Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More on "Top Shot"

By CosmicConservative
I mentioned "Top Shot" in my last post about BB guns and slingshots. In that post I mentioned how surprised I was at how poorly some of the contestants performed on the show considering they are supposedly the best competitive shooters in the nation. Well, last night was just more indication of the same thing. The show is obviously modeled after "Survivor". When the season starts there are 20 or so contestants who are split into a "red" and a "blue" team. Each team get's T-shirts and jackets of that color and then each episode is a "team challenge" where the two teams compete against each other, and an "individual challenge" where two members of the losing team for that episode have to compete against each other to remain in the show, with the loser going home. Yesterday's "team challenge" was a pretty simple affair. Using an ancient British military revolver (the same one Indiana Jones uses in the movies) the team had to shoot out 30 jars full of paint from a distance of 35 feet. The trick was that the paint jars were mounted on a large 5x6 grid and the grids themselves were moving back and forth at about the speed a person might walk. Each team member had to rush to their shooting platform, load the empty revolver, shoot six times, then "crack open" the revolver to eject the spent shells, leaving the revolver on the platform for the next team member to do the same after the shooter ran back to the rest of the group. So, 35 feet. Targets the size of a Gatorade bottle. But moving from left to right until the end of the track, then reversing from right to left until the other end of the track is reached, then reverse again. Both teams first shooter missed five out of six tries. Five out of six. And each team had supposedly put their "best pistol shooter" up first after the practice range results. So, from that point on the red team sort of got the hang of it and beat the blue team pretty convincingly, finishing off their 30 targets while the blue team still have more than half of theirs left. A couple of standout shooters were able to hit four or five of six shots, but no shooter hit six of six. Since they had to cycle through the team multiple times, some shooters got as many as twelve shots, and some only hit with 2, 3 or 4 of their total shots, meaning a success rate of between 16 and 30%. So, OK, you're thinking, but it was a MOVING target. Yeah, I suppose so, but some of these shooters are military or police members and you would think they have been trained to shoot moving targets. One of the best shooters was, again, the IT guy who has no formal training and no competitive shooting experience. Anyway... so now that the blue team has lost, they have to send two members to "elimination" in the individual challenge. In this case they were using another ancient British military weapon, but in this case they were using an early bolt-action rifle with a ten-round clip. The gun (and I don't remember what it was called) was the standard military issue for the British army in WWI. At that time the British Army was trained to shoot fast, and developed a technique of working the bolt on the gun without removing their fingers, reaching forward with their middle finger to pull the trigger. Doing this they could fire a round every second or so, and then they would do a fast reload using a "strip clip" which allowed them to jam bullets directly into the clip instead of having to completely swap out clips. Strip clips were only five bullets though, so loading from a strip clip had to be well more than twice as fast as swapping out a full clip for it to be effective. At that time the British Army had a drill they called the "Mad Minute" where soldiers had to load and fire the weapon as many times as possible within one minute, shooting at a target about the size of a grapefruit some 50 yards downfield (I don't recall the exact distance) two feet across 200 yards downfield. The EXPECTED success rate for a soldier to be considered fit for active duty was fifteen successful hits on the target in one minute. The average successful on target rate for one minute was 25. The record was something like 38. So... the first guy comes up. They are shooting prone, from sandbags. The easiest and most accurate possible way to shoot a rifle. He misses his first three shots. He's not using the "hands on bolt" technique so he's working the bolt, re-gripping the gun, finding the trigger, aiming and firing. He's getting about one shot off every five seconds. Eventually he finds the target and starts to score some hits. At 30 seconds he's hit the target three times and is still working on his second clip. His next 30 seconds are identical and he ends up with six hits in one minute. ONE HIT EVERY TEN SECONDS! He managed to get off a total of eleven shots. So I'm figuring "This guy sucks! I could do better than that!" (And I have no doubt whatsoever that I COULD do better than that). The next guy is from Britain, knows the stories has at least heard about the technique and claims to have shot the gun in his teens. So I'm figuring he's a lock to win this