Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Well, I saw this one coming

By CosmicConservative
I've not been a huge fan of Mike Shanahan in spite of two Super Bowl victories a decade ago. After three years of missing the playoffs, and being the first team in the history of the NFL to blow a three game lead with three games to play, Denver Broncos owner Pat Bowlen fired Mke Shanahan today.
ESPN - Denver Broncos fire Mike Shanahan after season falls apart DENVER -- He was known as a genius, a mastermind and, yes, a Super Bowl champion. Shockingly, though, Mike Shanahan has a new title: unemployed coach. Shanahan became the latest and most stunning victim of the NFL coaching purge, fired Tuesday by the Denver Broncos after a late-season collapse knocked the team out of the playoffs for the third straight year.
I never cared for the "Mastermind" label that got stuck to Mike Shanahan. I think he's a good coach, but without John Elway, Terrell Davis and Shannon Sharpe, he's barely posted an above .500 record. In fact Denver post Elway, Davis and Sharpe looks a lot like Dallas post Aikman, Smith and Irvin. I have been a fairly vocal critic of Shanahan's non-coaching decisions, particularly his draft choices and free agent signings. His handling of the QB situation in Denver has been epic phail. He apparently believes that the best way to get a QB to perform is to publicly call them out and threaten to replace them with someone new as soon as possible. His trip from Elway to Bubby Brister to Brian Griese to Jake Plummer to Jay Cutler has been painful to watch. Of that post-Elway group it is interesting to note that Griese has the highest QB rating as a Denver QB, including Cutler. I always thought Griese was a better quarterback than he gets credit for. At least with Cutler Shanahan had not yet begun the guessing game of who would replace him, but I suspect that would have started next year if Shanahan stayed true to form. I won't miss Shanahan. I'm sure there are worse coaches in the league but I do think Mike Shanahan may be the most overrated coach in the history of the NFL. But to be fair, I would have much preferred to see Wade Phillips canned.

Comments (9)

