Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

My Way News: Iran presses forward with nuclear plans

By CosmicConservative
A few quotes
My Way News ARAK, Iran (Reuters) - Iran's president launched a new phase in the Arak heavy-water reactor project on Saturday, saying Tehran would not give up its right to nuclear technology despite Western fears it aims to make atomic bombs. President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was speaking just days before an August 31 deadline set by the U.N. Security Council for Iran to halt uranium enrichment -- the West's biggest worry in Iran's atomic program -- or face possible sanctions. "No one can deprive a nation of its rights based on its capabilities," Ahmadinejad said in his speech to inaugurate the heavy water project. The Arak project, once complete, will produce plutonium as a by-product that could be used to make atomic warheads. But the reactor that will produce this is still being built. Western nations accuse Iran of seeking to master technology to produce nuclear weapons. Iran, the world's fourth largest oil exporter, insists it only wants to produce electricity.
OK, just for the sake of argument, what is the legal reason the US, Russia, France, England, Australia, Israel, India, Pakistan and others can have nuclear bombs, but Iran can't even build reactors that might create the materials needed for bombs? I am absolutely in favor of stopping Iran, but not on arbitrary grounds. Ahmadinejad may be a nut, may be a religious fanatic, may be the next coming of Hitler, but what is legally, morally or ethically wrong in his assertion that a nation that is capable of producing nuclear technology has no higher authority telling it that it cannot do so? My problem with Iran is the provable connection they have with terrorism, their public rhetoric asserting that they intend to commit genocide, etc. All of these are strong arguments in favor of a multi-national group overthrowing the current government. But what if, say, Canada were doing this, Or Finland? Would the same rules apply?

Comments (13)

qwerty182764
"OK, just for the sake of argument, what is the legal reason the US, Russia, France, England, Australia, Israel, India, Pakistan and others can have nuclear bombs, but Iran can’t even build reactors that might create the materials needed for bombs? I am absolutely in favor of stopping Iran, but not on arbitrary grounds. " And there's your mistake. What is "legal"? You have to have some sort of agreed upon representation, some sort of social contract and shared loyalty to have a context in which legal and illegal have meaning. This doesn't exist on the international scale. I doubt it will exist until Earth has to fight Mars or something in some hypothetical future conflict. International politics is arbitrary. We're stopping Iran from getting nukes because we think that country's nutjob leader will use it to cause mayhem and destruction, and expand the influence of the islamo-fascist gestalt. We don't like it, so we're stopping it. (Well, talking about it at this phase) There's nothing more to it than that. I don't mind Canada having nuclear reactors at all. We're not nervous about France having nukes (yet, anyways, depending on if they have a civil war and overthrow some decades from now). We're not nervous about Japan's nuclear reactors or technology. These people aren't murderous fanatics, or lead by murderous fanatics. Furthermore, they don't make up an opposing power bloc which aims to destroy us (whatever Frances dreams are about transcending us).
qwerty182764
So yes, different rules do apply. Basically, we apply our rules to suit our interests, just as any other nation will apply their diplomatic and foreign policy to suit their interests. We're kidding ourselves if we think we're at a stage yet where different nations are willing to sacrifice for the sake of loyalty to each other. Within nations, this level of loyaly exists. Outside nations, it doesn't. That's one definition of what a nation is.
CosmicConservative
Qwerty: Ok, so other than national self-interest, what principle applies to our insistence that another sovereign nation cannot do what we do routinely? I have already said that I support the national self-interest, but that just boils down to a "might makes right" argument. We can tell Iran what to do because we have a bigger stick. I'm trying to get to first principles here. If we can't get to first principles, then we should admit that there is no higher ideal than national self-interest and then we should apply the Bush doctrine and go take them out. But admitting that essentially says that Ahmadinejad is right and that if the situation were reversed, Iran could impose its "national self interest" on our own pursuit of nuclear technology. I just want people to understand that. I'm all for it, but I don't like hiding behind fancy words. We're the biggest dude in the neighborhood, and we don't want anyone else to be able to knife us in our sleep, so we confiscate knives. Fine, that's the deal. But admit it. Don't pretend it's something it's not.
qwerty182764
"I am absolutely in favor of stopping Iran, but not on arbitrary grounds. Ahmadinejad may be a nut, may be a religious fanatic, may be the next coming of Hitler, but what is legally, morally or ethically wrong in his assertion that a nation that is capable of producing nuclear technology has no higher authority telling it that it cannot do so?" Well, I was trying to point out the situation as it stands, not necessarily as it ought to be. If Iran didn't have any higher authority (us) telling it it cannot produce bombs, no principles would stand in their way, they would go ahead and do so and the world would be several million people poorer for it. As for why it's ethically wrong for them to have bombs? Intentions count. Intentions determine what you'll do with your power, whether you'll use them to build and defend, or raise and destroy, to force your will, or to merely protect your children. If I asked you who you would rather be given awesome unanswerable powers, person A or person B, there would be no information on which to base the determination. If you said Martin Luther King Jr, or Ghengis Khan, the situation is far more clear as to what each party would then go on to do with them.
qwerty182764
In fact, in this era of terrorism, it might be more appropriate to say that intentions count more than capabilities do? It's not even just the fact that Iran wants nukes. If they started amassing tylenol, we'd probably have to stop them, because we probably already know what their aim is, even before we know exactly what they intend to do with it. Why should a person be denied the right to have an exacto knife? Who are we to tell them no? What is it about them carrying an instrument that we're comfortable with our own grade-schoolers wielding? Well .....
