Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Cloning and Artificial Intelligence

By CosmicConservative
I have been reading Ray Kurzweil's book "The Singularity is Near" and it has gotten me thinking more about the future than I normally do, and I normally do that quite a bit. One of the things that it is making me think about is the difference in public acceptance of cloning and of artificial intelligence research. Cloning is generally viewed with deep suspicion, and in fact laws have been drawn up to outlaw any cloning research based on the premise that it is morally wrong to mess around with the fundamental properties of human life. Artificial Intelligence is generally viewed with puzzlement or cynicism, in fact many deeply religious people consider the research to be a fool's errand since they view human intelligence as the sole province of divine intervention. But it is probably true that Artificial Intelligence research is nearly as far down the road to practical reality as cloning is. In fact an artificial intelligence comparable to a human brain is now considered to be likely to be created within a decade or two, probably closer to a single decade. There are many roads on the map to get to a working AI system, but many of them essentially are reverse engineering the human brain and applying the patterns and techniques used by the brain to create electronic versions of the brain. In essence this is "cloning" the human brain's information processing capabilities. I haven't voiced an opinion on cloning here because I am conflicted on the subject, but up until now I have been highly supportive of AI research. I'm now wondering if these are fundamentally inconsistent positions. It might be helpful to describe "cloning" as mass producing the hardware of the human body, while "AI" is mass producing the software of the human mind. I think that history has taught us that the human mind is the more important of those two systems. So if I have some fundamental issue with recreating human life in a lab, then logic compels me to say that I should be more opposed to AI research than to cloning. Or at least equally. But I can't do it. I still find myself fully supportive of AI research. And if anything, that is making me rethink my position on cellular cloning.

Comments (15)

