Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

ARM wrestling...

By CosmicConservative
So, back a few years ago, during they heady days of the refinance craze, we refinanced our house. We refinanced mostly to get a shorter term mortgage (a 20 year, we couldn't quite swing a 15 year). The agents we worked with pushed hard for us to take an adjustable rate mortgage (ARM). My wife and I are pretty conservative though (whooda thunkit?) and we decided to go for an old-fashioned, boring old fixed interest rate loan instead. My logic in making that choice was that I may end up paying more for the mortgage, even in the long run, but that I would at least be able to plan my finances around the largest single bill I have to pay each month. So now I see that there is all kinds of furor in Washington DC to give people who refinanced with ARMs some sort of relief because their inability to keep up with their monthly payments is driving the housing market into the dumps. So I'm sitting here thinking, "waitaminute... if the govt. bails these folks out for making a bad financial decision, what about folks like me who made a good one? What's in this for me?" And I know it is uncharitable, and perhaps even some of my readers are caught in this crunch, but I have to say that I have very little sympathy for people who chomped down on the ARM bait and are now impaled squarely on the hook concealed therein. I let that particular bait float on by because I saw the hook and decided I didn't want it set in my mouth. What am I missing here?

Comments (5)

Andy
CC: You are not missing anything here. First of all, I don't believe that this is a true crisis. I know a lot of people that got ARM's that are doing just fine. They knew the likelihood of interest rates rising, and made provisions for it. In fact, I only know one guy personally that is about to lose his house, and he on a fixed rate...has nothing to do with rate fluctuations...just a downturn in his business/financial situation. You are dead-on right about one thing for sure, and I think it is the most important point in this debate that is going on (I think mostly in the media). Hundreds of millions of citizens of the US are not in trouble with their mortgage payments. They have either paid for a house, or are managing their mortgage notes every month (some of them sacrificing other things to do so). The public at large is not going to be sympathetic to the several hundred thousand home-buyers that are in this trap (or to the lenders for that matter). This is an issue that is easily understood by anyone that ever tore the coupon off, swallowed hard, and mailed the check. This is not philosophy...it is real life that the huge majority understands. A lot of things can garner political support...those without health care...those without prescription drug benefits...those without a jet pack, etc. I could be wrong, but I think this is a true "non-starter" for the politicians. Oh, you might find a few Congressional Districts that have been particularly hard-hit, but for the most part I believe that "voters" would not particularly thrilled by their representatives supporting bailing out either the borrowers, or lenders. We are all selfish by nature. The very same thought came to me as this supposed "crisis" surfaced in the media..."What...is the government going to bail out the guy that is past due, and leave the guy that is current (or the guy like me that has worked hard and paid his house off) in the lurch?" "I want my check, too!!!! Of course, I know that most of what government does is senseless, so it may happen. But I believe that there will be hell to pay for any idiot politician that jumps on this train.
Bart the Builder
As a builder, I have been at closings where mortgage companies were providing customers with "interest only loans" and even 100% financing. I was afraid that eventually this would come back to bite me as I have seen my sales slide to almost nill this past summer. I am not at all sympathetic for the mortgage institutions who started these creative financing schemes. The Fed needs to stay out of this and let the free markets adjust on their own.
Andy
Bart: You are dead right. The market will take care of it. We have all seen ups and downs (some more severe than others), but the ship always rights itself. I have been disgusted with government bailouts for a long time...bankrupt companies that can't pay their retirees...airlines that can't stay airborne...even the Savings and Loans whose main requirement to get a loan was to be able to "fog a mirror." The market should have resolved all of these things, but Big Brother stepped in. After 9/11 Congress voted this huge bailout of the airlines. There was one airline out there that had over a billion dollars cash on hand and did not need the bailout...Southwest...they knew that they would survive the disaster. In truth, Southwest was punished for their wise management policies, because Big Brother put everyone else back in business that had not managed well. (To go out and compete again against Southwest) They all should have gone belly-up. They had not prepared for disaster as had Southwest, and a few others. If the federal government steps in to bail out these financial institutions right now, home builders (and buyers) will see a retreat of credible financing that will rattle the teeth of the construction industry. These people are not stupid. You can only burn the good guys so often...eventually they will turn to other investments. I was once in a business that cost me my shirt. I was competing against another company selling a similar product and service. The only reason that I could not survive the competition is that my competitor didn't pay his suppliers. He would go bankrupt every so often, leaving his suppliers holding the bag...then go con another supplier into working with him. It is hard to compete against a guy that has no material costs...trust me, I know. This is the same thing, though on a larger scale. My competitor looked to his creditors to take the punch...these lending institutions are hoping that the taxpayer will take the punch. And in the end, the good guys will throw up their hands, lick their wounds, then take their ball, and go home.
pace
We took out an ARM 4 years ago, in order to lower our payments and pocket the change. Our plan was to sell the house around the time the mortgage went variable. Plans changed, and we decided to stay in the house indefinitely and continue to invest in improving it. The mortgage went variable last year, and as expected the mortgage company have been gouging us on the rate, which went from 4% to 7% in the space of 18 months. Hindsight is everything, but given the information we had at the time and our intended plans, I don't think it was a bad decision. We just refinanced again to a long-term fixed, and while the rate was not quite what we would have attained 4 years ago, it is still very good when you look at the historical data. It's considerably better, for example than our first mortgage that we took out ten years ago. If people took out ARMs in order to get into more house than they could otherwise afford, then they are indeed foolish and the government should not bail them out in any capacity. Regardless, all the media hysteria around the creeping mortgage rates is ridiculous. The rates are still lower than at any time in the 1980s and 1990s, and are less than a point higher than the historical lows of June 2003. What are we complaining about?
gjh
Want to buy a house in SE Michigan? 10,000 to choose from within 20 minutes of Detroit.