage, healing or aggro management, if they are lucky, they will be told to step it up. Usually they are simply dumped from the raid and the raid leaders put them on their "ignore" list. And as important as it is for a role to perform adequately in that role, there are many other things that raid members appreciate in their raiding party. Such as not dying during an encounter. It also includes having appropriate equipment, potions, flasks, elixers, scrolls and food to buff up the party, as well as being able to utilize the highest level of skills to improve the raid's chances of success. Perhaps I like it because it's the ultimate geek fantasy. Everything is quantifiable, verifiable and demonstrable. Since it is everyone's best interest for everyone to perform to their best abilities, tips, hints and tricks are freely shared, so just by raiding you learn how to better perform in your role. Some of the fights you have to perform are so complex and so difficult that it is truly an accomplishment to pull them off. Plus you have to perform cooperatively to succeed. Every class has a primary role, but also has a series of abilities that make other classes jobs easier. So the best raids (and most successful) happen when every player is focused on the team, not on themselves, and is doing everything possible to perform their role while also supporting the other roles as much as they can. And since every fight produces publicly available logs of every swing of a dagger, every healing spell, every buff that expires, etc... there is nowhere to hide. If you screw up, everyone knows it was you. If you want to keep playing, the only way to do it is to get better and better. Among the quantifiable elements in the game are tools which score a character's gear. One is called "GearScore" (geeks are so original) and it's the primary means of rating a character's gear. Right now the general agreed upon value for a "raid-worthy" character is to have a gear score of at least 5,000. At this moment Rhlyssa's gear score is 5.5K. The average value I've seen in ICC raids is about 5.7-5.8K, so Rhlyssa is still a bit under-geared. But in combat she has been holding her own in DPS (Damage Per Second) against other raiders with gear scores of 5.8 - 6.2K. What that tells me is that when she finally gets her complete set of tier 10 gear, she'll be back at the top of the charts. And for some reason, that's important to me. I probably won't rest until I can go into ICC 25 on hard mode, clear out the instance, and be at or on par with the top damage producer in the raid. And by then I expect the next release will be out... :)

Comments (11)

Drax
It all depends on what type of PvP in which you engage. In UO, for example, there were several types of PvP. The first was "pick up" type PvP which was essentially going out individually or with others and looking for a fight against, well, anyone who wasn't one of "us." The second was Factions which was much more involved. You were a member of one or another faction and fought against the others. You could capture cities (and have control of them and the vendors therein -- which, if exploited correctly, meant riches for your faction (or those members willing and able to properly exploit the opportunities of buying/selling commodities). It could last months. The third was Champion spawns. These were areas where an altar was set which spawned particular types of creatures. You cleared those critters out and it leveled up with more difficult creatures of the same type (spiders, dragons, etc.) Finally, the boss critter spawned. When you killed it, a certain number of skill scrolls would pop into the backpacks of the members involved in the raid. (Some of those scrolls were worth 15-25 million gold, a considerable sum even in UO.) Of course, the raiders would try to wait until the champ was almost over before they attacked those fighting the spawn. They would come geared to kill players rather than spawn and you had to fight them off while fighting off the spawn. (Or try to kill them before they killed the boss critter and escaped into a central "gate room" where -- likely -- others were lying in wait.) And, of course, once the scrolls popped into backpacks, thieves would pop up, having snuck around invisibly until they snagged the scroll from your pack and began running away through the spawn. Ah, the screaming. The cursing. Those could take several hours, depending on how many participated, how difficult the champ was, and how balanced the raiders and the spawners were. (Some degenerated into all night guild fights....) Then, there was the Harrower. This was the top of the toppers. Once you kill the boss of a particular spawn, you would get a skull. Once you had the skulls of all the champions, you could place them in an altar in the "gate room" at which point a gate would open to the Harrower, which, at the time, was the baddest critter in the game. Everyone could see that the gate had opened. Anyone could go through the gate to see where the Harrower had spawned. It wasn't long before messengers were running all about the land telling everyone they met where the Harry was and who was running it. The most people I had on my side (guildmembers, allied guilds, and random raiders) raiding the Harry was around 50 -- attacking a force about the same. That took all day. All day. Most of the time it was around 20 or so people on both sides for six hours or so. Sorry. MMORPG's are for PvP. Everything else is just farming man...farming.
