Last night was my 8th and final "Beginner Novel Writing" class. I am a pretty harsh critic sometimes, and I have high expectations for any time I spend a chunk of money. The class cost me $315 to take, which is a lot of money to me for a class which has no immediate and obvious financial return. In fact I found it very difficult to pull the trigger on the class because of the expense. I can buy a lot of books on wrting for $315. In fact I could buy a fancy Kindle and a lot of books for $315. And I like techno-toys and books...
But I actually think it was $315 very well spent. I learned a lot about writing, both on the content side and the mechanics side. I added a number of new tools and tricks to my repertoire of writing techniques. I also got a good feel for my progress as a writer compared to others who are trying to write their own books. In general I came away feeling very optimistic that I will finish my book, even though I've also learned that I have a lot more work to do than I thought I did when going into the class.
So I ended up pretty happy about the class. Happy enoough to sign up for the "Intermediate Novel Writing" class for another $285...
Yeah, I should have done book reviews of "Game of Thrones", "A Clash of Kings" and "A Storm of Swords" as well.
Those would have at least been positive reviews. Well, mostly positive anyway.
When I first read "A Game of Thrones" I found it to be a generally positive variation of the fantasy tropes that litter the genre. After wasting hundreds of hours reading the never-ending stories of the "Sword of Truth" and "Wheel of time" series only to finally just get tired of them, I thought that I had at least found a book that understood the need for a story to have an ARC. You know, a "beginning" and an "END!"
But with "A Feast for Crows" George R.R. Martin has become Terry Goodkind or Robert Jordan. He has stopped telling a story and has begun to provide endless anecdotes about a series of less and less compelling characters. Plus he has thrown all attempts at creating a plausible world to the winds.
I have rarely found myself in the position of wishing a protagonist of a story would just die already. But I found that to be the case with several of the story's point of view characters. Jaime Lannister, the deliciously evil incestuous queen fornicating oath-breaker and hurler of children from windows has now become a sympathetic character, whose life has been misunderstood and who has a heart (and hand) of gold. Bullshit. He was a sociopathic, psychotic killer. And he was far more interesting that way. Just KILL HIM.
We already have one Stark child navigating through a series of personalities with Arya, now we have Sansa becoming a second Stark child who has lost her identity and adopted a new one. But even her new personality is still a simpering, whimpering weak, witless fool who still cannot fathom that the world is harsh and arbitrary, and who still yearns for fairy tales. Just KILL HER.
Cersei has gone from political genius to clueless tool, squandering riches, good will, alliances and bed partners right and left. At least she has maintained a sense of evil throughout, unlike her hapless and misunderstood Kingslayer twin.
I finished the book, but I had to make myself finish it. I have no desire to read another 1,000 pages of personal anecdotes about food, travel, sailing, sex and circumstance which goes nowhere from a story perspective.
I don't recommend this book. I certainly am not going to wait another decade to find out whether Cersei is executed or if Jon discovers his heritage, or if Arya recovers her sight and her name...
I. Just. Don't. Care. Anymore.
So, as part of my ongoing novel writing class, we were assigned to write a certain number of pages each week (which I am well ahead of) and to read one book on writing novels (I'm about halfway through) and to read at least one book in the genre in which we are attempting to write our novel.
So I picked "Game of Thrones" as the book I would read. I mostly picked it because I was curious about it having heard lots of good things about it, as well as seeing part of the first episode of the HBO series based on the book.
Of course "Game of Thrones" is just the first book in an ongoing series that was intended to be a trilogy, but has now grown into five published novels (each with more than 1,000 pages) and at least one more in the works. The series is known as "A Song of Ice and Fire" (hereafter referred to as "ASOIAF").
Reading ASOIAF I have been struck by some rather startling similarities between that and my own novel. Things like main characters having a connection with animal companions, or obsidian blades having special powers/uses. But those similarities are completely overshadowed by the differences.
ASOIAF is a bloated monstrosity of a story. It rambles from one viewpoint to the next seemingly at random. Characters live and die as if on the whim of the author. Gratuitous sexual encounters and foul language are so commonplace that even in the royal court obscene words are thrown around with wild abandon.
ASOIAF is a wildly successful series. It has received widespread critical acclaim, and has been nominated for numerous awards. Books from the series have topped the NY Times bestseller lists.
