Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Experts slam upcoming global warming report - CNN.com

By CosmicConservative
Experts slam upcoming global warming report - CNN.com WASHINGTON (AP) -- Later this week in Paris, climate scientists will issue a dire forecast for the planet that warns of slowly rising sea levels and higher temperatures. But that may be the sugarcoated version. Early and changeable drafts of their upcoming authoritative report on climate change foresee smaller sea level rises than were projected in 2001 in the last report. Many top U.S. scientists reject these rosier numbers.
Translation: "You're not scaring them enough!!" What I love is that the report's critics are called "experts" but the report creators are not. Don't you love that? It makes it sound like all the climate scientists in the world are outside bitching about a climate report that is being prepared inside by chimpanzees. Didn't they let experts create the report? Sure they did. So why isn't this article titled "Climate Experts lower Global Warming fears?" Because that's exactly what they did. I guess the answer to that question is pretty obvious, isn't it?

Comments (9)

lance
OK. I think we are making progress? We've gone from "global warming is junk science and is not happening", to, "it's not going to be as bad as they say it is". It's alright to admit this is a problem and address it head on. I know Rush would stop sending you flowers, but sometimes you need to walk on your own for a while.
CosmicConservative
lance: Is it necessary for you to hurl insults at people you don't even know? Just so you know, I am no fan of Rush Limbaugh, and I'm sure he's no fan of mine. I've been debunking global doomsday prophecies since the 1977 Global Cooling scare that showed New York City under ice on the cover of Newsweek magazine. Here is my perspective on Global Warming, and it has not changed in several years. 1. The data is questionable. The famous "hockey stick" graph that is the "smoking gun" of Global Warming has been proven to have been doctored to remove the temperature spikes of the "Medieval Warming Epoch" so that it appeared more alarming. The data at different levels of the atmosphere show different levels of cooling, and some levels actually show warming. 2. The premise is questionable. C02 is a rather minor gas in the whole atmospheric greenhouse effect picture. Water vapor has an effect that is hundreds of times more impactful than C02. Even methane has been shown to be more influential than C02. All of the C02 produced by every automobile in the world added up would not be a significant fraction of the amount of C02 emitted by natural sources, especially volcanic activity. 3. The models are questionable. The latest models have only just recently (like in the last year) attempted to crudely include the temperature exchanges of the sea-air interface. In 2005 when the hurricane season went haywire, every global warming "scientist" pointed to a particular computer model which showed increased hurricane activity as a result of global warming and shouted "SEE!! WE TOLD YOU!!" because the hurricanes "proved" the model. Of course then we had 2006 with its virtually nonexistent hurricane season, and those same global warming "scientists" pointed to a DIFFERENT model that showed reduced hurricanes due to "changing ocean currents" and said "SEE!! WE TOLD YOU!!" In complete ignorance of their own contradictory assertions of just a year earlier. 4. The predictions are questionable. Take the melting ice caps for example. I have seen some "scientists" predict rising ocean levels of "up to two feet" from the melted glaciers on Greenland. Of course anyone who cares to look at history knows that Greenland was once free of glaciers over much of its surface when the Vikings landed there, colonized it and GREW CROPS FOR OVER A HUNDRED YEARS before the glaciers returned. During that period (again, known as the "Medieval Warming Epoch") the sea levels were only a few inches, if any higher at all, than they are today. You can believe what you want to believe. You can get all worked up about SUVs while we have coal seam fires burning in China that emit more carbon dioxide than all of the U.S. energy production combined. But don't presume to lecture me on a subject I have studied very well.
gjh
What happened to the depletion of the ozone layer? Every body jumped on board, banned CFC's. The problem got solved. Junk science, I think not, just good science. Pull your heads out of the sand or wherever else they may be stuck!
CosmicConservative
gjh: More insults. At least you are consistent. Find some post from me attacking the science of ChloroFlouroCarbons before you accuse me next time. I stand by my analysis of Global Warming. We'll see who is right in the next decade or so. I say things will be more or less the same as today fifty years from now. No major population shifts, no destructive flooding of New York City (New Orleans is another matter, but it's already below sea level), no massive crop failures across the midwest, etc... I intend to be around to check on it. Get back to me in 2057 and we'll see who turned out to be closer to reality, OK? I am a huge fan of technology. I'm quite confident that we'll be off carbon-based energy for the most part well before 2057, simply through market forces alone. As I said, check back with me.
gjh
I just stated that the depletion of the ozone was poohooed by the very same factions that are doing it to global warming. I'm not totally convinced that this is 100% the right answer but it appears that the science is probably right. I don't believe that cigarettes are the only cause of lung cancer, but they are a major contributing factor in the disease. There are still "scientist" out there preaching everyday that tobacco is not the major cause, I'm not superstitious, but then again I don't chances. I quit 8 years ago. Just a note, when I say the right, I don't mean to demonize you, I paint the rightwingers with a broad brush. I paint the pack of jackal attackers that come the right with that same brush. I look at the issues by looking at as many sides of an issue as I can find and then I look at who is spewing the word. I look at The Nation, The National Review, Huffington Post and the Washington Times. the lists go on. Remember when the Bush Admin took over the White House and the Washington Times, wrote as a news story that the Clinton Admin upon leaving trashed Air Force One anf that all the "w's" we removed from the computer keyboards. This was stated as fact and spread around the MSM. Some picked up on it and others didn't. When it was found to be false, did anyone in MSM correct the "facts", no it never happened. By the way, who wrote the story about the incident in the Times? Tony Snow. Look at the issues at hand from sources other than your side. It may allow meaningful discussions with those you may think you disagree with.
