Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Clemens tapes phone call with accuser

By CosmicConservative
And posts it on the Internet. Apparently he thought that the secretly taped phone call provided some support for his contention that McNamee had only injected him with B-12 instead of Steroids and Human Growth Hormone. Unfortunately for Roger, the phone call does not provide any evidence that McNamee had lied to the Mitchell committee. So it is unclear what Roger hoped to gain by making the recording public. However, there may be a great deal for Roger to lose. Since he had his attorneys present when he made and published the recording, a recording that was made without Mcnamee's knowledge or consent, I have to assume that the laws in New York allow for single-sided recording of a conversation. I know that different states have different laws about whether you have to reveal that you are recording a conversation to the other participant. I can't imagine that Roger's attorneys are equally ignorant of those laws, so I assume they must have recorded it legally. If not Roger may be in more trouble than he knows. Publishing the conversation may have run afoul of other laws though, and I am certain that McNamee's attorneys are in conversation with both state and federal prosecuters pressing for Roger to be brought up on some charges for publishing the conversation. There may be actual legal jeopardy for Roger in this act, McNamee's main attorney strongly implied that he thought there was legal jeopardy. In fact he more or less said that he was going to try to put Roger in jail (which is a sort of empty threat since only government prosecutors can do that, but I know what he meant). But forget about the potential legal jeopardy that Roger may have exposed himself to. This has to be a public relations nightmare. Roger has revealed himself at the very least to be a manipulative, under-handed jerk. This could easily damage his chances for getting into the Hall of Fame as much as his alleged steroid use. I am probably not the best example of what sort of PR problem this may have created primarily because I have always thought that Roger was a bully and a jerk. But what I am reading on the message boards indicates that a lot more people think that now than thought that before Roger pulled this stunt. This is becoming very interesting. Unless the recording provided direct and incontrovertable proof that McNamee was lying, I cannot fathom what positive benefit Roger expected to come out of making the phone call public. You would think that at the end of the phone call he and his attorneys would have sighed and said "Oh well, it was a good try" and worked on some other under-handed, Snidely Whiplash scheme to try to "get" McNamee. Instead they decided to publish evidence of their own sneaky, dirty scheme without doing anything to clear his name. If this is an example of the sort of advice he is getting from those attorneys, I hate to think how they will handle a possible criminal case brought against him. What a maroon....

Comments (7)

Boyd
While there was no outright confession on the tape, I'm still left with the opinion that McNamee is lying. "What do you want me to do, Roger?" "Someone has to tell the truth about this!" [crickets] No admission that he lied, but he doesn't deny it, either. And sometimes you have to get underhanded and sneaky when someone is in the process of slipping that stiletto into a soft spot on your back.
CosmicConservative
I don't read it the way you do. I read it as McNamee being unwilling to call Clemens a liar to his face. I read it as McNamee desperately trying to revive a friendship that he hates to lose, but not being willing to lie and say "I lied" even to make Roger feel good, when that's what he really wants to do. The [crickets] are there because McNamee can't bring himself to say to Roger's face (virtual face anyway) that his hero and benefactor is trying to make him lie on what he figures to be a recorded phone call.
Boyd
I guess that's just like witnesses to the same event seeing different things. Ah, the variety of life!
CosmicConservative
Well, in this case I suspect we will end up with some pretty hard evidence supporting either your or my interpretation of that phone call Boyd. I will certainly remark upon that as it occurs. McNamee and Clemens are either purposefully or accidentally maneuvering in such a way that the ponderous wheels of our judicial system are going to produce a legal judgement on one or the other's truthfulness. And I have already stated that I think Roger is the one lying, and nothing in that tape convinced me otherwise. Indeed, if anything it reinforced my opinion of Roger by showing what a manipulative bully he really is. McNamee had absolutely nothing to gain by fingering Roger, and everything to lose by lying to the Mitchell committee. Roger has nothing to gain by admitting his steroid use and everything to lose. Several of the other players that McNamee named have admitted that McNamee told the truth about them, so the preponderance of the evidence is solidly on McNamee's side right now. In my opinion.
Andy
I don't know how this will come down, but one thing is for sure. Clemens has been accused of a lot of things, but I don't ever remember an accusation that he was "real smart." I saw Clemens on 60 Minutes. I am wrong about as often as I am right while judging people. In this case I can't trust my 50/50 judgment, because TV production people have a way of editing out, and leaving in footage to influence opinion. So, I just have to go with my gut. I think Clemens is certainly guilty of stupidity...and probably guilty of shooting up (with a wink and a nod). Like I said, video editing can play tricks on you, so I could be dead wrong. I really hope that I am wrong. I'm not a Clemens fan (even though I do admire some things about the guy), but it would be good for the game if he is really as "clean" as he says. It is always best in the long run to go ahead and come clean with your transgressions early on (concerning anything). I am just not sure that Roger is that smart.
Drax
It seems that the sports talking heads are leaning towards believing Roger now when, before, they were not...as a result of the tape. I don't understand why. Hearing the tape, it seemed clear to me that Roger was doing everything in his power to ensure that he didn't do anything which might put him in jeopardy. It seemed equally clear that McNamee suspected that he was being taped and was doing everything in his power to walk the line on saying anything one way or another BUT constantly giving Roger the opportunity to ask him to do something illegal. (Which is how I read the "What do you want me to do?" refrain...) McNamee also comes across as a broken man who has lost everything and, now, may be willing to go to jail for Roger...if Roger asked him to. (What's he going to do for a living now?) I don't believe Roger for a minute. All he had to do is ask "Why did you lie about me?" He didn't. McNamee CAN'T admit to lying as it would negate his deal and put him in jail (another reason for his stating his willingness to "go to jail" for Roger...as that would be the inevitable outcome of his retracting his statements about Roger). Most importantly, he didn't HAVE to name Roger to get that deal. I suspect that there is actual EVIDENCE out there somewhere as naming someone like Roger without a "stained dress" seems rather foolish. (And, do you think that any trainer doesn't keep records? Ask Barry....)
CosmicConservative
Well, I've sort of put my money on one horse in this race, now I'll just have to wait to see if I put it on the right one.