Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

It's good to be a Democrat...

By CosmicConservative
So, two years ago the press was snickering and snorting over the claims of rabid right-wingers who ignorantly claimed that Obamacare was unconstitutional. Nancy Pelosi famously responded to a question about the constitutionality of the law with "Are you kidding me? Are you kidding me?" as if to say that the mere thought that Congress had left the Constitution behind were the incomprehensible ravings of a lunatic. Other Obamacare supporters claimed that Obamacare was allowed under the "general welfare" clause while still others turned the question around and directly asked "where does the Constitution say we can't do it?" People like me, who claimed that the enumerated powers clause trumped even the commerce clause were generally treated like three-headed toads. So now it appears very likely that the SCOTUS will overturn Obamacare. The response of the same press that seemed unable to comprehend that Obama/Reid/Pelosi had disgorged a constitutional abomination on the country are now saying that it's probably good for the Democrats if Obamacare is overturned. Why? Because they claim that by overturning Obamacare the Republicans will "own the issue" in the election giving Obama a major boost in his ability to mobilize his base and expand his appeal. In fact an emerging meme is that the dismal performance of the Administration's attorneys in front of the Sacred Seven is due to a deliberate decision by Obama to take a dive so that he has the upper hand in the election, allowing him to pass an even more onerous and economically destructive bill when he is inevitably re-elected. Now, as far as the conspiracy theories go, I am reminded of the old maxim that malice or conspiracy should never be assumed where raw incompetence can be a perfectly reasonable explanation. And raw incompetence is what I've been charging this administration with since before Obama's coronation. So now the question is whether the press, which got the whole issue totally wrong in the first place, can convince the 2/3 of Americans who believe the bill is unconstitutional on its face that the SCOTUS validating that opinion is somehow going to convince a majority of them that they have to vote for Obama so he can get rid of the SCOTUS judges who just ruled exactly how they said they wanted them to in the first place. More and more I am becoming convinced that the press is so wholly invested in Obama that they are no longer capable of rational analysis at any level. Ideological purity is not the biggest thing, it's the ONLY thing. This is going to be an interesting year. I hope the nation survives it.

Comments (4)

Dadman
I've wondered the same. I'm not sure the Democrats are rooting too enthusiastically for Obamacare to be upheld at this point because if it is upheld it will tend to energize a seemingly unengaged, uninspired conservative base of voters. Conversely, if Obamacare is struck down the Dems will have an issue that will instantly energize their base. The Democrats will easily spin this not as a political defeat, but as a rallying cry to vote Republicans out of office. I'm frankly worried such a tactic could shift the upcoming elections away from being a referendum on Obama to a referendum on healthcare. You're right, it's going to be an interesting year...
jussayin'
College students are not all that favorable toward Obama due to the jobs not being there for when they graduate. Independents are going to remember that Obama played nasty politics with the contraceptives mandates, and no matter how you spin it, it is seen as a run around the Catholic and other churchs. Moochelle is a vacationing fool. When the independent voters look at the cuts they have had to make and look at her flying off on expensive vacations on the taxpayers dime, that will not be favorable. It isn't concern about firing up the Democrat base that will make or break Obama's re-crowning. They need the independent voters to be excited about him, and that isn't happening. Healthcare being struck down (if it happens, which is no given) means that the Republicans can run ads about how Obama, that great "constitutional scholar", signed into law a law that was shoved down on the people, and is deemed ILLEGAL. It becomes a headline for incompetance. I can't think of anything that would be more embarressing to a President than to have the only real signature issue they signed into law being overturned by the Supreme Court as being unconstitutional. Let it fire up the fringe base leftists. That is not, nor never has been enough to elect a President. It won't fire up the independents that are imporant as ultimately they decide who wins.
CosmicConservative
Jussayin' I find it hard to disagree with your analysis, but we are in a very distinct minority. The conventional wisdom is that overturning Obamacare will allow Obama to claim that Republicans have returned the nation to a broken health care system with no alternative and at least HE provided an alternative which was shut down by evil Republican justices who ruled according to heartless Republican prejudices, not scholarly constitutional principles. Still, I've said for two years now that this election will be entirely about Obama, and it will be entirely a question of whether the nation wants to fire him. Who he runs against is almost immaterial. And from that perspective there is little doubt that March has been a very bad month for Obama.
Dadman
I'm not sure the ideologues running this country are capable of feeling shame or embarrassment about much of anything. Don't underestimate the Dems ability to spin a defeat of Obamacare into a political advantage in November. Hopefully, it will not be enough of an advantage to keep Americans from firing the current POTUS. But I also worry about how it might impact congressional races in both the House and the Senate. From a purely political perspective it might be better for conservatives in November if the SCOTUS upholds Obamacare allowing the new Republican president to repeal it as promised. But who really knows...