CosmicConservative
gjh: I always am amazed at how different factions decide what are "facts" and what are not. The story of the trashing of the White House was exaggerated, but it was not made up. There were keyboards with missing "w"s and public documents repairing those keyboards after Bush took over were posted on several blogs. GW Bush told his people to downplay the whole thing, that there were a few isolated incidents but that the entire White House was not trashed and it was better to just go on than to make an issue of it. That's why the issue disappeared, and I think Bush was right to move on. I am quite comfortable with my record here on cosmicconservative to listen and present both sides of arguments. If you think I am some sort of right-wing robot who tunes in to Rush Limbaugh each day to get my marching orders, you are not reading this site. I do the same thing you claim to do. I read Huffpo, DailyKOS, Democratic Underground, Firedoglake and several other prominent liberal websites and blogs. Sometimes I agree with the Left, more often I agree with the right. My comments on global warming are fact based and presented rationally. There is not one single thing I've said about Global Warming that you can dispute. Go ahead and try. I'll debate it with gusto. Note that I do not claim that Global Warming is not happening. I have presented strong cases that there is significant evidence that the warming is not directly related only to human C02 emissions. I have and can continue to provide evidence that there are several factors involved, including geological evidence of warming cycles and evidence of increased solar output (did you know that the ice caps on Mars are melting? That storms are at a historic high on Jupiter and Saturn? That Pluto is not cooling off as fast as expected as it returns past Neptune's orbit?) Furthermore I am skeptical of the doomsayers who think that global warming is going to be some sort of catastrophic event that will threaten our global civilization. If it happens it is likely to cause some inconveniences such as midwest farmers switching from wheat to corn, while Canadian and Siberian farmers grow more wheat. Some ski resorts may go out of business. But the predictions of global calamity and billions of people being forced into nomadic lifestyles are difficult for me to accept, mostly because I am quite aware that warming of this sort has happened before in human history, and nothing that dramatic happened then, so I don't see why we are expecting it this time. If you read my posts and read my comments you will learn that I am far from a right-wing zealot. And then you might understand why I find your knee-jerk anti-conservative insults not only indicative of a character flaw, but also evidence of an unwillingness on your part to actually engage people constructively in debate.
gjh
That is why in a previous post I suggested to look at the Gore film. It literally scared the s@@t out of me. I don't scare easily but in my occupation I've spooked a couple of times. Each time it was well founded. It is very difficult to cook the numbers when peer review is involved. It happens from time to time but it will be revealed. Does cold fussion ring a bell? I would like to hear who the anti warming scientists are and where they stand in scientific community. One guy standing alone might be a brave stand but documentation and peer review in this case is required to make a believable arguement. Take the 2 hours, watch the film. The idea that anyone who supports or believes that this question could be real does not make them America haters. The things that are happening in China with the worlds greatest easily accessiable coal deposits are something that causes me concern. We have the technolgy to make clean coal power but we don't have the incentive or the mandate to make it happen. Exxon just announced the largest profit in the history of mankind today but virtually nothing has been invested in alternate or more effective power sources. The Tar Sands in western Canada have more energy than the whole history of petro explotation of North America. Nothing is being done to make the product clean. We have the brains and resources to make this happen but little is being done to make it happen. We complain that the Asians are kicking our butts in auto manufacturing and profits do we need them to lead the world in clean petro production and usage? This is not a conservative or liberal problem. This is a North American and world problem. Look at it this way, by denying that Uncle Louie is an alcoholic because we don't want cause problems in the family, doesn't make Uncle Louie any less of a drunk. I've never been accused of being a "greenie".
