Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What does Whitney Houston's death teach us?

By CosmicConservative
Soooo many lessons... 1. If you had any doubt whether the Hollywood elite would party on in the shadow of the death of one of their own, while police cars, ambulances, crime scene detectives and grieving friends and relatives desperately tried to reach the body of the dead celebrity, rest assured, Jane Fonda, Kim Kardashian, Britney Spears and hordes of others have no problem dancing the night away while the body bag is being moved through the hallways and past their rented limos. For what it's worth, Taylor Swift and Miley Cyrus did refuse to attend the post Grammy party held just a few floors below Whitney's dead body and her grieving friends and family. 2. It doesn't matter how much money you have, or how much support you have or how much attention the media gives your behavior. If you want to abuse drugs and alcohol, you can. Repeatedly. Disastrously. And in the end, Permanently. 3. As if Michael Jackson didn't teach us this well enough, it's worth revisiting with Whitney's death. Nothing changes the world's perception of a celebrity from disgraced, pathetic has-been to immortal, brilliant superstar like choking to death on your own vomit in a drug-induced catatonic daze. 4. Even if you can't hit the high notes as well as a caricatured country singer has hit them for decades, if you are pretty enough and die in a drug-induced catatonia, you will forever be considered the better singer. I was never a huge Whitney Houston fan. I thought she was better than most of her contemporaries. Comparing her version of "I will always love you" to Dolly Parton in her prime.... I gotta say, Whitney was a pale shadow of Dolly's powerful, soulful, note-caressing version. And I'm not really a Dolly fan either, but I just gotta say...

Comments (19)

mtnlurker
Yes, JSullins. I believe it is the only song to go platinum three times. Twice for Dolly and once for Whitney.
CosmicConservative
If you have never heard the original Dolly Parton version of "I will always love you" you are the poorer for it.
mtnlurker
Sorry, I have to correct myself. It went to number one three times, not platinum. Well, I did see Best Little Whorehouse in Texas.
CosmicConservative
I saw a video of Dolly's original performance on the "Grand Ole Opry" singing that song in black and white before she had developed the "biggest boobs in Hollywood" persona. Just absolutely incredible talent.
Dadman
Your contempt for Whitney is perplexing. She had issues like so many others did/do in the entertainment industries, but that doesn't change the fact that she was phenomenally talented singer - and I'm not saying that because she just died in a 'drug-induced catatonia'. It's just demonstrably true. And I don't think it's necessary or legitimate to compare Whitney's and Dolly's versions of 'I Will Always Love You' for the purpose of denigrating the performance of the recently departed. They're both unique, outstanding performances in different genres. They're both great. Personally, I prefer Whitney's version...and not because Dolly has been victimized by caricature and contempt for country music by some elitists. Finally, I will say that I don't think any performer will ever match Whitney's version of our national anthem at the Super Bowl in 2007. It was amazing... RIP, Whitney Houston. I hope you have found your peace...
CosmicConservative
"Contempt"? Really, you think my comments are "contemptuous?" Because I said Dolly could hit the high notes better and her version is a better version? The "contempt" I think I demonstrated was contempt for the Hollywood culture which allows dozens of so-called "elitists" to literally dance the night away as Whitney's body was being carted away. The other "contempt" I demonstrated was contempt for popular culture in general which glorifies the deaths of drug-addicted celebrities and turns their tortured lives into celebrations of the very culture that destroyed them. This post wasn't about Whitney Houston. It was about what her death teaches us about our culture. I absolutely have shown contempt for that culture. The only comment I made about Whitney herself was that while I wasn't a fan, I thought she was a better singer than most of her contemporaries. That qualifies as "contempt?" Oh well. Rest in peace Whitney Houston. Your life should be a cautionary tale about the perils of fame, excess and drug abuse. Why you decided to live a life of self-abuse is a mystery to me. But no more so than John Belushi, Michael Jackson, Marilyn Monroe, Amy Winehouse or a host of other celebrities who have destroyed themselves on the altar of fame.
JSullins
Something that always makes my brain explode is trying to understand people who have so much and then go on to destroy their lives. Man, if I had all that money, no 9-5 day job, I could do so much... but to destroy yourself instead? Very difficult to comprehend. Then again, I suspect that poor inhabitants of 3rd world nations might look at me and say, "you have it so great, how can you be so fat and out of shape?"
