Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sports

Well, I saw this one coming

By CosmicConservative
I've not been a huge fan of Mike Shanahan in spite of two Super Bowl victories a decade ago. After three years of missing the playoffs, and being the first team in the history of the NFL to blow a three game lead with three games to play, Denver Broncos owner Pat Bowlen fired Mke Shanahan today.
ESPN - Denver Broncos fire Mike Shanahan after season falls apart DENVER -- He was known as a genius, a mastermind and, yes, a Super Bowl champion. Shockingly, though, Mike Shanahan has a new title: unemployed coach. Shanahan became the latest and most stunning victim of the NFL coaching purge, fired Tuesday by the Denver Broncos after a late-season collapse knocked the team out of the playoffs for the third straight year.
I never cared for the "Mastermind" label that got stuck to Mike Shanahan. I think he's a good coach, but without John Elway, Terrell Davis and Shannon Sharpe, he's barely posted an above .500 record. In fact Denver post Elway, Davis and Sharpe looks a lot like Dallas post Aikman, Smith and Irvin. I have been a fairly vocal critic of Shanahan's non-coaching decisions, particularly his draft choices and free agent signings. His handling of the QB situation in Denver has been epic phail. He apparently believes that the best way to get a QB to perform is to publicly call them out and threaten to replace them with someone new as soon as possible. His trip from Elway to Bubby Brister to Brian Griese to Jake Plummer to Jay Cutler has been painful to watch. Of that post-Elway group it is interesting to note that Griese has the highest QB rating as a Denver QB, including Cutler. I always thought Griese was a better quarterback than he gets credit for. At least with Cutler Shanahan had not yet begun the guessing game of who would replace him, but I suspect that would have started next year if Shanahan stayed true to form. I won't miss Shanahan. I'm sure there are worse coaches in the league but I do think Mike Shanahan may be the most overrated coach in the history of the NFL. But to be fair, I would have much preferred to see Wade Phillips canned.

NFL wrap-up, week 15

By CosmicConservative
OK, so I didn't do a status last week, I was just not up to it. Although the fact that Dallas collapsed in the fourth quarter to a Pittsburgh team they had owned the first three quarters didn't help... Last week Denver looked awesome. Cutler threw three touchdowns and went over 300 yards. He looked great and the Denver O looked unstoppable. Dallas looked good for three quarters, but fell apart in the fourth quarter. The end result was both teams stood at 8 - 5, but Denver looked to be a playoff lock, and Dallas was on the outside looking in. This week Denver (and Cutler) regressed again, losing 30 - 10 to a Carolina team that looked sharper than usual in their passing game. Denver looked bad on both sides of the football, Cutler threw one interception but had two other easy interceptions dropped by the defensive back. Even so all Denver could muster was 10 points, while their defensive secondary was shredded by Jake Delhomme. Denver's game strategy to commit 8 men against the run was ill-conceived at best. They made Jake beat them, and Jake was quite happy to exploit an overmatched Denver secondary. Dallas looked great against the defending super bowl champs. I really thought they had no chance to win this game, but they won pretty convincingly, sacking Eli Manning 8 times while Tony Romo threw two touchdowns and had no interceptions. Even with some key players (like Marion Barber) still clearly not fully healed, Dallas ran the ball effectively and passed the ball well. If Dallas plays like they did yesterday for their remaining games, they can beat anyone. As of now Romo is still in the top three QB rankings and Cutler is still outside of the top ten. And you know what? I've not heard a lot on ESPN lately about how Jay Cutler is the "best young QB." And more and more grudgingly I am hearing Romo get credit for Dallas's wins. Yesterday Romo was sacked early and was clearly not himself the rest of the game, but even with limited mobility he made the plays he needed to when he needed to. Maybe, just maybe Romo is starting to get some respect. But as I have said for two years, I don't think he will get any real respect until he wins a few playoff games. Denver still has the edge in playoff opportunity over Dallas. Denver only has to win one of their two remaining games to be in, while Dallas has to win both. And Dallas clearly has by far the more difficult teams to face. But if they can beat Baltimore, and Philly is out of the race by the last weekend, we might just see Dallas as the final NFC wild card. At least both are still in the hunt in mid-December. That's better than a lot of the last decade.

A sad day for Baseball

By CosmicConservative
ESPN - Greg Maddux to announce retirement Monday Greg Maddux has thrown his last pitch. The four-time Cy Young winner will announce his retirement Monday at the baseball winter meetings, near his home in Las Vegas. Maddux, who turns 43 in April, ranks eighth on the career wins list with 355. He went 8-13 with a 4.22 ERA last season with the San Diego Padres and Los Angeles Dodgers.
A sad day indeed. I sort of figured he would retire when he got one win more than Clemens this year. Hall of Fame lock. No doubt about it. He'll get a higher percentage of votes than anyone in a long time.