thing. So he gets set. Shoots. Misses. Shoots again. Misses again. He TOO is doing the standard bolt to trigger and back to bolt technique. He's also really struggling with loading the gun. Still he's getting off more shots than the first guy, he's getting a shot off about once every four seconds. But he's missing more. At 30 seconds he's ALSO at three hits. And at the end of a minute, he too has six hits. SIX HITS! I could have shot my first clip, hit at least five times, taken a short break for a swig of coke and a smile at the crowd, then loaded a second clip, hit four or five more times and been done with it with twenty seconds to spare. Anyway, the first guy ends up winning because the tie-breaker rules on the show favor the person who misses less if they hit the same number of times. He shot fewer times, and he won. Even though the stated goal of the challenge was to shoot "fast and accurate". Oh well... Still, those guys are supposed to be world-class marksmen, and they couldn't hit a grapefruit at 50 yards 2 foot diameter circle at 200 yards prone with a military rifle more than six times in one minute. I could do that with my single shot .22! And my .22 has to be loaded directly into the barrel, it has no bolt guides to slide the bullet into the barrel, you have to push it in with your thumb before sliding the bolt forward. What a joke... Still, it's a fun show.

Comments (12)

CosmicConservative
200 yards? I'll check. It's hard to see when they have the target on one camera and the shooter on another camera.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, it was 200 yards, but it was a 24" target! That's huge. I should have paid more attention though. Still think I could have done better than six hits in one minute... So, did you watch the episode Dadman?
CosmicConservative
For comparison, a 2' target at 200 yards has the same angular size as a 2" target at 50 feet. It's a pretty sizable target for that range.
Dadman
Yep, I saw the episode and have been a fan of the show for a couple seaons now. I'm not convinced the contestants suck as much as you imply although I was amazed by how many shots they missed in both competitions. Seems odd. But of course they are shooting in a high-stress context with cameras trained on the. Performance anxiety might be contributing to their poor showing. You'd think some of them would be used to that though...
CosmicConservative
I probably shouldn't use such loaded terms as "suck" but I am looking at it from an expectations perspective. These people are supposed to be the best in the world, and I frankly think I could match many of them. Not all of them though. There have been a couple who have really impressed me. I was happy to see Chee get a chance to compete, he is always sat out by the other team so he's only competed a few times. But when he does compete, he is very, very good. I have also been very impressed with Gabby. The ones that amaze me are the ones like William or Greg or Terry or Dylan, people who have repeatedly done poorly in multiple challenges. Some of them still maintain incredible egos in spite of their lack of performance. Yeah, I'm sure the pressure of the cameras and competition weigh on them, but Chris, the IT guy, has had the least of that and he seems to thrive under it. Anyway, I do love the show, and there are some amazing performances that completely blow me away, but still, week after week I am left just shaking my head over some of the performances. On my lunch walk today I paced off 200 yards from a speed limit sign, just to get an idea of whether I could hit it from 200 yards without a scope, while prone and using sandbags. Honestly? I didn't think it would be a problem. Maybe not every single shot, but more often than not.
jussayin'
The gun was a lee-enfield. I thought the shooters should have done better than they did as well, but neither was all that smooth with working the bolt. Trying to work the bolt action, site and fire as quickly as possible might have contributed to the poor performance. I enjoy watching the show, when I remember to, but I don't watch with regularity. One thing that I notice is they use misleading editing on the program. I guess it is meant to keep drama going or something, but I agree with you that the results of these contests should be a little more impressive than they are. I like how they use weapons that are definitely out of the comfort zone for most of the contestants, though I think their practice times seem a bit weak. The guy demonstrating the bolt action seemed overly impressed with himself, where he just had to show off more than really give good instructions. They did say about trading accuracy for speed, but it seems that the work with the expert should have been more on how to work the bolt action quickly, even giving the alternate methods, while being in a shooting position and demonstrating and allowing practice for working the bolt, getting the finger to the trigger with minimal gun movement, which seemed to be the goal. You should look into trying out for the show. Couldn't hurt. It would be interesting to see how you do and your impressions on the shooting skills in that environment.
