Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Nacchio to pay the price

By CosmicConservative
I don't talk about work much on this blog, but I used to work for this guy....
Nacchio Ordered To Forfeit $52 Million - Money News Story - KMGH Denver DENVER -- A federal judge has ordered that former Qwest Communications chief Joe Nacchio forfeit $52 million to the government as part of his sentencing. The judge also notified Nacchio that he will serve jail time for 19 counts insider trading but has not yet imposed a prison sentence.
I pretty much had a huge chunk of my savings wiped out when Joe's financial shenanigans came to light and Qwest stock went from roughly $65 per share, to about $1.50 per share. I'm not a vindictive person, but I have no sympathy for him or his cronies at all. I'm sure he will end up a very rich man regardless, and I'll end up working at Wal-Mart when I retire....

Comments (9)

Andy
Okay CC, I have a statement and a question. When I hear someone talking about how much they lost in one particular stock crash, It always raises a question in my mind. That question is: Was the stock worth anything to begin with? As an example, I have family members that lost substantial amounts of money in the dot.com bubble. But when I try to explain to them that they were holding something of no value to begin with, they get upset with me. So a dot.com that has never made a penny and is trading at $100 a share is really worth the true amount of zero. Sure, anything is worth what someone will pay you for it, but the true value of it is really unknown. In the dot.com bust, millions found out what the true value of their holdings were. So I really have a tough time having sympathy for the loser. Now, in the case of Enron I can have more grace for the employees. In that case the employees were actually being encouraged to invest their savings into Enron stock while the truth that it was worthless was being hidden. I can have sympathy for them on that count, but the reality is that they were holding an equity that was virtually worthless. So when I heard them say "we have lost hundreds of thousands of dollars each," I just have to go back to the reality that they didn't lose hundreds of thousands...they never really had it to begin with. They could have if they had cashed in, and I know that there were some roadblocks put in their way, so I can have more grace for them. The question is CC, was Qwest a similar situation as Enron? I did not follow the Qwest failure like I did the Enron fall. Was the company really profitable, but mismanaged to lead to the downfall, or was it a house of cards that never was substantial to begin with?
CosmicConservative
Andy: I really don't like to discuss any work related issues on the blog for a lot of reasons, not the least of which is that it could get me fired if I'm not careful. But I suppose with Joe going to the big house, I can probably discuss those days without risking loss of employment. In my case I lost a lot of money because of stock options that I was holding onto. For several years they had increased in value steadily, I didn't have a ton of options, but I had enough that I was thinking that my daughter's college wouldn't be that much of a problem, especially if they continued to appreciate at anything like the rate they had been appreciating for a couple of years. When Qwest came in and bought US West, where I worked, there was a stock-option swap that actually increased the number of options I held and for a short time I was actually sitting on a pretty good chunk of "paper money". Had I sold those options at that time I would have been able to do serious repairs on my house, buy a new car or perhaps buy a boat or something. Instead I held onto them and when the initial news of Joe's financial shenanigans came to light, the stock dropped like a lead weight and the options I had been holding were literally not worth the paper they were printed on. So you could argue it either way. Obviously all I ever held in my hands was paper, so you could say it had no intrinsic value. When it peaked for that short period of time after Joe moved in, but before his evil ways were found out, I could have made one phone call and would have had real shiny dollar bills in my checking account within a week. So in that sense the money was "real." As real as any paper assets, including the folding stuff I put in my wallet with dead Presidents' pictures on them. It might make me feel better to tell myself that it was never really "real money" but that's playing semantic games in my opinion. It was real enough that it hurt like heck to lose it.
Andy
Okay CC, Thanks for the information. I am assuming that US West was a really profitable operation. It was bought by Qwest, that either drove it into the ground, or bought it with "really funny money" (unlike the "somewhat" funny money that you have in your billfold). Like I said, I did not follow that story. Don't get me wrong, I was not trying to criticize...just to learn. Also, don't get me wrong...I wasn't trying to make you feel better about the loss. I know I would be really bummed out. That's why I invest all of my extra money at Brookshires.
CosmicConservative
Andy: US West was one of the "Baby Bell" phone companies that were split off from "Ma Bell" the old AT&T. So yes, I'd say that US West was a fairly profitable company. I didn't take it as criticism. I'm mostly (mostly) over the bitterness and anger. But I'm glad to see Joe go down....
Andy
Yes CC, Bitterness and anger come on quickly, and fade slowly. No matter how "Jesus-like" we fashion ourself to be, events like that (and I have had my own in the past...trust me...if I ever take two or three hours to tell you the story you WOULD) remind us just how human we still are. Thank God that Jesus finally wins out for most of us.
Andy
I messed up...(and I have had my own in the past…trust me…if I ever take two or three hours to tell you the story you WOULD) should continue with (feel better about your loss). Of course MY loss is always more dramatic and destructive than the loss of others.
CosmicConservative
Heh, it is always the case that our own troubles are those that are the most serious. I can't complain (well, I can and do.... but that's not what I mean...) Joe deserves his fate. Lots and lots of people lost years worth of savings and many had to postpone retirement or get second jobs because Joe wanted to "play with the big boys" in the Fortune 100, and felt that lying and cheating was a fine way to get there.
Andy
Thanks for more info CC. I am thinking about postponing my retirement (which I am really enjoying). I guess that means I will have to get a real job now. I already have a second job, so that one is taken care of. Seriously...I know that it must have been a big hit on a lot of folks with great expectations. I do feel badly for all. It just "shows to go ya"...just when you think you've eaten the bear...the bear eats you. I have the T-shirt on that one. Give Cosmic Wife, and the Cosmic kids my best. Please tell Cosmic Wife that I would like to meet her one day...and introduce her to her new rival...you know...the girl that has a crush on you (Man, how I hope she reads this). btw...are you going to send your reunion photos to the photobucket thing?
CosmicConservative
Andy: I have to get the photos off the camera, but if I have any that turned out, I'll be sending them to the reunion bucket.