CosmicConservative
LOL... PvP is fun, but I would not like it the way you described it above. I don't care for World of Warcraft's style of PvP either. UO is too anarchist and chaotic, and WoW is too controlled and constrained. And I love the idea of guild wars. I think guilds would be far more fun to participate in with guild wars as part of the game design. But the vast majority of people don't want to play a game where they log on in a friendly inn and some sneaky bastard player ganks them and steals their stuff. That sort of game environment quickly devolves into a situation where the hardcore gamers who have "all day" to play take total control of the server and the casual gamers are nothing but prey. That's only fun for the hardcore gamers, and frankly that's not enough people to support a WoW or EverQuest type of business model. PvP is something that deserves its own post. I would need to address it conceptually before I addressed the implementation or rules around it. The last thing I would want to do is create a game system where a bunch of arrested adolescents indulged their inner barbarian by making the game miserable for the majority of my paying customers. But on the other hand, I also don't like the model where PvP is allowed only in very controlled and limited circumstances which are contrived and artificial. Raiding is almost the antithesis of PvP. Raiding is about cooperating to defeat an evil foe, while PvP is all about indulging the inner desire to go toe-to-toe with another player for bragging rights. I would suspect that games which do PvP the way you describe are completely dominated by males, and mostly young males. If I were a game designer I would never design a game where a raiding group could be jumped by a bunch of opportunistic predators at the last minute to steal the rewards of their hard work. I frankly see nothing fun about that. I wouldn't play a game like that for long, that's for sure. In World of Warcraft there are four basic types of PvP. 1. Duels. Any player can challenge another player to a duel. Any player can accept or turn down such a challenge. Duels are to the death or until one player runs a certain distance away from the other player. The only benefit gained from a PvP duel are the honor points you gain from defeating an opponent. I have only dueled a couple of times, and I don't generally like it. 2. Alliance vs. Horde PvP. There are certain parts of the WoW world where Alliance and Horde co-locate and can attack each other at will. This can be done one on one, or in groups as large as you can manage to pull together. But you have to be opposing factions to fight. No alliance player can attack another alliance player. Victory in these battles provides a small amount of gold and honor gained. There is no looting of the dead bodies. 3. Battlegrounds. These are staged battles where Horde and Alliance teams pursue a specific objective. There are about six or eight different battlegrounds now. Most of them are some variation of "capture the flag" or "defend the flag." Some are small teams, some are huge teams. Some require mastery of special techniques such as seige engines, others simply rely on individual character abilities. Besides the honor gained, victory in a battleground provides tokens that can be used to purchase gear that is specifically designed for PvP. 4. Arena. Arena is like gladiators. Individual form teams which persist between bouts. Teams are ranked and gain and provide honor based on their records and placement in the arena rankings. Arena provides the best gear from turning in arena tokens. I've only participated in one arena event and our team lost two out of three of the encounters. I don't really care for any of the above types of PvP, although some of the battlegrounds are fun until they get boring. But again, if you aren't a serious PvP player, you'll just get whacked over and over again in a battleground or arena. The majority of PvP players on WoW are specialized builds tailored specifically for PvP. In fact the term "twink" is reserved in WoW for a player who has optimized every possible PvP attribute to maximize their abiltiy to kill other players. Usually this means wearing a completely different set of armor, using completely different weapons and utilizing a completely different "talent tree" which is how your character invests in particular powers and abilities. The battlegrounds typically are for a range of levels (such as level 20-29) and twinks are always level 29 and maxed to the hilt with every possible buff, epic armor and weapon and every maximum buff allowable. Especially Horde. For whatever reason Horde takes PvP much more seriously than Alliance. Battlegrounds on our server at least tend to be dominated by Horde groups who not only are individually geared for battleground play, but enter battlegrounds in groups who have coordinated their objectives. As a result it's rare for the Alliance to win a battleground in WoW. I spent three months doing PvP in WoW and had Rhlyssa all twinked out for that purpose back when she was level 29, and again when she was level 39. I haven't done any significant PvP now in over a year, mostly because I find the PvP options in WoW to be lacking.
