Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hobbies

Perseid's this week

By CosmicConservative
Starting tomorrow night you have a better chance than normal to see shooting stars, for a few days anyway.

Every August, just when many people go vacationing in the country where skies are dark, the best-known meteor shower — the Perseid meteor shower — makes its appearance.

The "shooting stars" promise to deliver an excellent show this year to anyone with clear and dark skies away from urban and suburban lights.

The best time to watch for meteors will be from the late-night hours of Wednesday, Aug, 11 on through the predawn hours of Aug. 13 – two full nights and early mornings. Patient skywatchers with good conditions could see up to 60 shooting stars an hour or more. [Top 10 Perseid Meteor Shower Facts]

The Perseid's are the most famous of the yearly meteor showers. Like all other meteor showers, the Perseids are essentially the debris from a comet as it makes it's way around the sun. And yes, that means that the comet's orbit and the earth's orbit have a point where they are remarkably close.

World of Warcraft update: Ice Crown Citadel

By CosmicConservative
OK, so I've been easing off on WoW play lately. I have been doing my daily quests and trying to build reputation with the Kalu'ak to get that fancy epic fish pole (three more days...) but I've only been doing the weekly raid in Ice Crown 25 man and a few minor runs in Ice Crown 10 man lately. In part that's because I've upgraded all of my equipment except one trinket to the appropriate epic levels, and Rhlyssa is now able to handle any challenge the game has. Of course the problem is that I am not yet able to handle the Lich King myself, but that's not a problem with my character, that's a problem with me executing the tactics properly. Our main guild raid group still has not managed to down the Lich King. We've done all the other content in Ice Crown multiple times, some of them on "hard mode" even. But the Lich King is still proving to be too much for us to handle. I presume we'll be making another try at him after today's recycling of all the instances. This week I only accepted the invitation to the Wednesday raid since I have other plans for Thursday, and for that reason I may not even get invited to the Wednesday run (which is fair, if someone can make both days and I can't, they should get the invitation over me). I really would like to take down the Lich King before the Cataclysm reboot of WoW comes out. But I'm no longer obsessing on it. If it happens, it happens. My old guild didn't take down Kel Thezud until literally the day before the Ulduar content was released. It may be that history repeats itself here. It's getting harder and harder to get a good raid team together anyway since most of the top raiders are now more focused on getting ready for Cataclysm and aren't that interested in raiding right now. Raiding costs gold, while other activities build gold, so lots and lots of players are now focused on farming, crafting and speculating in the auction house than in raiding. The assumption is that when Cataclysm comes out players will need gold to purchase new equipment, so that's what folks are concentrating on. My own pursuit of gold is stalled in the 4,000 - 6,000 gold range, but that's mostly due to all the gems and enchantments I was buying as I continually upgraded my gear. Since I doubt I'll have much more gear to enchant for a while, I expect my gold will start to build again. I am pretty curious about Cataclysm. The rumor mill has it as a major revamping of the entire WoW universe, with no more "no fly" zones and lots of changes to the old Azeroth world. I'm looking forward to being able to fly anywhere, that has long been one of my major irritations with the game. In the meantime, I guess I'll keep on doing the dailies and trying to build gold for the Cataclysm release. If I happen to get into a good raid group and take down the Lich King, I'll let you all know.

Stargazing report... 7/24/10

By CosmicConservative
Well, this weekend was the first time in a long time that I got out the telescopes. A friend who owns a small Netwonian reflector wanted to get together since his son is showing an interest in astronomy. He has been having trouble getting his telescope's automated goto ability to work. So I was looking forward to helping him out, if I could. Instead I spent virtually the entire session trying to get my own goto to work. For some reason my SkySensor 2000 goto system would not do a two-point or three-point alignment. Two-point is minimal for visual observing and three-point is minimum for long-term tracking of objects (usually for photo taking purposes). But I was only able to get a two point alignment twice, once early during the session, before I realized that the telescope was set much too high and had to lower it, which meant having to realign it, and once at the very end of the session when the kids had already pooped out and were sleeping in their truck. So, I've never been unable to align my telescope like that before. It was quite frustrating. I would align on the moon, and then on Saturn, but it would only align on Saturn. I would align on Saturn, and then on Arcturus and it would align only on Arcturus. This went on for hours as I frantically attempted to complete a two-point alignment on a variety of stars including Mizar, Dubhe, Albireo and others. Then, when I finally did get an alignment, the full moon made it virtually impossible to see any deep sky objects. Oh well, we'll try again next new moon....

