Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Weapons in space

By CosmicConservative
Where is the Pentagon going in space?
The Space Review: Space weapons: hardware, paperware, beware? What else might the Pentagon have up its sleeve (or “down its silo”) along the lines of space combat hardware? In an insightful assessment by a former top DoD “space warrior”, published earlier this year, the answer seems to be, “not much – if anything”. Former Brigadier General Simon (“Pete”) Worden, writing in the March/April 2006 issue of the pro-disarmament Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, directly addressed the theme of a “war scare of sorts” that had recently erupted when “the New York Times published a front-page article alleging the United States was on the verge of authorizing a massive, secret space weapons development program” involving orbital deployments. “There’s just one problem,” Worden continued: “A massive U.S. space weapons program does not exist. Not only has there not been a space weapons push, but overall U.S. military use of space is in sharp decline.” He provided examples of year-by-year retreat from earlier grandiose posturing, adding that “most of what might be called true offensive space weapons, such as space lasers, were canceled long ago [and] the programs of the Missile Defense Agency for space-based missile defenses, never large in recent years, have been marginalized by Congress and Pentagon leadership.”
Pretty much nowhere it seems. One of the quotes from the article talks about how a "senior US official" says that "space weapons are not inevitable. Oh really. Tell that to the Soviet Union which has deployed weapons in space in three decades. Well, I guess you can't tell them anything now, since they are gone, but some of those weapons are probably still up there. I can't think of anything more "inevitable" than something that has already happened. But it is also foolish to think that humans will move out into space and not take weapons with them. I'd put that in the "duh" category. Which makes me wonder what the intellectual capabilities are of "US Officials" who actually make or influence policy. Sometimes I just get depressed about the whole thing.

Comments (2)

qwerty182764
"overall U.S. military use of space is in sharp decline." Not sure what he means by this. If it's true, it shouldn't be! All the fancy, cheap smart bombs, all the interoperable systems that can all talk to each other, all the real-time communication and observation sharing in nations that have never had electricity, much less cable-internet is thanks to sattelite communications. I read some paper recently about the need to replace and upgrade Milstar, our secure communications system. If we're smart, we'll completely cover the earth in com and observation sattelites in the future. Want to run a squadron of 300 drone bombers from Florida? That takes bandwidth and LOS. That takes sattelites. Want to get the trajectory of a few hundred enemy missiles within feet, to intercept? You need even more sattelites. Need I go on? Currently, we're fighting a bunch of fanatical barbarians from the stone-age, who would probably prefer to teach mythological nonsense about space and forget it even exists. But this might not always be the case. In the event of a power-play with an actual competent industrial power, one of the pieces of infastructure that they will want to develop is a sattelite infastructure to establish their own independent smart-weapons and communications capabilities. It also means that our sattelite systems have a big fat target painted on them. Arms races are an inevitable consequence of competition. You're never going to be rid of them. They're practically built in to the laws of nature. In a world of the unarmed and valuable, the lone predator wins, and wins big.
CosmicConservative
Well, if we don't create something like the USS Enterprise at some point, I'm going to be very disappointed....