Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Climategate tipping point?

By CosmicConservative
The recent Phil Jones interview where he admitted that his data, his analysis and his methodology were irredeemably flawed has precipitated a Global Warming crisis in the English press. In effect the British press is now publishing more stories critical of the Global Warming alarmists and more stories supportive of AGW skepticism than they are of the reverse. This is a stunning turnaround for a press that was wholly committed to AGW and has been for a decade. The American press has not yet pursued this story at all really, but the alternative media is getting the message out in spite of the journalistic malpractice of our media. But a more important result has begun to emerge. Stories quoting scientists who not only question the AGW dogma, but who have performed peer-reviewed research demonstrating results completely counter to the AGW party line are even beginning to appear in the US press. Since the whole AGW house of cards has been built almost entirely on the claim by algore and his AGW ilk that there is a worldwide AGW "scientific consensus," the reporting of stories which clearly refute that consensus cannot help but erode the AGW argument at its root. That alone will cause the house of cards to come crashing down eventually. I've been hesitant to call "Climategate" an end to the AGW stranglehold on the media and politics, but I'm getting close to saying that has been the result. In Europe anyway, the press is actually doing their job, and the results are having calamitous effects on the AGW movement. It should only be a matter of time before that result moves across the Atlantic. The New York Times and the State Run Media can only hold it at bay for so long. And in so doing, they are simply digging their own graves faster.

Comments (6)

Old Goat
But that might mean Hollywood was wrong! How can that be? I think AGW is right up there in validity with those documents that Rather reported on.
CosmicConservative
As has been noted from the start by people like us, the Left loves AGW because it gives them ammunition to pursue their true statist agenda. They will glom onto it as long as they can for the same reason. Since the press in the USA is almost wholly far left moonbat style of liberal ideology, they will be among the last, if not THE last to desperately try to hang onto the mythology.
Drax
I think that "Climategate" has done is to convince fence-sitters (such as myself) to become more skeptical than before. The vast, vast, vast majority of us have to bow to authority on this issue. We don't have the ability to understand the calculations nor have access to the data (or to even understand why this piece of data is important as opposed to that...) So, we have to bow to authority. Now, it appears that the "authority" upon which most people rested lied. That hurts their case. I no more NOW know whether there's artificial global warming than I did before "Climategate." Just because one or more people lied about their research and findings doesn't MEAN that they were wrong; it just means that they're liars. Just because skeptics said that they were wrong (and/or were liars) doesn't mean that the skeptics are right. I don't think that, ultimately, Science is sufficiently advanced to forecast what is to happen in the future as it regards weather and weather patterns. When they get SEASONAL weather right, I'll start paying more attention to them, but, unless they can tell me NOW what the weather's going to be like NEXT WINTER in Shreveport, what credibility do they have trying to forecast what the weather is going to be like 10 years from now all over the globe? So, I'll continue my basic "risk/cost analysis." Those steps which can be taken to minimize damage to the environment, reduce or eliminate toxins in the air -- we should take -- so long as it has no appreciable impact upon our standard of living. Can't hurt and might help. But, this "science by consensus" (on this and ANY other matter) has to STOP. Unfortunately, the only ones who can stop it are the very ones who initiate it -- THE SCIENTISTS who profit from it.
CosmicConservative
Drax, add this to your analysis. Skeptics like me didn't just say "ah, they are full of crap." We said that their graphs left out known historical events, that their data collection sources were heat biased, thattheir computer models were fundamentally flawed and that their methods were confrontational and unscientific. Now that even Phil Jones has admitted we were right on all points you might want to consider us skeptics as being more reliable and accurate than you might have before. We AGW skeptics don't deny hat the climate is warming, what we are saying and always have said is that the science shows a steady warming since he last ice age, but nothing in the data or theory of climatology clearly demonstrates recent the recent climate changes are unnatural, unprecedented or alarming. That's what we've said all along.
CosmicConservative
By the way that last post and this one were sent from the endodontist chair as I await oral surgery, from my Droid, so forgive the typos and stuff please.
Drax
That's cool tech! From a 'Droid...sounds like something we read about (and thought we'd never see) as children reading Clarke... Again...I have absolutely no foundation to recognize the conclusions of ANY authority -- on ANY side of the debate. I can set up bare minimums as to whether their conclusions should be taken as CREDIBLE (as opposed to "correct"). Has the theory been peer reviewed? Has the process whereby the conclusion was reached been vetted by those who understand such things and deemed to be a valid process? Is the data which is being used an acceptable foundation from which valid conclusions can be drawn? AGW proponents presented these three areas (and, with time and thought, I'm sure I could concoct several more) as being satisfied, and, for the most part, this is the way it was presented in the press. (Well, "for the most part" basically means "uniformly.") One had to really watch things closely (and know where to look -- and know what to look for -- and know when to notice that something's missing -- etc...) in order to even have an INKLING that FOIA documents requesting the foundational data were being denied, that the program which crunched that data wasn't transparent to review, or that the very peer review process had been corrupted. And, even then, "Climategate" caught just about everyone off-guard with both the nature and the scope of the lies -- not only from the so-called "scientists," but the government (which didn't enforce the FOIA demands -- or demand transparency in process, data, and results), the press (which hid or conspired to conceal that the peer review process had been corrupted), academia (which has proven to be corrupt across the board), the UN, NASA -- ETC. ETC. ETC. This is IMPORTANT STUFF. Supposedly this is END OF THE WORLD STUFF. (Well, the only part of the world I truly care about -- that part of it which allows the HUMAN RACE TO SURVIVE...) Yet, at every step of the process, those who were CHARGED WITH ensuring that the "science" was "science" either passively or actively conspired to LIE to us. Tar. Feathers. We can check the "peer reviewed" literature, but, I'm betting that they still work...