Today is Comic-Con day

By CosmicConservative
Why would anyone ever, ever want to go to Comic-Con? slaveleias I mean, what a bunch of goofy nerds, eh?

Strategy & Tactics

By CosmicConservative
In my last post I mentioned that I don't think most people have a clear understanding of the difference between "strategy" and "tactics". This comes up a lot when people play wargames of any complexity and players brag about or bemoan the ineffectiveness of their "strategy" in the last battle, and someone invariably will say "you mean 'tactics.'" Here are a couple of the most common definitions of "strategy"
  • The science and art of using all the forces of a nation to execute approved plans as effectively as possible during peace or war.
  • The science and art of military command as applied to the overall planning and conduct of large-scale combat operations.
... and here, from that same source are the most common definitions of "tactics":
  • The military science that deals with securing objectives set by strategy, especially the technique of deploying and directing troops, ships, and aircraft in effective maneuvers against an enemy
  • Maneuvers used against an enemy
Hmmm... other than the definition of "tactics" referencing the word "strategy" is there really that much difference between the two definitions? If you replace "strategy" with "military leader" in the defintion of "tactics" the result looks a whole lot like the definition of "strategy" above. So what is the difference? If you go back to the roots of the greek and/or latin words from which they are derived, "strategy" basically means "from the office of the general" where "tactics" basically means "arrangement or deployment of forces". In my mind it really boils down the the simple statement that "strategy" is the "what" and "tactics" is the "how". For example, in the Civil War General Grant had one overriding "what" that he was attempting to do, and that was to use the overwhelming industrial might and manpower advantage of the North to wear down the South. That meant that as a "strategy" even if Grant lost a battle, he could still be winning the war. That's perhaps the best example of how "strategy" and "tactics" are distinct. For most practical purposes if you are engaged in a real or imaginary wartime scenario you should be able to ask yourself "what are we trying to do" and completely separately ask yourself "how are we going to do it?" For example, let's say that you are the United States in WW II and you are contemplating your options. Let's say that you decide that you will divide and conquor the enemy, ignoring or simply stalling along one front (say the Pacific), while pressing the enemy on another front (say, Europe). That's a "strategy." That says nothing about how you intend to do it. The whole issue gets complicated because both strategy and tactics become heirarchical. In other words, once you have a strategy in place, execution of that strategy necessarily involves making lower level plans that also break down into "what" and "how." So when you say "Our strategy is to stall in the Pacific and Press the European front" and you give that to your military commanders, one group of them will focus entirely on Europe and come up with a lower level, more detailed "strategy" of their own. That "lower level strategy" might well be something like "we'll focus on the soft underbelly of Europe and take Italy out first." Again that's a "what" not a "how". And so on for ever lower levels of planning. Another way I've heard people describe the difference between the two is that "strategy = plan" and "tactics = execution." To me this is pretty close to the "what" and "how" I described above, but describing it that way might help some people determine the difference between the two. In our last weekend's D&D campaign, we needed to enter a highly defended compound and defeat a general inside the compound. The "strategy" we came up with was to try to use subterfuge to get as close as possible to a defending tower, and then to attack the tower from close distance using surprise, with the goal of putting our own forces on top of the tower to gain tactical advantage for any future combat. How we did that was that we disguised most of the group and pretended to have captured another group member who was a known enemy of the general inside the compound. Once we got close enough using the subterfuge, we employed some specific abilities and items to allow us to quickly engage the archers at the top of the tower as we simultaneously engaged in melee with the troops below. Our strategy was to use subterfuge to get close enough to allow us to use certain abilities that would not be useful from a distance, with the strategic goal of gaining the top of the tower for our own use. If we had simply chosen a strategy of charging the compound, by the time we would have engaged the troops on the ground, the archers in the tower would have been nailing us with arrows repeatedly. Taking the top of the tower allowed us to set up our own ranged attacks on any potential reinforcements. The strategy worked, but it was a close run thing because as all commanders know, it is a rare plan that survives contact with the enemy. Our first effort to gain access to the top of the tower ended up with my character being teleported off of the tower 60 feet above a tyrannosaur infested pit, where he was dropped unceremoniously. However, even that had the desired strategic objective of distracting the archers and the commander on the top of the tower long enough that our ground forces were able to push back the guards and our secondary force was able to reach the top of the tower without facing withering arrow fire. Sure my character almost died, but hey, that's how things go. Now we've got the top of the tower and the front of the tower secured and we'll need a new strategy for storming the interior of the tower, but the higher level overall strategy of taking the tower and putting our forces in a tactically advantageous position has already been successful. That will make it very difficult for the general to send in reinforcements to come to the aid of the trapped guards in the first tower. In the actual battle we used a variety of tactics, including using grappling hooks and ropes to scale the wall while the defenders at the top were engaged with my character, who had used a rare (and costly) magic teleporting arrow to immediately engage the archers and battle commander at the top of the tower to keep them from picking off the other party members using grappling hooks. Dunno if this helps, or if anyone wants to disagree, but that's how I see "strategy" vs. "tactics."

