Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Criminalizing the innocents

By CosmicConservative

West Virginia is not the only place in the United States where law enforcement officials are blaming the law-abiding people for a meth problem that already has pushed behind-the-counter Sudafed and other pseudoephedrine-based over-the-counter medications. You have to sign a log and you are limited as to how many Sudafed packets you can have. It is like buying rubbers in the old days.

This is akin to gun control

In 2005, West Virginia adopted these restrictions under the promise that this would end the meth labs. The meth labs grew. Now the state government wants more control — more regulations — more pushing around people whose only “crime” is to have a cold or allergy.

via Sudafed supporters push back « Don Surber.

The Cosmic family (excepting myself) relies heavily on anti-allergy drugs. Sudafed, Claritin-D and others. For years the government policy on purchasing these drugs has been an absolute joke. Anyone who doesn't realize that forcing innocent, allergy-suffering families to submit to having their names entered and tracked and being unable to get their medicine because they've gone over some arbitrary "limit" set by faceless accountants in some government bureaucracy, is simply making it a struggle for innocent people while the criminals who are supposed to be the target of these draconian measures are not impacted by them at all. Government at work. Because it's not working their response is to double down on the failed policy, further punishing innocent people while having zero impact on the criminals. This is a nation run by idiots.

Comments (9)

mtnlurker
You have no idea, Cosmic, how stupid they are or pretend to be. When the assumptions to questions and statements are that the public is at fault or must be monitored I fear for this country. I await the day when I will be arrested because I mention to a friend in public that I am a wizard that killed 20 savages.
Dadman
Did you hear Snuffleupagus was recently arrested for exceeding his Sudafed limit? Poor hairy pachyderm... BTW, I concur; this nation is run by idiots...
Drax
The nation, unfortunately, is filled with idiots and they vote for like-minded folk to rule them. I can't tell you how many times I have had conversations with so-called "conservatives" who, when confronted with the changes which have occurred during my ADULT life which impact on our freedom SUPPORT those changes. Just ask your "conservative" friends how they feel about just those laws which affect our behavior while inside a CAR. Seat belts. Child seats. DUI (now about 2 beers in most jurisdictions). Insurance. Bazillion others. Most of them will agree with these laws which restrict our behavior in the belief that they are either "for our own good" or they are "good for society." Maybe they are. Certainly the arguments can be made that they are one or the other (or both) - but the argument that they are bad for LIBERTY and INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY seem to have been entirely forgotten - even by conservatives. (Try to talk to "conservatives" about the Patriot Act or the ability of the government to indefinitely detain Americans without trial or to kill Americans without trial or take over websites without trial or any of the many, many other SERIOUSLY unconstitutional and liberty (and life) limiting actions supported and advocated by "conservatives" and you will wonder just what the hell "conservative" MEANS anymore.)
Dadman
Nice post, Drax. Now, they are targeting what we eat and you have to wonder how many conservatives will find a way to rationalize the coming wave of taxes and regulations targeting all of the foods we love...
CosmicConservative
Well, but saturated fats are bad for you. You shouldn't eat them. Everyone knows that. You just need a little help there. And we're here to help.
ASEI
I increasingly find myself on the libertarian end of the drug war. There was a time in this country where anything was available over the counter. Cocaine was available over the counter - it was even a drink additive. Were there problems because of this? Yes. Old people with debilitating illnesses were becoming addicted to pain-killing drugs. Even so, it is hard to imagine that those problems are at all on the same order as the problems created by the drug war. There was no vast criminal (criminalized?) underclass that got into hard drugs as a statement of rebellion. There was no vast organized crime network owning several countries existing for the sole purpose of thwarting the ever expanding police crackdown intended to stop the flow of drugs. While I never intend to use anything like these myself (I'd rather be taking something that makes me smarter and more aware, not dumber and numb), I think we'd have a chance of radically improving the country by ending all of these "controlled substances" that our government no longer trusts us to handle. That goes for a lot of things that aren't addictive also - chemicals, tools, ect.
ASEI
That's the other thing: The damage isn't limited to law vs. organized crime: We aren't trusted with chemistry anymore. We no longer have the right to interact with that part of the world without submitting to inspections and doing it as part of a business. Anyone with a chemistry set is a suspected meth/terrorist bomb factory. We found this out the hard way while trying to build a solid-fueled rocket for a college club. Anything invented after the start of the drug war is prescription, period. It has to go through intensive FDA vetting, and nothing is "safe" enough for us to make a decision as to whether or not to use it as individuals. We need permission for anything new. This has immensely retarded medical progress.
CosmicConservative
I've never been a fan of drug laws. I've not seen any compelling evidence whatsoever that our drug laws or "drug war" have done anything to reduce drug use or reduce crime. In fact I would say that crime is higher due to our criminalizing drugs. Once people are already "criminals" for taking drugs, it's a lot easier to rationalize stealing to pay for your habit. Especially since the cost of your drugs is artificially inflated by the criminality anyway... What the laws have done pretty well is fill up our prisons.
Drax
The notion that criminalizing such behavior actually curtailed such behavior should have been debunked during prohibition. Too, the effect of criminalizing such behavior - causing the rise of criminal enterprises to supply those who engage in such behavior should have become apparent at the same time. I don't know why people don't learn from history, but they don't. You don't criminalize behavior which has no effect on anyone but yourself. If the behavior has some negative effect on others, you deal with THAT. (For example - DUI. You punish the person not for driving under the influence but IF doing so RESULTS in affecting others. You don't punish someone for doing drugs - you punish them IF that behavior causes them to neglect their kids or harm someone else. But, simply getting high - without any significant negative effect on others - is no reason to put someone in jail. Can someone seriously argue that it is better for a child to have his parent(s) be put in jail or convicted (and not be able to find a decent job) - and have to spend huge sums on black market drugs - is BETTER than having those (stoned) parents at home and spending only modest sums on legal drugs?)