Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Season 4 of "Top Shot"

By CosmicConservative
I'm going to put this in the category of "reviews" just because it's sort of a review. But it's really more of a stream of consciousness reaction to the series. For those who may not know, "Top Shot" is one of those silly "reality shows" that have infected the television landscape like pustules on a plague victim. The host, named "Colby" something or other, is one of those deliberately-primped-to-be-rugged guys that irritate me to no end just by their preening, strutting affected hyper-masculinity. Everything about the guy annoys me, from the way he has a six-day growth of beard every day (the look initially made famous by Don Johnson in "Miami Vice" and I hated it just as much then), to the way he wears just slightly faded and worn jeans, to the way he stands to the way his blinding white teeth burst through his Clint Eastwood-esque squint when he spits his cliche phrases for the camera.... I've described the concept of the show before, so I'll just reiterate that it's based on the "Survivor" model except instead of voting someone off the island, there is a vote to determine two candidates in each show who have to face each other in an "elimination challenge" to see who goes and who stays. This gives Colby a chance to strut and preen as he says in his patented, clipped delivery, "you have fired your last shot" as he sends the hapless loser packing. But in spite of Colby's pervasive and irritating presence, the show itself has managed to do something that very few TV programs have done in the past decade. It has made me actually look forward to each episode. I do watch a couple of other shows right now ("Swamp People", "American Pickers", and "Pawn Stars") but I can take or leave those shows. I typically bring my laptop computer in and watch with the Cosmic Wife. They are engaging and I do enjoy them, particularly "American Pickers" but if I miss an episode or two, I don't sweat it. I make an effort to watch "Top Shot." Why? Because guns. So many guns. And bows, slingshots and atlatls. Not to mention rocket launchers, grenade launchers, sub-machine guns, gatling guns and twice now... Cannons. I mean, if you can't get a thrill out of watching a super slow-motion video of an artillery shell being fired directly at the camera... well, you might want to check your pulse. So anyway, this is the fourth season of the show. I've posted a couple of reactions to specific shows this year, including one where I was very disappointed with the overall accuracy that was demonstrated by these supposed "world-class shooters." But that was really an anomaly. In general the shooting is extremely good. But there is another dimension to the show, and that is the dimension that probably is intended to draw in viewers, although I admit that it doesn't really draw me in that much. Except in rare cases I almost never "root" for anyone. I have a few shooters that I like more than others, and I have to admit that I like seeing the hot chick shooters compete, even though they tend to get booted pretty early, but usually I don't get into the personalities of the shooters. I just like watching the shooting. This season though, I found myself getting drawn in. And as it happened the final two in the season finale who went up against each other were one of my favorites (Chris, the IT guy) vs one of my least favorites (Greg, the ex-soldier). From the start of the show it was clear that the military, police or competitive shooters were rather dismissive of Chris, who had never shot in any competition or been a member of any armed force. He was just a self-described IT geek who shot recreationally but who survived the auditions and ended up on the show. On I think the first episode, he and Greg both performed poorly on a specific team challenge, and Chris ended up being voted to do an elimination challenge, which he survived. The challenge involved using a pistol to shoot a series of plates where you had to shoot six plates in a row without a miss to move to the next row. Both Greg and Chris failed to complete a row of plates in that challenge. But after that, Chris steadily and quietly performed well in challenge after challenge. He showed a specific skill in being able to pick up a weapon he had never seen before and master it quickly. For example, using the atlatl, he nailed a perfect bullseye at the farthest distance, shutting out his opponent in the elimination challenge by scoring 9 points on one throw. Nobody else even got close to the bullseye on the farthest target. Greg, in the meantime, continued to spectacularly fail in challenge after challenge. Plus he demonstrated extremely poor interpersonal skills, repeatedly frustrating and angering both his teammates and the other team. He formed an early clique with three other shooters and they voted to protect each other instead of voting to send the worst performers to the elimination challenges. Even so Greg was sent to three elimination challenges during the season. And I have to give him credit. For whatever reason, while working as part of a team, Greg repeatedly choked badly in competition. in one competition he seemed to completely freeze up for an agonizingly long time trying to make difficult shots. In one case he took forever to make a shot, only to realize he still had the safety on, and then went through the whole agonizing process again, taking forever and missing his shot to boot. But in the elimination challenges, with him one on one vs another shooter, he was a totally different person. He survived all three elimination challenges, sending home shooters that I personally believed were far superior to him. So, in the end, both Chris and Greg survived the team challenges and entered the individual rounds. Both were considered to be the weakest remaining challengers, even though Chris had been perhaps the strongest shooter overall since that first episode. By now I was rooting for Chris and rooting against Greg. Well, in the end they ended up being the final two. And the final challenge was a series of seven individual shooting tests consisting of a flintlock pistol, an ancient British pistol, a Colt pistol, a crossbow, two different rifles and ending with a six-shot grenade launcher. Oh, did I mention that Greg's main credential for appearing on the show was that he was the military's champion grenade launcher in 2003? The second pistol challenge was a repeat of the "perfect series" test that both Chris and Greg had failed so spectacularly back in episode 1. Well... of the four season finales, this one was by far the closest. Chris took a small but significant early lead over Greg until they got to the crossbow, where Greg caught up. Both nailed the perfect series test shooting 12 plates in a row with a Colt revolver without a single miss. Good for them. Greg took the lead in the rifle challenges, ending up on the final challenge a good six seconds ahead of Chris. And the final challenge was the grenade launcher. They had to hit two targets with grenades one at 25 yards and one at 50 yards I think. Anyway, Greg hit his first target before Chris even got his grenade launcher loaded and into firing position. It looked very bad for Chris. When Chris missed his first shot, it looked like all was over, but Greg missed his shot at the farthest target. Then Chris nailed both targets with two successive shots in a stunning example of his uncanny ability to master unfamiliar weapons. His winning shot not only hit the target, it nailed the exact center of the bullseye, while Greg's final shot went just wide. I actually cheered.

Comments (2)

Dadman
It's a fun show. And don't be too hard on Colby, a Survivor alum by the way; he's just reading a script and likely delivering his lines, dressing, standing, etc. as directed. I do agree the way he speaks is very affectatious. He needs to tone that down... The things I like most about the show: guns, competition, extreme slo-mo, and exploding targets. You really can't ask for more in a TV show. Except maybe a few more babes... ;)
CosmicConservative
Perhaps I am harshing a bit much on Colby. He does have a modicum of charm that he displays on occasion, but those times are usually when he drops his superman mask. I did see a portion of a (different, not "Top Shot") show where Colby was actually doing some shooting himself, and in that show he was not nearly as irritating. So you may be right. What irritates me so much about his "Top Shot" persona is how deliberately contrived it appears to me. Perhaps it appears so deliberately contrived because he is having to push himself to come across that way. Still, after four years I'd like to think that he could have eased his true personality into the show... It's still a fun show.