Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Reading & Writing

By CosmicConservative
So, as part of my ongoing novel writing class, we were assigned to write a certain number of pages each week (which I am well ahead of) and to read one book on writing novels (I'm about halfway through) and to read at least one book in the genre in which we are attempting to write our novel. So I picked "Game of Thrones" as the book I would read. I mostly picked it because I was curious about it having heard lots of good things about it, as well as seeing part of the first episode of the HBO series based on the book. Of course "Game of Thrones" is just the first book in an ongoing series that was intended to be a trilogy, but has now grown into five published novels (each with more than 1,000 pages) and at least one more in the works. The series is known as "A Song of Ice and Fire" (hereafter referred to as "ASOIAF"). Reading ASOIAF I have been struck by some rather startling similarities between that and my own novel. Things like main characters having a connection with animal companions, or obsidian blades having special powers/uses. But those similarities are completely overshadowed by the differences. ASOIAF is a bloated monstrosity of a story. It rambles from one viewpoint to the next seemingly at random. Characters live and die as if on the whim of the author. Gratuitous sexual encounters and foul language are so commonplace that even in the royal court obscene words are thrown around with wild abandon. ASOIAF is a wildly successful series. It has received widespread critical acclaim, and has been nominated for numerous awards. Books from the series have topped the NY Times bestseller lists. So why do I find it so laborious to read the books? I enjoyed the first book, but as the story has plodded (and I mean "plodded") along, I am finding it harder and harder to care about some of the story lines. I can't read more than a few pages without thinking about why the author chose to do this or that or some other thing. Each chapter ends with a breathless crisis, many times ending with a clear intention of the author to make the reader wonder if a character has been killed or not. The first couple of times he did that it was sort of interesting to wonder if the plunging knife had found a heart or was turned aside at the last instant by a shield or armor... But it has become old and tired, and I no longer really care about the outcome. He kills so many characters to so little purpose that any sense of urgency about a threat has been long lost. I understand that he wants to make the reader think that anything can happen to any character at any time, but all he's really done is teach me not to care about any character since I can't expect any character to survive any length of time. Also his characters are described in all of the reviews I've read as "deeply complex characters" and I disagree entirely. Virtually all of his characters are mostly a caricature, and have ridiculously appropros names to boot. In his efforts to distinguish characters one from another he has them repeat actions or words to the point of absurdity. "You know nothing Jon Snow." I swear, I was GLAD when Ygritte died so I didn't have to read that ten more times per page. It's like he thinks rote repetition of actions or dialog is the only way to distinguish a character. I do think he does an excellent job with "names" that are given to characters against their will. The Imp, Kingslayer, Hound, Littlefinger, etc. I really like that. He also does a credible job of building a "palace intrigue" backstory, although not nearly so well as Frank Herbert in "Dune." The rapidity which major characters reassign their alliances is unrealistic, imho, but entertaining. What really interests (and concerns) me is that his approach to writing seems to be competely counter to my own approach. And he writes a bestseller which get great critical reviews. Where he is verbose, I try to be concise. Where he is profane, I try to be subtle. Where he is arbitrary, I try to be logical. Where he is in the reader's face, I try to stay behind the curtain. All in all my whole approach seems to be counter to his. And yet our stories have surprising similarities. It makes me wonder if my writing style has any market at all.

Comments (7)

