Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Art and science

By CosmicConservative
The Astronomy Picture of the Day is one of the best things about the Internet. But they do have a rather liberal interpretation of what qualifies as an "astronomy picture." Today they, for some reason, have put up Vincent Van Gogh's famous "Starry Night" painting as the APOD. Here is a small reproduction of the painting: starrynight_small.jpg It is one of my favorite paintings, although I'm not really a huge fan of "post-impressionism" or other forms of "modern art." (I think I have previously posted my specific lack of enthusiasm for "abstract expressionism" which I think is more a license to con rich gullible people out of their money than it is art in the sense most people view art.) The question has been raised whether this painting is purely an imaginary vista or if it actually exaggerates, but faithfully reproduces the essential elements of an actual night sky. The moon is pretty clear, but what are the other objects in the sky? And what about the huge swirly thing? There's a pronounced glow along the horizon, could that be a representation of the Aurora Borealis? What do you think?

Comments (34)

Cullen
You know how you stare at a light source for a while -- even something a minute as a starry sky -- and close your eyes and you have all those weird patterns going on? This painting has always kind of reminded me of that.
CosmicConservative
I think that's just you Cullen. ;)
CosmicConservative
Heh, or maybe you and Vincent, I guess....
brad Albone
Abstract Expressionism is aparently beyond your conciousness. Notice, I didn't say beyond your comprehension. I beleive you have a right to your opinion, no matter how ignorant it is. Please don't take offense as the words to follow are written in an attempt to plant the seed of understanding in your somewhat synical mind. :) The genre is adhered to the unseen elements of our nature, i.e. intellect, spirit, soul and emotion, all of which have a subconcious residence. The true abstract expression is only valid at a level that involves life experiences that can only be expressed to those who share an understanding of emotion at the depth which is being delivered on the canvas. An understanding that cannot be expressed with words, and perhaps not even with image. What appears on my canvas is the manifestation of the unseen elements that make up that part of me not otherwise seen. Feel free to quote me.
CosmicConservative
Well, whether abstract expressionism is "beyond my consciousness" or not, spelling "cynical" correctly is within my consciousness. All your rambling, pseudo-psychological babble does is convince me that my opinion is right. "unseen elements that make up the part of me not otherwise seen"... right. How much do you charge for that new-age mantra?
brad
Well, so you're a better speller than me.....perhaps. As far as my fee is concerned......well, you seem like an interesting character, so I would be willing to give you a cut rate. I'm not into new-age at all. I have given much thought to my words while searching for an explanation for what appears on my canvas because what manifests before my eyes does have an origin within me and each work I create gives me a strong sense of self discovery. It doesn't represent nature, it doesn't represent the craft, or any likeness to any particular reference for our minds to process in a concrete way. Hence, "abstract". Yet what appears is asthetic and does invoke a response by the viewer, as does all art. What you refer to as pseudo-phsychological babble makes perfect sense to me. As far as the Van Gough, I believe the "other objects" in the sky represent stars of various magnitude. The huge "swirly thing" may be a representation of the wind. Perhaps the artist wished to represent what ancient scientists once believed to be the makeup of our universe, i.e. Earth, Wind and Fire. This would rationalize the texture of the apparent flames also, discolored to bring the appropriate attention to the large portion of the canvas it fills, while the moon and stars offer the actual fire. So, what do you think?,,,,just more pseudo-psychobabble? or perhaps intelligent insight. If I had to guess the location of the view, I would have to say Vermont. :)
CosmicConservative
Well, you are commenting on a very old post, almost two years old in fact. So don't expect much interaction. I agree that the stars are being represented as being of different magnitudes. As a stargazer I have been out many nights when a high icy haze in the sky causes the stars to have a distinct halo very similar to what Van Gogh has depicted here, and the brighter stars have larger halos. I interpret the "big swirly thing" to be a representation of the Milky Way itself. Most people don't realize that you can see the Milky Way on a dark night, because they have never been out on a dark night, there are too many streetlights these days. If the night is dark enough the milky way does seem to swirl across the sky. In fact the name "Milky Way" is derived from the ancient myth that it was milk squirting from the all-mother's breast. I don't think Van Gogh subscribed to ancient alchemical notions like the elements of earth, air, fire and water. I think he was trying to capture how he perceived the night sky in a way that would faithfully reproduce his own reaction to it. Here's the deal about abstract art... I think I mentioned that I am an avid stargazer. As such I see a lot of beautiful objects in the sky that have no relationship to any "real" object here on earth. In fact the resemblance of many astronomical nebulae to abstract expressionist art has been noted by others besides me. I never said that abstract expressionist art could not be aesthetic. I said that I think that many, if not most, art of that type is of no more intrinsic artistic value than a mud splatter. There was an art competition somewhere in the east cost, and a farmer, as a lark, dipped his mule's tail in different colors of art and tickled the mule's butt to get it to swish it's paint-soaked tail across a canvass. He entered the resulting "abstract expressionist" painting into the competition and won. Jackson Pollack once poured paint into a gutter and allowed passing cars to splash the paint on the canvass and sold the result as an "abstract expressionist" masterpiece. He also once hurled paint into the backwash of a jet engine and allowed the jet thrust to blow the paint onto a canvass, and again sold the result as a masterpiece. I won't even go into the "artist" in England who littered a room with trash and called it art, or the one in New York who sells used urinals. There may be some value in abstract expressionism, but in general the people who buy it buy it because they think it's valuable or gives them "aesthete cred" not because they think it's beautiful. In short they've been conned by the artist. Anyone who spends tens of thousands of dollars on a urinal with a plant growing out of it is nothing but a sucker. Plain and simple. You can call it artistry. I call it con artistry. If I want something abstract to look at and appreciate, I'll just go outside with my telescope. Not only is it free, but it is far more beautiful than "paintings" done by blowing mouthfuls of paint on a canvass. That's more or less how I see it. ;)
CosmicConservative
One final comment. I do appreciate abstract art that I think is truly aesthetic. "Random" is not aesthetic by definition. But a well-thought out collection of abstract designs pleasingly apportioned and balanced in form, color and perspective is fine. Mondrian is an example of that sort of "abstract" art. Even some of Pollack's work when he still cared to put an effort into it qualifies. But for every truly excellent bit of abstract expressionist art, there are thousands of half-baked, slapped together monstrosities whose only purpose is to be able to scoff at people like me and sneer at our "ignorance." Which is fine with me. I've never been a snob of any sort, and I'm not about to worry about the opinion that art snobs have of me.
