Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Trying to sell an underwater house...

By CosmicConservative
Is just about the most insane thing I've ever done. It is looking more and more like I am eventually going to just have to mail my keys to the bank and say "knock yourself out, maybe you can sell it better than I could." Of course that will wreck my credit for seven years.... but hey... See the thing is that I could swing a down payment on a new home without selling my existing home. So one option I have is to buy a new house without selling the old house, so that my impeccable credit rating gets me a good loan on the new home, and then once that is secure, just walk away from my old house and default on the loan. Sure it will screw up my credit, but my new home payment would be locked in, and I'd just have to deal with bad credit for seven years.... Talk about being screwed.....

Comments (19)

mtnlurker
Be careful. If you do a short sale you must get, in writing, an agreement from the bank that they won't come after you for the difference. If you buy another house the finance person will look at all of your current debt to see if you can afford the new house. I suggest that either you stay or work with the bank on a short sale.
CosmicConservative
Doing a short sale is just as damaging to your credit as having your house foreclosed, or even defaulting on the loan. I'm not sure why I want to pay a real estate agent for the privilege or wrecking my credit.
Dadman
Have you considered renting your home out via Vacation Rentals by Owner or vrbo.com? Or just simply renting it instead of selling it?
CosmicConservative
Dadman, yes I briefly considered adding being a landlord to my list of misery-inducing, hope-crushing, life-destroying responsibilities.
Dadman
Hmmmm....being a landlord certainly has its downside, but life-destroying seems a stretch...especially if it allows you to preserve your credit rating... :) BTW, Intel in its somewhat less than infinite wisdom has eliminated the jobs of nearly 100 people and is now making us reapply and interview for about 40 new positions, only 2-3 of which will be compatible with my skills and hard-earned experience. It's surreal. Anyway, it's highly likely I will be losing my job at Intel in the next couple of months and I'm trying really hard to not let it be hope-crushing...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, sorry to hear about your job situation. Knowing Intel though I am sure you have a nice separation package in store if you don't get one of those jobs. You should take the time and put together a portfolio of cartoons and embark on the career you were born for.
CosmicConservative
I came real close to applying for a project manager job at the company that makes the games I play. It would be a significant drop in income, but man it would be fun... I just couldn't figure out how to pay my bills....
Dadman
I will get a decent severance package that will buy me some time to ponder new paths. Emotionally, the prospect of losing my job at Intel, after so many years, is a roller coaster ride of fear and intrigue. I try to stay focused on the intrigue, but the fear usually wins. I'm REALLY not proud of that. BTW, Are you attending the reunion? I just purchased a round-trip flight to Dallas for only $207 today. I hope you can make it...
CosmicConservative
I am currently planning on attending, and will do so if things don't degrade to the point that I can't.
Andy
Wow. Sorry to hear that both of you guys are looking at what you are. Sucks. Somehow I thought that by middle age things would get less complicated. Man, was I ever wrong. You guys are both healthy, smart, and have people in your corner. I know nobody likes to hear, "It could be worse." But, it really could. I think about my BIL, who is facing a real financial struggle now...and trying to face it with a bum ticker at 52. Oh well...just wanted you guys to know that I've got faith in you both. I mean that sincerely.
mtnlurker
The difference between walking away and doing a short-sale is that they won't sue you for the difference if you do a short-sale. If you walk away they can sue you if they don't get enough from the sale of the house. Your credit rating is not your biggest problem. =============================================== I am sorry to hear about your job situation, Dadman. I was laid off in 2008 from a company I had been with for 13 years. The fear and depression hit me hard. It was not until a friend helped me get a contract job that I started to turn it around. Good luck.
CosmicConservative
Andy, thanks, I suppose it is worth something to know that there are folks in my corner, but I would frankly be happier just to see some sort of actual progress made. There's really only so much that human beings can take and it is never pleasant realizing your own limitations in that regard.
JSullins
The laws on "sue them for the difference" -- doesn't the amount have to exceed a certain threshold before they can come after you?
CosmicConservative
I dunno, I'm new to all this. I don't see how they can sue for "the difference" anyway, unless the house has been deliberately damaged. The contract I signed with them fundamentally said "Here, we'll give you money to buy the house, you'll pay us back nearly three times that amount over the life of the loan, and if you don't make a payment, we get the house." I don't think I'd have a hard time in court saying "Looks to me like I met the contractual obligations here."
JSullins
I heard in the news a month or so ago about banks coming after people who had done this, in court. In those news items, I'm almost sure, the bank's loss on the subsequent seizing of the home had exceeded a certain dollar amount, which then allowed them to pursue the former owners under some law or other. Something like that.
Dadman
The near-term future is a fog of uncertainty. If I get one of the new-fangled job roles, then all will be well and the immediate uncertainty will dissipate. Life might actually return to normal. If I don't get one of the new jobs then all bets are off. If I choose, I'll be given the opportunity to look for other opportunties at Intel - both permanent and temporary - which may or may not be fruitful, or I can choose to walk out the door immediately with a slightly larger severance package. I'm not sure what I'm going to do yet. Sooner or later, I'm going to have to leave Intel and I might as well get paid well to part ways - that's one of my lines of thinking at least. But I'm sure I'll stick with Intel if given the opportunity. I'm not even close to being set for retirement. I have to work (probably need to to preserve my sanity) to prepare better for future financial requirements. I appreciate the friends and family who are in my corner. They tell me everything is going to be alright and although I'm not always as convinced as they are I'm grateful for their reminders that change can often be a good thing if it forces us to move in directions that inertia prevents so effectively. And by all accounts I've heard from the previously departed there is in fact life after Intel... :)
Andy
Cosmic, "it is never pleasant realizing your own limitations in that regard." I feel ya', my friend. Truly. Dadman, "And by all accounts I’ve heard from the previously departed there is in fact life after Intel…" Don't believe 'em! They're just trying to cheer you up. ;)
Foobarista
Before you walk away, you may want to figure out exactly if your mortgage is a "recourse" mortgage (this varies from state to state). In some states (ie, CA, where I live), a purchase money mortgages (ie, the one used to buy the house) is a non-recourse note, meaning the house itself is the only collateral by law and they can't come after you for a balance if they get the house in a reasonable state of repair. Second mortgages and refinanced mortgages often _are_ recourse mortgages in CA. You may want to read the text of your mortgage carefully, and maybe talk with someone who has a clue about this stuff in your area.