Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is the Health Care "reform" bill constitutional?

By CosmicConservative
I know there has been enough discussion about the potential unconstitutionality of both the House and Senate's version of Health Care that Nancy Pelosi actually responded by claiming that the Commerc Clause gave Congress the power to force you to buy a product or else get fined and/or jailed. But forgive me if I don't consider Nancy Pelosi an expert on constitutional law. I also know that "is it constitutional" is no longer remotely a question about looking at the constitution itself, but instead is a much less exact science of reading the current members of the SCOTUS to see if they could find a tiny crack big enough to drive this oil supertanker through. Still, I wonder if the SCOTUS will rule it unconstitutional. There are several arguments about it being unconstitutional, among them are: 1. The Congress simply doesn't have the power to enforce any laws that are based on "enforcing the public good." Of course people used this argument to oppose the New Deal, School lunch funding, food stamps and a wealth of other programs that have never seriously been challenged by the SCOTUS. But is there any limit to this? 2. The congress simply doesn't have jurisdiction. This is the argument Pelosi is trying to short-circuit with her argument that it's a "commerce clause" issue. Of course if this is a commerce clause issue, then the commerce clause is simply a license to do anything you want. Which it more or less is becoming, if you want my opinion. 3. Even if the commerce clause can be argued to provide a rationale for health care reform, it does not allow Congress to create a mandated product that people must buy. The commerce clause simply cannot be pushed that far. Again, this was also addressed by Nancy's argument that Congress can do whatever it likes by invoking the Commerce clause. That would include, I suppose, forcing you to brush your teeth. 4. Even if the commerce clause can be invoked and stretched that far, a clever attorney could use the "takings" clause to challenge the bill's constitutionality. That clause states that the government cannot take anything from a citizen without providing adequate compensation. So forcing people to buy health care would have to be demonstrated to provide adequate compensation. Statistically that would be difficult since the entire reason for forcing people to buy health care is to overtly subsidize older, less healthy people by making younger, healthier people pay into the system. That's more or less an admission that there is no adequate compensation, it's an overt and admitted wealth transfer from the young to the old. Of course this is why the actual construction of the bill puts this mandate forth as a "tax" while the rhetoric of the bill is that it is NOT a tax. By being an actual tax the Democrats feel they can avoid it being seen as "taking" property from a citizen. But they can't SAY that because then Obama will have (again, for the seeventh or eighth time) broken his "promise" not to raise taxes. I don't know if any of these will be successful in court, but if I were the Republican Party, I'd put a team of lawyers on the last one of these and force the SCOTUS to at least rule that this is a tax, so they can beat the hell out of Obama over his massive increase in taxes after promising no taxes on anyone making less than $250K per year.

Comments (7)

kevin in WI
Wasn't this country founded partly in revolt against a piece of legislation that mandated the "purchase" of a stamp on newspapers, books, pamphlets, contracts, etc. (i.e. the 1765 stamp act)? It is very sad that our free republic has devolved into this.
Drax
The answer to this question, as all like questions, is: "It depends on what 5 people with robes say IF they address the issue at all." Certainly, it can be supported via the "general welfare clause" as have so many other things. The extent of the power this allows Congress hasn't been tested. If one believes in a limited government, one doesn't WANT it tested. The answer, unfortunately, may be one which we do not want to hear. And, once answered, the difficulty in overcoming the edict of those 5 can be insurmountable.
Brian
I don't think they are going to have a branch to stand on if they try to challenge this bill as unconstitutional. They make you pay social security tax. There is not much difference. I think the fact of the matter is, something has to be done to reform health care. And by health care I mean the trillions of dollars the government is spending on it. Especially with the baby boomers right around the corner. Something has to be done or actual health care will be the least of our concerns.
RPM
Mock & Tolin: The Constitutionality of the Health Insurance Tax Rodney P. Mock & Jeffrey Tolin (California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo -- Orfalea College of Business) have posted Purchase or Else: The Health Insurance "Tax", 126 Tax Notes 224 (Jan. 11, 2010), on SSRN. Here is the abstract: With the Affordable Health Care for America Act, H.R. 3962, passed by the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate’s version of a health care bill, the Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act, H.R. 3590, recently passed, this article reviews the particulars of each Act’s respective tax or penalty imposed on individual taxpayers who fail to purchase acceptable health care coverage, and questions whether or not such constitutes a “tax” at all, and if such does, whether or not it is an unconstitutional regulatory tax, indirectly regulating that which Congress cannot under the “Commerce Clause” of the U.S. Constitution; namely, non-participating taxpayers who merely “fail to purchase.”
Drax
RPM: Even assuming the provision concerning forcing people to purchase health care insurance or be fined/imprisoned is unconstitutional (and I think it is), if SCOTUS is able to strike that unconstitutional provision leaving the rest of the bill they WILL -- that is Con Law 101...
CosmicConservative
Drax, if they do, they undercut one of the fundamental financial pillars of the bill, meaning that ruling would instantly add a substantial fraction of a trillion dollars to the growing defecit. But as Obama seems to think.. "deficit schmeficit! Who cares?"
Old Goat
The bigger problem is that even if this garbage is passed and brought before the Supreme Court and found unconstitutional, it will already be in place and mean that those who were fined will be given their money back along with free government run health care. I think they might find it unconstitutional, given that they blew apart McLame FindGold. Look how long that took though. The wheels of justice turn very slowly.