Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More planets than stars in Milky Way

By CosmicConservative
This isn't really news to most folks who have paid any attention to astronomy or cosmology. It's more of a confirmation of what most experts have suspected for a couple generations now, ever since the stellar lifecycle models were proposed and passed most reasonable observational tests.
WASHINGTON (AP) — The more astronomers look for other worlds, the more they find that it is a crowded and crazy cosmos. They think planets easily outnumber stars in our galaxy and they are even finding them in the strangest of places. And they have only begun to count. Three studies released Wednesday, in the journal Nature and at the American Astronomical Society's conference in Austin, Texas, demonstrate an extrasolar real estate boom. One study shows that in our Milky Way, most stars have planets. And since there are a lot of stars in our galaxy — about 100 billion — that means a lot of planets.
It is nice to see this public acknowledgement that planets are common in the Milky Way (probably well over a trillion planets just orbiting stars. Who knows how many "rogue planets" are roaming around in interstellar space. By some estimates that number might even be bigger than the number of star orbiting planets.) However, even through the filter of crappy science reporting, there's still something that I've never seen addressed in any story about planets, and that's the vastly increased likelihood of earth-like bodies capable of supporting life. See, the thing is that the stellar lifecycle models don't just predict that most stars probaby have a dozen or so planets (like our own system) but that a large fraction of those planets are gas giants. And that is what we are seeing when we find planets orbiting other stars. What did surprise cosmologists and astronomers when the first observational confirmation of planets orbiting other stars came in was how many of these gas giant planets are in close orbit to their stars. The assumption was that most stellar systems would resemble our own solar system, with rocky small planets close to the star and larger gas giants further out. That doesn't seem to be the case though, at least so far. The majority of systems we see have large gas giant planets in orbits more like Mercury, Venus or Earth. So of course the idiots who call themselves science reporters bemoan that those planets are not "earth-like" and therefore are not candidates for looking for "alien" life. But nothing could be further from the truth. See, the stellar lifecycle models don't just predict that stars have planetary systems. They also predict that gas giants have moon systems, and that those moons can be equal in size to what we think of as planets. So for every gas giant that is in close orbit to its sun, there is a fairly high probability that "hot Jupiter" has a collection of moons that could easily be the size of Mercury, Mars or even Earth. Using our own solar system as a model, we have eight acknowledged "planets". However those eight planets have over a hundred moons, and at least eight of those moons would qualify as planets if they were in orbit around the sun by themselves. So that means we should essentially not only DOUBLE the estimate of the number of possible life-supporting objects, we should actually QUADRUPLE that estimate since virtually all such "moons" are rocky bodies more resembling earth than gaseous bodies resembling Jupiter or Uranus. So if half of the trillion or so "planets" now estimated to be in stellar orbits are gas giants, then there are likely TWO trillion planetary-sized objects with earth-like composition. How many of those would be in the Goldilocks zone? Meaning how many would there be where water could exist in a liquid state on the surface? Well, that's still a guess, but based on what I've seen from the data so far, probably five percent of the planets discovered so far would be in that zone, but the vast majority of them are "hot Jupiter" type objects. By the way, that's not necessarily because most planets in their star's "goldilocks zone" are gas giants, that's basically because our planet-detection process is still far more likely to find massive bodies in close orbit to stars than smaller bodies, or massive bodies in larger orbits. Anyway, just throwing my own personal guess at things, I would guess that most stars have SOMETHING orbiting in their goldilocks zone. Some of those objects will be earth-like planets, some will be asteroid-like bodies and some will be gas giants with their own collection of moons. So my guess is that there's likely to be a near one-to-one relationship between stars and rocky bodies capable of having liquid water on their surface. Which puts the total number of such bodies into the hundreds of billions in our galaxy alone. Now, if we plug that into the Drake Equation, that vastly increases the odds of there being alien life in our galaxy, which would therefore greatly increase the odds that there is intelligent life in the galaxy, which then greatly increases the odds that there are technologically advanced beings in our galaxy.... But then that takes us right to the Fermi paradox. "Where the hell are they then?" By the way, using the standard of a potential life-supporting body being something large enough to have differentiated its composition and that composition being mainly of "rock", our solar system has 27 such bodies currently known. Two of them orbit in the Goldilocks zone today. Mars and Venus are both right on the edge of that zone, and in the past and future both of them have been or will be in the Goldilocks zone. That means our solar system has four bodies that would merit close examination as potential life-bearing bodies if we were to be examined from some other vantage point outside our own solar system. Four. I'm guessing that might be a pretty common number of potentially life-bearing planets for most stars. That means that roughly 15% of bodies of earth-like composition with reasonable surface gravity in our solar system are, have been or will be in the "Goldilocks zone" of our own star. That would mean if there are two trillion such objects in the galaxy, and our solar system can be used as a model, there should be roughly 300 BILLION Goldilocks zone inhabiting earth-like bodies in the galaxy. My personal guess is that life is actually pretty common in the galaxy.