Dadman
I thought I detected a whiff of contempt, or at least disdain (if there is a difference), for Whitney herself. But, fair enough, the post is mostly about popular culture and I completely agree with your assessment. It's horrific. Fame seems to be, all too often, fatal. And those who manage to survive fame are often scarred for life and rendered permanently miserable. Celebrities who avoid such a fate seem exceptional.
CosmicConservative
JSullins, there really must be something to the idea that fame and fortune are not everything we "po' folks" think it is. I have a bad habit of referring to my children's major concerns as "first world problems." Meaning what they consider a "problem" would be considered a blessing for much of the world even today. The overriding lesson I have learned from watching the rich and famous, as vicariously as I have done so, is that everyone has problems, and no matter how difficult those problems might be in an objective analysis, to that person those problems are life challenges of the first order. Being rich doesn't make your problems go away, it just gives you a completely different set of "problems." And based on my observation of people who agonize over "first world problems", I have no doubt that most of them would agonize just as much over other problems if they were rich. One huge difference between people at my economic level and the Whitney Houstons of the world is that the ready availability of temptation and the ease to succumb to that temptation are vastly increased in direct proportion to their wealth. So their perceived problems are just as bad, but I don't have a dozen "helpful friends" tossing drugs at me as a "solution" every single day. Living at that socio-economic level is really like an alien life to me. I can't even imagine what it's like. I just know it must not be as easy as it looks. But then again, I am also always reminded of Loretta Lynn's famous comment: "Ive been rich and I've been poor. Rich is better."
JSullins
And seriously, I could stay off of drugs and spend my millions easily enough... I'd build this awesome game room... From which I'd never emerge... only to eat... naw I'd have a pizza oven in there too.... and then.... hmmmmmmmm
Drax
I used to be amazed at the outpouring of - I don't know what - when a celebrity, after years or decades of very public attempts, finally succeeds in killing himself through excessive and repeated use of brain-numbing drugs or alcohol. The reason why people who have never met these celebrities invest so much emotion in their lives completely eludes me. And, when they predictably kill themselves as so many have done in the same fashion, the public, rather than using them as an object lesson (on so many levels about so many different areas of life) - celebrate them. They live this drug-induced haze of a life fully in the public eye - a gaze which no longer judges or condemns and, in failing to do so (both in life and death) they simply prime the pump for the next poor sap to follow in his footsteps. There is no shame any longer. That has consequences.
Dadman
I think what people rush to celebrate are their positive contributions to society - in the case of Whitney Houston, her music - not their pathetic, drug-infested lives. I agree that the now common tragic conclusions to so many celebrities' lives should be held up as strong cautionary tales...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, for the last several years, virtually every photo and mention of Whitney Houston in the news has been about her wild drug-fueled frenzies, her wasted body, her bizarre public behavior. In fact just the day before she died the Hollywood media was all over her for having come out of yet another drug-fueled party stumbling, disheveled and yelling at the paparazzi. Immediately upon her death the same media is filled with photos of her in her glamour days, young, beautiful, full of life, full of promise, full of talent, worshiped and admired by millions. There's a message there that gets through to young people, and to other troubled celebrities. Maybe it's intentional, maybe it's not. But it's a message. And it's a powerful one.
Dadman
Since her demise I've seen the media revisit the good and repeat the bad ad nauseum. This crap is nothing new. The media are despicable, no doubt, but they've always covered these tragic celebrity stories in a manner that is both inconsistent and salacious. So, if there's a message being sent I would argue it's a familiar one...
CosmicConservative
Nothing new at all. This is what our culture has done for a long time.
Dadman
Every culture really. It's more human nature than strictly American nature...