So why do I find it so laborious to read the books? I enjoyed the first book, but as the story has plodded (and I mean "plodded") along, I am finding it harder and harder to care about some of the story lines. I can't read more than a few pages without thinking about why the author chose to do this or that or some other thing. Each chapter ends with a breathless crisis, many times ending with a clear intention of the author to make the reader wonder if a character has been killed or not. The first couple of times he did that it was sort of interesting to wonder if the plunging knife had found a heart or was turned aside at the last instant by a shield or armor... But it has become old and tired, and I no longer really care about the outcome. He kills so many characters to so little purpose that any sense of urgency about a threat has been long lost. I understand that he wants to make the reader think that anything can happen to any character at any time, but all he's really done is teach me not to care about any character since I can't expect any character to survive any length of time.
Also his characters are described in all of the reviews I've read as "deeply complex characters" and I disagree entirely. Virtually all of his characters are mostly a caricature, and have ridiculously appropros names to boot. In his efforts to distinguish characters one from another he has them repeat actions or words to the point of absurdity. "You know nothing Jon Snow." I swear, I was GLAD when Ygritte died so I didn't have to read that ten more times per page. It's like he thinks rote repetition of actions or dialog is the only way to distinguish a character.
I do think he does an excellent job with "names" that are given to characters against their will. The Imp, Kingslayer, Hound, Littlefinger, etc. I really like that. He also does a credible job of building a "palace intrigue" backstory, although not nearly so well as Frank Herbert in "Dune." The rapidity which major characters reassign their alliances is unrealistic, imho, but entertaining.
What really interests (and concerns) me is that his approach to writing seems to be competely counter to my own approach. And he writes a bestseller which get great critical reviews. Where he is verbose, I try to be concise. Where he is profane, I try to be subtle. Where he is arbitrary, I try to be logical. Where he is in the reader's face, I try to stay behind the curtain. All in all my whole approach seems to be counter to his. And yet our stories have surprising similarities.
It makes me wonder if my writing style has any market at all.
When I started college at La Tech university in the autumn of 1977, just a month or so following the unexpected death of Elvis Presley, I picked "Biomedical Engineering" as my major. That lasted only as long as our first class video of a knee replacement operation, whereupon I immediately switched my major to "Physics" and am still glad I did. I am a physics snob, I freely admit it. Physics is the ultimate science. Pretty much every other branch of science can trace its roots to physics, and virtually every scientific theory or law was put forth from a physics standpoint, with the bulk of them having been proposed originally by physicists.
One of the reasons physics was such a good curriculum is that physics labs were jam-packed with wonderful toys, but there were very few actual physics students who used them. Consequently the few physics students in our school had virtual unfettered access to a wide range of scientific gadgetry.
Like lasers.
My second college roommate was also a physics student, or else was in one of the other hard sciences that had a bunch of physics requirements. His name was Victor. He was pretty much the prototypical science nerd, including the white shirts with plastic pocket protectors, belt-holstered slide rule and plastic dark-rimmed glasses. He was the first person I ever met who owned their own computer, in this case it was either a kit computer or else it was an Apple I. I don't recall, I only recall that programming it required a mind-numbing process of "peeking" and "poking" page after page of hexidecimal values into the computer's memory. We programmed a lunar landing simulator on that computer. As I recall it took us weeks before we finally got it right.
Our room frequently had some bit of equipment from the physics lab. Typical items you might find in our dorm room would have been triple beam balance scales, prisms, diffraction gratings, microscopes, circuit breadboards, high-precision calipers, gauges, vernier devices, multi-meters (volt, ohm, current), even an oscilloscope on occasion..
One of our favorite pastimes was to use the oscilloscope and multi-meter to investigate random integrated circuits that some previous physics lab instructor had inexplicably collected and stored in an anti-magnetic bag. Some of them we could find specs for, but this was years before the internet, so many of them were pure mystery and we'd try to figure out what they did. Back then integrated circuits didn't do a whole lot, a typical IC might do nothing but amplify a signal, or do electronically controlled AND, NAND, OR and NOR gates. Many were just electronically controlled switches. Our crowning achievement was when we figured out that one mysterious chip was basically a periodic signal generator. We even managed to connect it up to a paleolithic LED display circuit and created an actual clock.
Yeah, fun times....
But without a doubt, the crowning achievement of our equipment appropriation was the laser. It wasn't a high power laser, it was a very low power laser that would be comparable to the laser pointers you can get today in the checkout lane at Walmart, but back then lasers weren't something that every kid had on their keychain.