CosmicConservative
OK gjh, this is more like it. Let's continue the debate in this vein, OK? One reason I haven't watched "An Inconvenient Truth" is because I've read Al Gore's book and know what he thinks about Global Warming. I also am quite certain that I am at least as well informed as Mr. Gore is on the subject, and quite frankly I think my degree in physics makes me quite a bit more qualified to examine the data and reach my own conclusions than Mr. Gore with his degree in fine arts and a career in politics. I also believe it to be irresponsible to traffic in fear the way Al Gore does in order to try to get his agenda followed. And Al isn't the only one. Over the years as Global Warming advocates (many of whom are thinly disguised anti-capitalists and anti U.S. activists) have seen their efforts fail to rally the public, they have racheted up the rhetoric to the point that it is now at the same level that pervaded the "debate" over nuclear weapons when the media reported that virtually every scientist in the US supported unilateral nuclear disarmament, a policy that if followed would have almost certainly have led to the US being defeated by the Soviet Union instead of the reverse, which happened because Reagan forced the USSR into bankruptcy by racheting up the arms race to the point that the USSR could not keep up. I believe similar demagoguery is at play today. And for many of the same reasons, with many of the same anti-US, anti-capitalist, so-called "intellectuals" playing the same role as before, which is the role of calling the US evil, US policy catastrophic and predicting ultimate gloom and doom if we don't take action so drastic as to ensure economic hardship for just about everyone. I tell people this story, it's a true story. Back at the turn of the 20th century New York City and other major metropolitan areas had a huge problem. One that many were predicting would lead to the end of urban life. The problem was an ecological, health and environmental disaster of monumental proportions. People who lived in the city were constantly sick and people who lived outside of the city hated to go to the city. New York hired a who's who of scientists to solve the problem. The most common solution was to drastically alter the behavior of the people who lived in the city, whether they wanted to do it or not. Many proposed criminalizing the behavior that led to the problem. But before any of those drastic measures had to be taken, technology solved the problem and people don't even remember the problem today. What was the problem? Horses which deposited tons of manure in the city streets each day. Manure which backed up the sewers and spread filth and disease throughout the city. Manure which had to be loaded onto barges and carried off of Manhattan island. Manure which was mathematically projected to fill New York to a depth of feet at the rate of growth of the city human and horse population. What was the solution? The automobile, which was hailed as the savior of the urban lifestyle because it was CLEAN, efficient and reliable. Now our modern equivalent of the horse manure problem of a hundred years ago is CO2 from burning fossil fuels. The solution? Today the most reasonable solution is to generate a far higher percentage of our power through nuclear energy. In the (hopefully) near future we should solve fusion power generation, and most of this wailing and gnashing of teeth will rapidly recede into our collective memory where it will fade just as the horse manure problem faded. That's the nature of technology and market forces. They've worked for thousands of years to solve problems. The solutions introduce new problems of their own, and those get solved too. That's what I believe will happen now. Al Gore, as much as I despise him, is part of that solution because his fear-mongering is driving people to more readily accept nuclear power. One person who used to violently oppose nuclear power and now openly lobbies for it is one of the original founders of Greenpeace. He now says it was a huge mistake to fight nuclear power because of Global Warming. Nuclear power will grow. More hydroelectric dams will be built. Solar power will rise, although there are limits to what we can do with solar power. The problem will be solved, ghj, the way humanity's problems have always been solved, with the timely and appropriate advancement of technology. You watch and see.
Aimee
Great blog, CosmicConservative, you obviously have done your homework. Just a reflection here, as I just watched "The Great Global Warming Swindle" Everything I believed to be true was thoroughly confirmed, and worse. I was just shocked to what extent data are falsified knowingly, to fit the green extremists doomsday theories. This is a much more organized crime than I had expected. Then the media's love of scary stories and politicians do the rest of the job for them, giving them credibility and power. Gore being a particularly pathetic figure, since I have no doubt he actually believes what he does is just and noble. The most horrific thing is: the real facts are there for anyone who bothers to look..! This lie has grown so huge the general public doesn't even question its validity anymore. Scientists who are critical, don't speak out for fear of having their grants denied or becoming stigmatized as being bought by big industry. At the same time, scientist who who keep on "the right side" - do research that is funded on the idea that CO2 emissions increase surface temperatures, acidify oceans, melts ice caps, floods the world, spreads dengue fever and malaria, create deserts and drought, famine, kills off most species and habitats etc etc, are more certain to receive funds for research. The world is amass with people who get their daily bread for promoting this theory. The movie clarified every argument that opposes man-made warming that I can only recommend it as crucial viewing, especially for those who has been misguided by "An Inconvenient Truth". Increased sun activity is the cause of this latest, small rise i surface temperature, not human CO2 emissions, which are a minute 0.28% of total planet emissions. A couple of decades later the temperature will cool again. The world isn't static, isn't that weird? However, I don't think we have to wait 50 years to prove this madness wrong, because: - The propaganda is getting ever more extreme. Basically every natural disaster is now blamed on human-caused CO2 emissions, it's getting downright ridiculous, even for Hollywood. - Statistically it might not be long before we experience another small cooling period - how will they explain that? The start of the last warming period saw an end to the "new ice age" scare. - 2007-2009 are polar years. Extensive research is being done on the Antarctic and Arctic, and fresh ice core samples from the Antarctic show the earth experiences a natural cycle of climactic change, going back hundreds of thousands of years. It's gonna be harder to doctor any evidence there. - More and more respected scientists are speaking out - as shown by "The Great Global Warming Swindle". Most of them are retired, so they can't punished for stating their opinion economically. Well, that's all for me. Doomsday is cancelled. I'm gonna tell everybody the great news:)