Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More climate "research" corruption

By CosmicConservative
So, Russian climate scientists are calling BS on the IPCC, NOAA and CRU climate datasets that were obtained from Russian weather stations. Basically they have looked at THEIR OWN DATA, which comprises something like 1/4 of all land-based measurements used by the IPCC and CRU to build the case for "Anthropogenic Global Warming" and have discovered that when they plot THEIR OWN DATA, they do not get a pronounced warming trend in the 20th century into the 21st century. In looking at the data the CRU used they discovered that the CRU threw out HALF of the temperature readings gathered by Russian weather stations, and the ones the CRU KEPT were stations which trended towards higher temperatures, mostly due to being in more urban locations. This is on top of revelations that the CRU threw out all but THREE weather stations in Northern Australia (out of dozens available) and those three were the HOTTEST stations reporting, and similar shenanigans in New Zealand. Basically Russian scientists are saying that the ENTIRE NOAA DATA SET upon which ALL CLIMATE RESEARCH is based, is a crock. The data has been EXTENSIVELY cherry-picked to throw out lower temperature stations and preserver higher temperature stations DELIBERATELY and for DECADES. This isn't some crank blooger who is making this charge, this is an official Russian Government statement. I said a couple weeks ago that the East Anglia CRU emails were likely the tip of the iceberg...

Comments (3)

Rodger V Rossman
CC, I am just half ass going about this, but what do you make of this: http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2009/12/06/did-russian-security-services-leak-climategate-e-mail-messages
CosmicConservative
Hmm... my immediate response is that Russia has something to gain from the imposition of Global Warming treaties, so I don't know that there is an obvious geopolitical gain for them in scuttling the Copenhagen talks. But who knows? The Russians are a complex lot. My personal opinion remains the same, the leak came from a climatologist on the "inside" who simply could not stomach what Jones, Mann et. al. were doing to his "science" and he simply decided to blow the whistle on them. I usually go for the simplest solution that makes sense, and that's what makes the most sense to me. The emails weren't "hacked" anyone who knows anything about hackers knows that. A hacker would have released everything, especially embarrassing personal emails that were certainly included in the raw data that was taken from the CRU. Someone carefully went through those emails and removed virtually all of the lame, mundane, but potentially highly embarrassing emails that exist on any large email server, leaving behind mostly emails that deal with the actual science. That smacks to me of someone who was specifically targeting the revelations of malfeasance, not just someone who wanted to show off how they could break into an email system. Of course that logic could apply to Russian agents as well. So who knows?
Rodger V Rossman
You are probably correct, for a lot of reasons, that the leak had to be internal. Now, if the Russians had a mole (don't 'ya just love that Cold War terminology....frickin' Reds) exposed the emails, the correspondences are still very damaging. Personally, I had never felt that the deceit was purposeful. More like how my team always seemed to win when I played statistical baseball with myself as a kid. All this has made me a little more respectful towards this particular conspiracy theory. A few weeks ago I came across several National Geographic magazines from the seventies. One, from 1976, had the rather intriguing title "What's going On With Our Climate?" Of course the concern was about a 3 decade long cooling trend. To be fair, the article was very robust in discussion of climate including the, then possible, accelerated greenhouse effect. The interviewed climatologists weren't stupid. However, the author did state that the best way to witness a fight is to get two climatologists in the same room. Makes one wonder how the IPCC managed to get those 300 to commit to a consensus. What was interesting about the long article was that the sharp increase in "global" (a bullshit misnomer when studying climate) temperature declined from the 40's into the author's time-1976. Of course, it picked up again, in the 80's and, depending on who you believe, declined again around 2000. So, the Al Gore paradigm is correct....except for that 3 decade period, which is squeezed and obscured on the 1000 year Mann hockey stick graph. Lies, damned lies and statistics.