Simple pleasures....

By CosmicConservative
When I was, oh, about 12 years old, I wanted to play in the school band. Back then we called it "Junior High School" today it's called "middle school" because I guess "junior" was too traumatic for some people. For some reason I decided I wanted to play trombone. I don't know why, but that's the instrument that caught my attention. After a bit of playing on checked out school instruments, I decided I needed my own trombone, so I started saving up my money from mowing lawns and doing other odd jobs I could find. After a while I had saved up about $50 or so, which was a lot of money back then for a 12 year old kid. Finally I found an ad in the classifieds for a used Elk Hart trombone (I think that's what it was called) for $40, as I recall. So I called them up and they still had it, so my dad drove me over to their house to pick it up. Things were different then. When we got there the father told us the trombone was in the attic, and pulled down the ladder thing and told me to go up and get it. Can you imagine someone doing that today? But that's what he did. So up I went, and sure enough, there it was, so I opened the case, looked at it, it looked in real good shape, so I closed the case and headed back to the stairs. But then something caught my eye. An old rusted up rifle lay beside the trombone. I mean seriously rusted, and the stock was pitted with age. I could tell it was a .22 rifle though, and I had been wanting one for a while, but my dad was holding out mostly because my mom thought I was too young to own a rifle. And of course I couldn't afford a new one. But there one was, looking tattered and beaten down by life and thrown up in an attic.... So I picked it up too. Again, can you imagine that in today's world? Bringing both of them down, I showed the rifle to the house owner and asked if it was for sale too. He asked me how much money I had, and I said "After the $40 on the trombone, I've got $10 left." "Sold." He said. My dad gave me a "you are going to get me in serious trouble" look, but did not say anything. So I handed the guy my $50 and we headed to the car. "That gun probably won't even work." My dad said. "You probably just wasted $10." "Well, it was my $10 to waste." I said. "You'll have to fix it up yourself, I'm not going to do it, and I'm certainly not going to pay a gun shop to fix it." he said with an exasperated sigh, probably trying to figure out how to explain to my mom how I ended up with a rifle. When I got home, my mother was predictably upset, but my dad argued that as a 12 year old, I was old enough to be trusted with a .22, that he'd teach me to use it responsibly, that I had always been a responsible kid, and besides, the thing was so messed up it probably wouldn't shoot anyway. Finally my mother reluctantly agreed to let me own it at least long enough to see if I'd actually do the work required to clean it up. And it did require some serious work. The barrel was pitted and rusted, the stock was covered in dirt and in general the thing had a disreputable look that you might expect to find in a gun left in a mud puddle over a winter. But putting my eye to the inside of the barrel, the rifling looked to be in good shape and the inside of the barrel was shiny and pure. The bolt didn't even work though, it was so gummed up and rusty. My recollection is that it took me weeks, maybe more than a month of daily sanding and polishing to get the gunk off of the gun. The barrel had to be sanded down by hand and it took a lot of elbow grease to get all the rust off the barrel. I had to take apart the bolt and individually clean, sand and oil all of the moving parts to get it working again. I had to carefully clean, sand and polish the breech to get it to hold a shell. The stock was the easiest part, and as such was the first thing I worked on. As it turned out the stock was actually in pretty good shape, it was just covered in mud and grit which sanded off pretty easily. Once I had sanded it down, polished an oiled it, the stock actually looked quite beautiful. It was looking at the stock that kept me motivated to keep on the tedious and difficult work of sanding, polishing and reassembling the barrel and bolt. But finally it was "done." By done I mean I had removed all of the rust and had taken off all of the grit and had polished oiled and tested all the parts. The barrel still had clear signs of the abuse of the years of neglect, but I had managed to remove all the active decay. To try to sand down all of the pits and gouges in the barrel would take months of daily sanding. So I purchased a small bottle of chemical gun blueing and blued the shiny steel barrel, then I put it all back together again. It looked like this: I thought it was the most beautiful gun I'd ever seen. So then came the day I actually loaded it up with .22 short (my dad insisted that I start with short before moving to long, and finally long rifle) cartridges. We had recently moved into the suburbs, but still had family who lived in the "woods" in a rural area, and my brothers frequently went to my aunt's house to target shoot. So I went with them and spent a wonderful day plinking at tin cans. Everyone was impressed with the little .22's accuracy. Soon I was hunting squirrels and rabbits with the little gun. And I treated it with respect, always cleaning it immediately upon returning from target shooting or hunting. That was over 35 years ago. I've had that sweet little rifle ever since, and I have pumped a lot of .22 shells through it over the years. But it's been a decade at least since I've shot it. In my memory it is a highly accurate gun, but memories can be funny things. For example, my cousins had a favorite beer, I think it was called "Pearl" and the cans had a red circle in the middle of the front of the can about the size of a penny. My memory is that if I could see that red dot, I could put a bullet in it. And even if the can was so far away that the red circle wasn't actually visible, I could still put the bullet close or in it just from knowing where it was on the can. I never put a scope on the rifle, and it took the life of a lot of innocent squirrels. But in all the years I owned it, all I ever knew about it was that it was a Remington single-shot .22. All of the model information had been sanded off with the corrosion on the outside of the barrel. But thanks to the magic of the internet, today I was able to finally definitively identify the rifle as a Remington Model 41 "TargetMaster". In looking it up on the web I have found that it was made in the mid 1930s (for only 3 years) and that it had a reputation for being a highly accurate .22 rifle. Somehow knowing the name and history of the gun actually gives me a sense of well-being. It turns out that it's not worth that much, a "good condition" version is worth about $150 or so. Mine is probably only worth about $50 or so since I foolishly took it to a gun shop and had it professionally blued since the chemical bluing I put on was wearing off after a decade or so. That no doubt ruined the collectible value of the gun. But I'm not much into collecting, and I have no intention of selling this thing anyway. I put way too much of myself into this gun, and I intend to keep it around as long as I'm around to keep it.

