Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How worried should we be?

By CosmicConservative
I almost titled this post "Should we be worried?" but I figured we're past that and into the "How worried should we be?" phase of the potential financial meltdown... FWIW, here's my take: I consider this to be a very much-needed lesson in basic economics for me, the country and the world. We tend to think of our everyday experience as being "normal" and we tend to view institutions like banks as being part of the "real world." but historically our economic "machine" is brand new and pretty much unprecedented. Especially in a world where "money" has become electronic as much as anything else has. The value of a currency has always been fundamentally about "trust" and the ability to get money when you need money has always been about "trust" as well. We trust that the government is going to be stable and that our financial institutions will be stable as well. Our government and our institutions trust that most people are basically decent and responsible. The result of that is that governments support banks, banks support people, people borrow and pay back money and the plumbing of finance generally goes unremarked upon. Over the years people have learned how to "leverage" money so that the same "chips" perform different "jobs" for different people, all in a chain of financial transactions that have become impossible to track due to the way money flows to and from reservoirs of "cash" as it moves around. In essence you can think of money as the oil and grease that keeps our lives smoothly moving along. But that's all based on trust. When trust starts to go away, the oil and grease starts to dry up. Banks are less willing to loan money when they don't trust that people or businesses will pay it back. People are less likely to save or invest money when they don't trust that their investments are being managed appropriately. When trust evaporates, so do the great reservoirs of "cash" that allow the flow of commerce to happen. And that's what it feels like is happening now. We've got a situation that is now worldwide where the reservoirs of available cash are drying up. That means people and businesses both will find it more difficult to borrow the money they need to keep their daily activities going. Less money to borrow means that a guitar factory can buy less materials, and therefore produces fewer guitars, meaning they make less money and can afford to pay fewer workers, etc... This is why the economy seems to have momentum. When confidence is up, that tends to drive more money into the pools of commerce, which makes it "easier" to get funding for businesses to make things and hire work. Conversely when confidence starts to drop, the reverse happens and less money is available, meaning that fewer businesses can get funding to make things and hire employees. Much of modern commerce flows along these "promissory" lines, not along the lines of hard cash or material goods. Companies plan their product lines and their payroll based not on what they have in the bank, but on what they feel they can borrow to fund their needs. They "bank" on their ability to gain funding and "bank" on their ability to repay the loans based on the creation and sale of goods created BECAUSE of their ability to borrow. This is also why it is so hard to manage the economy. It's virtually impossible to quantify "trust" much less to quantify how trust is growing or shrinking. So, how much trust HAS evaporated from the system? Well, I don't know how to answer that. I can only answer for myself. I can only say that I am not pulling my money out of banks and putting it in my mattress. This whole situation reminds me of the scene in the movie "It's a Wonderful Life". When George Bailey (Jimmy Stewart) attempts to stop a run on the bank by pleading with his fellow citizens by saying (paraphrased here) "your money isn't in the bank, Bob, it's in Frank's house and Jim's house. If you close your accounts now, you'll just be playing into Potter's hands, and he'll end up owning ALL your houses. You have to hang on and work through this with me." That's sort of where I see things now, with the government playing both the role of George Bailey and Henry Potter at the same time. George Bush in particular has sounded like George Baily of late. But he's right. The key to surviving this crisis is to remain calm. The more people remain calm, the less impact this will have. So pretty much our financial future right now depends on how rational our fellow citizens are. So yes, I'm plenty scared....

Comments (8)

mtnlurker
The money I have in the market I won't need for several more years. At this point I am watching it value drop pretty sharply. But I will let it ride. If it all goes away I will just start over.
Andy
Cosmic: My oldest son (in the US Air Force) called me from California last week seeming to be in a panic about "how worried" he should be. As a Father, I tried to give him comfort, yet a straightforward assessment of things. I basically told him that the truth is almost always somewhere in the middle. The sky is not falling, and everything ain't coming up roses. It's interesting that I reminded him of George Bailey in It's A Wonderful Life (he and his younger brother memorized the movie "word for word" back in the days when we lived in an area that only had one TV station...and watched a lot of videotapes). I reminded him that our whole economy, currency value, and future as a nation depends on "confidence." It pains me that we have so many "confidence men" pulling the strings, and so many dupes ready to trust them. But it is what it is! I concur with mtnlurker. If it all goes away, we will just start over. Most of us won't like it, but we will do it. Truthfully, it might be good for all of us.
Stevo
My Take I believe "trust" might be a sigificant oversimplification. When the US abandoned the "gold standard" it is true that the value of money depended largely on "trust". To a great extent the value of such fiat monies was directly related to the GNP of their respective nations. The trade Gap has been steadily increasing for the past 13 years. We can argue cause and effect but I tend to place the blame on short term solutions to long term problems. As the value of the dollar has continued to drop our government has elected to disguise the effect by entering trade agreements with developing nations to allow cheaper consumer goods to enter our markets. In the short term this has the popular political effect of mock prosperity. The problem is that as our jobs and money leave the country the standard of living in those developing nations begins to rise. This has the net effect of raising the price of goods as we have diminished our ability to pay. Protectionism has been touted as an enemy to free markets and has the stigma of a dirty word. Until the now "global standard of living" equalizes I fear that without some protectionist policies we still have a long way to fall. The American public would have to endure a period of want and poverty as inflation of consumer goods would spike. However this would create a need to rebuild our own industrial complex. The United States was able to do this before because of vast natural resources we can do it again but the American public does not have the stomach for it. If we don't, the only place to go is toward a global equalibrium, and that my friends is far far below where we are now.
CosmicConservative
Stevo: I hear what you are saying, and I've seen other similar arguments. But I've also heard counter-arguments to that description, especially the part about our money "leaving" the country due to trade imbalance. The flip side of that is that as we lose purchasing power, those countries lose markets, and so there is some natural equilibrium that will be found well before all economies reach a global equilibrium. Besides that, your description implies that the current credit crunch is not really tied to all of the bad loans that were made, but more to the overall economic policies (starting with going off the gold standard). In general I tend to go with the simplest explanation that would satisfy the data, and right now the bad loans of the past decade or so seem to adequately explain why the specific part of the market is having the specific problems they are having. That is not to say that your description does not hold true in a deeper, more meaningful way and that this mortgage thing may just trigger an economic chain reaction that goes as deep as you describe. I hope not, and as of this moment I am crossing my fingers that it is bad, but not THAT bad.
Stevo
In fact I believe that the bad loans were a smokescreen to hide these deeper economic problems. Short term solution,, print and pour money into the market to give the illusion of prosperity. I.E. low interest rates and readily available credit. Banks and govenments absorb private equity. Problem,,,when the lenders hold the notes on too much of the available private equity they have in fact created a shortage of liquidity. What we are seeing is exactly that. I'm just putting some beef jerky out there for people to chew on......If you want to have some real fun, apply this reasoning to why the Euro is reacting unfavorably to the current U.S. credit debacle.
CosmicConservative
Steveo: I only took one economics class in college and I frankly considered it to be a joke. So I certainly can't claim to have any economic credibility. I am quite intrigued by your comments. I tend to think of systems as gears, levers, fuel, lubricant, etc... even systems like the economy. Your comments make sense from that perspective. I think I'll have to look into this some more.
Stevo
Credibility? Heck Cosmic I don't have a degree in anything. This is merely my in-credible observations based on personal political and economic observations. I do tend to think of these things on a more mechanical level like yourself, action/ reaction, cause/effect. From a socio/political stand point I also like to consider motive. If we wanted the opinions of economists all we would have to do is change the channel and shop for the "expert" opinion dijour.