Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie review: The Lightning Thief

By CosmicConservative
So the Cosmic Daughter is a prolific reader and she periodically insists that I read one of her favorite books. I try to always do so since she has excellent taste and only recommends quality books. Sometime last year she came home with a book titled "The Lightning Thief" and suggested I read it. So I did. It's a very well done book. The basic premise of the book is that the Greek Gods are real and have never gone away, and that they and their demigod children still dominate the world, although their existence is a deeply kept secret. The hero of the book is, of course, a demigod, one "Percy Jackson" who has been raised in ignorance of his nature by his mother and his smelly step-father. The story begins with the revelation that a major earth-shattering war is brewing among the gods of Olympus due to the theft of Zeus's magical lightning bolt, a weapon that is more powerful than any nuclear bomb humans have ever created. And even though Percy doesn't even know he's a demigod, the gods believe he is the thief. From there the story takes the reader on a wild ride through a mash-up of Greek mythology and modern pop culture. It's a charming book, but with sufficient darkness and danger to give it an edge that will keep you wanting to turn the pages. And it has a suitably satisfying ending that is at the same time clever and sentimental. I thoroughly enjoyed it. So when the movie previews started I found myself looking forward to the movie, and tonight the Cosmic Wife and I went to watch it. We both enjoyed it. The movie was very faithful to the premise, the tone and the cleverness of the book. Logan Lerman, the actor who played Percy, looks like an excellent actor on the rise. This was a difficult role to pull of in a sympathetic way, but he did an excellent job. Alexandra Daddario, as Annabeth was a good fit for his foil and female companion. They even managed to generate some chemistry from time to time. Pierce Brosnan was suitably impressive and classically stoic as Chiron, the centaur trainer of the demigods. The story was usually well paced and action packed, but seemed a bit disjointed to me, in part perhaps due to expectations I had from the book. The biggest complaint I have about the movie is one that is only due to reading the book, and that was the complete absence of the sub-plot involving Mars, the god of war. In the book Mars not only played a major role, but was a very enjoyable character. I was disappointed that one of my favorite parts of the book was completely left out of the movie. But judging the movie based only on it being a movie, I think it was entertaining and should provide a solid evening of enjoyment for kids of all ages. And as I said, I think this Logan Lerman dude has a very promising future.

Comments (4)

Cullen
I took the kids to see it this weekend and we enjoyed it also. My oldest loves the series and she loved the movie, but seemed to have the same issues with it you do. Not having read the books, I enjoyed it enough. I thought it was quite well-paced.
Dadman
My son has read all the Percy Jackson books, multiple times, and he was disappointed in the movie because it failed to follow the book closely enough. I told him that is typical when books are translated to the screen. Logan Lerman played the ungrateful son in '3:10 to Yuma', btw...
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I looked him up and saw that. He's got a fairly impressive filmography already. I don't disagree with your son's disappointment, I was disappointed too. I was actually really looking forward to Mars's appearance, I had envisioned him as something similar to the biker nemesis in "Raising Arizona". But, for those who have not read the book, I don't think that is something they would notice. I notice that the movie is getting just about a 50% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, I suspect most of the negatives are from people who liked the book more than the movie. The rumor is that the author was not happy with the movie.
Cosmic Daughter
I agree that the movie was not similar enough to the book. I am starting to see a pattern with the movie-introducing-book system. In general the movie takes the thing the director thinks the audience would like to watch and exaggerate it to spike up an interest in the book or series. I admit I was also upset when Mars was not in the book. I must admit that the battle with Luke was fascinating and that didn't happen in the book either. I don't blame Rick Riodan for not liking the movie. The gods were very important characters and we only see Zeus, Poseidon and Hades up close. Another disappointment of mine was the scene in St. Louis. When Percy jumps off the arch and falls into the river. I only hope that people don't stop there and go read the books to find out how the main plot ties in.