Prometheus, Satan and the death of reason

By CosmicConservative
I assume all of my readers are familiar with the story of Prometheus. In Greek mythology Prometheus was a Titan, one of the race which preceded the Gods of Olympus, but who survived the battle between Zeus and Cronos when Zeus and his siblings overthrew the Titans (as the Titans had overthrown Uranus before them). In Greek mythology Prometheus is the divine being who was variously credited with teaching humans to use fire, to slaughter animals and keep the good meat (as opposed to sacrificing it to Zeus) and in some cases, teaching humans the very foundations of civilization. In reward for his efforts, Zeus chained Prometheus to a rock and had an eagle eat his liver every day, while it grew back overnight. That Zeus, what a kidder. The allegorical message behind the Prometheus myth was that humans received the blessings of civilization as a divine gift, and you can trace that concept all the way through to the Declaration of Independence if you really want to. Prometheus means something like "forethought" and as a concept the name probably most closely means "reasoned thought" or something like that. That's not coincidental. Prometheus essentially is credited in Greek mythology as the being who taught humans how to be human. Now, I am probably not the first to point out the striking similarities between Prometheus and Satan (Lucifer). Both were supremely powerful divine beings, Prometheus a Titan and Lucifer the most powerful arch-angel. "Lucifer" means "light-bearer" or "light-bringer" and the name has elements of fire associated with it. Both Lucifer and Prometheus defied the supreme God of their respective mythologies to give humans their first taste of "knowledge." Both first taught humans how to (or how to try to) deceive that supreme God. Both were punished for eternity for their sins. It has always been interesting to me that eating from the "tree of knowledge" was the "original sin" of Christian myth. In Greek myth that same event, delivered by Prometheus instead of Lucifer, was not considered to be a human sin, far from it, it was considered a key event in the growth and development of humankind. Why do I bring all this up? Well, lots of events of the past year or so have been used by Leftist moonbats to argue that the earth has grown tired of human arrogance and is out to teach us a lesson. Millions of words of drivel have been published by our major media outlets and spewed out on radio and television about how "mother earth" is striking back at us "arrogant" humans for our sins of burning carbon. In it's most pure and essential form, the belief of these anti-human moonbats that "carbon" is an evil source of power is an absolute and direct repudiation of the use of fire itself. burning gas in your car engine is no different chemically and environmentally from burning a log in your fireplace, or in your cave to keep warm and to keep the beasts of night at bay. When people decry the use of carbon fuels, they are effectively calling human civilization itself a "sin." That's because there would be no human civilization without fire. Fire, in its various forms, is the unique and critical source of civilization. When modern pseudo-intellectual moonbats talk about how earth is "fighting back" at humans for their arrogance, they are quite literally no different in any significant regard than the villagers who see a volcano and assume that the gods are displeased with the village. There is no substantive difference between Daniel Glover calling the Haiti earthquake a payback from mother earth for global warming and the seashell and feather decorated village shaman telling the village chief that the earthquake was caused by inadequate sacrifice from the village foodstores. But there is a more fundamental and disheartening aspect of this anti-civilization perspective. Because at root, that's what it is. These people are striking a blow against the very foundation of civilization itself. They are quite literally saying that human beings would be better off without fire, so that our use of fire did not anger the spirits of the earth who are displeased when human beings display such arrogance. In fact, these people aren't much different in principle than the hard-core fundamentalists of any religious stripe who argue that humans are too arrogant and need to be taken down a peg by their favorite sky-father. In the end what this means is that for these people, Prometheus literally IS Satan. The "gift" of fire given to humans, as well as the gift of "forethought" or reason itself, is the most deadly of all sins because it has allowed humans to become too powerful and too populous for the good of the planet. It's amazing to me that people can express these sorts of views without realizing just how atavistic and anti-rational they are. I can accept the argument from some people that we need to carefully examine our use of energy and the growth of our species. I can accept that human civilization has had a demonstrable impact on the earth, and that from a purely naturalistic perspective, that impact has been detrimental to the "natural world" as we know it. However, I don't take a purely naturalistic perspective. Unlike most Lefty moonbats, I don't accept the notion that the earth was a pure and pristine magical wonderland before human beings arrived on the scene. I don't accept the notion that every single species on the earth is a special and unique specimen that must be preserved at all costs. I take a different perspective. And that perspective is that human beings are the literal best hope for earth to have a chance to spread it's gift of life throughout the universe. No matter what human beings do on this planet, eventually the earth will be a lifeless ball of molten rock, spiraling down into the broiling surface of a red giant star. And that's if an asteroid, or a nearby supernova or any of a dozen other natural events don't wipe us out first. Super volcanoes, Pole shifts, orbital anomolies, comets, gamma ray bursts.... whatever your particular brand of poison, eventually something is going to destroy this earth. And if Al Gore and his ilk have their way, when that happens, all of earth's past, present and future will die and be forgotten. At this point in time only mankind has the potential to spread earthly life beyond this planet, and produce a civilization that can survive a solar flare, or a random passing black hole. Al Gore and his ilk believe they are protecting the earth, instead what they are doing is making earth a cage instead of a cradle. Prometheus gave humans the key to leave the cradle. And I'm dead sick of those brain-dead Leftist moonbats who are hell-bent on taking that key and throwing it away in a misguided attempt to placate some sort of supernatural force which only they can see. Carbon is that key. Prometheus was right.