CosmicConservative
Heh.... I might look at it... I'm seriously considering making a two foot target and going out in the mountains to set up a 200 yard shoot and have the Cosmic Wife time me for a minute with my ancient bolt-action single-shot .22. I'm pretty sure I can do better than six hits in a minute, but maybe I'm fooling myself. One thing that I just don't get is whether the guys shooting the lee-enfield could have just used the standard ten-shot clip instead of trying the more difficult and complex strip-clip. I would certainly have asked.
jussayin'
I had wondered about that myself, regarding the 10 clip over the strip-clip. Maybe it was part of the challenge as a means of having them interrupt their chain more often. The six hits seems really low for people who are supposed to be able to shoot really well. Even if they are not rifle shooters, which it didn't sound like from their comments about their history. Not being familiar with the weapon it might have affected their aim. Different weapons, the sights, could have it running off target enough with limited time to compensate for the way it fires to where they aim. These being old weapons, the sights are set, so that might account for some of it. Though in the practice they were being told where the shot hit.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, but they had an hour to practice with it the day before the individual challenge. One OTHER thing I've wondered is if the contestants can ask simple things like "Is the weapon bore-sighted? If so, at what distance?" Because then they could mentally compute the elevation they'd need to compensate for bullet drop or rise depending on the distance. But they never mention that. I assume that's the sort of thing you're able to ask, otherwise you just sort of have to assume some "standard" sighting distance for pistols vs rifles I suppose.
pace
The British rifle was likely a Lee-Enfield .303 which was standard issue in both WWI and WWII I think. I was a Royal Air Cadet for a short time, and we used them for dry-fire training/drill exercises IIRC. I remember it being heavy (I was just a teen).
CosmicConservative
One of the things my father gave to me as he was clearing out his old work office but didn't have room to store everything was a Winchester Model 94 "Crazy Horse" collectable rifle. It had a broken lever, even though it had supposedly never been used or fired. The box was sort of ratty, but the gun itself was in pretty good shape, except for the broken lever. I purchased a replacement lever from Winchester and replaced it myself. It seems to be fine, but I've never fired it, mostly because the gun is supposed to be a "collectable" and I know that simply using something for its intended purpose destroys its value for collectors. Just a quick aside here. I hate that. I really, really hate that whole concept of collecting things for the express purpose of never using them. There is something about collecting things for the express purpose of sticking them in a glass container and gazing at it longingly that just rubs every single part of my personality the wrong way. But I've stuck to it in this case in the hopes that eventually the gun would be worth the effort and trouble of irritating my psyche in this manner. So far, no good. There's thousands of this model of "collectable" Winchester Crazy Horse Model 94 out there. I've been tempted to take this out to the firing range for years now. It uses an unusual ammunition too. Something called ".38-55". I bought a box just in case of the zombie apocalypse, but I've never fired it. It's probably of the same vintage, or near to the same vintage of the Lee-Enfield. At least in terms of design. The Model 94 Winchester was probably the most commonly sold rifle worldwide for most of the early 20th century. At least to civilians. And it's a pretty nice rifle. But it's heavy. Real heavy. The barrel is thick, I presume because it was made of steel that was not as strong as modern rifle barrel steel. But in spite of its weight, it's a surprisingly small rifle. It's a bit shorter than my .22 from butt to tip of barrel. I have no idea how accurate it is. It's probably worth about $600 or so, which is probably pretty close to what a new rifle of similar caliber and capability would cost. So why not just start shooting with it? It's got to be a decent hunting rifle, people hunted with the same model for generations. Sigh... I'll probably keep it in it's eroding box hoping that some day it will be worth enough to make a house payment...