Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Weight loss...

By CosmicConservative
So, I'm a bit more than one year into my "new lifestyle" to control my weight. I am still wearing size 32 pants, so I'm doing pretty good, although my weight has crept up a few unwanted pounds in the past few months (most likely due to loss of focus during the holiday season). So because of that I've been doing some reading on weight loss. And although what I am finding is not surprising or really even new, the tone and approach to the discussion on weight loss does seem to be changing a bit. Essentially it appears that folks who are trying to lose 15 - 30 pounds typically can keep the weight off for 12 - 18 months, but less than 5% of study participants keep it off longer than that. People who lose more than 30 pounds tend to not only regain the weight much faster, but they also tend to end up gaining MORE weight after dieting and end up MORE obese than they started. There has been a lot of work done on the human metabolism's response to dieting. And that's where all the really interesting research seems to be right now. More and more the weight-loss scientists are saying that losing weight itself isn't that hard, but KEEPING IT OFF is about as close to impossible as a human endeavor can be. In essence NOBODY keeps weight off for more than a few years at most. NOBODY. Even the "less than five percent" figure that is frequently cited by long-term studies is skewed because it doesn't include those who drop out of the long term studies themselves. And would you like to guess who is most likely to drop out of a long-term study on weight loss? I'm guessing it's not the folks who are happily skinny for the rest of their lives. So that means the actual number of folks who lose any significant amount of weight and keep it off PERMANENTLY is probably in the 1% range. Or less. Now, that actually meets my own experience. I really only know one person who I know lost over 30 pounds and has kept it off for three years now. One person. Everyone else I know who lost 15 - 30 pounds (or more) has easily put that much back on since their weight loss. Why is that? Well, my guess is that it's simply mentally, emotionally and intellectually exhausting to maintain weight loss if you've been heavy. I was reading a story about how one person managed to keep their weight down for five years, and the reporter who interviewed the person was astonished at what that person did to maintain their weight, which included: - Weighing themselves EVERY SINGLE DAY (I do this) - Counting EVERY SINGLE CALORIE (if I don't do this, I gain weight) - Treating high-carbohydrate foods like drugs (I also do this) - Exercising diligently for up to two hours per day (I don't do this) - Tracking every activity to count calorie burn rates (I don't do this) - Ensuring that at least 1/3 of calories are protien (I do this) In summary, the effort required by this individual to keep their weight off is a NEVER-ENDING focus on quite literally EVERY MORSEL OF FOOD they put in their mouth, while monitoring EVERY SINGLE ACTIVITY to calculate caloric input and output. Doing this the individual interviewed is able to maintain their weight. However, if there is the slightest deviation from this regimen, the weight goes back on and losing it requires draconian caloric starvation to get the weight back down. Now, a year ago, when I started this "lifestyle change" thing, I sort of assumed that I would develop new habits and that eventually I'd just adopt a new "food and exercise norm". But that hasn't been the case. Twelve months into it, I also have to literally watch EVERY SINGLE MORSEL of food if I want to maintain my weight. In two months, just by relaxing a bit to enjoy some holiday meals and snack on some holiday cookies, I've put back on ten pounds, and now I am having to crack down hard again to lose that weight again. It appears that this will be the case for the rest of my life. Or that's what the research seems to indicate. So, will I be able to be in the presumed "less than one percent" of folks who lose weight and keep it off? I'm gonna give it hell.

Comments (9)

JSullins
I lost about 25 pounds awhile back, mostly with exercise. I stopped the exercise and am right back to where I was before. Maybe if you picked up a team sport it would relax the need for morsel-watching?
CosmicConservative
Living out in the boondocks where I live, I don't have much shot at joining a team sport that would satisfy the daily exercise needs of my weight-loss regimen...
Dadman
Team Snipe hunting, maybe? As I've mentioned before I lost 30 pounds many years ago and kept it off about 5 years, but the weight eventually crept back on. Lost 20 over the past few months and had the same outcome as you with recent holiday sweet nibbling. It's frustrating to say the least. I think we underestimate just how much age slows down our ability to burn calories. Any and all calories consumed above our basal metabolism, which steadily decreases, is quite efficiently converted to fat. I hate it. :(
CosmicConservative
Most of what I'm reading indicates that there is something more nefarious going on than just a slowing metabolism as we get older. The scientific evidence seems to suggest that your body adjusts quite readily to being heavier, but treats attempst to lose weight as quite literal starvation, and that triggers all sorts of mechanisms that greatly reduce the body's ability to lose weight, including, but not limited to, cravings for carbs, lethargia, fat retention, increased hunger, etc... Apparently for our ancestors the ability to lay on the fat was such a huge survival advantage that a large fraction of the human genome is devoted to making it easy to gain weight and virtually impossible to lose it... Or that's how it seems...
Dadman
I've actually done a fair amount of reading into this subject myself and you are right about what the research says. Skipping meals is bad because it triggers those 'starvation' signals that tell our bodies to rev down our metabolism and store more fat. Many 'experts' I've read recommend 6 small meals per day and my own experience eating this way in the past has been positive. I wonder to what extent age is a real factor. The so-called 'middle-age spread' seems to be one of life's inevitabilties, but I wonder if the spread is the result of a reduced basal metabolism and shrinking muscle mass (thus reducing our ability to burn calories efficiently) or the result of reduced activity levels. There are very few middle-aged folks who are as active as they were as kids. I know I was one of those skinny kids who could eat anything I wanted and never gain an ounce. But I also burned a gigazillion calories a day running, jumping, climbing trees, riding a unicycle, etc. It wasn't until my mid-20s that I started gaining weight and the variable that changed was my activity level. Ultimately, the tendency to gain weight as we age is probably a function of age and activity level...and certainly evolutionary imperatives play a big role as well.
Andy
Well, being the fat guy (and probably the one you mentioned that has kept it off for more than five years...if not, well you know TWO people who have), I studied this a lot. I have concluded that genetics are hard things to overcome when it comes to our weight/health/habits/moods/etc. We are all so similar, yet SO different in our makeup. What works for some just WILL NOT work for others. I eat a diet that is probably 70% carbs, 20% fat, 10% protein, and I rarely get hungry. In fact, I sometimes eat just because I know it's time to, and if I don't I might get weakish later in the day. When I ate a high protein diet, I was always hungry. Starved! I lost about 80 pounds 20+ years ago, and as of this morning, I've gained about 20 of it back (I went and weighed, so I could be accurate with this comment). I think that is due to the aging metabolism. Supposedly, we lose about 10% per decade...or that's what I read back in my weight-loss days. I really believe activity has more to do with it than anything. I'm very active, even though I don't exercise regularly like I once did. BTW, congrats on staying in 32s. You and I can swap clothes now. Yep! I finally graduated from 30s mid-2011. Guess it's catching up to me...
CosmicConservative
Well, I've shed about four of those unwanted newly gained pounds, but I've got some ways to go to get back to the 175 I set as my original goal when I started this. I am trying to decide if I want to push it further. I did for a short while and got down to 172 but that only lasted for a few weeks before I started going back up again. Assuming I can get down to 175 again, I think I will make one more push to get down to 165. I do think 165 would be more of an "ideal weight" for my body. Of course the chance of keeping it at that weight is pretty slim. "Slim" get it? I crack myself up... :)
Dadman
My goal weight is 170...and I still got a ways to go...
CosmicConservative
What really gets me is that my poor eating habits are rarely about being hungry. In fact I almost never feel hungry. I tend to nibble out of boredom or habit it seems, or else because I crave a particular taste (chocolate... salt... cheese... those are my nemeses...)