21st century comic book females

By CosmicConservative
Just a few images I found on a google search of "comic book females" just to give an idea of what comic books are like these days. power-girl-4 powergirl MarvelGirls Supergirl

Blood of the Lich King!

By CosmicConservative
So, as I've chronicled here, for the past month or so I've been back on World of Warcraft after about an 8 month hiatus. I left my old guild and joined a new one because my old guild was really more of a clique with the "insiders" doing all the raids and the "newbies" being left to fend for themselves. The guild leader refused to invite new members to the top raids unless they had passed a "raid test" but he would not respond to requests to set up such a test. Eventually about a third of the active guild members quit the guild and went to start a new one. I did not move to the new guild, instead I was invited to join a more established raiding guild. Within a week of joining the new guild I had been tested and then invited to join the core group of raiders, and I've been raiding ever since. Right now (unless the Ruby Sanctum is active now) the most difficult task in the game is to defeat the Lich King himself. To do so your raid group has to storm his citadel and defeat a dozen increasingly difficult encounters. The raid group I'm with as of last week had defeated every encounter except the final two, "Sindragosa" and "The Lich King". These are both extremely difficult fights. There still aren't very many WoW players who have completed those raids, some six months after they were introduced. Our guild, which is a serious raiding guild, has only about half a dozen members who have completed all of the encounters. So, last night we defeated Sindragosa. That leaves only the Lich King. We defeated Sindragosa relatively easily, so we had plenty of time to tackle Arthus (the Lich King himself). The Lich King encounter is not terribly difficult to understand. I had watched a video of it on Youtube and had read through a couple of combat guides, so I more or less knew what to expect. But knowing what to expect and actually executing it are two different things. A 25 man raid with a major boss and several flunkies, minions and lieutenants is a lot to keep track of. There are four stages to the fight (although some guides break it up differently):
  1. The initial attack of the Lich King.
  2. The retreat of the Lich King leading to his casting of "Quake".
  3. The battle with the Valkyries and the "Defile" spell.
  4. The final showdown.
Each of these require separate strategies. For the intial attack of the Lich King the party has to survive the massive damage the Lich King does with his legendary sword. To do so means the party's tank (or tanks) have to engage him first since a single blow will kill anyone but a tank. Once the main tank has engaged the Lich King, he alternately attacks the tank and summons minions to aid him. The minions have to be picked up by the the "off tank" or they will rip the party apart. For the moment the off tank simply has to be able to absorb the damage (meaning the healers have to be able to heal both tanks simultaneously while each is taking heavy, heavy damage). As this is going on Arthus casts spells on random party members which spread damage around them. The afflicted party member has to immediately run out of the group and get to the off tank so that the effect can be dispelled. Then they can return to the melee. This goes on until Arthus is reduced to 70% of his hit points. Once he is at 70% Arthus abandons the direct attack and rushes to the middle of a huge platform and begins casting powerful ranged attack spells. In this