brad
Actually I didn't even expect the attention you gave. I do agree that there may be a serious lack of boundaries regarding what is and what isn't legitimate expressionism in art. I also agree that color and cohesiveness are necessary elements to a balanced work. There is a point where the table of who is and who isn't ignorant turns. It's a liquid arena, and like most mundane endeavors, money often does determine how art is valued. Personally, I create because I must.It's comforting.
CosmicConservative
Well, I think we can agree on that. I wish I had more of an aesthetic appreciation of life and that I had more creative talent (I think those two actually go together). It is well within the bounds of probability that my perspective on this leans more towards the practical and less towards the aesthetic. I can intellecttually appreciate your comment about creating because you must, but my own compulsions are typically more down to earth, although I believe some of them to be every bit as creative as abstract expressionist art.
brad
Well said. I think we are both speaking about passion, whether it be creative, functional or otherwise. I used to be a functional artist. I made and sold a couple thousand jewel boxes, each one unique in its own way. I applies many different fantasy faux finishes. The usefullness and practicality of my work was satisfying. I may return to my designs, but right now I am currently in a two dimensional period of oil and canvas. Why? I don't know. I just am. It's a one way journey that sometimes looks familiar as I realize the multiple times I have come full circle. It's not babble. It's understanding. I can appreciate the practical and I will return to complete the designs I have stored and filed. I have several designs for vanity armours, a functional avenue that has yet to be explored. Regardless of the avenue you pour your passion to, it will show in the end product, whether it be furniture, art of any genre, or a simple wooden cribbage board, it's the makers hand that annoints the work.
Phil
This is a question, more than a comment--I am trying to track down the name of a painting/artist ... the abstract image is of a face -- as though it has been peeled with an apple peeler -- so that the face looks more like a spring, or coil, than just one solid piece of skin. It is not bloody, or gory -- it is actually peaceful ... Any chance you know this work? Or can direct me to a site?
Dadman
Phil: I believe that work was done by M.C. Escher. Google Escher and you will likely find the work you are looking for...
fizz.
i agree with cullen, even though the comment was posted ages ago i totally feel the same way about this painting but can i ask what is this painting done by? pastel?..
Bullshido fossilido
Baby, baby, baby! Where do I begin? Why is it that so many people who look at Impressionistic or Abstract art ask the question, "What is it suppose to be?" This is like looking at someone's tombstone and asking, "Who was this person and how did their life touch others?" Neither the abstract painting or the tombstone were designed to answer the above questions. However, it appears to me that Mr. Albone is more interested in talking about and asking questions of himself than addressing the initial comments of CosmicConservative. To be honest, a strong hit of LSD would do well to explain the painting properly to CC and probably would help BAlbone think about something other than his own thoughts.
brad
Well Bullshido fossilido, you can start wherever you like, but since you asked, I'd be happy to guide you. You should absolutely start by containing yourself and your obviously clueless interpretation of what my purpose is. The attention you give to me is totally unsolicited and unwelcomed as I did not address you in any of my postings, nor did I address any of your concerns. So, after containing yourself, go ahead and take some more LSD and visit another grave yard, if that is what floats your boat.
Bullshido fossilido
Ha. Contain myself indeed. After I stop laughing. Dear, dear Balboone... what can I say. Most probably, nothing that could cut through the dense material that is your construct of reality. Open your eyes dude. The world is a totally beautiful place and full of possibility. The negative vibes that permeate the space that is your own limited reality are nothing more than the shadows and illusions that watch in fear and cause you to tremble with panic. If I were to guess, you probably are someone who suffers a severe case of short-man syndrome... but then I am only guessing. If you're not short, than you are obviously a tall man full of your own ego and thoughts of self-centered flattery. Ha, I say. Take that.