Drax
Well, PvP in UO is a "good vs. evil" kind of thing. You have one group/guild which is attempting to PvE against a champion, knowing that the evil-doers might raid at any time. (Guards are posted. Plans are implemented against the eventuality.) The evil-doers have to attempt to raid at a time when doing so won't allow the spawners to re-spawn and re-organize after the initial attack while the former raiders are now the spawners -- and the former spawners have become the raiders. I agree it can be chaotic. But, that's the fun of it. Starting and keeping a spawn against a PvP guild not only gives you "bragging rights," but a tangible thing (several, in fact -- the loot from the champ as well as the oftentimes extremely valuable scrolls). Then, of course, raiding a spawn started (and worked for an hour or more) by a rival guild (who raids your guild's spawns) and taking it over and keeping it (and the scrolls) is tons of fun as well. Or, if you just want to skulk around on your thief...that can be profitable as well... They've done a bunch since I quit UO, so I don't know the status of PvP any longer. I was part of a small group working with the designers with ideas to help balance it. The main ideas I had been harping on for years were adopted....then I quit, heh...
CosmicConservative
Drax, I think you would be surprised by the immersiveness of WoW. PvP aside (and there are PvP servers in WoW, I've just never played on one, so I don't know what they do) the experience can be quite aesthetically pleasing. I suspect the next release, the "Cataclysm" release will introduce some new graphics requirements that my laptop may not satisfy...
Drax
The problem with PvP in WoW is that, to get good at it takes horrendous amounts of time. Then, to stay good at it (because it is insanely template and equipment dependent -- both which change with some rapidity) you have to keep playing with regularity. I could start playing UO again tomorrow with my current equipment and templates and be competitive.
CosmicConservative
Drax, that's not actually true. As I said above, PvP in WoW is level based. Blizzard rarely, if ever, goes back and creates new content or equipment for lower level characters. If I had kept Rhlyssa twinked at level 29 since April of last year, she would be just as effective in PvP now as she was then. There are no new weapons, armor, spells or enchantments that would make a level 29 character today any better than a level 29 character for the past five years. It's only at max level that things get better for PvP over time. And that's to keep people playing. When I hear you say that nothing in UO has changed in the past five years and that your character would be just as good after not playing for 18 months, my reaction isn't "cool! I want to play that!" My reaction is "huh... sounds like UO is milking their players for subscription fees without providing anything new for their money."
Drax
Heh. What I said is that I would be "competitive" with my template and equipment. Every MMORPG has the "template of the day," usually one which comes from the latest expansion. It's what drives people to buy the latest expansion. Keep up or suffer the disadvantage. I could "suffer the disadvantage" and remain competitive. At least I think so. UO is much more skill dependent than equipment dependent. Anyway, I'm going to stop talking about UO. I'm starting to get the shakes...
CosmicConservative
Heh.... Well, as far as competitive goes, I went 8 months without advancing Rhlyssa and after getting back online with her it took me just about four weeks, with a week and a half of that with me on vacation, to get her back up to par with current raiders. So she's "competitive" again already. In fact my raid tryout for the new guild must have gone OK because just before logging off yesterday I got invited to the core group weekly raid, something I had been told would probably take months to happen. Yes I went from about 34K gold to about 18K gold, but I wasn't using that gold for anything else and I'll just build it back up again now. In those four weeks (or 2.5, depending on how you calculate it) I replaced every single item she used with a new and better item. Some through raid drops, some through tokens and some through spending gold. Also during that time, even though my gear wasn't really good enough, I did manage to get her into two 10 man and two 25 man IceCrown Citadel raids, which is one reason she was able to replace her equipment so fast. Now it is true that it might take two months to get her gear to the top-level collection it was 8 months ago, but getting that high is mostly for bragging rights and ego, her current gear is more than capable enough already. And the skill thing... I don't think non-WoW players, or even WoW players who don't raid, have any idea of the skill level required to perform competently in a raid. Those raids are intense. The game designers have gone miles out of their way to make it deliberately difficult and force players to master virtually every aspect of their character's abilities. During a raid encounter you have to monitor your health, your combat rotation, your energy level, your position and you have to know and understand your role's requirements for the fight. For example, there is one boss encounter in the IceCrown Citadel that goes like this: First the boss has a mana shield that you have to DPS down before you can damage her. But you can't just beat on the shield because she has powerful minions who come to her aid which have to be picked up by a tank and then DPS'd down so you can get back to taking down her mana shield. Some of the minions are spellcasters, and some are melee fighters. The melee fighters are invulnerable to melee damage. If you try to fight one (which I did the first time I was in this encounter) you will just get killed almost immediately. The tank has to pick this guy up and ranged or spell casting team members have to kill