second stage, he also summons a large number of minions that engage the party directly. While this is going on the party also has to deal with slow-moving orbs which immediatly kill anyone they touch, so they have to be destroyed by ranged attacks. Usually there are three or four such orbs coming at the party simultaneously. This phase of the fight is a matter of mowing down the minions before the Lich King casts "Quake" which destroys the outer portion of the platform, sending any unwary raid members to their deaths. (I managed to get to the inner platform in every battle at least.) Once Quake is cast all raid members have to rush to the middle of the platform for the third and most difficult stage of the fight, and re-engage Arthus. Of course any remaining minions also have to be dispatched. At this time Arthus summons his most powerful defenders, flying Valkyries who grab random raid members and dump them over the edge of the platform to their doom. While carrying a raid member, the Valkyries can't fly out of range of melee though, so the raid party has a chance to kill them before they lose a raid member. So the raid leader assigns groups individual valkyrie to kill. It is amazingly difficult to pick one target out of a milling melee of some 30 members while dealing with spell effects which obscure your vision. And as if that isn't difficult enough, Arthus casts his most deadly and powerful spell, "Defile" which targets a random raid member who has 1.4 seconds (yes, you read that right, 1.4 seconds) to get out of range of the rest of the raid before a black circle spreads out from their feet. Any raid member within the black circle causes the circle to expand further. So as soon as the circle drops, the afflicted raid member has to run out of the circle, while the circle is expanding because he/she is inside it. If the circle touches any other raid member, it grows faster. If more than a few raid members are touched, the circle quickly engulfs the entire platform, wiping the raid. We never made it to the final stage, in every fight the Defile enchantment caused a raid wipe. That is by far the most difficult spell effect I've had to deal with. Even though Rhlyssa herself (my character) never was defiled, she found herself caught in the rapidly expanding black circle several times. Those times that she avoided the circle, she somehow became the target of Arthus's attention and was one-shot into oblivion by the Lich King. We will try tonight again. The videos and strategy guide all say that if you can get through the third stage of the fight with most of the party intact, the final stage is a fairly simple melee beat down where you simply have to put Arthus down before his enrage timer goes off. We came close twice to reaching that final stage. But that defile effect is unbelievabely nasty. It would be very nice to complete this final raid, then I could again say that Rhlyssa has successfully performed the most difficult task in the game. At least until the Ruby Sanctum content is released... There are rumors that it has already been released, but nobody in our guild has seen that and it's not showing up in our raid menus, so I don't think it has yet. One final comment, throughout the entire time that the "Wrath of the Lich King" content has been released, WoW characters have had to deal with quests, dungeons and raids where you encounter the Lich King but are unable to attack him. I know it's only a game, and I know that we got our butts kicked, but I have to say there is a fairly nice sense of accomplishment and satisfaction just to get my daggers into his pasty, undead flesh.

Online gaming, Player vs. Player ruminations...

