Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hot Earth Hysteria Heats Up...

By Dadman
MSNBC.COM - Bush administration in hot seat over warming This article alleges the Bush administration is actively suppressing the bad news of global warming. We've all heard this before. It's an interesting allegation given just how much media coverage the issue of human-induced global warming gets day in and day out. And with the new Congress, we'll certainly be hearing a lot more about it. In the mind of Barbara Boxer, and most liberals, the scientific debate over this issue is essentially over. I suppose this means climate scientists should pack up the labs, turn out the lights, and go home. There's nothing left to study. It was the Union of Concerned Scientists who conducted the survey that indicates the evil Bushies are suppressing objective, impartial scientific inquiry...
The Union of Concerned Scientists, a private advocacy group, and the Government Accountability Project, a legal-assistance group that represents whistle-blowers, sent out the survey to 1,600 scientists. Surveys were returned by 308 scientists. Not all answered every question, but the survey found that: - 43 percent of respondents reported edits during review of their work that changed the meaning of their findings. - 46 percent felt administrative requirements that impaired climate-related work. - 67 percent said the environment for federal government climate research is worse now than five years ago.
Interesting. That's what...a 19% response rate? Not very good. I'm not a statistical expert, but I have to wonder if a response rate that low doesn't cast serious doubt on the legitimacy of the survey's conclusions. I have to wonder what the 81% of scientists who did not respond to the survey think about Bush's outrageous suppression tactics. I even have to wonder what they might think about catastrophic human-induced global warming. I guess we'll never know. And of those 19% who did respond, is it conceivable they had a political axe to grind which motivated them to respond to this obviously politicized survey? Certainly it is. This survey and it's results are clearly bogus. It was generated by a group with a political agenda, responded to by a very limited number of scientists with the same agenda, reported by a biased media incapable of critical analysis of any kind, and is now being cited by politicians to score political points against President Bush. What a sham, what a joke, what a shame...

Comments (19)

Kevin in WI
We shouldn't be at all surprised by this. This trifecta of liberally biased or anti-administration surveyor, responder, and media commentator is the way it has been for a very long time. There is a lot of irony in scientists conducting such an unscientific poll. Irony, the last breadfruit of a tired cynic...
Dadman
I can barely bring myself to say the words 'climate scientist' with a straight face anymore. Same with journalist. Objectivity has gone the way of the dodo...
CosmicConservative
Never forget that a large portion of the agenda that drives the Global Warming hysteria is actually an anti-capitalistic, anti-Western, anti-Progress cadre.
Dadman
I am well aware. They can't wait to use the power of government mandate for force us all to live according to their own social/political vision. I can't wait.
CosmicConservative
The California Legislature just passed a bill mandating compact fluorescent bulbs to replace all incandescent bulbs in government light sockets. What cracks me up is that this sort of thing requires a vote of the legislature. It would seem more appropriately to be an executive branch decision. If I were Arnold I'd say "I'll use fluorescent bulbs when you put the additional funds in the budget to pay for them."
gjh
I watched An Inconvienent Truth on pay per view two nights ago. Take the time watch it then comment.
CosmicConservative
gjh: I read Al Gore's book "Earth in the Balance" where he said, among other things, that the greatest threat to humanity was the internal combustion engine. I don't need to see Al's latest psychotic, paranoid, politically motivated diatribe, thank you very much.
Dadman
I've seen portions of it, but will watch the whole thing and post my review here later...
gjh
That is why we have a problem. The right will not even consider anything other than their marching orders.
CosmicConservative
gjh: I said I read Al Gore's book "Earth in the Balance." How does that fit in with your insult? It doesn't. Notice that I don't insult you, I prefer to let your own behavior reveal your personality defects directly instead of manufacturing character defects for you. So, gjh, how many of Rush Limbaugh's books have you read?
Dadman
gjh: I truly resent the implication that I don't think for myself. I am an independent conservative. In a past life, I voted for Clinton and, I'm ashamed to say, Michael Dukakis. Since that time, I have seen the light and no longer accept the politics of the left as anything more than wishful, sometimes foolish, thinking...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I think your resentment is exactly what gjh is looking for.
gjh
I'm missing something here, I did not insult anyone personally, I just said the right (in general) does not look at the facts, as they (generally) attack with,"latest psychotic, paranoid,politically motivated diatribe... I only asked to watch the stupid movie and comment for or against. Rub yourself with borax and toughen up that thin skin.
CosmicConservative
gjh: How can you seriously make a statement saying that "the right generally does not look at the facts" and other such stereotypical insulting comments without understanding that when you direct them at people like me on the right, they are insulting? Are you serious? Can you truly be that insensitive to the reaction to your comments? My skin is plenty tough, I made my points and rebutted your charges well. If you think your posts here demonstrate a superior understanding of facts and a superior ability to debate compared to me, Drax, Dadman, mtnlurker and others, you are seriously deluded about yourself and your abilities.
gjhoroky
Cosmic you are starting to give the right a bad name. In the future I'll refer to your rants as the reactionary right so I don't insult the true conservatives.
Dadman
gjh: Please present the evidence that proves human activity is causing global warming and refutes the possibility that we are experiencing a natural global warming trend. Don't tell me Al Gore said so. Cite the evidence...
CosmicConservative
gjh: You seem to be incapable of understanding the implications of your own words. You are the one insulting us, gjh, not vice versa. When have I said "the left does not look at the facts?" or "the left always attacks with psychotic, paranoid, politically motivated diatribes." You repeatedly say the right "doesn't think for itself." As a conservative you state that I "only respond to my marching orders." How you can make statements like this, and then whine about how we are insulting you is quite literally incomprehensible to me.
Rick Larson
I certainly agree the internal combustion engine is as close to a hidden evil as ever has been. The thing uses less than 20% of the energy produced and is the greatest cause of deadly emissions as ever there was caused by man. 100 years from now our ancestors will curse their long-dead relatives using such a precious resource in such trivial pursuits at the expense of our safe haven from the cosmic rigors of space.
CosmicConservative
Rick: 100 years from now it is hard to believe we will not have nearly unlimited power due to fusion reactors which use sea water as fuel. Oil, which is far from a "precious resource" will still be plentiful and will be used for all the things it is used for today. And what is burning fossil fuels doing to expose us to the cosmic rigors of space? 20% efficiency is not bad for engines. What do you think the efficiency of an electric car is Rick?