Dadman
Well, by my estimation a significant number of people these days talk too much (and think too little), and they are profane, arbitary, illogical, emotional, and confrontational. If they relate to people like themselves - in novels - you might have a problem. :) So, I'm kinda kidding around here, but I guess it is something worth thinking about...
CosmicConservative
I had my workshop last night and we reviewed two members' 15 page submissions. One was a young high school girl who was writing a story that seemed to be X-Men meets Twilight. It was entertaining, but it was very hard for me to follow the action or figure out the story's plot because she had immersed it so far into that genre that you really had to have familiarity with some of the common tropes and concepts of that genre to have a clue what was going on. The other submission was a story written by a guy about my age about a marriage that was falling apart, told from the alternating points of view of wife and husband. At one point he had the wife planning on an intimate evening having forgotten that it was her husband's poker night (heh... "poke 'er night...") and so she had to instead call a friend of hers over for company instead. This woman had, up until then, been characterized by an intense malaise about her life and her marriage, her internal dialog was all about how she wondered how she ended up where she was, but didn't really care. She wasn't sure she loved her husband, but didn't really dislike him either. But when her friend comes over she immediately breaks down and starts spilling her guts out to her friend with no provocation beyond a polite "How are you doing?" She reveals details of their intimate encounters (or lack of them) whines about how miserable she is, how she wanted to have it all, but ended up with nothing... blah blah blah... The whole conversation rang false to me. I just couldn't see this blase, barely engaged women suddenly falling to pieces and literally "blubbering" to her friend. So I said that I found that part of the dialog to be unrealistic. Every woman in the room disagreed with me violently. I came away thinking that I have been so socially deficient in my life that I can no longer even determine what constitutes the dynamics of a normal friendship. And yet still, I just don't see it. Do people really turn into slobbering, blubbering whiny babies at the slightest provocation? I mean the whole thing was supposedly precipitated by a missed opportunity for some intimacy when the previous text outright stated that such intimacy had long ago stopped being important to either of them. But as I said, the women loved that scene and found it so compelling.... I guess if I ever do get anything published, I won't have much of a following in the fairer sex...
Drax
Yeah. People do this. The blubbering bit may be a female thing, but, spilling guts? Oh, yeah. Routine.
JSullins
Cosmic, I have read the first 3 (or 4?) of the ASOIAF books before dumping them all in the trash. Besides being way too graphic, the author has gone too far towards character-based. It's basically a series about characters... which I guess works for some people. I think there are many successful styles out there, and people who like different things as well. I'm behind on my re-reads of your stuff, but I think your style when you're at your best will serve you well. Your first few chapters, I have always maintained, are your best. The middle and end of what I'd read previously were the weakest.. At any rate, don't despair. Do what you do best and don't weaken yourself by comparing your work to others'. Learn what you can, sure, but keep in mind those authors are different people with different gifts than yours. As for the women... I wonder how much of their violent disagreement with you was simply stemming from their desire to show support for a woman in such a situation. Perhaps they were letting their emotional biases cloud their ability to make objective critique. Then again, if the dialog works them... so be it... you never were thinking you were writing for the Oprah Winfrey audience anyway, right?
CosmicConservative
JSullins... I have a new rewrite of chapters 1-3 ready. I added a new set of scenes providing more context for the relationship between Lirak, Mayrie and Patrik, and I've tried to make the dreams Lirak has be more obviously a major plot point of the book. I'm on about Chapter 6 now in my rewrites. I think what you see in the first chapters you've read is that I have spent a lot more time on edits and rewrites of those chapters and I am just now getting into later chapters. Sometimes I think the rewrites are going to take longer than the first draft. I suppose I should send out another version of Chapters 1-3. I really do think they are pretty well done now, but who knows... I may never finish the dang book due to rewrite-itis....
JSullins
I've read quite a few author's notes that also cite continuous rewriting. I think you're probably on the right track :)
Jack
Hey everyone, I have news that is somewhat off-topic but at least it's in the area of creative endeavors (which is on-topic). I just wrapped principal photography yesterday on my latest feature film. It's a suspense thriller titled "Call Me On Tuesday". It stars Jason London (Dazed and Confused, Carrie 2: The Rage), Danielle Harris (multiple Halloween movies from both the original series and the reboot, The Last Boy Scout), Kevin Sorbo (Hercules, Andromeda), and Lochlyn Munro (Unforgiven, White Chicks, Scary Movie). It's listed on IMDb, so go check it out. I'm wiped out now so I'm going back to sleep. Seeya. Jack