By CosmicConservative
In my last post Drax and I got into a bit of back-and-forth over Player vs. Player (PvP) styles. He used to be a major player in Ultima Online (UO) and I've done a fair bit of PvP (in the past, not lately) on World of Warcraft (WoW). PvP play is considered by some to be the only real challenging and rewarding online play. As Drax put it in the other post, "everything else is just farming." ("Farming" is the process in a MMORPG of gaining items that can be used to make things or to sell for gold.) I disagree with that because I think defeating the game's bosses is plenty challenging and rewarding and requires significant amounts of coordination and cooperation with other players, which is pretty good practice for real life getting along with people. If you are a jerk in a raid, you frequently won't be invited back. The skills required for succeeding in raiding are not limited to the mastery of your character's abilities, you have to master real life skills in negotiation, socialization, communication, cooperation and fair play. A good raid team is very much like a team in any sport, people know their roles, they know the rules of engagement and they have practiced and studied their role extensively so that they perform at their best. For the most part all of these are valuable real life skills and I believe raiding promotes socialization and cooperation, skills a lot of people lack in the modern world. The fundamental concept of PvP is that one or more human players are pitted against one or more other human players in competition. That's why it's called "PvP." ("PvE" by the way, means "Player versus Environment" and indicates a situation where the player is competing against the game itself.) Now the first thing I want to make clear is that I greatly prefer human vs. human competition to human vs. machine competition, so my initial and preferred bias in playing games is to do PvP. So far my favorite PvP situation I've ever played was in "Janes WWII Fighters" a combat WWII fighter simulation where players could dogfight other players over the internet. The graphics were incredible and the experience of dogfighting was so realistic that the Air Force uses these sorts of simulations in their training today. Whether this is a character flaw or not, I have to admit that defeating another human being has an entirely different visceral feel to it than simply defeating the computer. Early on, even before playing Jane's WWII fighters, I used to fly on a local network using the Macintosh flight simulator "Falcon" against one of my co-workers, named Jeff. Jeff had completely mastered the game and had all the awards and medals possible, so he clearly knew how to fly his virtual falcon and according to the computer itself, he was a master ace. I never came close to mastering the game to that level and had only a handful of medals and awards. But whenever we flew against each other, I won more than I lost in one-on-one combat against Jeff. There are two reasons for that. The first is that I simply get more energized and excited about human vs. human competition, so I raise my game. The second is that human beings can only know what they process and can only process what they see and hear in the context of what they are expecting. The computer knows everything about the game all the time, because it IS the game. That means that I was able to do things that I knew would mess Jeff up, but which the computer would simply process and file away. For example, in one of our big head-to-head battles with several co-workers observing (this was when I worked for a software development company, so this qualified as "research" ;) ) I added a couple of air to ground missiles to my Falcon along with my six air to air missiles. Usually you don't carry air to ground missiles if you are going to dogfight because they don't do any good in a fight and they marginally decrease your Falcon's performance. So no virtual "top gun" wannabe would carry air to ground weapons because they don't add anything to your offensive capabilities and they detract from your airplane's aerodynamic performance. But what I knew from playing the game is that launching an air to ground missile looks and sounds to another player almost exactly the same as an air to air missile launch. So by carrying two air to ground missiles, I had two decoys that I could use to fool Jeff into thinking I was out of missiles when I wasn't. The idea was that I could sucker him in close where I could lock missiles on him after he thought I was out of missiles. And it worked perfectly. During the fight I fired off four sidewinders, which he managed to evade, while I also evaded several of his missiles. But during the fight I had launched two maverick missiles (air to ground) and after I fired my fourth sidewinder, Jeff relaxed, thinking I only had guns left, and got sloppy. So I was able to get a lock on him fairly easily and blew him out of the sky. That would never have worked against the computer because the computer "knows" the difference between a sidewinder and a maverick launch, while a human would have to be paying very close attention to have any hope of identifying the difference in the middle of dogfighting. I love that sort of thing. I loved the look of incredulity on his face when I launched that fatal missile. "What? How? .. Where?...." He was convinced I had hacked the game to allow me to carry more sidewinders. That's what I love about PvP, the ability to match wits and skills against an opponent. In MMORPGs though, PvP is something entirely different. In those games you don't log in just to do combat and then log off, a MMORPG is defined by the persistence of an individual character as that character advances from level to level and acquires goods, skills and abilities. So even the discussion of what "PvP" is or should be is eventually a philosophical discussion. As was clear in the previous post, UO and WoW have implemented PvP almost entirely at the separate ends of the MMORPG PvP spectrum. UO has an almost anything goes approach