Dadman
A 'brave new world' is coming whether we like it or not. I'm sorta glad I won't be around to see a world/society that has fully embraced human genetic engineering, cloning or AI. I know that's a rather pessimistic way to feel, but I believe these technologies will dramatically undermine the mystery and wonder of life. What we consider 'miracles' today, such as musical prodigies, will be reduced to technical manipulation. Beauty and intelligence will become commodities to trade and sell. No thanks. I want no part of such a world...
qwerty182764
"Cloning is generally viewed with deep suspicion, and in fact laws have been drawn up to outlaw any cloning research based on the premise that it is morally wrong to mess around with the fundamental properties of human life." For me, it isn't so much messing around with the fundamental properties of human life that's the problem. (We do that all the time) It's that the human involved (the one under the microscope) has no say in how his life will be messed with. Furthermore, we don't know what we're doing yet in terms of genetic manipulation; and I fear the means by which we will figure out what we are doing will involve destroying or crippling the lives of many clones/genetic-manipulated-people at birth in the hopes of, perhaps, eliminating genetic disease at some point in the future. Also, for many people, the quick and easy way to eliminatng genetic disease involves not modifying the genetics of a child at conception, but simply wiping out every embryo found to have one!! Add to that the bizzare expectations people have of clones (that they're xerox copies of their parents on account of their DNA alone; or that they're not people and can be exploited with a free concience; or that they don't have souls, ....), and you have 50 gallon drum of worms to open. I'm all for treating people, and improving human health and ability. Too many people are all for pruning humanity to fit their preconcieved ideals of life, meaning, and beauty, and it's hard to trust them with that sort of power. "In fact an artificial intelligence comparable to a human brain is now considered to be likely to be created within a decade or two, probably closer to a single decade." Well, the computing power may or may not be there. But the software has always been the primary issue. Our programs to date are basically huge long lists of static instructions. Brains, on the other hand, are neural networks that somehow manage to self-organize around our sensory organs. (Aside: your genes couldn't possibly alone dictate the "programming" of your brain. There's simply not enough information there. Nor could they dictate the path of every blood vessel and capillary, just a basic pattern of growth and interaction) These neural networks have neurons that act as complicated, adapting switching mechanisms, that view the inputs of each neuron they're connected to with constantly shifting values based on feedback. Somehow, this all gives rise to the pattern of our minds. If we want to duplicate that, we have to make a lot of progress in creating artificial neural networks that can adapt and respond to simple situations (and we are doing so. There are actual bound journal volumes on adaptive neural networks in the Engineering Library here. We have come a long way in object recognition, ect). After we get that nailed down, then we need to create systems with the intelligence of a fruit-fly (imagine if our mars rovers were [i]that[/i] agile in autonomy!!). And work our way up from there. It'll be an exciting climb. It'll probably also be littered with all sorts of clever programs along the way solely designed to pass the Turing test (fool people into thinking that an actual thought process is occuring).
qwerty182764
": your genes couldn’t possibly alone dictate the “programming” of your brain. There’s simply not enough information there." Oops, perhaps I opined too soon. Now that I think about it, iterating patterns can produce patterns of extraordinary (even infinite) complexity from a set of very simple instructions. (Mandelbrot set, for example). So maybe the nature/nurture balance is still on natures side.
qwerty182764
"I know that’s a rather pessimistic way to feel, but I believe these technologies will dramatically undermine the mystery and wonder of life." Here it is again. The idea that something is only meaningful or wonderful if we don't know anything about it! What good are mysteries if you resolve never to explore them?
CosmicConservative
Dadman: A couple of points. 1. I'm not sure you're not going to be around to see it. Kurzweil puts the "singularity" as occurring in 2045. He also believes that medical advances will increase lifespans significantly in the next 20 years or so. 2. I'm also not sure that the things you think will be reduced to technical manipulation will be. There' still the whole issue of will to deal with. If we truly create artificial intelligence, instead of just powerful machines, then there is no reason that we won't see more of what you want, not less.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: Excellent points, I'm glad you post here. Kurzweil's "predictions" are based on exponential growth in key technologies that will allow reverse-engineering the human brain much faster than any linear projection would indicate. He makes a pretty compelling argument I think. He talks about both hardware and software and actually lists some key metrics about the computing power necessary to mimic a human brain. Then he uses projections of data processing technology from the past fifty years to demonstrate the exponential effect, and then he simply plots it out. You should read the book. It is thought-provoking.
Dadman
My argument is not that we should never explore mysteries, but that mysteries cease to be mysteries once we've figured it all out...and that may not be a good thing with respect to qualities such as human intelligence, creativity and beauty. Presently, when a child is conceived it is essentially a mystery how that child will turn out. He or she might be a mathematical prodigy, or incredibly athletic, or preternaturally beautiful, or an individual with more pedestrian capabilities. As the mystery of these human qualities begins to be unraveled then it is just a matter of time before we begin to genetically engineer our offspring to conform to our concept of quality. And that will ultimately lead to the commoditization of such qualities as beauty, strength, eye color, artistic creativity, intelligence and the like. When new human beings are brought into the world they will be 'designed' per the specifications of the individual creating them, much like creating the car of your dreams at mercedesbenz.com. When we reach that place then, I would argue, we will have rendered the very qualities we are seeking to obtain meaningless and counterfeit. Is manufactured beauty still beautiful? Is pre-fabricated creativity just an oxymoron? Wonder and awe is a derivative of randomness. Once we've figured out all the mysteries of life and developed the technologies necessary to manipulate our genetic code, how long will it be before every new human being brought into the world is engineered to be beautiful, tall, strong, intelligent, creative, and every other attribute deemed to be desirable by society? We will effectively extend keeping up with the Joneses to our very DNA as we strive to 'produce' higher quality kids... "I know our little Johnny has a 190 IQ and can run the 40 in 3.8 seconds, but the Joneses have come up with a genetic combination that will product a 250 IQ, a voice like Pavarotti's, and the ability to throw a football 150 yards! We should find out who their genetic engineer is." Sound good? Not to me. I truly want no part of that brave new world.
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I don't think that even if we can control genetics as much as it can be controlled, that we will have created robo-life. There will always be chaotic effects and the expression of quantum effects that will keep things interesting. But what we may be able to do is to do away with a lot of genetic defects and at least pick hair color or eye color. Is that a good thing or a bad thing? I'm not sure I know.
Dadman
I guarantee you that people will push the limits of the technology as far as they can and if it indeed becomes possible to genetically engineer individuals to the level I suppose they will then that will be, in my humble opinion, a very bad thing... I would even argue that engineering out 'imperfections' is a very dangerous slope and smacks of eugenics... How precisely do you define 'imperfection' and who gets to do the defining?
Drax
I'm a cynic, I suppose. I can't believe that human cloning won't lead to (somewhere) organ farms, and, ultimately, brain transplants for those who can afford it. (Really...I think that will happen....sigh....blame the science fiction writer, not me.) AI? So long as it's controlled and killable, I'm okay with it, heh.
CosmicConservative
Drax: If human cloning could recreate individual organs without requiring the entire reproduction of the human body, would that be something you opposed? Say, for example, that stem cells from abandoned embryos could be fused with nuclei of your kidneys and poof! a new kidney is ready, would you oppose that?
Drax
If this part wasn't in the premise: "stem cells from abandoned embryos," I don't see any problem with cloning individual organs to order. I just know that, human nature being what it is, demand for embronic stem cells will create (or maintain) the supply. Not an outcome I'm comfortable with. Hmmm...If you cloned a body without a mind, would it be "wrong" to harvest it? Science is getting us into some really murky ethical waters...and it's accelerating.
CosmicConservative
That's why I asked.... I see a future that is so different from today's notion of "humanity", "life", and "morality" that I'm not even sure what to think about it. I'm participating on a Dean's World thread on M-theory, which is an 11 dimensional "superstring" theory that is supposed to provide a breakthrough in physics that will have more impact than Relativity theory, and what that theory suggests about the universe is at least as philosophically unsettling as these questions are. Einstein once said "the universe is not merely stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we CAN imagine." (Or something like that, and maybe it wasn't Einstein, but it was some physicist from that same period...) I'm beginning to think that this is profound in a way that it was not intended. That is, I am confident that the universe is understandable, but perhaps it is only understandable to intellects augmented beyond current human abilities.
Dadman
Many physicists think string theory is nothing more than philosophy masquerading as science. As I understand it the theory is impossible to test (at least for the time being...)
CosmicConservative
The upcomding Large Hadron Collider was built specifically to test a prediction of String Theory. I have been hard on String Theory precisely because of the testability issue. So have lots of real scientists, the end result being the building of a multi-billion dollar particle accelerator. Which is good for the local economy of Switzerland I suppose. Good think we killed the SuperConducting Supercollider here in Texas. That darn Bush can't get any pork even for his "home" state. Now, there is still debate whether the "test" that the LHC will allow actually "proves" anything other than that String Theory happened to predict something that is truly described by some other phenomenon that is less complex and doesn't require ever-escalating numbers of inaccessible dimensions.