NFL report, week 13

By CosmicConservative
I can't figure out the Denver Broncos. Last week they looked inept in a blowout loss at home to the hapless Oakland Raiders. This week they all but sewed up the AFC West title in a near blowout win in New Jersey against the powerhouse NY Jets. Jay Cutler had a monster day (for Jay Cutler; 27/43, 357 yds, 2 TD 1 int). Compared to Tony Romo's more average day on Thanksgiving (22/34, 331 yds, 3 TD, 1 int), it is worth noting that Cutler's best performance so far this year actually rated a notch below Romo's performance in QB rating. The result is that Romo is now the top rated QB in the league for the season and Cutler has climbed to #13. Now the question is which Denver Broncos team is going to show up for the rest of the season? And will the Cowboys be able to navigate one of the toughest December schedules in the NFL? ('Boys have @Pittsburgh, Giants, Ravens and finish the season @Philadelphia). It is not a stretch to say that the 'Boys would be lucky to go 2-2 in their final four games, ending at 10-6 and hoping for a Wild Card spot (and a first round road game in the playoffs if they are lucky). Pittsburgh and the Giants are arguably the two hottest teams in the NFL right now, the Ravens are chasing Pittsburgh and any divisional game in the NFC East is always going to be tough, especially played in Philly, one of the toughest stadiums to visit in the NFL. Denver's December looks much easier (Kansas City, @Carolina, Buffalo and finishing the season @San Diego). Only Carolina of that group has a winning record. Of course KC and SD are both divisional games, so that's always tough, but Denver would have to cave in to do worse than 3-1 in that stretch. That would put them at 10-6 and winning the AFC West to host one playoff game at least. At least both teams are playing meaningful games after Thanksgiving. And Cutler looked great yesterday, in fact he looked a lot like.... Tony Romo..... ;)

9 millimeters of blue-steel goodness

By CosmicConservative
OK, so now that Obama has been elected, and before his administration can effectively raise the prices on guns so that only rich people or thieves can own guns, I have decided to buy a 9 mm handgun with my (hopefully) upcoming yearly bonus from work. So I'm looking for recommendations. I currently own a few guns, but only have a .22 pistol, which has about the stopping power of a spit-wad. As my dad used to say, I want a gun that picks up an attacker HERE and puts them back down again THERE. I also want it to be as accurate as possible, although I can't afford a precision target pistol... Any thoughts?

NFL Week 12 roundup

By CosmicConservative
Romo - (pinkie finger still in a splint) W, 23-39, 349 yds, 3 TD, 0 int. Cutler - (healthy as far as I know) L, 16-37, 204 yds, 0 TD, 1 int. Romo stayed in the #3 spot overall, Cutler dropped to #16, no longer in the top 10. I might point out that both teams were playing supposed NFL doormats at home. You know who is looking better and better every week? Matt Cassel, New England's backup QB. Could there be a brewing QB controversy in New England? Hm.... Elsewhere in the league some teams won, some teams lost and Brett Favre continued to prove that his decision to retire last year was somewhat premature.

