Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Melancholy about technology

By CosmicConservative
So yesterday I dug deep into my closet and dragged out my old Nikon FM2(n) camera with the motor drive and the manual focus lenses. I dusted off everything, put new batteries in the motor drive and hooked up the 180mm f2.8 ED lens that I used to think was the coolest thing I had ever owned. I even found an old roll of 35mm 400 speed film in the bag, and put that in too. Then I took it outside and took a few pictures, just to see if I remembered how it all worked. I did, and it did. As I carried it around (not on a neck strap, just by hand) I was struck by two completely contradictory thoughts simultaneously: "Man this thing weighs a ton!" and "Geez! this thing is built like a tank!" I swear, I could fend off a mountain lion with that getup, it probably weighs close to 4 pounds total. When I graduated from college in 1984, my father purchased a Nikon FE-2 for my graduation present. I loved that camera, and I have boxes and boxes of prints from every vacation, my courting of my wife, honeymoon, photos of kids... I thought that was the most incredible gadget I had ever owned. But eventually as my financial situation improved, I fell in love with the Auto-focus cameras that were taking over the photographic world in the 90s. Concidentally, I ended up buying a Nikon N90s and for several years the old FE-2 became my backup camera. Eventually I traded the FE-2 for its completely manual twin camera, the FM2(n), but it also was simply a backup camera. Then came the day a few years ago when I realized that digital cameras were going to replace 35mm film cameras, and I decided to sell my N90s and all my fancy accessories for it while there was still a demand for it, and to go ahead and take the digital plunge for my casual photography, and use the FM2(n) for my "real" photography. Well, there has been very little, if any, "real" photography in the past two years. The money I got from selling the N90s I used to buy a Martin 000-M guitar, and since then my hobby of choice has been the guitar, not the camera. And with the purchase of two digital cameras with quite respectable performance, the Nikon has been absent on our more recent hiking and camping trips as well. So what triggered this sudden nostalgia for my old manual film-based camera? Of all things, it was an article on Cloudy Nights, an amateur astronomy website, where someone was buying old manual focus lenses on eBay and removing the optical elements to use the focusing mechanism as a cheap telescope focuser. Now for the past two days I have been scouring eBay for manual focus lenses of the type I used to lust after. The legendary Nikon 80-200 f2.8 zoom lens! The 300mm ED IF f2.8 wildlife lens! The 400mm f3.5 super telephoto lens that used to rule NFL sidelines until Canon took over sports photography in the 90s. So I got my old camera out, and just holding it in my hands it brings back the long-lost feelings of owning something that was the best at what it did. Of course there are lots of Leica owners out there who will sniff at my lowly FM2(n) and Nikkor lenses, but that's an old battle, although one vigorously fought. I remember comparisions of photos taken with the FE-2 vs. Leica cameras and lenses, battles where Leica owners would literally claim that their cameras could outperform the diffraction limits set by the laws of physics. Oh, those were the days, weren't they? Which film had the finest grain? Could you produce higher quality results with filters and black and white technical pan film recombined at vastly higher resolution than color film could reach? Which lenses performed best wide-open? Was the 300mm f2.8 "soft" around the edges when wide open? Which was better, the reds of Kodachrome or the greens of Fujichrome? I'm sure some of this is still going on with professional photographers, but much of it now feels to me like the dance band playing on the Titanic. It is hard to believe that just ten years ago I was drooling over camera equipment that now seems quaint, outdated, even obsolete. I think about heading out to Rocky Mountain National Park with my FM2(n), motor winder and telephoto lenses on a sturdy ballhead tripod and I wonder what the folks around me would think while I set it up. As they whip out their tiny little Sony digital cameras and snap photo after photo while I carefully check lighting values and study the image on my ground glass screen for the best possible focus, changing aperture to try for the best depth of field, carefully using my cable connector to fire the shutter so that there is as little vibration as possible... I feel like an anachronism just holding this thing. But I still love it. I love the feel of it. The construction of it. The glass in the lenses, the smooth sliding of the aperture diaphragm, all of it just has a feeling of significance to it that our digital cameras simply lack. It used to be that you had to learn something about light, lenses, aperture and shutter speeds to take decent photos. Now it truly has become point and click. I've seen some absolutely amazing photos taken by tiny digital cameras with internal processors that calculate every possible variable setting for the best possible result, processors that are smaller than the batteries in the lumbering behemoth of mine. And the final thing I realize as I put the camera back in its case for the night, is that this camera was beloved by photographers for many reasons, one of which was its (then) tiny size. I guess it is the nature of progress that all technology is relegated to the scrap heap of history. But I have to say, as I close the case on the camera bag, this stuff deserves a better fate.

