Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The future of roads...

By CosmicConservative
It's been a while since I did any "futurism" post. And since I am dealing with a lot of road construction on my daily commute right now, I want to contemplate what roads will be like in the future. First, and most importantly, I think roads will become intelligent. They will react to traffic by reconfiguring themselves automatically to optimize traffic flow. That means a road could automatically change how many lanes it has moving east and west based on the flow of traffic by redrawing its lines in real time. This intelligence will be coupled with near-instantaneous communication between the road and the vehicles traveling on it. Roads will tell cars where to go and how fast to go. Roads will also know WHO is on the road, each car will have unique codes built into their transponders allowing the road (and the road monitors) to know not only how many cars are on the road, but whose cars they are, and how many passengers are in them. Roads may also provide their own wireless power to the vehicles that travel on them, but that will be much further down the road (pun alert) in a temporal sense. All of the technology we need to accomplish self-reconfiguring roads and communication between roads and cars exists today. The technology to power vehicles from the road itself is going to not only take some major technological breakthroughs, but it will have to be done very carefully to avoid destroying the world economy when the existing fuel infrastructure goes away. Back to intelligent roads.... Because roads will be intelligent, and because computing power continues to double every 16 months or so, roads will not only be intelligent, they will be super intelligent. They will control traffic flow not just on the highways, but in the cities side roads as well. Vehicles traveling through a city will be like water flowing through a sieve. Dedicated highways will still exist, but there won't be a huge difference in travel time between highways and side roads, except where speeds will have to be controlled for social engineering factors. In the future your vehicle will not hit more than a very few red lights at intersections because the roads will optimize your path to have the fewest stops as you try to get from your home or work and onto the highway. Eventually these intelligent roads which talk to individual vehicles will make mass transit completely cost and time effective. At that time individual ownership of vehicles is likely to be phased out in favor of government owned vehicles that are dispersed and controlled by the roads themselves to optimize moving people to and from their homes to their destinations and back with all the convenience of private vehicles, but none of the cost or risk associated with them.

Comments (12)

