Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Today's bad science example

By CosmicConservative
Chimps choose more rationally than humans - UPI.com LEIPZIG, Germany, Oct. 8 (UPI) -- German researchers have demonstrated chimpanzees make choices that protect their self-interest more consistently than do humans. Researchers from the Max Planck Institute of Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig studied the chimp's choices by using an economic game with two players. In the game, a human or chimpanzee who receives something of value can offer to share it with another. If the proposed share is rejected, neither player gets anything. Humans typically make offers close to 50 percent of the reward. They also reject as unfair offers of significantly less than half of the reward, even though this choice means they get nothing. The study, however, showed chimpanzees reliably made offers of substantially less than 50 percent, and accepted offers of any size, no matter how small. The researchers concluded chimpanzees do not show a willingness to make fair offers and reject unfair ones. In this way, they protect their self interest and are unwilling to pay a cost to punish someone they perceive as unfair.
So here's my analysis of what is wrong with this story: This sentence:
The researchers concluded chimpanzees do not show a willingness to make fair offers and reject unfair ones. In this way, they protect their self interest and are unwilling to pay a cost to punish someone they perceive as unfair
... is supposed to demonstrate that chimpanzees are "more rational" and operate in their own "self interest" more than humans do. The problem is that the only factual part of the statement is the first part "chimpanzees do not show a willingness to make fair offers and reject unfair ones". The next part, about the "willingness" of chimpanzees is pure speculation. There is no basis for proving that the second part of the statement is actually driving the behavior in the first part. Furthermore, there is no way TO prove it. It is a statement of OPINION masquerading as scientific fact. So why does it get reported? Because it makes human beings look bad. That'll get you published every time. But wait! There's more. The fundamental assumption of this group of scientists is that it is more "rational" for a person or chimpanzee to accept an unfair portion of something that is shared than to object to the unfairness. In essence they are saying that acting on the principle of fairness is "irrational." Taken in human terms this would mean that it is "irrational" to complain about unfair distribution of wealth. Which more or less means that the entire liberal ideology is "irrational" since pretty much all liberals do is "object to unfairness" whether real or imagined. Wait, maybe it's good science after all. ;)

Comments (7)

ams182764
It's only irrational behavior in a non-iterated game. If you punish someone for making an unfair offer in the short term with refusal, meaning that you both get nothing, then in the long term he will only profit from this game if he makes a fair offer. It's a short-term/long-term rationality thing. Elementary game theory. We actually studied this one in class. Another way to interpret this is that humans think in longer terms than chimps do, so things like taking short term hits in order to enforce longer term fair dealing matter more to people.
ams182764
So when the chimp plays this game, exchange situations, especially with weird humans in labcoats being somewhat rare, he probably doesn't think of it as an iterated game (provided he understands it at all). Whereas a human is probably thinking at some level "reject it now, so that next time this happens..."
CosmicConservative
ams: Which is precisely my point. Humans reject the unfair offers based on the principle of fairness, which is something that [most] humans have learned over time is the most rational way to share since it provides the most equitable distribution of goods. My problem is not so much the experiment as it is that the "scientists" in this experiment have interpreted the results by assigning motivations to the chimpanzees as if they sat down with them afterwards and asked them why they did what they did. The most reasonable way to interpret these experimental results is that chimpanzees are purely opportunists and will take what they are offered because they don't think about the long term consequences which is exactly the opposite of "rational" behavior. It's bad science because the scientists have assumed motivations they can't prove, reached a conclusion they can't support and published a result that has not been thought through adequately. And it's been picked up by the "mainstream media" because all of those bad science things result in the "story" that chimpanzees are "more rational" than humans. This sort of thing just bakes my cookies...
Andy
You kind of lost me, so help me out here CC. Does this story, and your take on it mean that all chipms are liberals, or that all liberals are chimps?
Drax
I don't get it. How is it in your interest to accept all offers, whether fair or not? Doesn't that just make you a target for those who would profit off of you, ensuring that you have little and they have much? I would think that this model of behavior would establish the exact opposite of what the "scientists" conclude it does. Maybe that's why we're studying chimps rather than chimps studying us?
Andy
Drax: I'm with you...I don't get it. As I wrote: "You kind of lost me, so help me out here CC." It seems to me that the conclusions of this study would be the exact opposite also. But I still want to know if all chimps are liberals, or all liberals are chimps. You wrote: "Maybe that’s why we’re studying chimps rather than chimps studying us?" Well, maybe some of the "scientists" involved in the study have not completely evolved...too close to the subjects to be objective.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Perhaps you made my point more clearly than I did. I reach exactly the opposite conclusion than the one these scientists reached based on the same facts. I shouldn't have put that dig at liberals in there... it just confused my point. It's really bad science though. The scientists ascribe willful intentions to chimpanzees as if they can read their minds, they conclude exactly the opposite of what I think a rational analysis would lead one to conclude, and then they wrap it all up in a sensational sound bite to grab some headlines. Bad, bad science.