As it happens, at right about that same time, a traveling troupe of college entertainers gave a "concert" for the school. Their concert essentially boiled down to playing a bunch of music while projecting their visual interpretation of the music on a screen. They were particularly fond of Pink Floyd. At some point they claimed they had integrated a laser into the audio circuitry and that the music they were playing would stimulate the laser to generate random effects on the screen. So then they played some classical music and the laser beam danced a drunken pattern across the screen creating a jumbled mess. Then they played some modern Rock and Roll, and lo and behold! The random patterns suddenly coalesced into highly symmetrical complex patterns. The crowd of young college students loved it. Of course Victor and I smelled a rat, and we thought we recognized some of the patterns as being a sort of signal kaleidoscope effect that you could generate by reflecting a signal across multiple axes. In other words, it looked like all they were doing was sticking a series of half-silvered mirrors into the laser beam which created the wonderful symmetry.
But that wasn't what intrigued us. What intrigued us was the notion of using a laser to interpret an audio signal.
In the end we decided that one way to cause music to create a visual signal was to bounce a laser off of a speaker. So we bought a couple el cheapo speakers at Radio Shack, or else liberated them from some no longer functioning radio or tape player. As it happened, at that time my summer job was as an apprentice glazer, and one thing glazers know how to do is cut glass. So I cut a long thin strip of glass from a mirror and then cut tiny little mirror rectangles from the mirror, each one roughly half the size of a grain of rice. Then we glued one of the tiny squares to the speaker's diaphragm. Then we plugged the speaker into a casette deck tape player, aligned the laser beam on the mirror so that it reflected onto one of the blank walls of the dorm room, and turned it on.
To call the results disappointing would be rather an understatement. Basically we got the laser to move, but the amplitude of the resulting laser beam perturbation was so tiny that even with it being reflected across the room, it was still almost unnoticeable.
Now, if it had been an electronic signal, we could have just used one of our ICs to amplify the signal, but we were dealing with actual noise in a crowded dorm room in a period of American history when people actually still cared if their music was disruptive to their neighbors. So increasing the volume wasn't an option.
So we went to the library and did some research on speakers. We discovered to our surprise that the actual physical movement of speaker diaphragms was quite small except on one axis. Plus the power of the resulting sound was due to the movement of the entire speaker diaphragm, not the tiny area we had glued the mirror to. In other words, the mirror was only reacting to a tiny fraction of the energy the speaker was dishing out.
So we went back to the drawing board and tried to figure out a way to exploit the full power of the speaker and increase the amplitude of the signal. According to the books on speakers, the amplitude of the speaker diaphragm's movement was inversely proportional to its tensile strength. In other words, the less "stretchy" the material was, the less the material would move. This is considered desirable in speakers because sound (or signal) distortion was directly proportional to speaker diaphragm stretch. So to get the sort of signal we wanted would require a much more flexible diaphragm material and the resulting sound would be somewhat distorted.
But we didn't know how to build speakers from scratch. Oh, we understood the THEORY of speaker design, that was physics, but the actual IMPLEMENTATION of a speaker was beyond our skills, that was engineering. Nevertheless we sacrificed a noble speaker volunteer and attempted to replace the stiff paper diaphragm with a much more flexible rubber diaphragm, made from a cut up balloon. To call the results a "dismal failure" would be too kind.
So there we were, defeated by the need to construct a speaker, or at least modify a speaker. But as I sat there with the bit of balloon rubber in my hand, and a disassembled speaker on the desk, I had a brainstorm...
We didn't NEED for the mirror's diaphragm to be driven by electronic signals. We just needed it to react to the music. And we didn't need to amplify the signal, we just needed to use a material which deformed much more readily than the hard speaker diaphragms did.
So I simply stretched the balloon rubber over the front of one of our remaining speakers and turned the sound on.
Remarkably, you could actually SEE the balloon rubber deform. So I glued another mirror shard to the balloon rubber, aligned the laser beam, turned off the lights and SHAZAM! It worked! In fact it was giving us virtually the same sort of patterns the traveling show claimed to get out of classical or big band music. No matter what we played the end result was a gyrating, pulsating mass of laser squiggles on the wall. The louder the music, the larger the pulsating mass was. By putting a beam splitter just in front of the speaker we were able to create a one-axis symmetry, but that was all we could do, and the result split the laser so that you got an identical display on opposite walls.
At just about that moment, one of our dorm neighbors came into the room. Now remember, our room was dark and we were playing some raucus rock and roll music, probably AC/DC or something like that, and this light was dancing all over two walls.
"Far out! A DISCO!"