Boyd
Sounds very 1984-ish, although 2084 may be a more realistic date. Once you start moving away from personal ownership toward government ownership, I think you'll find a lot of resistance to the ideas you present, though.
ams182764
Hmm. I'm a little skeptical of all this. An engineering principle (long since forgotten, apparently in the modern world) is that you use the least technology necessary to accomplish a job in the simplest most elegant way. That way you don't end up with a fragile (mechanically and operationally) system that will break often and encounter a variety of failure modes that a dumber, more generalized system wouldn't. For example - your road displaying different traffic signals under different traffic conditions - it would require vastly (and I mean vastly) more expensive materials than dumb asphalt to display all this, and extensive surveillance to measure traffic conditions. Display panels would probably be breaking all the time due to the beating they would recieve from the vehicles pounding over it, and the weather. And what would the marginal benifit be over having well understood road rules that all drivers follow, and a series of signaling lights? As far as the roads telling cars where to go - this is centralized control of a complex system. It would crash in a heartbeat. In a central control scheme, the number of interactions and conflicts to be managed would scale with the square of the number of vehicles in the control area. Every car has it's own agenda and destination, and centralized control simply doesn't scale well in this sort of environment. The FAA has enough trouble managing planes in the air (where there are miles of space between each vehicle, no terrain considerations, three dimensions to maneuver in, and only a few thousand of them with a fixed set of destinations. It is a problem orders of magnitude easier than managing road traffic) Better that control is left with each vehicle locally, and signposts (Whether visual or some sort of radio transponder) simply provide info to the drivers. In this system, the number of conflicts to be managed by each vehicle is relatively constant, varying only with congestion. This system would also handle the cars without transponders and computer control systems. It is ridiculous to expect every car to instantly upgrade to computerized control, and you need a system that can handle both.
ams182764
"Eventually these intelligent roads which talk to individual vehicles will make mass transit completely cost and time effective." Only if they end up being as slow, cumbersome, and inflexible as mass transit, forcing people back onto trains and out of the suburbs.
CosmicConservative
Well, we'll see. There are already some trials of roads similar to these in Japan. As far as the materials go, it's not nearly as difficult as you think, and does not require replacing the asphalt. The technology to do this is really as simple as putting wireless access points every hundred yards or so, coupled with small color-changable elements where road lines are today. Based on current technological progress I'd guess that within ten years such materials will be paintable, use solar energy to charge, and will be remotely configurable. As far as a centralized system is concerned, that's an architecture question. If we can create CPUs that allow multiple traffic paths internally at the speed of light, I'm pretty confident that we can create distributed processing systems that allow for traffic control to be managed both centrally and locally simultaneously. All it takes is a heirarchical system where the central computer says "here's what the big goals are" and the distributed computers to say "here's how I contribute to those big goals." If the centralized computer goes down, then there's a problem, but that's simply an issue of architecting a redundant backup with automatic rollover. Virtually every critical system in the world has that architecture today. As I said, we'll see. As far as the concern over government ownership vs. private ownership is concerned, I'm quite certain that by the time these sorts of roads are in use, private ownership of a lot of things is going to be seen as a quaint historical footnote.
mtnlurker
Couldn't you do some of this by having the cars communicate with each other? If the cars passed information back down the road, wirelessly, couldn't they tell each other about congestion or a problem and suggest re-routing.
Andy
Okay: I live in Louisiana...we are still trying to teach everyone to drive on the right side of the road. I mean, it is like we have a huge British immigrant community here. Roads in the future as CC envisions (in Louisiana) would be like the Bumper Car ride at the State Fair. What I would like to see in the future is a road that fixes it's own potholes. The futuristic look that CC lays out is very doable. Driving through Texas a while back, I saw electronic X's and O's that alert the driver to which lanes are clogged, and which are not so clogged. It was very helpful...but I grew up watching Walter Cronkite's 21st Century...I am still waiting for my jet-pack.
CosmicConservative
mtnlurker: Yes, to a point, but the problem with the cars doing it is that becomes a peer-to-peer network issue and none of the cars are likely to have the computing power, or the communications power, to communicate the larger strategies and crunch the massive numbers needed for the proactive traffic management I am talking about. Yes, cars talking to other cars is part of this too, but the roads must roll man, the roads must roll.
CosmicConservative
Andy: Jet packs will just screw all this up. AMS commented above about technology being best when it is least and in terms of moving people around, roads like this are far more cost effective (not to mention safer) than jet packs or flying cars will ever be.
Andy
CC: No matter how much sense you make, or how much safer and cost efficient your vision is...I want my jet pack, dadgummit! I don't care if it screws up the entire future of transportation...I want it, I want it, I want it! Seriously...good food for thought in your vision. I actually like some of the concepts (ixna on the government issued vehicle deal though).
Boyd
Until Andy mentioned it, I kinda forgot about Louisiana. That state alone pushes the likely date for any of this back about 100 years. I mean, really, this is a state where the entire Department of Transportation is three guys in the back of a 1959 Chevy pickup with a pick and two shovels. They're not going to be able to go to something like this until their great-grandchildren are the ones in the back of that pickup. Sorry, just had to poke fun at you guys. It's a great pastime in Texas, right up there with Aggie jokes. :)
CosmicConservative
Well... if it's that much trouble, maybe we can sell La. back to France...
Andy
Boyd: You are wrong, wrong, wrong! The entire Transportation Department of Louisiana is about 50,000 shovel-leaning public employees. In Louisiana, we spend billions for transportation, and get the crappy roads that we have...kind of like A dear old friend (dead now) once told me that driving on I-10 between Lake Charles and Baton Rouge is like "driving on a peanut patty, with the goober side up." "Your Tax Dollars At Work" Go ahead Boyd and make as much fun as you want...it is all well-deserved...trust me, no matter how badly Texans rib Louisiana, it will never match how we rib ourselves...and with good reason.