Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Were Hillary's tears genuine?

By CosmicConservative
So there is this pervasive meme going throughout the right-wing of the blogosphere that Hillary's "tearing up" moment yesterday was contrived instead of genuine. The logic goes something like this... Hillary generally comes across as a cold, heartless, steel-nerved bitch from hell. Her polling and focus group research told her that she needed to somehow touch the heart strings of America and so she planted a question and faked the tears so that people would say "oh see! She is human after all." Now here's the deal. I don't think that such a thing is beyond Hillary. In fact I am certain that Bill Clinton did that exact thing on more than one occasion. It is not only possible that Hillary would perform such a cynical, manipulative act, in my opinion it is quite likely that she would do so, her recent cackle-a-thon is enough proof of her insincere attempts to fake sincerity already. But in this case I am certain her tears were genuine. Why? Because she would never have faked a tear-up moment over such a lame issue as "gee, Hill you wonderful woman, how do you handle the rigors of the campaign trail?" She and her handlers would immediately say "WRONG MESSAGE!!!" when someone proposed such a thing. Her tear-up moment would have come over something like evil right-wing-conspiracy attacks on her beloved husband, or better yet, her daughter. She and her entire entourage would immediately recognize that to be seen crying over how hard it was to go out and campaign for the job would simply make her appear weak and overly emotional. And in fact, it should. I am no Hillary basher, but I have to say that if the difficulty of campaigning for the job is so hard on her that she tears up when someone lobs her a softball question (coupled with such sycophantic nonsense as "how do you stay so wonderful?"), if that is so hard that just to contemplate it causes tears to well up in her eyes and her voice to break, I think it is absolutely fair and reasonable to ask how she will deal with the true rigors of actually being the President.

Comments (9)

pace
"If women ran the world we wouldn't have wars, just intense negotiations every 28 days." - Robin Williams
Drax
Pace: Heh. CC: I've seen Bush well up and choke up before, so I don't really care if someone wells up in a genuine emotional woman. Here's Hillary at the moment it occurred: She just got beat in Iowa and the prediction is that she'll lose in NH. She's tired and feels beseiged. Then someone says something really nice to her and it caused her to emotionally respond. She didn't break down into tears or lose control or do anything which was untoward. I have no problem with her in that regard. (Of course, in just about every other regard, I have nothing BUT trouble with her...) Why the win in NH? I think she's getting the majority of the Edwards' votes and will continue to get them as he continues to dwindle in the polls (although he might get a bit in South Carolina if the past is ANY indication). Gee...this is an interesting cycle.
CosmicConservative
I agree that it is interesting. I did not think Hillary would win in New Hampshire, which shows you my political acumen. But your analysis of Hillary's "emotional moment" is just reinforcing my point. Imagine if Mitt Romney, after losing in Iowa and being behind in the polls were asked by a gushing supporter "Gee Mitt, how do you stay so upbeat?" And he teared up, his voice broke and he said "It's hard, it's so hard, but... I do it for the children, and you know some people out there are so wrong and so 'not ready' that it really becomes personal for me..." I mean really, come on. If a man did that, he'd be laughed out of the race. And with good damn reason.
Andy
Pace: Good one! Cosmic: Good food for thought. I don't think it was a contrived moment at all. She's tired. Sometimes I forget that Hillary is a human, but she is. When any human gets worn out physically, just about "anything" might happen emotionally. But you're right. Mitt, or McCain would be history if something like that happened.
Drax
Wait. Contrary to all evidence to the contrary, Hillary is a woman. Common experience tells us that women are different from men and that tears from them simply don't have the same meaning as they do when they come from men. Must she BE a man in order to be taken seriously?
CosmicConservative
No, but you have to be tough to be a President. As I said, tearing up because someone asked you how tough it is to be on the campaign trail does not bode well for Hillary (or anyone, man or woman) being able to negotiate in a hardball fashion with Putin or any other world leader. I'm pretty sure Margaret Thatcher never teared up under similar circumstances, and when Edwin Muskie teared up because someone asked him about his sick wife, he was laughed out of the race. If you want to play hardball, you have to play according to the accepted standards of the game, and crying over such a lame softball question is not on the list of acceptable reasons to break down. Not in my book anyway.
Drax
Heh. I'm fairly certain that Margaret never had "similar circumstances." Their political circus is completely different from ours. Muskie was a man. Different standards. I mean, we have to recognize that women and men react differently to the same stimuli, don't we? Isn't that a given? Do I think that her "tearing up" doesn't mean that she isn't a calculating cold witch who would put a missle down someone's chimney if given proper reason (or if she thought it would help her in the polls)? Of course not.
CosmicConservative
It's as much about what other leaders will think, as what Hillary is capable of. If Hillary is perceived as weak and emotional going INTO a negotiation, that could severely weaken the U.S. position in that negotiation, and could actually even end up with unnecessary escalations because someone like Putin might think they can "rattle" her, and so they advance what is supposed to be a bluff that they never really intend to do, just to get her to back down, but she instead responds forcefully which causes the whole situation to escalate. Hillary may be the toughest, meanest bitch on the planet, but if Kim Jong Il thinks she's a weak, emotional woman based on something like this, I think the odds of a nuclear confrontation go up significantly.
CosmicConservative
It is in part because Hillary is a woman and these preconceived notions could work against her that she needs to maintain iron control on her emotions as Margaret Thatcher did. The "different standards" you mention do not give her "allowance" to react emotionally, instead they actually reduce her opportunities because they play into those stereotypes. And she has to understand that. Still, my whole reaction to this is obviously completely different than the general American citizen, because I definitely would not have been more inclined to vote for her because of this, but according to polls, a lot of people did. Which again, worries the hell out of me because the idea of Hillary becoming President because she broke down during the campaign about how "tough" it is to run for President just about blows my freaking mind.