Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Toys: technology vs. craftsmanship

By CosmicConservative
OK, so everyone knows that boys like their toys. I am certainly one of those typical testosterone-based-lifeforms (TBLs) who enjoys toys. (I'm feeling particulalry alliterative today...) I may be weird (OK, I am definitely weird in any GENERAL sense, but in this case I mean I may be SPECIFICALLY weird on this particular topic) but I find myself just about equally drawn to technology and to craftsmanship as valuable attributes of my toys. For example, perhaps my single most treasured possession is my 92mm apochromatic refractor telescope. It is the closest material thing to perfection that I own. It has no flashing lights, no circuitry, no elecronic interfaces, nothing but a tube, some glass lenses and a precision mechanical focuser. It is about as basic as it gets, but what sets it apart from other telescopes is its incredible craftsmanship. It is as much art as it is science. On the other hand, I absolutely love my iPod, which is essentially a mass-produced commodity made of plastic and circuitry which will be obsolete before I finish typing this message. There are other examples, my iBook vs. my hand-made Martin acoustic guitar. My handheld Global Positioning System vs. my fly rod and flies.... But these seem to be two completely mutually exclusive attributes. And more and more I am suspecting that for most people technology trumps craftsmanship. To put it bluntly, if my iBook were lovingly constructed out of mahogany, with exquisite dovetail joints and a hand-burnished french varnish finish that took days of polishing and sanding, would I hold on to it any longer if I could afford the new Mac laptop which is ten times as powerful? It seems that when techology and craftsmanship collide, it is craftsmanship that is sacrificed for the simple reason that there is really no point to investing in crafting such things when they will be obsolete within months anyway.... That was the point of my other post, it sort of makes me wonder about our society in a way. I wonder what it is teaching our children.

Comments (2)

Cullen
I wonder if it is technology causing the fall of craftsmanship or the way society approaches commodities. We have the ability to make electronics and other gear to a higher quality standard. A lot of these things could be thoughroughly upgradable. Are driven to constantly want something new because technology moves so quickly, or is technology producing these disposable commodities because we want something new so often? It sure would be nice to buy an affordable computer that was built as well as my guitar. Or an affordable car that was built as well as my old 1965 Ford. I think that's the key -- affordability. There are still products being built to exacting standards, we just can't afford them. Well, I can't anyway.
Aaron
It seems that when techology and craftsmanship collide, it is craftsmanship that is sacrificed for the simple reason that there is really no point to investing in crafting such things when they will be obsolete within months anyway…. Not so with me. Even though I enjoy a lot of high-technology software (for purposes of convenience), and the latest studio-graphics computer games, I still have some very old ones that were fun to play, nevertheless. Plus, it never stopped my from painstakingly coding my own in C and C++. (Ahhh, falling blocks. Who could forget a good tetris analog?) Time constraints prevent me from investing too much in this, as doing anything seriously fun with it requires too much time. In fact, if the majority of the fun I have isn't learning how to program something new (you spend a lot more time cursing the compiler than playing the final product), usually I lose focus and stop.