Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cutler vs. Romo at the quarter point of the season

By CosmicConservative
How good is Tony Romo really? How good is Jay Cutler? Which has been over-rated? Which has been under-rated? Well, this year so far ESPN and other sources I read have clearly considered Tony Romo to be having a slow start to his year. He had a "bad" day yesterday with only 176 yards, roughly half of what he was averaging last year at this time. By contrast the sports media is in awe of Jay Cutler's "breakout year" where he has the leading offense in the league (Dallas is #2, and virtually tied with Denver in every category) and has been the second coming of John Elway. Now don't get me wrong, I am glad that Cutler is doing well, and I hope that the discovery of the diabetes and the treatment he is getting will keep him at the top of his game for a long time to come. But if you look at the actual numbers of the two quarterbacks, you'll see that even this year with his "poor start" Tony Romo still has a higher quarterback rating (100.5 vs 98.1), more touchdowns (11 vs 10), higher yards per attempt (8.4 vs 7.8) and a higher touchdown percentage (6.8 vs 5.2). Cutler leads in total yardage (1,502 vs 1,368), interceptions (4 vs 5), attempts (191 vs 162) and completions (125 vs 104). Now Cutler's leads in yards, completions and attempts is as much about game plan and the need to keep throwing the ball in high scoring games as anything, so I don't put nearly as much weight in statistics that are all about how many times a quarterback throws the ball as I do about how likely he is to complete the pass, how frequently he finds the end zone and how high his quarterback rating is, so just based on these numbers alone, I would actually rate Romo higher than Cutler this year. Of course you couldn't tell that Romo is doing well based on ESPN's designation of Drew Brees as the "best" QB in the league this year (but with an honorable mention going to Jay Cutler). Here are some other quarterbacks whose actual statistics are superior to Jay and Tony, just for comparison: Brett Favre Phillip Rivers Kurt Warner What really just amazes me is how Cutler's "breakout year" and the adoration of ESPN and the media looks a whole lot like Romo's "disappointing" start to 2008. Couple that with Cutler throwing to Brandon Marshall and having "genius" offensive coach Mike Shanahan calling plays (compared to "defensive minded" Wade Phillips) and the comparison is even more puzzling. At this rate at the end of the year if Cutler and Romo have virtually identical years with around 3,500 yards passing, 35 or so touchdowns, a QB rating of around 100, etc... Cutler will be annointed the "next great one" and Romo will be saddled with a "disappointing year." You watch. It's almost like watching Obama vs. McCain... ;)

Comments (3)

Andy
Cosmic: Just throwing this out, because I really don't know the answer. Romo has Marion Barber, and Felix Jones in the backfield. These are two tough, explosive backs for sure. It would make sense to me that Romo wouldn't have nearly as many passing yards as he did last year. (ball control, ball control, use all your weapons, etc.) At the same time, having explosive backs should free up his receivers even more. I watched the 'Boys yesterday and Romo really had a hard time hitting his targets (maybe just "one of those days"). And he has turned the ball over clumsily several times this season. It hasn't cost him much yet, but it sure could have. My question is, does Cutler have the whole weight on his shoulders (throwing arm), or does he have the same weapons in the backfield that Romo does? If he doesn't, I'd have to give a nod to Cutler as having the better year so far. It might be a good sign for my 'Boys though. Even though Romo hasn't played his best, it's usually better to start weak and finish strong than the other way around. Don't know...but it's going to be fun to see how it unfolds.
CosmicConservative
In terms of pure offense, Denver and Dallas are remarkably similar. Denver is a bit more pass-centric, and Dallas has a bit more running game. But otherwise they are at the top of the offensive charts with almost identical overall statistics, including total yards, points and victories. I'd give Dallas the nod on defense but yesterday Denver turned in their first decent defensive game of the season. Romo and Cutler have both had bone-headed turnovers this year, and more or less in equal measure. Yesterday, for example, as the game wound down (and most coaches would have run the clock down) Cutler made a very dangerous throw into double (triple?) coverage and very nearly threw a game-changing interception, but instead the defender missed the ball and the receiver caught it for a game-clinching first down. Even the homer Denver radio announcers questioned the throw under the circumstances. Cutler and Romo are, imho, remarkably similar when it comes to how they approach the game. Both can be brilliant, accurate and patient, and both can be impulsive, inaccurate and foolish. I would say that Cutler, this season, has more of the weight of the team on his shoulders than Romo does, but no more than Romo had last season or the season before. My point in the comment was to point out that the media, most of whom annointed Cutler as the next Big Thing three years ago, continue to grade Cutler on a curve. No matter how you look at the actual statistics through four games, Cutler is, at best, in the top ten where Romo is solidly in the top five. Yet ESPN runs a story about Phillip Rivers being the "best" QB (because Brady is injured and Peyton is having a bad start) but in the first paragraph they cite CUTLER as the only viable competition for "best" in the NFL, although six or eight QBs currently have superior statistics across the board when compared to Cutler, INCLUDING a 40 year old Brett Favre (who has more TDs, a higher completion percentage and the highest QB rating in the league at the moment). I understand that the NFL "elite" look at Jessica Simpson and can't take Tony seriously, but what about Kurt Warner? Brett Favre? Phillip Rivers? Or what about current reigning Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning (who also has a higher QB rating than Cutler, although slightly below Tony)? Here's what I think is going on. All these "experts" predicted great things for Cutler out of the box. Cutler had a decidedly average first year and they all defended him, saying his sophomore year was going to be the big breakthrough. But Cutler ended up fading down the stretch and wound up in the middle of the QB ratings at the end of the year. I think these "experts" keep resurrecting Cutler because they all predicted him to be great, and virtually all of them predicted Romo would be a big flop in Dallas. Cutler keeps on showing just enough promise that they think they can revive their OWN reputations by getting on the Cutler bandwagon each year. And maybe they will end up being right. All I see is that Cutler's "breakout" year so far looks a whole lot like Romo's "disappointing" start, and I see the same old thing happening here that I have for the past two years. Cutler is great "on paper" but Romo keeps confounding and irritating the pundits by continuing to be better "on the field" even during a "poor start." If Cutler had the same statistics as Romo the past three years, I shudder to think of how many of these "experts" would be inducting Jay into the Hall of Fame already.
Andy
Okay, I got you Cosmic. I missed the point that you were questioning the media coverage more than the QB. You're probably right. Sports media guys (and really all media guys) pick their horse, and lay their bets. Their gray mare, or bay has to break a leg before they'll finally turn on them. I don't get to watch the Broncos much, so I can't make a judgment on Cutler. But I do get to watch Romo weekly. He's good. He's tough. But he makes bone-headed decisions still. I'm positive that I wouldn't make the same mistakes (with a collective ton of behemoths breathing down my neck). ;)