him. The spellcasters are immune to ranged or spell damage and have to be killed by melee DPS. But, as noted, they are spellcasters and that means they are casting spells while you are trying to fight them. Besides trying to kill them you have to also interrupt their spells. But you can't do any of that unless you can FIND them in the battle in the first place. That means that you start the fight beating on the mana shield and wait for the raid leader to announce "incoming adds!" which is your cue to run to the general area that they spawn. Then you have to pick ONLY the spell casters because if you even prick one of the melee adds with a weapon, it will aggro you and you'll just die in one or two attacks. Even if you are just 10 yards or so in front of one of the melee adds, it has a frontal area of effect that does massive damage, and the healers will be focused on the tank to keep him alive since he has to be in front of the addd. So you have to locate the caster in the middle of the chaos, weave through the melee adds so that you can engage the caster and then interrupt and DPS him until he's dead. But one of his spells that you are trying to interrupt is a mana shield of his own, and if he gets that spell off, he gains 50K damage immunity that you have to beat down before you can damage him again. Any of the adds can randomly blow up, doing massive damage, so you have to be ready to run away. Any of the adds can be transformed by the boss into an aberration, some aberrations have to be DPS'd down, others have to be kited. And as if that isn't enough, the boss can raise a random dead one which makes it roughly twice as powerful as it was when it was alive. The boss spawns these adds on a timer. If you can't kill a set of them, then the next set will just add more that have to be killed. But worse than that, if you aren't taking them down almost immediately you can't get back to the boss to take down her mana shield. So you are running back and forth during the fight, frantically looking for the adds you are supposed to take care of, while simultaneously trying to avoid stepping in front of a melee add, or getting aggro by one of the aberrations roaming around. Assuming you manage to deal with the adds and take down the boss's mana shield, then the boss becomes both a melee and spell casting opponent. But now she's casting spells directly on the party instead of summoning or buffing her minions. And again you have to interrupt the spells you can while looking for the AoE spells which you have to run away from, all the while doing as much damage to the boss as you can. And she's on a ten minute timer, so that if she's not dead before ten minutes are up, she enrages and it's a virtually guaranteed party wipe. I've done this fight three times and have read the online strategy guides and I am only just now getting comfortable in my role in that fight. And this is considered one of the EASY encounters in ICC. There are much harder ones.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and I didn't even mention the times that the boss mind-controls a party member, who also has to be picked up and kited around so that he (or perhaps YOU) don't start killing off party members. And again, this is an easy fight. The vampire boss which bites you and infects you with a disease that you have to go spread to other party members is by far the hardest fight for me right now. That fight has so many things going on that you generally have to be dealing with at least three issues simultaneously and if you screw up even one of them, you'll cause a party wipe almost immediately. That's the fight we have wiped on most frequently. It's hard enough in 10 man, but in 25 man you have to find your bite target in all the chaos, get to him/her to bite them, and you have 10 seconds (15 in ten man) to accomplish this. If you don't, you become a mind-controlled vampire yourself which doubles your damage and hit points and sends you randomly against other party members, which you kill pretty easily in your massively augmented form.
Drax
I don't discount the "skill" that is necessary to successfully PvE. But, I was talking about PvP.
CosmicConservative
The same is pretty much true of PvP. When I stopped 8 months ago, even though I didn't PvP much, I had a full set of tier 7.5 PvP gear. I've already replaced about four items (out of 17) with better gear, including what is supposed to be the top rated PvP legging armor. I haven't yet gemmed or enchanted them because that takes gold and I need to focus on PvE right now. But if I were focused on PvP, I'd probably have the same situation in reverse. Upper, but not top, tier PvP gear can be purchased with Emblems of Triumph, which are the same things I've been using to purchase much of my PvE gear, and PvP gear drops in raids frequently, which is where I got my leg armor. If that were my focus I'd be pretty similarly competitive compared to my PvE status by now, if not much more so. It's generally much quicker to gain PvP tokens and gain PvP honor than PvE. Battlegrounds are always open for participation and have no limit for play (raiding instances can only be played once per week). So in four hours you might complete a dozen battleground encounters while not getting through a single ICC raid. PvP advancement and gear is easy, but PvP player skill is pretty hard. Back when I had Rhlyss twinked as a PvP ganking rogue, I was pretty happy if I could top the kill charts in PvP combat. And as I said, I only did arena once. Arena matches are pretty much nonstop, you just do them until you're tired of them. And you gain points even if you lose, so getting the top level PvP gear is really just a matter of investing time. In PvE you have to actually win to get the items the boss's drop. If I had focused purely on PvP gear, I'd probably have the T9 gear fully equipped by now with three or four T10 pieces. In PvE I have about half of my gear at T9 and only a single T10 item.