while WoW has a far more restrictive and arbitrary approach. And I don't like either of them. In fact I have never payed a MMORPG where I thought the PvP was done properly. Games which take the UO approach inevitably become dominated by hardcore players who exploit the weaknesses of casual gamers. This tends to drive casual gamers away and greatly reduces the ability of the game system to grow and expand. That's because nobody appreciates working their virtual butts off for a powerful scroll or item, only to have another player steal it or kill them and loot it. This violates many people's sense of fairness, plus it seriously angers people. Games which take the WoW approach go to such great lengths to protect their casual players from predation by hard-core gamers that they end up feeling restrictive and arbitrary. You can fight another player but only in very ritualistic ways. And nobody can steal your stuff out of your backpack, nor can they loot your body when you die. Casual gamers love this because it means they can move more or less freely through the world without fear of roving bands of rapacious players opportunistically looking to cash in on the casual gamer's hard work. I would prefer a third paradigm for PvP, one that is neither arbitrarily constrained, nor one which promotes anti-social greedy behavior which drives paying customers to other game systems. Let's just look at a very simple example of player vs player interaction. Can I pickpocket that other player? If so, what are the consequences of doing so? One of the things I really don't like about WoW is that your PvP interaction is entirely dependent on your location. What you can do just fine in one place is completely impossible to attempt somewhere else. What can be done against one player can not be done against another. Etc... If we want to introduce the abiltiy to pickpocket, then there should be no limitations to when or where the player should be allowed to attempt it. If my character has the skill, he should be able to use that skill against friend and foe alike. But if we allow that, we have to deal with the consequences of getting caught. This is where things get sticky. If I'm caught stealing from someone from an opposing faction, that's no big deal, it probably just becomes a PvP fight. But if I'm caught stealing from a party member or a guild member, that has some interesting ramifications. What if I steal from a friendly NPC? Do I immediately become an enemy of that NPC's faction? What impact would pickpocketing have on my character's reputation? What if some of my abilties, skills or items are dependent upon reputation do I lose those abilities, skills or items immediately? What if I try to pickpocket something that is too high a level for me to use? What if I get away with it entirely? Is that a good thing (demonstration of a critical skill or ability) or a bad thing (stealing from allies isn't usually seen as a positive trait.) In the world of "soulbound" items, which are items a character cannot sell or give to another player, are soulbound items off limits? Or can I pickpocket them but not be able to use them? If so, what's the point of pickpocketing then? Should pickpocketing have level limitations? For example should a level 10 character find it more difficult to pickpocket a level 80 character than a level 5 character? If so then that implies that a level 80 pickpocket could pretty much pickpocket low level players with impunity. And if that's possible, some will do so simply because they can, even if the result of the pickpocketing rarely provides anything of value to the level 80 character. Many players would simply revel in the realization that they've made life harder for some low level player even if they couldn't do anything with what they pickpocketed themselves. That's just how people are. In the real world all of this is tied to our criminal system. Punishment is meted out by the state, generally, and according to specific laws. Society is patrolled and overseen by government agencies ranging from the Special Services to the local Police. Crimes are reported, warrants are obtained, searches are performed and trials are held. I don't think the vast majority of players want IronForge and StormWind (cities in WoW) to become havens for lawyers. So it is unlikely that we could deal with such infractions on fair play in game through any sort of civil procedure. So what do we do with our pickpocket who has been caught picking the pocket of a party member or a guild officer? Let's say we are in a raid and a phat lewt dagger drops, which is won by the hunter, but which the rogue beleives should have been awarded to him. So the rogue pickpockets the item at the first opportunity, and is caught red-handed by the hunter. What happens next? And how does the hunter prove that the rogue attempted to pick-pocket him in the first place? Does this open the door to people abusing the system by accusing others of things they didn't do? So even something as simple as pickpocket seems to have an unending tangled web of consequences that lead to all sorts of ways to abuse the system. Fighting, killing and looting a victim would be at least ten times worse than pick pocketing. Or a hundred times worse. what do you do when a player starts killing and looting all the citizens in a city, or every random player he encounters? I'm sure the WoW game desingers have wrestled for years with exactly these questions. And it needs to be stated that these games are not real life, there is no way we could model real life to the point that allowing pickpocketing and killing of random players to have appropriate real world consequences. And that means it would be abused by those who want to pursue only their selfish ends. I would like to see PvP introduced in such a way that players can interact more naturally and with fewer arbitrary and silly limitations. But unless you have enforcers of some sort constantly roaming the cities and the rest of the world, it's going to be impossible to handle without serious abuse occurring.