Comments (11)

mtnlurker
But you didn't answer the Fermi Paradox. My response is the most people don't realize how big space or even our own Milky Way galaxy really is. 300 billion candidates for life-bearing planets would still get lost in the vastness of this galaxy.
CosmicConservative
mtn... well, I didnt' get into any details about the Fermi paradox, but I did factor in the vastness of the galaxy just as Fermi did with his original calculations as reported by those at lunch with him the day he uttered the famous phrase "Well, where IS everyone?" (Some report it as "Where the hell is everyone?"). Here's the deal. Let's look at the Milky Way Galaxy and use CURRENT TECHNOLOGY as our baseline for colonization of the entire galaxy by a single sentient species. The average distance between stars in our galaxy is thought to be about two light years overall (stars are much closer together towards the center of the galaxy). However it is also thought that the inner 10% or more of the galaxy is uninhabitable due to the extreme hard radiation of the central black hole and the density of Sirius type high-radiation stars. So we'll use 4 light years as an average distance (which just happens to be about the distance to the closest star to earth). Using current technology we can build starships that can attain 10% of light speed over that distance. Those can be built either using nuclear power or can be light-sail or ion engines. At 10% of lightspeed it's a 40 year journey from earth to Alpha Centauri. Without getting into the overall density of stars, let's say that each star is adjacent to four other stars, but we'll say that our first journey is just to Alpha Centauri. Let's say it takes 100 years between the time a ship reaches a new star and when that ship has self-replicated four new ships that can reach other stars. (It does not require a habitable planet for this, by the way, and in fact it would be best to plan on replicating the ships from the destination star's asteroid or Kuiper belt anyway). After 140 years we will have colonized five stellar systems. Each of those five will colonize three more in the next 140 years. Each of those fifteen will colonize three more in the next 140 years, and the radius of colonization will have reached 12 light years. At that rate of expansion it would take 1,400 years to colonize a sphere of the galaxy with a radius of 40 light years. 14,000 years to colonize a sphere with a radius of 400 light years. 140,000 years to colonize a sphere with a radius of 4,000 light years. 1,400,000 years to colonize a sphere with a radius of 40,000 light years. In 14,000,000 years the colonization rate would greatly exceed the available stars in the galaxy. Fourteen million years may sound like a long time. But it's not. It's not even long in geological times. Dinosaurs ruled the earth for longer than that. A lot longer. In a cosmological sense that's an eyeblink. That's not even a single revolution of the galaxy around its axis. So the question of "Where is everyone" is absolutely a paradox. There are solar systems with similar composition to our solar system that are BILLIONS of years older than ours. For the entire galaxy to have been colonized long, long ago, all it takes is for some sentient species to have reached our level of technology ten million years or so ago. But it is quite possible to achieve interstellar speeds much higher than 10% of the speed of light. And if life is common and evolution is similar to earth's, it would seem that our galaxy should have had at least a FEW such sentient races. If all it takes is ONE, and logic compels us to believe that there are likely thousands.... Where the hell are they?
ASEI
I thought some of the more recent results from Kepler were showing a bias towards smaller terrestrial-sized planets? - that terrestrials are relatively more common than the middle or large gas giants, and it's just been our technology that has prevented us from seeing them up until this point.