CosmicConservative
I'm still wishing we could get down to first principles and that there was a moral imperative that went beyond "We don't like you and we know what you are going to do with them". But it seems such principles would require either overt divine intervention ("Thou Shalt Not Allow Iran To Process Plutonium!" delivered on a golden tablet perhaps), or else some sort of national oversight like many on the Left erroniously perceive the UN to be. In the absence of such acknowledged authority, I guess we're left with "might makes right" and "we know what you are up to," both of which are understandable and actionable to someone like me, but which will never pass the John Kerry "global test." Thus my concern with electing Democrats....
Drax
The basic question is wrong, I think. The question, as I understand it, is "Why is it wrong for Iran to have the ability to build nukes, when it is okay for other countries to have them?" This is a question about the right of nation states to control their own destiny. If taken in that context, then, of course, there is no differentiation between Iran and Canada, between North Korea and Great Britain. But, what if Iran was a democracy? In that case, we would have a different outlook on the question: "Should we allow Iran to have nukes?" So, it really ISN'T a question of comparing nation states, but a question of the NATURE of the GOVERNMENT of those nation states. Thus, when we ask: "Who should be allowed to have nuclear capability that doesn't now, when we have the capability to prevent their obtaining it?" we are not asking about nation states per se, but who CONTROLS that nation state. As such, we can, and should, attribute a moral element to this question that we can't when we are simply talking about the relative rights of nation states. We must think of regimes, not geography, if we are to survive, I think.
CosmicConservative
Drax: That's just a fancy way of saying "my government is better than your government." What I'm getting at in all of this is that international geopolitics really is like a nursery school recess without the teachers there to control the children. We have the capability to control Iran because we are the biggest kid in the recess playground. But that's only true if we have the will to do it. And that will comes from different places in different people. George W. Bush sees it as you do, and would invoke "national security" as the reason for stopping Iran. But Howard Dean, John Kerry and John Murtha would likely NOT do the same thing, saying that there is no "governing authority" giving us the right to do it, or even worse, saying that the UN forbids it, which is essentially subjugating US national security to a bunch of thieving bureaucrats. That's why I was hoping to find some compelling first principle that we could invoke. Although I was pretty sure when I started this that such a principle did not exist. This is, in my opinion, a core difference between Right and Left. We on the Right are willing to say "national security trumps world opinion." My concern is that the current crop of Democrat "leaders" believe the reverse. They believe "world opinion trumps national security." Which scares the bloody bejeebers out of me. Especially with all the "experts" predicting a turnover of the House and Senate to Democrats in November. If that happens I don't see how we can stop Iran, the Left simply doesn't have the same view of this as we do.
qwerty182764
"That’s why I was hoping to find some compelling first principle that we could invoke." I'm not quite sure what you're getting at. Given a set of actors, they can pursue their own interests, other people's interests, or spend their effort in futility, or do nothing at all. Just because a principle comes out favoring someone's interests doesn't make it invalid. One would have to wonder what a principle that served no ones interests (just spun wheels) would be worth.
Drax
I, too, am confused about what you mean by "first principle," if it doesn't include, at the least, doing what is in our interests as those in power see it at the time. There IS no argument, legally, morally, or otherwise which supports the notion: "We can have nuclear weapons, but, only those we deem worthy are allowed to join us in this club." Every nation state is, by definition, sovereign, and able to do whatever it likes within its own borders. Every nation state is, by definition, sovereign, and able to do whatever it likes without its own borders so long as as no one stops them. There is no legal or moral support for any argument which attempts to confine the reality of those two statements. Accordingly, when the U.S. decides to take action, the ONLY question is whether that action is in the interests of the U.S., not whether it's "right" or "legal." Because, almost every action which the U.S. takes which affects another sovereign is almost certain to be viewed, at least by the country we're acting against, as being both "wrong" and "illegal," infringing upon their sovereignty. "Right" and "wrong" in these judgments which have no place in today's world. "Legal" only has a place in a setting in which a country has offered up its sovereignty to another authority, for it is only a higher authority which determines an act to be "legal" or "illegal." All that matters is whether a particular course of action is in the interest of the nation. Anything else not only is meaningless, but muddles the thinking, causing people to concentrate on issues which have no place in the interaction between sovereigns.
