Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Book Review: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hollows

By CosmicConservative
I finished HPATDH last night. I don't want to spoil anyone's enjoyment of it so I won't reveal any details that would be important to discover as you read the book. Or I'll try not to anyway. There's a lot going on in this book. There's danger, intrigue, young love, betrayal, murder, heroism, sacrifice and revenge... and a whole lot more. It's definitely going to be well enjoyed by most Harry Potter fans, and it should be. My problems with JK Rowlings' writing style have been well documented here and on other websites where I post. Basically I think she's very good with characters and story-telling, but she struggles when it comes to describing anything that resembles action scenes, whether that be a quidditch match, or a life and death struggle between Harry and Voldemort. That has not changed, and this book is full of action scenes, it probably has as many action scenes as the previous six books combined. It is difficult to write a review of a book like this, mostly because there has never been a book like this that I know of. There are hundreds of millions of people worldwide who have been waiting for this book for a long time. It is an instant best-seller. It will be immediately loved by millions and hated by millions, regardless of how good or bad it actually is. I did enjoy the book in spite of its many flaws. Rowlings tells a good story, and the things that bother me about it likely don't bother most people. So I won't dwell on them. It's a good read. The basic messages are still firmly pro-life, pro-family and pro-friendship. The religious references are more obvious, but will still elude most people I think. In the end the book is profoundly Christian, in much the same way that the Narnia or Lord of the Rings books are profoundly Christian. I expect there will be endless debate on the way the book ended and whether it is the "right" ending. From my perspective, I thought the end result was pretty much what it should have been based on the original track the story went on and the general audience that reads it. Of course I have lots of issues with the specific path Rowlings took to get there, but I don't have any fundamental issues with the final conclusions of the story lines. I think most of the book's audience will be pleased with it. I was also pleased that Rowlings actually wrote an ending to the series. These days it is getting more and more rare for an author to actually complete a story when they have a popular franchise going. The author wants to ride the gravy train as long as possible. Now that Rowlings is the richest woman on earth, I guess that's not so much of an issue and she felt like she could end the story. I'm sure there will be unlimited licensing for years to come for movies, games, animated cartoons, lunch boxes, etc. So it's not like the cash will stop rolling in just because the last book has been published. In all, I give the book 3.5 elder wands out of 4. I heartily recommend it to anyone. One final thought. I want to personally thank J.K. Rowlings for writing these books. She has turned an entire generation into readers again. That is a seriously positive thing and she should be rewarded for that. I don't begrudge her a single penny of her profits on the endeavor. Good show.

Comments (2)

gjh
Glad you enjoyed the book, can't wait til tonight when I get my copy. On another note, what has happened to this blog? I know it is your own plaything, but it used to be about the politics of being a conservative and a political discussion forum. Has this adminstration embarrassed you and others so much that you no longer make comment about anything, other than throwing rocks at Al Gore? How 'bout Gonzo? Spector? amnesty? The navel gazing is getting old.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Mostly I've been on vacation. But yes, this administration has embarrassed me. As I've told you probably 200 times now, I'm no fan or defender of GW Bush. He has always disappointed me on many issues. But at least he fights our mortal enemies. Which is more than I can say for any Democrat except Joe Lieberman.