Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Romophobia...

By CosmicConservative
I admit that I read more than I should on sports topics. In particular I read a lot of commentary on NFL teams that I follow, mostly the Broncos, the Patriots, the Colts and the Cowboys. Today, with a few rare exceptions, I am seeing a monumental dismissing of a 5 - 0 team that just won a dramatic last second victory on Monday Night Football. The general consensus is that Tony Romo is washed up, and Dallas is going to be chewed up and spit out next Sunday by the New England Patriots. Now I agree that New England is a superior team. But not by much. Certainly not by enough to make it a foregone conclusion that they will clobber the Cowboys in Texas Stadium. Pretty much all of this is due to Tony Romo's five interceptions. The theory is that the Bills figured Tony out, and that Tony's little mind isn't agile enough to deal with the befuddling defensive schemes that the Bills threw at him. Then that is coupled with the belief that Bill Belichick is far more cunning than Bills coach Dick Juaron (yeah, I had to look that up). Since Belichick is such a brilliant mind, the feeling is that Romo will throw more passes to Patriot defenders than to Cowboys receivers. Steve Young referred to the Cowboys as "leaking lots of oil." Another writer made a joke about Romo becoming the corporate spokesperson for "butterfinger." I can't remember seeing a quarterback of an undefeated team who just won his last game on a last second critical drive being treated so badly. Oh, wait. Yes I can. Last year when the Bears' Rex Grossman was being ridiculed as the Bears relentlessly made their way to the Super Bowl. So I guess the question is, is the Romo - Grossman comparison fair? Is Romo a dud? What I find surprising in all of this is the complete overlooking of the Dallas defense. If I have my figures right the Dallas defense has given up exactly 3 points in the last two games. In their prior game against the Bears they gave up 10 points. That means in three games they have allowed a single drive for a touchdown, and two field goals. If not for kickoff returns and interception returns, the Cowboys would have allowed a grand total of 13 points in their last three games. That's 4.333 points per game. And they have been particularly good against the pass. And they just got back one of their top corners. Here's what I think. If Romo can play game six like he played games 1 - 4, and the Dallas defense can play game six like they played games 3 - 5, then Dallas has every chance to beat the Patriots. So, if the pundits are right and Romo is really a befuddled, easily confused quarterback, then New England will show that and stomp the Cowboys. But if last night was the fluke, not the norm (and a LOT of good quarterbacks have thrown a lot of interceptions in a single game) and Romo plays well, then I think the game will boil down to how well the Dallas defense plays. If they play up to their ability, it may well be Brady who is explaining his interceptions next Monday. Don't count out the Cowboys. That defense is looking tougher every week. And I bet they have a real reason to target this game as their breakout game of the season. I'm betting it's a good game. It could well come down to a single play on special teams being the deciding factor in the game. I would predict a score of 24 - 21 or therabouts. And flip a coin for the winner. I would not be at all surprised to see a rematch in the Super Bowl...

Comments (8)