buckblog
The Broncos loss could be my Cleveland Browns gain, I hope.
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure Shanahan is an upgrade in most places. As I said, I never believed he deserved that whole "mastermind" reputation. Here is the not so pleasant history of Mike Shanahan: He was fired twice for insubordination, once by the Raiders and once by the Broncos under Dan Reeves. He has gone through something like six defensive coordinators in eight years. He has perhaps the single most miserable draft and free-agent acquisition record in football. In fourteen years his draft record looks like this: Jay Cutler. (and that's a whole 'nother story). His free agency record looks like this: Champ Bailey (and he gave up Clinton Portis + draft choices to get Champ, I'm still not sure that was a net gain for Denver). I suppose I should put Brandon Marshall in there somewhere... that's a good pick. I think he was once a pretty good offensive coach, but the league figured out his tactics about eight years ago. For the past several years it's been Mike Shanahan who has been unable to adjust to what the opposing coaches have been throwing at him. Good luck on getting Shanahan, if you get him, you will need it.
Andy
Yea Cosmic, I kinda thought Wade might get canned. Of course he had some bad breaks this season, but this last month has just been horrid. I guess Jones has got a little grace left for the big boy. Shanahan is over rated for sure. You know, a great QB can sure make a coaching genius. Elways & Aikmans don't come along often. Nor do Sharpes, Davises, Smiths, or Irvins. But it sure is fun when they do, huh?
CosmicConservative
In Denver Mike Shanahan is regarded as some sort of Football deity. Ever since Elway retired and Davis got injured I have watched Mike Shanahan's offseason moves and have just shaken my head. I've had discussions with other Bronco fans and they all say "Mike's the best coach in the league" or "Mike's acknowledged to be a coaching genius" or stuff like that, and to try to reason with such folks is a waste of time. I try to say "compare Mike's record with, oh, Bill Belicheck, Jimmy Johnson, Chuck Knoll, Tom Landry, George Siefert, Bill Walsh or a half-dozen other hall of fame coaches. Take away the two Super Bowl seasons with Elway and company and you get a coach who has won, I think, one playoff game, has had one 13 - 3 season but otherwise has been decidedly mediocre. But even that is missing the point. The point is that "coaching" was Mike's SECOND most important job in the Bronco's organization. His FIRST most important job was to be general manager, which means making personnel decisions, managing the draft and the free agent markets and generally organizing the Broncos into a stable and competitive organization. In that role Shanahan has been an obvious failure. When people say "it's not fair to judge Mike's coaching when he doesn't have the weapons he had with Elway" they don't understand that they are not HELPING Mike. That's the PROBLEM. Mike can coach, but he can't MANAGE the team. And his ego is too large to allow him to accept a demotion to merely "coach". I suspect strongly that when Mike gets picked up by another team, and he will, his new boss will not give him GM responsibility. And with a good GM I think Mike will probably prosper again. But keep him out of the front office. His personnel decisions have been miserable.
Andy
Heh! Maybe he can go to Detroit. Two or three wins, a lucky first round draft pick, and he's a genius again... ;)
zombyboy
While I think he is a bit overrated, I think you are underrating Shanahan and that Denver will miss him in more ways that we know. That said, I also think that it was the right decision and that, as long as they bring in a smarty, young coach, it will pay dividends immediately. Of course, I'm also convinced that Griese and Brister really weren't the guys that could lead the team to playoff glory. Jake and Jay both could if Shanahan had drafted better, had played the free-agency game a little better, had hired better defensive coordinators (or, at least, given them the talent and time to build a solid defense), and had coached a little better. In the draft and in free agency, Shanahan the personnel director was a mixed bag that trended negative. His good decisions (let's be honest, Clady, Cutler, Hillis, Royal, Marshall, Stokley, Bailey, and a handful of others were all wonderful pick-ups either through the draft, trades, or free agency) didn't offset the bad (far too numerous to make even a shallow dent in the numbers--but starting with the last three years worth of defensive picks would give a good idea of how bad it has been). The offense heading into next year is set. We'll have an embarrassing number of good running backs to choose from (once they've all healed up from their injuries, that is), we have more good receivers than at any other time in Broncos history, our offensive line has to be considered one of the best in the league. Cutler has the potential to be a great player--and with the right coaching and mentoring, I think he can reach greatness. Special teams and defense, on the other hand, need a nearly complete retooling. You know, I could ramble on for quite some time about this, but I think I'll end it up with this: Shanahan needed to go. If they hire the right guy for the job (and the right guys for all the other vacancies that are about to pop up), it will be fun to watch the team rebuild. There's a lot of talent on the team--mostly bundled on the offensive side of the ball and in Champ Bailey's broken body--and a long way to go before they contend for another Super Bowl. But it could be a pretty exciting journey.
CosmicConservative
Zomby: A couple of thoughts... You list a reasonably large group of successful draft/free agent acquisitions by Shanahan, presumably the best he's done in your opinion. My personal opinion of even the list you have provided is that there is nothing exceptional in that list with the possible exceptions of Marshall and Bailey. And to get Bailey Shanahan GAVE at least as much as he GOT, so I don't see that as a net positive, even as good as Champ is. I would bet you that if you looked at the acknowledged WORST GM in the game you'd find an equally "impressive" list of "good" picks. And I'm still simply not sold on Cutler. Here's a guy who is going into his fourth year as Denver's starting QB. He has played football his entire life. He is frequently described as a "smart" QB. Yet he makes some of the most bone-headed plays I've ever seen. In the final division-title deciding game Cutler was throwing that ball all over the field. He had at least two easy interceptions dropped by defenders who seemed to be so surprised to find the ball in their hands that they didn't know what to do. Twice he turned on the run and threw the ball all the way across the field across his body to covered receivers. I frankly don't see how you do that. Nobody does that. Even Brett Favre doesn't do that. Cutler does it about a dozen times a year. The guy has a less than .500 record as a starting QB. His lifetime QB rating is below 90. His interception ratio is Favre-esque. I want to like him, but I can't escape the pure, raw statistical evidence of his play. You can't say that the Denver Offense is in good shape and then excuse a QB with a mediocre QB rating. Yes he throws A LOT, and he throws for a lot of yardage, but at the expense of critical, game-changing interceptions. Off the top of my head I can think of four or five games that Cutler threw the ball, and the game, away just this year. Yes he has the "tools" to be a great QB. But until he actually PLAYS like a great QB I'm going to rate him exactly where his ACTUAL STATS place him, which is dead in the center of mediocreville. Frankly I think Jake Plummer was better. And I thought Griese was better than Plummer. In fact if I had to rank the post_Elway Denver QBs, I'd put Cutler below all but Bubby Brister.
zombyboy
I think we'd have a lively conversation over a beer or three on this subject--and we wouldn't necessarily end up with a lot of common ground. Without going into any other specifics, I do have to say this: I'm really surprised that you don't tag Clady as special. Whatever you think of any of the others, Clady's showing in his rookie year was phenomenal. But any time you feel the need to argue the finer points of the Broncos, give me a shout. Not sure where you live, but it can't be too far from me.
CosmicConservative
You're probably right about Clady. And Eddie Royal looks like a keeper too. But are they head and shoulders above what OTHER teams have drafted or got as free agents? That I'm not so sure about. Every team has a couple of players like that at some position. It's almost impossible not to. Interesting comments on the radio today about some things I missed the last couple of days. Apparently Jay Cutler made some comments about how the Broncos better keep his favorite coaches when they bring in a new head coach. That's a lot of gall for a below .500 win/loss, 86 QB rating, zero playoff appearances player to make imho. But then Pat Bowlen, the Broncos owner, said that Jay is "the man" for the Broncos, which implies that he will be listening to Jay... I can't say that bodes well for internal organizational stability if true. The idiot radio sports reporter then said "you better listen to a top 5 QB who's going to be a top 5 QB for a long time." Top 5? Jay Cutler? According to what scale? Are you kidding me? Here's my list off the top of my head of SEVERAL QBs that are demonstrably BETTER than Jay Cutler: Tom Brady Peyton Manning Eli Manning (yes, even with his miserable first two years, he has turned the corner imho) Ben Roethlisberger Tony Romo Drew Brees Phillip Rivers Matt Schaub Brett Favre ... and that's just off the top of my head. Where does this Cutler-mania come from? The guy has literally done NOTHING to warrant such praise and adulation. NOTHING. Yet this is what people think of him. I really, truly, deeply, do. not. get. it.