So for a short while, until the novelty wore off, we were in the DJ business. During that period we discovered the wonders of silver and gold mylar and bought some mylar helium balloons. We would tape light objects to the helium balloons until they were neutrally buoyant and then turn off all the lights, crank up some "Peaceful Easy Feeling" and lay in our beds watching the light show and every now and then the mylar balloon would drift across the laser beam's path and would be reflected all over the room until the balloon sailed back out.
Physics nerds.... what can I say?
So as I was sweating in my hotel room last night, in spite of the blasting air conditioner, the Cosmic Wife said they were predicting snow at our elevation and above.
Snow isn't unlikely, we typically get our first snow around mid to late September. But sitting here in the 90 degree 95% humidity of Atlanta, it's hard to visualize snow falling...
I know I'm a pretty strange person. But how strange I am is sometimes only revealed even to me when my brain takes a hard, sharp turn out of normal life for no discernable reason...
That's what happened today. Or really, it started last night.
I just got fed up with my office/hobby room. Over time it had acquired so much junk that it was simply bursting at the seams. My compulsive pursuit of newborn interests tends to act like a giant junk magnet, and I just pull stuff into the room by the bucket load, but nothing ever goes out. This tends to continue until I start having visions of the TV crew from "Hoarders" showing up.
So for the past day I've been boxing up junk and hauling it out of my room, probably to end up in a storage unit as we start seriously trying to sell our house next spring. Here are the things I've been dragging out of my room...
Old computers. Old hardware. Old electronic equipment. I had two shoe boxes full of old floppy disks. I don't even have a SINGLE computer in the house anymore (and I've got something like a dozen computers here) that can read a floppy disk anymore. A dot matrix printer. My Apple Newton. My original Macintosh (OK, I correct myself, I DO have a single computer that can still read floppy disks, but it can ONLY read floppy disks...). Games by the dozens. Sometimes multiple copies of the same games. When and where did I get a Pokemon version of Monopoly? And why do I have two identical boxes of Scrabble?
I've got three huge boxes waiting to go into the garage now (I can't put them in the garage because the Cosmic Wife had a similar urge to clean out the garage, so I can't put anything in the garage, including the car, until we get the garage all cleaned out.) They are jam-packed full of stuff that I still think is too important to throw away or try to dump on some unsuspecting school or church. And my room is still full of crap!
Model airplanes, calendars, jigsaw puzzles, entire collections of magazines (Papier, the Origami magazine, Sky and Telescope, Outdoor Photography...) a veritable library of programming books (Linux, C#, HTML, XML, XSLT, Java, Java, Java, C, C++, hell I've even got a PASCAL programming book in here!) I have an entire shelf full of D&D gaming books going back to the old version 1 of the game. Not to mention four or five notebooks full of old campaign notes, maps and NPC sheets...
I've got three boxes of LEGOS! One is a huge box that I bought for a work team building exercise years ago. Radios, watches, iPods (yes IPodS, plural. An original 40G model that still has a hard drive, and two versions of Nanos), iPod accessories, photographs, cameras, telescopeS (again, yes, plural, I have three telescopes just in THIS ROOM, I have two more in the walk in bedroom closet..)
Paints, clay, foam poster board, foam sheets, bags of rocks (yes, I have three different bags of rocks in the room... two are for making terrain for my gaming, and one is a bunch of flint and obsidian that I have been using to make arrow and spear heads as well as one sweeeet piece of obsidian that I am determined one day to turn into a knife blade).
Oh, did I mention my guitars? Three of those in the room.... oops, no, I can't count. Four. I have another one downstairs.... And music books, amplifier RCA jacks and cords, music stand, guitar cases, tuners, metronomes...
Two entire shelfs full of cartoon books, Calvin & Hobbes (eight books, plus the still shrink-wrapped collectors full set of strips), Peanuts, BC, Pogo, Bloom County, Tumbleweeds, Doonesbury... heck I've got over a dozen Doonesbury books alone...
Then there's all the tools. Why I have an entire set of socket wrenches, two hammers, a rechargable drill, allen wrenches... At least I KNOW why I have the Dremmel tool, that's for working on my miniatures....
Oh, did I say miniatures? I'm not even going to bore you with the extent of my miniatures that are overflowing the room...
I've been at it all day and I'm still not seeing daylight. I just uncovered a bunch of old papers including a bunch of report cards going back to third grade, the entire set of paperwork for my Close-Up trip to Washington back in 1977, every article I ever got published, two games I created and tried to market, and the rules for three more I never did market, a box of old letters from ex-girlfriends...
