Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Crushing of scientific dissent

By CosmicConservative
Interesting article on how Global Warming advocates are using institutional intimidation, political posturing and, now, even legal actions to stop any actual scientists from challenging the assertions about Global Warming that have become accepted truth by the MSM and everyone who is politically to the left of Attila the Hun. MIT's Inconvenient Scientist. Of course what you hear about on CNN and CBS etc... is the supposed "silencing" of Global Warming proponents by the Bush administration. But the real inconvenient truth is that the true crushing of dissent is coming from those who claim to be the victim of it. Read the article if you can find the time.

Comments (5)

mtnlurker
"In the debate over climate change, Schneider said, there simply was no legitimate opposing view to the scientific consensus that man - made carbon emissions drive global warming. To suggest or report otherwise, he said, was irresponsible." How is this science? It is also not debating. Even if I agreed I still want to hear both sides.
CosmicConservative
It's not science, it is dogma by definition. This is why scientists are frequently charged as being just another religion. There is far too much adherence to dogma, especially when it is politically sensitive. What it shows is that scientists are people. The real power of science is not that they don't have dogma, but that in general dogma is more frequently challenged and overturned. Global Warming is not yet in the "challenged and overturned" phase. It is still in the "ideology" phase. I hope that doesn't last too long.
qwerty182764
I find it increasingly strange the specific level of disagreement there is between the left and right in this country. It's no longer on the level of which decisions will be best for our country. It's no longer on the level of whether or not our country should be benifitted in the first place. It's no longer even on the level of what constitutes right and wrong. (Example: the "Free Tookie!" campaign) Our disagreement has reached the point where we can't even agree on what's real anymore. Who's actually oppressing who. Who's silencing who. What's actually going on in any corner of the world. Which country starts what war. What base-line data actually is. How many bodies were originally in a war photo. Ect Ect. Naturally I agree that one side is far closer to reality, which is why I'm a conservative. Some people will even go so far as to deny my primitive concept of "reality" as something one can be close to. :-P Makes your head spin.
qwerty182764
You know, one thing I find annoying on politicized topics (such as nuclear energy, one of the subjects of my recent blogrant) is the impossibility of finding information, plots, results (the numbers, not the interpretations), in the sea of narratives. There seems to be a mountain of narrative in the way of every mound of data. (And I realize the irony that my recent post only adds to this, though I try to link with information sources). Want to make an effective, believable, useful argument? Make a graph of your data, all your data, and reserve your narrative for explaining how these things were discovered. If people then wish to concatonate graphs to show a trend, then it would have far more force IMO than someones misanthropic opinions.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: In debate after debate with Leftists I have laid out fact after fact, and all to no avail. Facts don't matter when your emotions are engaged. I talk a lot about what the Anthropological Correllary to the Cosmological Principle. The Cosmological Principle says the universe looks the same from any perspective it essentially is the scientific way of saying that there is nothing at all special about the earth and its place in the cosmos. It's a powerful scientific tool and is the absolute foundation of all cosmology. If it is wrong, then we know pretty much nothing about our universe. The "Anthropological Correllary" extends that concept to human society. Basically it says "no matter what your ideology is, the world looks pretty much the same to you." By which I mean, Lefties think Righties are nuts, just like Righties think Lefties are nuts. For every "fact" I think I prove and they think is fantasy, they have a "fact" that they think they've proved that I think is fantasy. I don't know if its true, but it sure feels accurate.