More on raiding in MMORPGs

By CosmicConservative
I know that a few of my regular commenters here have played Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPGs), but most have not. There are probably others who have played WoW or games like WoW, but never raided themselves and may not really understand the whole raiding dynamic. In fact I am a big fan of "The Guild" a web video series that parodies the antics of members of a raiding guild in a generic MMORPG, but "The Guild" gets far more wrong than they get right, making me wonder if Felicia Day has ever really been seriously involved in raiding before or during the creative process of making "The Guild." It's possible she has but she feels that it is easier to parody the average person's assumptions about raiding to mine the humor there than to accurately parody an actual raiding guild. If so, she's probably right. Much of the stuff that happens in a raiding environment wouldn't make sense to a non-raider and as such wouldn't have much comedy potential. Years ago, when I set up my first account on EverQuest, I didn't know anything about raiding. I was looking for an online version of Dungeons and Dragons, not some totally new gaming experience. In fact, for a long time I was frustrated with EverQuest because I kept trying to make it into an online version of D&D, when really a MMORPG in combat is more like a networked first-person shooter than any table-top role playing game. But over time I became accustomed to that reality and committed myself to the level grind in EverQuest. I had a couple of friends I played with frequently and we would group to do instances, which is sort of a baby version of raiding that at least introduces the concepts of role-based combat. But it wasn't until my EQ wizard reached level 60 or so that I discovered raiding and realized that raiding was, in fact, the justification for the existence of the genre. Everything else about MMORPGs is basically some sort of grind, or some sort of training for raiding. Raiding is what it's all about. And why is that? Well, I suppose different people have different motivations for raiding, and there are no doubt lots of MMORPGamers who enjoy the game just fine without raiding. But the ultimate goal of the game itself, as created by the game designers, is to defeat the game's top bosses. And the top bosses are all in the raids. OK, OK, I can see an argument for PvP being just as fulfilling and just as much fun, and I've done lots of PvP myself in WoW, but PvP is, by its nature, a series of short, limited engagements with strategy and tactics that are defined and executed in fractions of a second. Raiding is much more strategic. It requires real planning and study to do successfully. Besides mastering your character's game abilities, you have to know when and why to use them over battles that frequently last ten minutes or more, in sessions that can last for two hours or more (most start-to-finish raids in IceCrown Citadel are set for three hour runs, and as often as not the raiders have to come back later in the week to complete the final bosses that they didn't get to in the three hours set aside). Raiding in a MMORPG is about as pure a meritocracy as I've ever encountered. It's a brutal example of survival of the fittest where your performance is quite literally rated on charts for the whole world to see, and if you don't reach certain thresholds, you simply aren't allowed to do certain things. That's because one under-equipped, under-skilled, or just plain ignorant player can wreck the plans of 24 other people simply by not having prepared properly for the raid. Raid leaders, in particular, scrutinize the equipment and performance of raiders. It is not uncommon at all for a raid leader to, without a word, kick someone who is not performing adequately out of the raid. Every serious raider has a series of meters and charts that they use to measure their performance. For Rhlyssa that is primarily how much damage she is doing. I use a damage meter that resets for every fight we get into. To save screen space I have it sized to ony show the top five damage producers in the raid. If Rhlyssa's name is not in that top five, I get nervous. Typically I want to be in the top three, and frankly I feel my proper place is at #1. Healers monitor their healing effectiveness both by how much healing they've done and by how few raid members are dying. Tanks monitor their ability to control the boss so that the boss focuses its attack on the tank. Everything is public to raiders who have the proper tools. When someone is doing an unacceptable amount of damage, healing or aggro management, if they are lucky, they will be told to step it up. Usually they are simply dumped from the raid and the raid leaders put them on their "ignore" list. And as important as it is for a role to perform adequately in that role, there are many other things that raid members appreciate in their raiding party. Such as not dying during an encounter. It also includes having appropriate equipment, potions, flasks, elixers, scrolls and food to buff up the party, as well as being able to utilize the highest level of skills to improve the raid's chances of success. Perhaps I like it because it's the ultimate geek fantasy. Everything is quantifiable, verifiable and demonstrable. Since it is everyone's best interest for everyone to perform to their best abilities, tips, hints and tricks are freely shared, so just by raiding you learn how to better perform in your role. Some of the fights you have to perform are so complex and so difficult that it is truly an accomplishment to pull them off. Plus you have to perform cooperatively to succeed. Every class has a primary role, but also has a series of abilities that make other classes jobs easier. So the best raids (and most successful) happen when every player is focused on the team, not on themselves, and is doing everything possible to perform their role while also supporting the other roles as much as they can. And since every fight produces publicly available logs of every swing of a dagger, every healing spell, every buff that expires, etc... there is nowhere to hide. If you screw up, everyone knows it was you. If you want to keep playing, the only way to do it is to get better and better. Among the quantifiable elements in the game are tools which score a character's gear. One is called "GearScore" (geeks are so original) and it's the primary means of rating a character's gear. Right now the general agreed upon value for a "raid-worthy" character is to have a gear score of at least 5,000. At this moment Rhlyssa's gear score is 5.5K. The average value I've seen in ICC raids is about 5.7-5.8K, so Rhlyssa is still a bit under-geared. But in combat she has been holding her own in DPS (Damage Per Second) against other raiders with gear scores of 5.8 - 6.2K. What that tells me is that when she finally gets her complete set of tier 10 gear, she'll be back at the top of the charts. And for some reason, that's important to me. I probably won't rest until I can go into ICC 25 on hard mode, clear out the instance, and be at or on par with the top damage producer in the raid. And by then I expect the next release will be out... :)