Romo vs. Cutler, chapter 4

By CosmicConservative
So, it's a bit past midway of the season. How are Tony Romo and Jay Cutler doing? Both teams are 6-4. Denver is in first place in the woeful AFC West, Dallas is tied with Washington for second place behind the Super Bowl champion New York Giants in the always tough NFC East. At this point it would seem that Denver is in a much better place to reach the playoffs than the Dallas is, but that says more about their respective divisions than their actual teams. Tony missed three games after breaking his pinkie finger in one game. He played yesterday with a splint on his pinkie and with a new throwing motion and ball-holding technique. Dallas is 5 - 2 with Romo, Denver is 6 - 4 with Cutler. Here's a breakdown of their stats: In quarterback rating (supposedly the most important stat for quarterbacks, maybe aside from wins) Romo is currently in third place with a rating of 99. Cutler is in tenth place with a rating of 90. Because of the disparity in games the most comparable stats are averages over those games so that's what I'll focus on. Romo's yards per attempt average is 8.31 yards, which is second in the league to Phillip Rivers. This is considered by many quarterback experts as one the best stats to truly measure how successful a quarterback is at moving the ball downfield. Cutler's 7.68 ypa is a respectable seventh place. Romo throws a touchdown on 6.6% of his passes. That again puts him second behind Phillip Rivers. This is considered a great stat for determining how good a QB is at getting into the end zone as opposed to settling for field goals. Cutler's 5.1% is, again, a respectable 5th place. Romo's completion percentage has taken a beating since he broke his pinkie (as has his interception count) but his 64.8% completion rate is still in the top ten (ninth) while Cutler's completion rate of 62.3 puts him right at the middle of the pack of NFL starters at #15. Romo's 7 interceptions account for 3% of his passes. Cutler's 11 interceptions account for 3% if his as well, so on this stat, they are almost exactly even. I will note though that three of Tony's interceptions came with a broken pinkie finger. So the result of analyzing these stats seems to indicate that Tony Romo continues to be a top three quarterback in the NFL, while Cutler is just barely a top ten contender. Which is pretty much exactly what my pre-season analysis of their career numbers showed. In other words, both of them are performing in 2008 after ten games more or less exactly as their stats from the past three years would predict. And yet I still see Cutler praised as the young QB of the future. He gets credit for Denver's 6-4 record leading the AFC West while Romo gets blame for his 6-4 record being a wild-card hopeful in the NFC East. I don't suppose anything is going to change here, no matter what their stats end up being this year. It certainly hasn't mattered so far. The narrative has been defined and the stories have already been written. Cutler, the first round draft choice of the mastermind coach vs. Romo, the three year backup who nearly had to walk on to make the team... In the meantime those stats just seem to keep on saying the same thing.... We'll see how things stand at the end of the year. From what I've seen so far, I expect they'll tell a very similar story.

Cutler vs. Romo at the quarter point of the season

By CosmicConservative
How good is Tony Romo really? How good is Jay Cutler? Which has been over-rated? Which has been under-rated? Well, this year so far ESPN and other sources I read have clearly considered Tony Romo to be having a slow start to his year. He had a "bad" day yesterday with only 176 yards, roughly half of what he was averaging last year at this time. By contrast the sports media is in awe of Jay Cutler's "breakout year" where he has the leading offense in the league (Dallas is #2, and virtually tied with Denver in every category) and has been the second coming of John Elway. Now don't get me wrong, I am glad that Cutler is doing well, and I hope that the discovery of the diabetes and the treatment he is getting will keep him at the top of his game for a long time to come. But if you look at the actual numbers of the two quarterbacks, you'll see that even this year with his "poor start" Tony Romo still has a higher quarterback rating (100.5 vs 98.1), more touchdowns (11 vs 10), higher yards per attempt (8.4 vs 7.8) and a higher touchdown percentage (6.8 vs 5.2). Cutler leads in total yardage (1,502 vs 1,368), interceptions (4 vs 5), attempts (191 vs 162) and completions (125 vs 104). Now Cutler's leads in yards, completions and attempts is as much about game plan and the need to keep throwing the ball in high scoring games as anything, so I don't put nearly as much weight in statistics that are all about how many times a quarterback throws the ball as I do about how likely he is to complete the pass, how frequently he finds the end zone and how high his quarterback rating is, so just based on these numbers alone, I would actually rate Romo higher than Cutler this year. Of course you couldn't tell that Romo is doing well based on ESPN's designation of Drew Brees as the "best" QB in the league this year (but with an honorable mention going to Jay Cutler). Here are some other quarterbacks whose actual statistics are superior to Jay and Tony, just for comparison: Brett Favre Phillip Rivers Kurt Warner What really just amazes me is how Cutler's "breakout year" and the adoration of ESPN and the media looks a whole lot like Romo's "disappointing" start to 2008. Couple that with Cutler throwing to Brandon Marshall and having "genius" offensive coach Mike Shanahan calling plays (compared to "defensive minded" Wade Phillips) and the comparison is even more puzzling. At this rate at the end of the year if Cutler and Romo have virtually identical years with around 3,500 yards passing, 35 or so touchdowns, a QB rating of around 100, etc... Cutler will be annointed the "next great one" and Romo will be saddled with a "disappointing year." You watch. It's almost like watching Obama vs. McCain... ;)