Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Warhorse

By CosmicConservative
Steven Spielberg vehicle... First let me say that I enjoyed the movie. It even choked me up a couple of times. The story is deliberately heartwarming and the writing, acting and directing are all excellent, with some absolutely stellar moments that will melt all but the stoniest hearts. The breaking of the movie into small vignettes of family bonding, calls to duty, proof of manhood or hints of romance punctuated with scenes of bone-chilling battle carnage, booming artillery or vicious military brutality was quite compelling, providing one of the best examples of directorial pacing I've seen in years. This is one of the (few) things I really like about Spielberg, I don't think there's a better director in my lifetime who understands how to manipulate the action and pacing of a movie to elicit the most powerful emotional reactions from the viewer. He does so masterfully in this movie. One of the best things about this movie is how it showed both the brutality and the humanity of soldiers on both sides of the war. There were no overt political comments about the causes of the war or the rationale behind the mind-numbing battle tactics. The story focused on the soldiers and civilians that interacted with "Joey", the titular warhorse of the movie. Even the soldiers who pushed their men in the most heartless manner were presented with some level of sympathy as they explained their actions as being the necessary evils of conducting total war. If anything, that sort of presentation of the actions of soldiers is more chilling than maniacal evil villainy since it presents the viewer with the opportunity to wonder what they would do themselves presented with the same choices as the men on screen. Of course it's a Spielbergian effort, which means the heart-string tugging is painfully obvious and predictable, but that's what you get with Spielberg, the guy is as subtle as a howitzer and always has been. I am not qualified to weigh in on the acting chops of a horse, or horses (no doubt they used several horses for different Joey scense), nor am I qualified to judge if a "thoroughbred" could actually perform some of the actions depicted in the movie itself, but there is no doubt that Spielberg managed to develop an emotional connection between the audience and the horses in the movie, particularly the big black warhorse which became a Homeric battle companion of Joey for much of the movie. Although most reviewers will likely wax poetic about the portrayal of Albert Narracott by Jeremy Irvine, I was not terribly impressed. Jeremy seemed to be posing for many of his shots, not acting, and whether at his choosing or the director's choosing he seemed to be preening for the camera far too many times. The overall impression I got was of an actor who is all too aware of his preternatural good looks. I'm sure those good looks will be getting lots of acclaim and attention just on their own merits. No, my favorite acting in the movie was by two of the supporting characters. First and most impressive was the role of Captain Nicholls, portrayed by Tom Hiddleston ("Loki" in the movie "Thor"). Although only on the screen for a short time Hiddleston managed to infuse his portrayal of Captain Nicholls with extraordinary sensitivity and compassion, while still maintaining both a sense of competitive manliness and a powerful sense of bravery and duty. The second role I found myself admiring was the young French(?) girl "Emilie" portrayed by newcomer Celine Buckens. Her portrayal of a young orphaned teenager living with her grandfather while war erupts around them is touching and she shows a nice comedic touch as well. I liked her grandfather (Neils Arestrup) too. The movie's critical events are all far too implausible to accept without suspending a healthy does of disbelief, but the movie is worth it. I highly recommend it. I give it 4.5 wire-cutters out of 5.

Comments (4)

Dadman
My grandfather rode a 'warhorse' for the Scottish army in WWI. Really looking forward to seeing this movie...
jussayin'
It was a great movie. This is the type of movie that Hollywood used to produce. Of course the life of the horse was a bit improbable, but isn't that the point of this movie? Yes, some of the movie is predictable, but instead of the silly twists and turns of the usual pap from Hollywood, this gives you more of what you want. Joey is heroic. You identify with him. You cheer for him. He is like the old John Wayne characters who succeed despite the odds, overcomes despite not being the right type. I thought the mother and father were well played.
CosmicConservative
jus, I thought the mother was well played, I wasn't real thrilled with the father character. There was no real depth of character there, the only sympathy you got for the father was through the mother's revelation of his past.
jussayin'
The thing with the father though, was that was how many fathers were in that era. Many families barely knew anything about the person that was the head of the family. I know the lack of depth of character building was there, but that fit in with the history and character of him as told by his wife. He is an actor who can convey so much with just his eyes. He was the stiff upper lip brit character of that era, despite the earliest scene with him going at it for Joey. He had a hard choice, he made it, flawed though it was in execution. He was also beaten down by life, some self inflicted, some brought on by "just life". Not sure if this was based on a book. Didn't see anything about that, but movies far too often flatten characters.