Andy
CC: When you posed the question a while back asking if Romo was for real or not, I am pretty sure that my input was that Romo is as "for real" as anyone out there. I think I also wrote something like "he will have some bad games...like everyone else does." For once in the last several weeks, I was right. He did have a bad game. But I think the guy is tough...physically, and mentally. Of course, I am writing this as a prejudiced Cowboy fan, but I would look for the boy to have a good game next week. He might not win, but I don't look for him to be "shell-shocked," or intimidated. Romo learned something Monday night (if he didn't already know it) that we probably all should learn...not everything depends on us, or our performance. Your points were well made concerning the 'Boys defense. The Pats will give them all that they can handle, no doubt, but the Cowboys' defense could make Brady look like Romo. Even the Bradys of the world have bad games. It's going to be fun to watch (unless the Pats blow the Cowboys out...in that case, please just disregard my comment on this, and e-mail me an aspirin).
Drax
I watch sports shows too and saw the Steve Young remarks. I must admit that I'm not seeing anything which even resembles a consensus that Romo is "washed up," or that calls to mind a Grossman comparison. On that same show Key said something along the lines that Romo had learned his lesson and will be fine against New England. Tom's comments went to the depth of NE's team in comparison to the depth of Dallas' team. In fact, if there's anything like a consensus about Romo it's that he had a bad game, got lucky to come out on top, but will rebound for the next game.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I mostly was reading things on the Internet. Although I did see the Steve Young comment on ESPN. The only person I saw challenge Young was Emmitt Smith, and I pretty much consider the source on that. Other than that what I saw were nodding heads. I think Young's comments clearly indicated his belief that the problem was more than a 'bad game'. The articles I read on Romo brought up last year's end of season record of 1 and 3 and his bobbled field goal hold. It sure seemed to me that they were trying to make a case that Romo can be brilliant one day, and horrible the next. In fact one article specifically referred to "the good Romo" and "the bad Romo" as if two different people wore his uniform. I do think the consensus of what I read was that Romo's good days are very good, but his bad days are awful. And they did not seem to suggest that his "bad days" were flukes, more that they were just part of the Romo package.
Drax
The remarks about last season were about last season. Some talking heads noted that he wasn't normally a holder, so his screw up was understandable. Young's remarks were essentially about the TEAM, that the 'Boys were "leaking oil," while the Pats were hitting on all cylinders. I don't really know how anyone can dispute that. The 'Boys played a HORRIBLE game all around. I don't know why that surprises anyone as I can't remember a team who hasn't played at least ONE "horrible" game..or one quarterback who hasn't had at least one "horrible" game during a season. I did hear on that same panel a couple of people (Keyshawn for sure) say that Romo will bounce back, having learned his lesson. I think the real test of the team (and Romo) is how they handle this crappy game in the locker room, more precisely, how T.O. handles not only the whooping that was a win but the fact that he didn't touch the ball very much in that whooping....
CosmicConservative
I'll dispute that the Cowboys "team" was leaking oil. In fact I would say that other than Romo, the Cowboys were pretty dang good. Especially the defense. OK, special teams allowed a touchdown too, for the second game in a row. But the defense was essentially perfect. The offense turned the ball over six times, and the only points the Bills got off of the turnovers were touchdown returns (meaning they scored on the Cowboys offense) and maybe a field goal. I don't know if the field goal came after one of Romo's interceptions or not. But that field goal was the only scoring that the defense allowed. I think that's pretty dang good.
CosmicConservative
I guess the thing that got to me in the stories I read is that this is what the "experts" were saying about Romo last year. That he was good until the defenses figured out how to fool him, and that he did not learn how to read them quickly enough. It just feels to me that the media hammers on Romo every time he makes a mistake, and then act surprised when he matches Brady or Manning in a game. But that's probably just 'cause I'm a Cowboys homer....
Drax
Heh. Talking heads have to talk. Romo is Dallas' quarterback, so you'll hear a lot about him, just as you'll hear a lot about Chicago's QB, and any NY QB. For the most part, the rest of the QB's get very little ink except Brady who gets nothing but good ink. Romo made some boneheaded plays last year. Understandable as he's a rookie, but there's no grace period for QB's...especially in Dallas or Chicago. (And likely none in Green Bay when that slot comes open...) He made some bonehead plays in the last game. The boys couldn't rush the ball, couldn't score from the red zone, lost the time of possession war, and gave up points on special teams. I agree that their defense was good.
CosmicConservative
Well, I have to admit that I only watched the first five minutes, and then went and apparently did just enough dishes to satisfy the football gods as penance and they allowed the Cowboys to win. So I can't really talk about the game in an authoritative way. When I went and looked at the drive history later that night though, it sure looked like Dallas ended most of their drives either with a score or a turnover. I didn't see a lot of punts. I did, of course, see a lot of turnovers. I will say that both of the interceptions I did see were of the "boneheaded" type. The first one looked like Romo threw to a deep safety who didn't have a white uniform within 20 yards of him. I guess maybe the ball slipped and was too high for someone, but it sure looked like the ball went where Romo was aiming it. I guess some of this angst is my own concern that Romo is exactly what his critics say, an up or down quarterback who is very good when he's good, but very bad when he's bad. I guess you could make a case for that based on his play so far. However, he still is 11 - 4 I think as a starter, and that's not bad.