Brian
I'm going to skip over the preceeding arguments - it was a busy weekend mostly spent off-line. Why can Canada and Finland develop these capabilities but not Iran? Capabilities and intentions. We're reasonably sure neither the Canuks or the Fins are going to start lobbing around nuclear weapons. Why? Lack of territorial ambition, better government, culture, attitude. You can postulate some very odd scenarios where Canada invades the United States and annexes the Pacific Northwest or Finland gets all agressive to Latvia but, really, it's low probability stuff. Can't, really, say the same about Iran.
CosmicConservative
I am in complete agreement with all of the arguments that we have a compelling national interest in stopping Iran from developing nuclear weapons. But the only authority we have to base that on is our own self-interest and capacity. This is precisely what drives Leftists nuts and makes them call the U.S. "immoral" and "imperialist" and "the true terrorist state". And from their position, that's all true. We are imposing our will on the world by virtue of our sheer capacity to do so. We on the Right are convinced that we have not only the right, but the obligation, to act in this way. The Left has always been uncomfortable with this because they view that as being "no better than" the enemy, since we are doing "the same thing" they are, which is pursuing our own self-interest and making it stick through sheer military or economic power. By a "first principle" I meant some self-evident property that was not derived from simple self-interest. A "first principle" is one that applies to all things, and self-interest by definition does not. "Free Markets" is a first principle. It applies to all markets, not just Western ones. "Self defense" is a first principle, if you are invaded, everyone recognizes your right and obligation to defend yourself. But "self-interest" is not the same as "self-defense." I guess I was hoping someone would make the argument that this is self-defense, but I'm not sure you can make that argument stick. What I'm trying to do here is demonstrate how the mind of a Leftist works on this issue. Your arguments are not convincing to someone who believes that national self-interest is the problem in the world today and that the US is the worst offender in that regard. Imposing our will on Iran is viewed as being just as bad and as wrong as Iran imposing their will on us. I suppose the best approach to this is the one that would suggest that Democracies have been demonstrated convincingly to be far less warlike than theocracies or dictatorships (both of which Iran qualifies for) and so the closest thing to a first principle that I could come up with is: Democracy itself must be defended from despots. Iran is a despotism, the USA is a democracy, therefore we have the right and obligation to ensure that they do not have the power to attack us, since history has shown that such attacks almost always come from the despotic rule on the democracy. Furthermore, I would say that principle can only be valid if the attack is restrained to removing that threat, and that embarking on nation-building would cross that line. Then you are truly in the realm of national self-interest, which is no longer a first principle, but which can still be effectively argued as a valid reason for national action, but the case is much harder to make.
Drax
Again. There is no argument that one set of rules holds true for one sovereign and another for a different sovereign from a moral or legal perspective. They are equal. Any act by one which imposes its will upon another is an act which infringes on the sovereignty of one, and, by definition, is an "illegal" act when viewed from the one whose sovereignty is being infringed upon, and, this act will almost certainly be viewed as "immoral" as well by that same country. You say "self-defense" is a "first principle." That is at least arguable. One country's self-defense is another's invasion. When the act which prompts the act of "self-defense" isn't outright aggression (say a build-up of border forces by one country along the border of another with a long history of a border dispute...) what is and is not "self-defense" becomes blurred, making this "first principle" a muddy one at best. National self-interest is no better a yardstick, as what is in the self-interest of one country may be the destruction of another (say...U.S. and Iraq). Thus, we get back to the fact that, as between sovereigns, there is no "first principle" which would allow for the statement: "We can have nukes but you cannot." The ONLY thing which allows for this type of statment is POWER and the willingness to weild it. We understood this during the cold war. We viewed the Soviet Union as the "bad guys." But, we recognized that we could not FORCE them to do what we wanted to do through the use of military might. Thus, we brought other pressures to bear on them. What right did we have to say that the exportation of communism was any different from the exportation of democracy? Viewed as a comparison of the relative rights of sovereigns, of course, we had no more right to tell them what to do than they had to tell us what to do. Recognition of the relative POWER of the other, however, caused us to not do things we wished to do as it caused them to not do things that they wished to do. We believe, with good reason, that countries such as ours (democratic type societies) are simply BETTER than others. We also recognize, again with good reason, that dictatorships are generally a bad form of government. When we look at the various forms of governments with this admittedly slanted view in mind, but a CORRECT view nonetheless, we can say: "Screw sovereignty. There is NO WAY we're going to let that maniac in charge of Iran get Nuclear weapons." The problem with convincing leftists is that they are unconvinced of the truth of the premise that leads to that last statement. They are unconvinced that the U.S. is a "good" country. Unless you first agree that we're the "good guys," you cannot come to the conclusion that making more "like us" is a "good thing." So, in arguments with liberals, one must concentrate on the PREMISE. The conclusion inevitably follows once they have agreed that a country such as Iran simply cannot be allowed to have nuclear capability. Of course, it would help if Mike Wallace retired.