Comments (5)

Cullen
It used to be that you had to learn something about light, lenses, aperture and shutter speeds to take decent photos. Now it truly has become point and click. I’ve seen some absolutely amazing photos taken by tiny digital cameras with internal processors that calculate every possible variable setting for the best possible result, processors that are smaller than the batteries in the lumbering behemoth of mine. Having been a photojournalist and now being an editor and sometime photojournalist, I would argue that you still need to learn something about light, lenses, aperture and shutter speeds to take decent photos. While your auto settings will take good, generic-setting photos, to get some of those thought-out, well exposed shots, you still need to know what to do to accomplish this. Will the majority of casual and amateur photographers need this? No, that's why digital photography is so popular. Cheap cameras produce very good results. But digital SLRs, while giving you all those great auto settings, are still amazingly versatile with their manual settings. Biggest thing I miss about "wet" film, depth of field. Digital photography really doesn't interpret depth of field. I miss that selective focus point with blurred surroundings. But I guess that's really a minor point given all the conveniences that digital photography has brought.
CosmicConservative
Yes, I agree that digital SLRs intended for pro use still require all the knowledge that the file SLRs required, including "film speed," depth of field, lighting, etc. But, and this is a very big but, 15 years ago if you wanted to post-process your image, you were pretty much out of luck unless you had an actual darkroom and knew how to manipulate film. Now you just load it into Photoshop and have your way with it. I do believe that even serious amateurs typically see great improvements in their final product using modern digital equipment, with much less investment made in learning the Camera, the Negative and the Print (to paraphrase Ansel Adams). Now the critical skill that seems to be the most important is none of the above, it's Photoshop.
Cullen
I am not going to argue with any of that. However, to produce known, repetitious results, you gotta know what you're doing. But, as I stated in my first post, the ease with which cheap cameras produce very good results make even the most amateur photographer capable of appearing the pro. Sometimes. Oh and I tell you what photographers are really forgetting -- flash settings. TTL just doesn't cut it sometimes. Lots of modern photojournalists don't have a firm grasp on bouncing or diffusing the flash. Otherwise, I'm in the same boat as you. The first newspaper I worked on (in the Army) was a small monthly. It afforded me a lot of time to do other things. I used to spend a lot of time at the darkroom at the Arts and Crafts Center for both work-related and personal photography. I miss laboring over a print for the experience of it. But I sure appreciate being able to batch process 20 or 30 shots in the time it would take me to process one black and white shot.
CosmicConservative
This comment thread has taken me back a bit to my old "serious amateur photographer" days, which has been fun. But the point of my original post wasn't to dwell on film photography so much as to discuss the melancholy feeling I get when I look at or use my old FM2 camera. I get similar feelings when I pull out my old portable typewriter, or my old vinyl LPs or my old Apple Newton Messagepad, or (insert old fuddy-duddy gadget here)... I'll post a new message that tries to get more to the point, which is that technology seems to trump craftsmanship and I really hate to see such beautiful machinery relegated to the dust bin of history by more technologically feature-laden devices that are typically not crafted nearly as well.
Cullen
Well, I certainly didn't mean to hijack the train of thought. I just found a tangent I have a lot of experience in and drove forward. I do, of course, see your point.