CosmicConservative
Recovered comments from the site move: Andy said, in February 15th, 2012 at 4:57 am I read somewhere that Dolly wrote that song in about 20 minutes…when she kicked Porter Waggoner to the curb. (Ick!) Personally, I think Whitney Houston was the best female singer of her time (at least in her genre). I always felt a little hurt inside as I saw her spiral downward. Sure, I understood what was going on, and actions have consequences and all. But, it saddened me. It didn’t surprise me when the news came of her death, but I’ll admit to pulling up a few YouTube videos and listening to her work again. CosmicConservative said, in February 15th, 2012 at 10:05 am Andy, I tend to shy away from words like “best” when describing artists of any sort because of the incredible wealth of talent out there and the tendency to confuse personal taste for objective judgment. Plus it is all too easy to get caught up in the narrative around certain celebrities and let that creep into our judgment. For example, there is a very good reason that Britney Spears rose to the top of the extremely competitive Disney talent factory. She got there (over people like Christina Aguellara and others) because she can actually perform. But for whatever reason, the narrative that surrounds Spears became that of one who rose to stardom in spite of her talent, not because of it. That’s not fair, but that’s how she is perceived now. I suppose Whitney Houston’s “generation” of singers to compare her with would be the 1980s and 1990s. That would mean it overlapped significantly with Madonna, Sarde, Stevie Nicks, Charlotte Church, Mariah Carey, Anne Wilson, Linda Ronstadt, Pat Benatar, Janet Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, Debbie Harry, Tina Turner, Debbie Gibson, Mariah Carey, Paula Abdul, Susanna Hoffs, Olivia Newton-John, etc. etc…. Is Whitney better than ALL of those? She’s pretty good. But I don’t know that I could say she’s head and shoulders above everyone in that crowd… Andy said, in February 15th, 2012 at 3:59 pm I’ll stick with “best,” Cosmic. It’s all in the ear of the hearer, and eye of the beholder. Madonna is a miserable skag, I have no idea who Sarde is, Stevie Nicks has always turned me off (even more so as she’s aged), I’ll pass on Charlotte Church (because I don’t see them as working in the same clubs), Mariah Carey was a wannabe, Tina Turner’s style NEVER appealed to me…then the others (Cyndi Lauper??? Seriously???) I really never heard so much of their work. Pat Benatar, and Linda Ronstadt, of course. But, I really don’t see them as having the same career pursuits. Heck…how many movies did Pat & Linda make? And, “Olivia?” I guess I’m a generational retard, but Olivia never crossed my mind as being popular in the same era. Smokin’ hot, and talented…YES! But I would never have tried to connect their popularity in the same time frame. Heck, I had the hots for Olivia when I was in high school (maybe Junior High…it’s kinda fuzzy)…never heard of Whitney until I was a grown man with children. Don’t get me wrong…I never had the hots for Whitney. But, like I said…it’s in the ear of the hearer, and eye of the beholder. Ginger Grant, or Mary Ann Summers? You know the old answer. Ginger once, Mary Ann forever! Dadman said, in February 15th, 2012 at 4:49 pm Andy: LOL. Whitney’s pipe’s were a phenom. In her prime I on occasion would characterize her talent as a national treasure. Of course, I think Tom Petty’s music is a national treasure too… Music preferences are always personal and therefore different from one person to the next. In fact, I’ve recently learned that brain morphology has a significant impact on how individuals process sounds so it’s no surprise that what sounds good to one person may be like fingernails on a chalkboard to another. It’s the same with taste – some people dig the flavor of grapefruit juice (or whatever) while it makes another’s head explode. We are all wired up so differently. And this is my answer to the old question: Ginger once, Mary Ann forever, and Olivia forever, 3 times a day!! Andy said, in February 15th, 2012 at 5:42 pm “Olivia forever, 3 times a day!!” Well, you’re a better man than I am, Dadman. Even though the thought of it is mind-blowing… I’d be lucky to get the door open for her before I fell asleep. I suck. BTW…Tom Petty’s music IS a national treasure! Imma look in to that “brain morphology” deal. I’m pretty sure I’m a victim of it. CosmicConservative said, in February 15th, 2012 at 5:59 pm Heh… Cyndi Lauper’s “Girls Just Wanna Have Fun” is a national treasure. Of course I have a soft spot in my heart for chicks who can belt out a song. Which is why I like Whitney, but Anne Wilson, Cyndi Lauper, Linda Rondstadt… man those girls could turn up the volume. Andy said, in February 15th, 2012 at 6:45 pm Oh…so that’s who Cyndi Lauper was! Now I remember. I’m sundowning. Linda Rondstadt…agreed! CosmicConservative said, in February 15th, 2012 at 7:33 pm edit See, the thing is, if I am looking for pure vocal talent, I don’t think you’re going to find that in pop music enough to really warrant the effort. That’s what opera is for. For popular music what I want is something that engages my emotions. Either get my foot tapping, get my eyes leaking or get my blood boiling. If you can do that and sing like an angel, that’s a bonus. Whitney’s songs, for the most part, just didn’t get my emotions going. In fact Whitney’s version of “I Will Always Love You” might very well be technically superior to Dolly’s version. But Dolly’s version breaks my heart. Andy said, in February 16th, 2012 at 5:01 am Oh yeah, I never went there with the Dolly thing. Agreed that it is a heart-rending song, and IMHO Dolly beats Whitney hands down. You KNOW that it was a very REAL moment in her life. It’s often hard to top the original, and I believe that’s the case here.