Great article. This is something I've personally given a lot of thought to back in the days that I actually read and contemplated philosophical writings. "Practical Wisdom" to me is most frequently encountered in society as what we refer to as "common sense." Unfortunately, as I realized four decades ago, there is nothing "common" about "common sense." I have always tried to teach my kids about this concept, but it's a difficult thing to communicate. To effectively execute "practical wisdom" requires three very important and frequently under-utilized skills: 1. Perception 2. Perspective 3. Analysis Without all three of these working together, it is very difficult to reach a wise conclusion to a complex ethical or moral question. You first have to recognize WHAT is going on, then you have to recognize HOW it is important, and finally you have to be able to investigate the likely outcome of different actions and apply perception and perspective to the conclusion. What this boils down to in many, if not most, cases is what I have been complaining about on this blog for years. And that is the complete lack of critical thinking skills that are being taught in our schools and universities these days. If people are wondering where common sense has gone, the answer is that it left the building when ideology become more important in our educational institutions than wisdom.What Is Practical Wisdom?
The ancient Greek philosophers spent a lot of time walking around in their togas discussing the nature of things, especially the nature of virtue. Take Socrates, for example. Socrates believed that man’s purpose in life was to seek sophia, or wisdom. According to Socrates and his student, Plato, achieving sophia gave a man a general understanding of the nature of virtue. And once a man reached an understanding of each of the virtues, he would naturally live them. For example, if a man understood the true nature of justice, he would naturally be just. Thus for Socrates and Plato, becoming a man of virtue was an exercise in abstract thought.
This idea of thinking-your-way-to-a-virtuous-life didn’t jibe with Plato’s student, Aristotle. While he agreed with his mentor that working to understand the nature of virtue abstractly was necessary to achieve virtue, he didn’t believe it was sufficient. For Aristotle, virtuous living also required a different kind of wisdom, one that was more particular and practical than the abstract, ethereal, and general wisdom of sophia. Aristotle calls this different kind of wisdom phronesis.
Phronesis has been translated different ways, “prudence” being the most common one. But the translation that I like best is “practical wisdom.” What is practical wisdom? Let’s read what Aristotle had to say in his Nicomachean Ethics:
Practical wisdom is a true characteristic that is bound up with action, accompanied by reason, and concerned with things good and bad for a human being.
Practical wisdom is not concerned with the universals alone, but must also be acquainted with the particulars: it is bound up with action, and action concerns the particulars.
Practical wisdom is concerned with human things and with those that about which it is possible to deliberate.
He who [has practical wisdom] is skilled in aiming, in accord with calculation, at what is best for a human being in things attainable through action.
via Practical Wisdom: The Master Virtue | The Art of Manliness.
Comments (2)