This room is like some sort of bizarre archaeological dig of my life. It's downright frightening....
Oh well, I have to get back to it. I've got three boxes and a couple bags of old origami to figure out what to do with....
So... I admit it. I, with my 305 page first draft of a novel, which I have edited and rewritten and tweaked, yes, I thought my work was likely the most complete and most compelling of the writing that we would encounter in the novel writing workshop.
But the third sample arrived from another group member last night, and I just finished reading it.
It. Is. Awesome. It reads like a warped cyberpunk version of Kurt Vonnegut on acid. It is a wild ride through a world far more alien and bizarre than mine. It's sixteen pages that shock, amuse, alarm and engage you. I hesitate to say it, but it stinks of genius.
I am truly humbled.
MR: Red Lemonade allows people to view free of charge complete manuscripts of books you have for sale. You’ve mentioned that having access to the full text online will help readers make up their minds and commit to buying a hard copy. This view differs from a general reluctance of publishers to post complete works online.
RN: Exactly. With the vast majority of books, the problem that most people have is they don’t know whether it’s going to be worth their time to read it. There are a tiny handful of books, in the case of each person, where they can be sure they want to read them. The reality is that I don’t think, in fact, there are a huge number of people reading our books for free online that have made a decision about whether to buy it. I mean there is probably a small number that are doing it for that reason and that number may increase, but I believe the number is smaller than has occurred to people because publishers refuse to do it. But what we’ve very clearly demonstrated by putting it for free online is that reading the book online has absolutely no negative impact on sales. Why in fact would it?
I'm not sure if I have previously posted that I am taking an 8 week novel writing workshop. I'm too lazy to look back to see. We have just finished week 3.
Part of the workshop (the biggest part, apparently) is having each writer submit a 15 page sample of their work which the rest of the group then reads and comments upon. I volunteered to go first, so last night we had our first critique session and chapters 1-3 of "Warrior" were up for critique from a group of ten folks I barely know and have only interacted with in the workshop.
The rules of engagement for the critique session are that the writer is not allowed to respond to any comment or even to talk at all until all of the critiques are finished. So you have to sit there on the hot seat taking notes while the results of pouring your heart onto pages are examined and analyzed from ten different perspectives. Really an uncomfortable and exposed situation to be in. There's no place to hide and since you can't rebut, you have to just accept the criticism and move on to let the next person critique.
To summarize the results, here are the things that were identified as problems by more than one of the group:
1. Not enough detail in my descriptions of the environment. This led to readers not being sure they were picturing events accurately.
2. Colloquialism and casual sentence structure in dialog. Some felt this was too "modern" and detracted from the stone age pre-industrial culture.
3. Not enough detail in describing my characters, and too many characters being introduced too early and at once. This coupled with the unusual names left readers confused about roles and relationships.
4. Some minor technical criticisms about specific sentence structure habits that editors don't like.
5. Lack of clarity around the obvious conflict between the protagonist and his older brother, exascerbated by the lack of clarity on the age of the two.
On the positive side, everyone said they enjoyed the read and wanted to read more. I'm sure some were just being nice, but some seemed very sincere about that. I figure that's got to be good.
The class instructor/facilitator does not provide his feedback in class. He dissects your writing in an email and sends it to you privately. I received his late last night (which kept me up later than I should have). His critiques were very specific about structural things, points of view, voice and story.
I came away from the experience more positively motivated than I thought I would. Everyone had specific parts of the story that they really liked, and some of the comments were dowright embarrassing they were so complimentary. Almost every criticism and suggestion for improvement was already on my list of fixes for the rewrite, so that made me feel like I had a fairly good sense of my own work and its weaknesses. That's very encouraging to me since it gives me some confidence that I am somewhat effective at identifying weaknesses in my own work.
The one thing that surprised me were comments about the casual, colloquial nature of the dialog. Some found that to be too "modern" and felt that it broke the spell of the story. I did it deliberately though because I felt like the more stilted, older style of speech was like hitting a literary speed bump every time someone said "I can not do this." or "You will need to do that." Instead of "I can't do this" or "You'll need to do that." The characters don't speak English so I don't see any reason I should translate their fictional language into archaic speech in English. I want the dialog to flow and I want the reader to be engaged in the story and I still feel that the stilted, formal approach just jars the reader.
But I am going to think about it...
Bottom line is I've got a ton of rewriting to do. A ton. Probably as much rewriting as I've done writing so far.