ASEI
"Where the hell are they?" One of my personal guesses as to why this might be the case is that there is a rather vast distance in *time* between any potential civilizations. Space may be crowded with Earthlike planets, but on how many of these planets would anything recognizable as civilization exist at the same time? Human technological civilization is maybe 500 years old. (Or 8000, or 200, depending on how generous you are with your definitions). I think we might remain "human-like" and "civilization-like" for maybe another 1000 years at the outside, barring any dark ages interrupting our progress. If we meet something that has been thinking/developing/processing state for a billion years, odds are we wouldn't be able to understand it, and it wouldn't be all that interested in us. Suppose you discover Earth, and decide to send an expedition to study it. Throw a dart at the dartboard of geological time - what are the odds it intersects with human history? Of course, I'm also making the assumption that any extremely old thingies that may exist out there are also relatively self-contained. If any of them had wanted to expand to consume the universe for whatever project of theirs they might want to pursue, then Fermi's paradox applies - they would have done so already.
tomnnva
Read "Rare Earth" by Peter Ward and Donald Brownlee, a couple of highly regarded scientists. They make the case that simple life, single cell, probably is common, but complex life almost never exists. "Follow the Money" is the reason so many scientists and the media support "Aliens are Everywhere".
CosmicConservative
ASEI, I'll have to check into the bias you are referring to. I would be surprised if that were true for a couple of reasons, one having to do with the number of still shining first or second generation stars (which are not expected to have many rocky planets) and the other having to do with the search technology itself. Also, the Fermi paradox calculations factor in supposed civilization lifecycles, as does the Drake equation and the general conclusion is still a perplexed "where the hell are they?" Remember, the 10 million year example I used was assuming a SINGLE civilization arising in the galaxy. If you suppose that sentience happens even a dozen times out of the trillion or so possible planets available, then the time frames compress dramatically.
CosmicConservative
Tomnva, I am familiar with the "Rare Earth" argument. Essentially it takes a few of the far right side variables in the Drake Equation and assigns infinitesimal probabilities to them so taht while single-celled life is fairly common, multi-celled life is rare and intelligent life is even more rare, suggesting that Earth may be unique. The main support for the Rare Earth argument is that although life began on earth almost immediately upon the earth's surface cooling enough to support life, it was almost 3.5 billion years before multi-celled life developed. Since we only have a single data point on the event which created multi-cellular life, there is no scientific method to determine the likelihood of it's happening. However, once multi-cellular life does appear, the rate of evolution accelerates exponentially.
mtnlurker
I am sorry but I have to disagree with one of your points. I do not think we, currently, have the capability to send a viable population to another star. Could this not be a limiting factor? Or do we just need another 20 or 100 years?
tomnnva
Actually, Rare Earth take into account things such as the presence of a Large Moon, Plate Tectonics and a number of other mechanisms that are unique to Earth within our own solar system, as to their argument of uniqueness of complex life.
CosmicConservative
Tom, one of the criticisms of Rare Earth is that they claim things are unique that we have no way of knowing if they are unique or not. How common are dual planet systems? We have at least two, maybe three in our solar system. So IF they are right, then maybe their argument is valid, but there is no way to know if they are right. It's pure speculation whether dual planet systems are common, whether plate tectonics is common or whether either of those have any actual impact on evolution that would not have happened anyway. mtn... Yes, we have the capability. Freeman Dyson proposed a nuclear spaceship that is completely feasible today. It was completely feasible almost sixty years ago. We lack the will to do it, not the technology.
ASEI
WRT detected planetary radii, this is what I was sort of remembering: http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-40EgRXiHStU/TVPW5NnZ3ZI/AAAAAAAAApU/bjxNseJ95vo/s1600/planet%2Bkepler%2Bvs%2Bus.PNG And even the falloff there is due to instrument limitations. I think the Gas giant bias is bias in our ability to find planets. The gravity wobble method measures supermassive planets in tight orbits. The direct observation method measures supermassive planets in extremely far orbits. The transit method (employed by Kepler) seems to give us some sensitivity to terrestrial-sized planets. Just because we can barely see them doesn't mean they're rare.