Bullshido fossilido
Correction..."The negative vibes that permeate the space that is your own limited reality are nothing more than the shadows and illusions that YOU watch in fear and ALSO cause you to tremble with panic ALARM."
Bullshido fossilido
P.S. If you are indeed a small man, you more than likely have other things than just a small mind to go with your limited and small vision of what constitutes ART.
Bullshido fossilido
P.S. LSD also stands for Lakeshore Drive. But then you would have known that if you new everything like you claim to know.
El Capitan
Dear Bullshido fossillido, I must concur. What type of man - or is he even a man - jumps onto a website and smears from the very beginning, the individual providing the service. How arrogant. In deed, if Baboone is not a little man, he certainly has demonstrated that he thinks like one. To put it mildly, he speaks the language of a psuedo-intellectual - although I imagine him more like George Wallace before the bullet. I enjoy reading the comments placed on this website, but I find Mr. Baboone's attacks to be sadly revolting and more resembling of the pungent and sick feeling I get when I drink poorly made home-made beer. But hey, that's just my viewpoint.
Blackfeet to Crow about
Come on guys. Personally, I think Brad makes some pretty good points about expressionist painting and outlooks. His point that the artist needs to approach his artwork from the viewpoint of someone who is empty and void of human perspective demonstrates his understanding of scientific perspective. Personally,if more artists concentrated on keeping their opinions to themselves and focusing more on producing colorful patches of eye-candy, we wouldn't have big mouths such as the Dixie Chicks espousing liberal political idiocies, i.e. the war in Iraq was a bad idea or that President Bush is a war monger who loves to invade other countries or pro choice is a legitamate choice for anyone who believes in democracy. I agree with people like Brad - it's America - Love it or leave it! Art isn't about the artist and for that matter, neither is patriotism about individuals are their so-called liberties. It's about our country and it needs to make sense. That's why I am a conservative and I suspect that's why Brad is one too. I'm sure you won't find him hanging around those California Liberal types are "art-house want-to-be's. And for that matter,neither will you find me there. Kudos to you Mr. Brad.
Brad
Thanks Blackfeet to Crow about; You appear to have a much greater understanding than my attackers. Your words are appreciated. To Bullshido fossilido and El Capitan, name calling is week and every critical word you write about me says much more about your character, or lack thereof, than they say about me. You are likened to two dogs running up to a fence and barking at me from your penned in area, all the while looking and waiting to see if I will drop down to your level and bark back. While you're waiting, just remember, every dog has his day. I stand a man and look on as witness to your self imposed demise. On a lighter note, I give honest input and back up my perspective with the essence of my being and the logic of my own rational thoughts, while also giving merit to those who have walked before me, such as the author of the following quote from and undeniably respected source. "Great Spirits have often been attacked by mediocre minds" Geronimo I look forward to your response.
CosmicConservative
Brad: Geronimo was undoubtedly right, but it is an illogical reversal to then assume that if an attack is being made, the victim is a "great spirit" or the attackers have "mediocre minds." "It rains on the just and unjust alike" isn't much of a way to separate the two categories...
brad
CosmicConservative: I would agree it not wise to assume, make no buts about it. As far as who posesses a "great spirit" and who has a "mediocre mind" is perhaps more obvious to some than others. It appears also that we both know that small droplets of water are probably not the source that will separate the just from the unjust. What's more important is what takes place after the separation.
CosmicConservative
LOL, tell you what mahh, I'll "get a life" when you get a spell checker and learn to type entire words in comments, deal?
Bullshido fossilido
Every once in a while, I bounce back to these posts just to see how this abstract expressionistic conversation has unfolded. Oddly, I am never surprised at what I find. Personally, I think these posts make Brad's first point about abstract painting. Put that in your tea and let it seep.
CosmicConservative
Wow, I'm glad this has at least left a mark in your consciousness Bullshido. I do hope you enjoy your donkey-tail-swish abstract expressionist contest winning paintings. Or whatever else makes you feel superior to others.
JSullins
Oh, man. For kicks I went back and read some of these "Brad" posts. HILARIOUS! ...to the point that I'm tempted to consider that he was attempting intentional humor by parody... of himself. This is my favorite: "You are likened to two dogs running up to a fence and barking at me from your penned in area, all the while looking and waiting to see if I will drop down to your level and bark back. While you’re waiting, just remember, every dog has his day. I stand a man and look on as witness to your self imposed demise." And now that I think on it some more, this sounds an awful lot like the language used by the North Korean propaganda machine. I wonder...
CosmicConservative
It's sort of a shame that this particular post got sidetracked on the abstract expressionist path though, "Starry Night" is actually a very nice painting and is impressionist, not expressionist and isn't abstract at all. In fact there is a lot of debate about how accurately Van Gogh was trying to be. The night sky can look pretty amazing under the right atmospheric conditions.
brad
The night sky can look amazing, beyond amazing actually. If you ever get the chance to look up from a quiet and remote spot in the Mojave Desert of California, the experience is more than words or pictures can express.